As the trackers set out, that chestnut tree stood alone, its withered leaves hanging limply from the branches, shivering in the cold wind. Even though Fain had given Aragorn a certain possibility, the Ranger still insisted on searching for tracks as if dealing with an enemy, and the Little Mage agreed with his approach. After all, a Ranger who had survived in the wild for years possessed far richer experience than he did.

Everyone searched carefully near the camp. The Ranger searched slowly outward, coming to the campfire ashes near the riverbank, and then resumed tracking all the way toward the hill where the battle had broken out. Suddenly, he bent down, pressing his face almost against the grass. Then he called out loudly to the others. The trackers immediately ran over; after all this time, they had only found some scattered dead branches.

"There is finally a clue!" Aragorn said, holding up a damaged leaf for them to see. It was a large greyish-white leaf with a golden sheen, which was now fading to brown. The Ranger said, "This is a mallorn leaf from Lothlórien, and it is still stained with tiny debris, and there is some debris on the grass as well. Look, there are also a few pieces of cut rope nearby."

"Here is the knife that cut the rope!" Gimli said, bending down from the tangled grass trampled by many heavy feet to pull out a serrated dagger. The hilt of this dagger was broken and had fallen aside. The dwarf picked up the hilt gingerly, observing it with disgust. It was a weapon of the Orcs, shaped like a hideous head with slanting eyes and a grinning mouth.

"As such, this is the most baffling puzzle we have encountered," Legolas said. "A bound captive escaped both the clutches of the Orcs and the encirclement of the cavalry, and then he stopped in this still completely exposed place, cutting his bonds with an Orcs-knife. But how on earth did he do it? If his feet were bound, how could he walk? If his arms were bound, how could he use a knife? If neither his hands nor feet were bound, why did he cut the ropes? He was even rather pleased with his own feat, so he sat down quietly to eat some traveling rations—even without the mallorn leaf, this alone would be enough to show that he is a Hobbits; this lovely race is always so gluttonous, and they all have sturdy little bellies."

"I'll be damned if there isn't sorcery here!" Gimli widened his eyes, and immediately apologized to the wizard in the group, "Sorry, Little Mage, this kind of sorcery is not the same thing as your magic."

"It's fine." Fain rolled his eyes secretly. It was rare to see spellcasters among the race of dwarves, but their achievements in runes and metallurgy made the magical weapons unique to their race renowned. The chief deity of the dwarves in this world was probably Aulë.

"When this matter is over, I will take you to Erebor to have a good look. However, we must solve this puzzle first." The dwarf patted Fain on the waist and said, "What was that old man doing at the time? Aragorn, what do you think of Legolas's explanation? Do you have a better one?"

"Perhaps I do," the Ranger said. "There are other close-at-hand signs you didn't notice. I agree with this: the captive is a Hobbits, and before he came here, either his hands or feet must have been untied. I guess it was his hands, because that way the puzzle is easier to solve, and also because I found from the marks nearby that he was carried here by an Orcs. Some blood was spattered over there, just a few paces away; that was the black blood of an Orcs. There are deep horseshoe prints all around, as well as the marks of a heavy object being dragged—it seems the cavalry killed that Orcs and later dragged the body away to burn it. But the Hobbits was not discovered; he was not entirely without cover, because it was night and he was wearing an elven cloak. He was exhausted and ravenous, so after he cut his bonds with the knife of the fallen enemy, he rested for a while and ate something, before crawling away to save his life. There is nothing strange about that."

"That is comforting," Boromir breathed a sigh of relief and said, "At least we know he wasn't killed along with the Orcs, and we know he actually ran into the forest."

"Yes, he probably still had some Lembas on him, and no one knows when he stuffed it into his pocket. That's just how Hobbits are; their pockets are always full of food. It really is too hard on them to let them join the expedition—heaven knows how hungry they usually are," Aragorn said. "I only said 'he', but I still hope and suspect that Pippin and Merry came here together, though I haven't found clear evidence of that."

"Then regarding one of our two friends whose hands weren't bound, what do you make of that?" Gimli asked.

"I don't know what that's about," Aragorn shook his head. "I also don't know why an Orcs would carry them away, but it certainly wasn't to help them escape, of that we can be certain. Wait, I think I understand something: why were those Orcs content with just capturing Merry and Pippin? They didn't search for the rest of us, nor did they attack our camp, but instead hurried at full speed toward Isengard—could they have thought they had caught the Ring-bearer and his loyal companion? But I suppose the masters of these Orcs, even if they knew full well, wouldn't give such explicit orders to the Orcs, let alone mention the One Ring; Orcs are hardly trustworthy and reliable servants."

"Perhaps the Orcs only knew they had to catch Hobbits, two of them," Ciri said. "It is said that Mordor has no plants, nor does it raise animals, let alone hunt. I think some Orcs must have had a craving and wanted to bring the Hobbits here to eat them—Hobbits surely taste better than stones."

"That is entirely possible," the Ranger said. "While they might not necessarily have wanted to eat the Hobbits, someone certainly attempted to sneak away with the precious captives. This is betrayal, something the race of Orcs is quite capable of doing. In any case, we can be certain that at least one of our friends has escaped, and our task is to find him and help him, and then return to Rohan. Since he was forced to enter a place like Fangorn Forest, we must not be frightened off either."

"I don't know which is more terrifying to me: entering Fangorn Forest, or trying to trek across Rohan on foot," Gimli said.

Now that they had reached some conclusions, the Ranger had a direction for finding tracks. Before long, Aragorn found fresh traces. At a spot near the bank of the Entwash, he discovered footprints—they belonged to a Hobbits, but the prints were very shallow; if the ground here hadn't been soft, they might not have left any marks at all. Then, right at the base of a large tree on the edge of the forest, he found more footprints, but the ground there was bare and dry, so even the Ranger couldn't make anything out.

"At least one Hobbits stood here for a moment, looked back, and then turned and walked into the forest," Aragorn surmised as best as he could.

"It seems we must go in," the dwarf sighed. "But I don't like this Fangorn Forest."

"I am not worried that we will encounter danger by entering Fangorn Forest, and the Hobbits shouldn't be either," Legolas said. "No matter what the legends say, I feel this forest does not give a sense of evil, which is the complete opposite of the Mines of Moria."

The Elf stood beneath the green shade of the forest, leaning forward to listen, and stared wide-eyed into the shadows. Ciri stood by curiously, imitating Legolas's manner as she looked inside. The Elf said, "No, it is not evil; or rather, if there is evil within, it is far away. I merely barely perceive the faint echoes from the dark places of those black-hearted trees. There is no malice near us, but there is alertness and anger."

"How can you sense that?" Ciri asked. "I can't see anything at all."

"Because Elves are the Firstborn. When the Elves first awoke, the very first thing they saw among all things was the stars in the sky, and the first sounds that reached their ears were the sound of running water and the sound of waterfalls crashing against rocks," Legolas said. "Elves have seen the beauty of the world and utterly detest evil. But if Elves too can fall—when they excessively cherish what they have made, or give birth to jealousy—tragedy and disaster will also descend upon them. But in any case, the power of the Elves is completely incompatible with evil. This feeling is something I cannot describe; simply put, it is intuition."

"Yet we haven't harmed those trees," the dwarf said. "They have no reason to be angry with me."

"Fortunately so." Legolas turned his head and said to Gimli, "However, it has indeed been harmed. Something is happening in the forest, or is about to happen. Didn't you feel that tense atmosphere? It is making it hard for me to breathe."

But apart from Legolas, the others felt nothing, only thinking that the air here was stuffy and smelled musty. But the Elf explained that this was because the forest was extremely ancient. By comparison, Legolas even felt as if he had grown younger. Ever since he began traveling with this group of children in the Fellowship—yes, in Legolas's eyes, they were all children—this was the first time he had such a feeling; he even felt that if one were to come to this forest in peaceful times, it would be extremely joyful.

Gimli was unsurprised by this; in the eyes of dwarves, the race of Elves were all a bit eccentric, let alone that Legolas was a Woodland Elf. But the dwarf still felt that they should be prepared, and if necessary, he would immediately swing his axe to chop down trees.

The trackers cautiously broke into Fangorn Forest. As the leader, Aragorn's job was tracking, while the others were responsible for keeping watch, but in this forest, even the Ranger could find very few tracks. Because the ground here was very dry and covered with fallen leaves, he still estimated that the fugitives would stay near water sources, so he frequently turned back to the banks of the stream, where he saw the footprints of two Hobbits.

"This is good news; they are still alive and doing quite well," the Ranger pointed at the footprints and said. "Wet footprints are still somewhat different from dry ones; they washed their feet here, and perhaps even drank water, though one print is slightly larger than the other. However, these traces seem to be from two days ago; the two Hobbits appear to have left the water's edge from here."

The Ranger led them to continue following the barely visible footsteps, coming to a steep cliff where the path abruptly ended. They raised their heads, looking up at the rock face and the rough stairs leading to the high rocky ledge. Beams of sunlight shone through the rolling, rushing clouds, and the forest no longer looked so gloomy and grey at that moment.

"Let us go up and see the scenery around us!" Legolas slung his longbow back over his shoulder. "I still feel out of breath and really want to taste the fresher air for a while."

The dwarf climbed steadily on this steep rock face; Ciri and Fain were no strangers to such climbing either, whereas the tall Boromir appeared very cautious, afraid of accidentally falling. The Ranger purposely walked at the very end, climbing very slowly because he spent the entire way carefully observing those steps and ledges.

"I am almost certain that the two Hobbits came up here," Aragorn said after climbing up. "But there are other traces here, very strange ones, which I cannot explain. I wonder if we can see something from this ledge that will help us guess where they went afterwards?"

The Ranger looked around but saw nothing useful. This ledge faced both east and south, but only the view to the east was open; from there, he could see the treetops of vast tracts of trees, descending and extending in rows toward the plains from which they had come.

"It seems we have made a huge detour," Legolas said. "If we had left the Great River and headed west on the second or third day, we could all have reached here. However, not many people can foresee where the road beneath their feet will lead them until the end of the road."

"But we didn't want to come to Fangorn Forest back then," Gimli said. "No one in their right mind would think that."

"Yet here we are, and right into the snare," Legolas suddenly pointed in a direction. "Look!"

"Look at what?" The dwarf stood on tiptoe and looked in the direction pointed out by the Elf.

"Over there, in the woods."

"Which side? I don't have elven eyes."

"Hush! Speak lower! Look!" Legolas pointed and said, "Down there in the woods, right on the path we just came along. It's him, can't you see him? The one moving between the trees! Feyn Virdien Ryanlan, I think we need your magic; please have your staff ready."

The Little Mage nodded. His elven staff allowed him to cast spells instantly, but he still prepared to use abjuration spells; caution was the primary priority when facing an unfamiliar spellcaster.

"I see him, I see him now!" Gimli lowered his voice and said, "Look, girl, Aragorn, and Boromir! Keep your voices down! Aragorn, didn't I warn you? It's that old man, wrapped all over in filthy, drab grey rags, which is why I didn't see him at first."

Right there, a hunched grey figure was not far from them. The man looked like an old beggar, walking exhaustedly leaning on a rough staff; he kept his head down and did not look toward them.