Bang.

A hurried knocking sound came from the wooden door.

Dumbledore covered the Mirror of Erised with a curtain, regained his composure, and sat back down in his chair.

"Come in."

Professor Snape stormed in, saying sternly, "Headmaster, someone has entered the restricted area and triggered my magic."

"I sensed it, but that stupid dog of Hagrid's was blocking the doorway, refusing to let me pass, and it nearly bit my leg..."

Snape suddenly stopped talking; he saw six steaming cups of milk on the table.

"Did you catch them?" Snape asked, squinting. "Who were they?"

Before Dumbledore could speak, Snape suddenly added, "It wouldn't happen to be Stark's 'League of Villains,' would it?"

"League of Villains?" Dumbledore rested his fingertips on the bridge of his nose and pushed up his glasses. "That's a strange way to put it. From what I understand, they are all excellent students, don't you think?"

"Excellent?" Snape grew angry. "Stark might have some cleverness, Diggory does nothing but grin foolishly, the Weasley Twins are constantly causing trouble, and Cho Chang just follows behind them... Oh, and they're selling maps at school. Are you going to do something about it or not?"

"The Hogwarts magic Map?" Dumbledore took a sip of milk. "William spoke to me about this last year. I agreed, and I even gave him quite a few suggestions."

Snape snorted. "And what about them wandering the castle at night?"

Dumbledore seemed prepared. He smiled and said, "I deducted points—five points from each of them."

Snape was speechless; he had deducted more than five points from Harry in the first five minutes of class.

He was about to say something else when he suddenly noticed the mirror in the corner, mostly covered by a curtain.

"You've brought out the Mirror of Erised again?" Snape frowned. "I remember you telling me... not to become obsessed with what one sees, and certainly not to dwell on illusions."

"Indeed, Severus," Dumbledore said calmly. "I am very pleased that you still remember the words I advised you with many years ago."

But Snape continued to stare at the mirror, as if wanting to take a look.

"Would you like to take a look?" Dumbledore's tone barely changed. "I can let you see it. It does not matter."

Snape did not answer. He stared fixedly at the edge of the mirror, then suddenly roared, "No! It's gone... she's dead... it's all gone... it's just fake."

Dumbledore sighed.

Snape turned around, his eyes vacant. He was in a strange state, struggling to banish that intense thought.

Except when writing letters to her, Snape did not want anyone to see him in such a weak state, Dumbledore included.

After a moment, he recovered and was as cold as before.

Snape asked in a mocking tone, "Professor, I am curious—when you look into the Mirror of Erised, what do you see? Is it a blank space, or... do you only see yourself?"

Before Dumbledore could speak, Snape added earnestly, "I think that for a great Wizard like you, having no weaknesses... you shouldn't have any emotions that could be hurt by others, right? Just like..."

"Voldemort?" Dumbledore said calmly.

Snape growled, "Do not mention that name in front of me!"

Dumbledore sighed, appearing hurt.

He said in a sorrowful tone, "Severus, you are as acerbic as always... We are all the same; we all feel pain. Our lives are filled with messy things. I also have sad emotions, and there are things I wish to see in the mirror. Life is just that baffling; I understand. You don't need to deliberately hurt an old man with your words to find psychological comfort, do you?"

A brief silence.

Dumbledore stood up. "Alright, did you bring the Potion? We need to go see what the designed challenges look like after being destroyed, and fix them up while we're at it."

Dumbledore waved his right hand, and a door opened, where Fiendfyre was burning.

He flicked his wand, the flames vanished, and the two walked through the door.

Snape asked, "Are you still planning to design the final challenge as your office?"

"Of course not... I already have a brilliant idea, as you saw."

"The Mirror of Erised?" Snape thought about it and did not object.

The two continued walking. There were a few bottles of nettle wine left on the table, but the poison and Potions were gone.

"Thieves..." Snape muttered.

However, thinking that he had already carted off the Dragon's leg, he couldn't really begrudge William for taking a few bottles of his Potion.

Even if he took a small loss, they were barely even!

Snape took a few bottles of Potion from his pocket and rearranged them on the table in the previous order.

Dumbledore picked up another piece of parchment William had left behind. He read it for a moment, and Snape leaned over to read it as well.

Another few minutes passed.

Snape asked suspiciously, "Do you know it now?"

Dumbledore paused for a moment, then nodded. "Of course I know. It's very simple logical deduction... Many great Wizards do not possess this skill. What, you don't know? Do you need me to explain it to you?"

Snape looked deeply at Dumbledore. "Then I think I know it too."

Snape pondered for a while and decided to modify the challenge again; the previous one was simply too easy.

He pulled thirteen bottles from his pocket and arranged the twenty bottles into two rows. Under each row of bottles, he marked 1, 2, 4, 8, 16 respectively.

Next to the two rows of bottles, he wrote Snape and Dumbledore respectively.

After finishing all this, he used his wand to conjure a quill and added a sentence to the parchment: The bottle with Snape's number, drink it, and it will send you back to where you came from; the bottle with Dumbledore's number will lead you forward... The others are poison!

Following his "conjectured" answer, Snape filled the bottles with the antidote and poison.

Dumbledore watched from the side, as quiet as an old man guarding the gate.

After finishing, the two continued along the corridor and encountered the Black Queen, who was still looking around in place.

She was still waiting for the pieces to return.

Dumbledore shook his head. "I will tell Professor McGonagall when I return that when she replenishes the pieces, she must also craft their facial expressions; otherwise, how will we know what she is thinking?"

Snape cast a sidelong glance at Dumbledore but said nothing.

The two continued forward and finally saw the keys lying on the ground.

Wrapped in his black tight-fitting pajamas, Snape bent down to pick up a few keys, handed one to Dumbledore, and rubbed the small hole on the key's wing with his hand.

"It should be some kind of large-scale Spell. The keys are still quite wet; the whole thing uses water as a carrier. The attack power isn't too strong, but... it is a magic I have never seen before," Snape analyzed.

"It is a little magic invented by William himself," Dumbledore smiled.

Snape was silent for a moment, then suddenly looked up and said in an inscrutable tone, "Stark is only in his second year and can already invent such offensive Spells. If you continue to let him be, aren't you afraid he will become the third Dark Lord?"