16
In front of the Department of Justice building on Pennsylvania Avenue, reporters from more than a dozen media outlets crowded at the entrance, with cameras lined up in a row and microphones standing like a forest.
At exactly ten o'clock in the morning, two black Lincoln sedans stopped at the entrance of the building.
The car doors opened, and Frank and Jim Clark walked out side by side, followed by their respective legal teams, including Alan Schuman and Kim Wexler.
Kim had finally participated in Frank's major case as she wished.
She deliberately flashed a bright smile at the reporters' cameras.
Participating in this largest antitrust case in the world was enough to make her famous in one battle.
Flashlights crackled and lit up in a flurry.
"Mr. Frank! Netscape and Google officially submitted complaints to the Department of Justice today. What specific behaviors of Microsoft are being accused?"
"Mr. Clark! External speculation suggests this is the Department of Justice's first shot at the tech industry after Bill Clinton's re-election. What is your attitude?"
Frank and Jim did not answer.
The group passed through security and stepped into the elevator.
The office of the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice is on the fifth floor.
The corridor is paved with dark blue carpets, and portraits of past Attorneys General hang on the wall.
Assistant Attorney General Joel Klein was already waiting at the door of the conference room.
Klein was in his early fifties, slightly bald on top, wearing a pair of gold-rimmed glasses, a dark gray suit, and a meticulous tie.
Standing behind him were several senior lawyers from the Antitrust Division.
"Mr. Frank, Mr. Clark." Klein reached out and shook hands with both of them one by one, "Welcome, please come in."
Frank and Jim sat down on one side.
The legal team spread out the documents on the table.
"Mr. Klein." Frank pushed the first document in front of Klein, "This is the official complaint from Google and Netscape. It is divided into five parts, covering Microsoft's behaviors in the browser market such as exclusive agreements, technological blockades, tying, standard tampering, and abuse of dominant market position."
Klein opened the document and read it page by page.
The conference room quieted down, leaving only the rustle of turning pages.
A few minutes later, Klein closed the document.
"Mr. Frank, Jim, I need to tell you something frankly." Klein put on his glasses, "The president summoned me alone the day after his re-election and told me to ensure that our market is fair."
"Therefore, your complaint will be handled with the highest priority, and I will try my best to promote the antitrust investigation against Microsoft." Klein patted the document, "But Microsoft will not sit idly by. Mr. Frank, you must be mentally prepared."
"Thank you for the trouble, Mr. Klein."
---
In the first week of December, Microsoft's counterattack arrived as expected.
Microsoft Vice President Paul Maritz held a large press conference at the Washington National Press Club, with hundreds of reporters present at the scene.
Maritz stood at the podium, behind which was a huge projection screen with a slogan printed on it: Innovation Should Not Be Punished — Microsoft's Antitrust Defense.
"Everyone," Maritz faced the dense cameras off stage, "Recently, some competitors have united in an attempt to use government power to strike down Microsoft. Their accusation, summed up in one sentence, is that Microsoft's integration of the IE Browser into Windows constitutes unfair competition."
He pressed the remote control, and a chart appeared on the projection screen.
"Let me answer this question clearly here. The IE Browser is not an independent software product; it is an integrated functional module of the Windows operating system, just like the file manager, control panel, and multimedia player. Integrating the browser into the operating system is a natural result of technological progress, rather than any illegal tying."
"In fact," Maritz continued, "Microsoft's actions fully comply with the Consent Decree reached with the Department of Justice in 1994. This agreement clearly recognizes Microsoft's right to integrate new features into the operating system. Our competitors are trying to misinterpret the meaning of this agreement simply because their browser products cannot compete with the IE Browser in the market."
He turned to the next slide.
"In addition, I would like to remind everyone of a simple fact: the Internet market is a highly open and competitive market. Any company can freely develop a browser, and any user can freely download and use the browser they like. The barrier to entry in this market is almost zero — you can even download and install Netscape or Google's browser within an afternoon. Talking about 'monopoly' in such a market is absurd in itself."
"At the same time, we will also provide evidence to the Department of Justice. We at Microsoft do not accept slanders!"
Less than two hours after the press conference ended, Microsoft's PR offensive began to spread across the United States.
CNN broadcasted clips of Maritz's press conference on the evening news, with the headline: "The Browser War is Market Competition, Not Monopoly".
The Wall Street Journal published an opinion article written by a law professor at Columbia Pictures University.
The core view of the article was: "The 1994 Consent Decree is a settlement agreement reached voluntarily by both parties, and the Department of Justice should respect the spirit of this agreement. If the government now overturns this agreement and re-investigates Microsoft's responsibility, it will send a dangerous signal to the entire tech industry — the government can tear up agreements with enterprises at will."
The commentary of The Economist was even sharper: "The complaints of Netscape and Google are essentially the continuation of a commercial war. They cannot defeat Microsoft in the market, so they choose to take action in court. If the Department of Justice succumbs to the pressure of these competitors, US antitrust enforcement will be reduced to a tool for commercial competition."
What Frank cared about even more was the movement on Capitol Hill.
On December 5, three senators jointly issued a public statement asking the Department of Justice to "prudently evaluate" the antitrust investigation against Microsoft.
The statement specifically mentioned the 1994 Consent Decree: "Congress respects the independence of the Department of Justice, but we also hope that the Department of Justice notes that the Consent Decree represents a consensus reached by both parties after full negotiations. Without new evidence proving that Microsoft has violated the terms of the Consent Decree, initiating a new investigation is inappropriate."
That evening, Frank received a call from Klein in his office at the Science and Technology Park.
"Mr. Frank," Klein's voice sounded much more exhausted, "I need to brief you on a situation."
"Please speak."
"The investigation has encountered some resistance." Klein said very directly, "The Antitrust Bureau held two special seminar meetings internally, and the focus was the scope of application of the 1994 Consent Decree. Some people insisted that the Consent Decree did not explicitly prohibit browser integration, so Microsoft's actions do not constitute a violation. Another group, although inclined to support the investigation, admitted that the current evidence is insufficient."
"What is the conclusion?"
"It is temporarily difficult for the investigation to enter the formal stage." Klein said, "I will strive to maintain the current review status, but if there is no new breakthrough evidence, opponents may push to terminate the investigation process at the next meeting."
Frank frowned.
Klein was silent for a few seconds, then lowered his voice.
"Mr. Frank, what I am saying now does not represent the position of the Department of Justice, but just a personal suggestion to you."
"Go ahead."
"The 1994 Consent Decree did not give a clear definition and limited scope to 'integrated products'. Whether the browser is within this scope needs to be redefined. The key now is that you need to supplement new evidence, not peripheral or indirect evidence, for example, the original contracts between Microsoft and PC manufacturers, with exclusive clauses written in black and white."
"Mr. Frank, if there is these, when they use the vague terms of the Consent Decree to excuse Microsoft again, I can use this evidence to dismiss it, thereby continuing to push the antitrust investigation forward."
"Thank you, Director Klein."
