Chapter 178: Excessive Indulgence?

“Economy?” Varian chewed on this unfamiliar word. He was well-read but had never encountered this term in any history book or legal code.

“Simply put, Your Majesty,” VanCleef dipped his finger in a coffee stain on the table and drew a simple circle, “economy is the flow of money.”

“As long as people can earn money through their own labor.”

“As long as the money they earn can buy the food, clothes, shelter, and everything else they need and want, anytime, anywhere.”

“As long as this process is stable, reliable, and protected by law and order.”

“Then, land is not essential.”

VanCleef watched Varian’s eyes gradually light up and continued, “A skilled worker building walls in Lava Fort, his monthly salary plus bonus is enough for his family to rent a decent apartment in Stormwind City, eat white bread and roasted meat every day, and his children can even go to school.”

“So, do you think he would still be fixated on owning a barren piece of land in Elwynn Forest that only yields a few bags of wheat a year and depends on the whims of the heavens?”

“What he needs is not that land. What he needs is a stable job that allows him to exchange his skills for a better life.”

Varian understood!

He understood completely!

What VanCleef did was replace ‘land,’ the sole means of production, with ‘job opportunities’!

He used higher wages and a more stable life to free farmers from the land, then firmly bound them to his vast industrial machine!

This was a more sophisticated and harder-to-break form of control than that of feudal lords!

“So—economic stability is the cornerstone of everything, right?” Varian’s voice trembled with a hint of sudden realization.

“Absolutely correct, Your Majesty!” VanCleef snapped his fingers. “You are truly the most talented student I have ever met!”

Varian ignored his flattery and fell into deeper thought.

He stood up, walked to the command center’s huge floor-to-ceiling window, and looked down at the bustling industrial area below, his brow furrowed.

“But history tells us that no kingdom’s economy can remain stable forever.”

“The history of mankind is a history of dynastic changes. Almost every kingdom, in its later stages, faces the same problems. Land annexation, the rich getting richer, and the poor getting poorer. Eventually, the poor, unable to survive, rise up and completely overthrow the old dynasty.”

“According to your theory, the poor losing their land is simply because they lost their source of income.”

Varian turned around, his gaze fixed on VanCleef.

“Then, the core of the problem becomes—how to ensure they can always earn money?”

“How to avoid the cycle of history repeating itself?”

This was the ultimate question!

An unsolvable problem that had plagued all the wise men and kings of Azeroth!

VanCleef smiled.

He knew that today’s lesson had finally reached its core.

He didn’t answer directly but instead asked a seemingly unrelated question.

“Your Majesty, before I answer your question, I would like to ask you something.”

“Do you think the phrase ‘excessive indulgence’ is good or bad?”

“Excessive indulgence?”

Varian frowned without even thinking.

“Of course, it’s bad!”

His tone was resolute, carrying the authority of a king and a moral judgment.

“Indulging in pleasure and being extravagant is the most shameful vice! It is a cancer that leads to the decline of a kingdom! The Light teaches us to be frugal and to exercise restraint. A qualified noble should be a role model for the people, not a slave to desires!”

These words were righteous, stern, and impactful.

This was a value system that had been passed down for thousands of years in the Kingdom of Stormwind, and indeed, throughout human society.

However, VanCleef shook his head.

“Your Majesty, in the world of commerce, there is no absolute good or bad. Everything has its value.”

He looked at Varian’s eyes, which were filled with confusion and scrutiny, and a mysterious smile appeared on his face.

“In my opinion, ‘excessive indulgence’ is just a neutral term.”

“It is not necessarily a bad thing.”

“As long as—they pay their bills honestly when they spend money.”

Varian was completely stunned!

He felt as if his understanding was being repeatedly overturned and reconstructed by this man in an unreasonable way!

Excessive indulgence, as long as you pay, is not a bad thing?

This—how could this be?!

“Your Majesty, let me give you an example.”

VanCleef stood up and brought up a vivid holographic image on the 3D sandbox.

In the image, a magnificent restaurant appeared. A richly dressed noble was cutting a sizzling, seemingly expensive steak with a dining knife.

“Suppose this noble is enjoying a top-grade sirloin steak from Goldshire. This steak costs fifty silver coins.”

“In your opinion, is this not a shameful waste? Fifty silver coins are enough for an ordinary family’s monthly expenses!”

Varian nodded; this was precisely what he disliked.

“However, Your Majesty, let’s look at it from another perspective.”

VanCleef tapped his finger lightly on the sandbox.

The image switched, showing a simple farm in Goldshire. A dark-skinned, strong-boned farmer was stroking a fat, sturdy cow, a simple, honest smile on his face.

“Because that noble paid fifty silver coins.”

“Therefore, this cattle farmer earned those fifty silver coins.”

VanCleef’s voice carried a unique, persuasive charm.

“What will the farmer do with the money?”

The image switched again.

The farmer, holding the money, walked into the town market. He first went to the grain store to buy a large sack of white flour for his family. Then, he went to the tool shop and bought a brand-new hayfork. Finally, he went to the tavern and bought himself a large mug of ale to reward himself for his hard work.

“You see, Your Majesty. Money has started to flow.”

“The farmer earned money, the grain store owner earned money, the tool shop owner earned money, and the tavern owner also earned money.”

“The grain store owner earned money, so he can purchase more grain from the distant Westfall. The tool shop owner earned money, so he can order more ironware from the dwarves in Ironforge. The tavern owner earned money, so he can hire a waitress to help him manage the business.”

“And that farmer, because his cattle sold for a good price, will be more motivated to cultivate more pastures and raise more cattle!”

“This process is called—economic circulation!”

VanCleef drew an arrow next to the circle, making it spin.

“In this cycle, everyone is earning compensation through their labor. Everyone is also using the compensation they earned to purchase the fruits of others’ labor. Money, like blood, flows continuously within this system, nourishing everyone.”

“And that ‘excessively indulgent’ noble, his seemingly extravagant consumption, was like the first beat of a heart, injecting the initial impetus into the entire cycle!”

Varian stared blankly at the constantly switching, vibrant scenes of the marketplace, his Adam’s apple bobbing with difficulty.

He had never considered this problem from this angle before!

He had always believed that the luxury of nobles was a plunder of commoners’ wealth.

But now he realized that as long as this process of “plunder” was a fair transaction, with clear pricing, then it actually promoted the flow and redistribution of wealth!

“Then—what caused the collapse of kingdoms in their later stages?” Varian’s voice already carried a hint of humble inquiry.

“Excellent question, Your Majesty!”

VanCleef tapped his finger heavily on the sandbox!

The image instantly became dark and oppressive.

It was still the noble, still the steak.

But this time, after he finished his meal, he didn’t pay. He merely contemptuously tossed down a badge symbolizing his family.

The restaurant owner, angry but daring not to speak, could only bow and scrape as he saw him off.

“Your Majesty, this is the problem.”

VanCleef’s voice turned cold.

“When a kingdom’s class structure becomes rigid to a certain extent, when the power of nobles becomes so strong that it can override laws and market rules.”

“They are no longer ‘consumers’ but pure ‘predators’.”

“Their estates can produce their own grain and meat. Their territories can mine their own ore and timber. They can even force artisans to work for them without compensation.”

“They have everything; they lack nothing. So, they—no longer need to spend money!”

“When money stops flowing. When wealth, like stagnant water, only comes in and never goes out, accumulating entirely in the coffers of a few people.”

“That vibrant economic cycle we just saw—dies.”

VanCleef drew a huge X over the spinning circle!

“The cattle farmer can’t earn money anymore. He can’t afford food, he can’t afford tools. His only way out is to sell his land and become a serf to that noble, working his entire life for a barely subsistence meal.”

“Grain stores, tool shops, taverns—everything collapses due to the loss of consumers.”

“The entire society loses vitality. The common people lose all hope of advancement. They are only exploited, and exploited again.”

“When this exploitation reaches a tipping point. When they can’t even get that subsistence meal anymore—” VanCleef didn’t continue.

But Varian had already seen the final, blood-and-fire tableau.

He exhaled a long, long breath.

That breath seemed to release all the understanding he had built up over the past thirty years.

He felt like a child who had just learned to walk, stumbling into a brand new world, full of unknowns and dangers, yet containing infinite possibilities.

“I understand.”

Varian murmured to himself.

“Therefore, to maintain the long-term stability of the Kingdom of Stormwind, the nobles are not important, and the number of poor people is also not important.”

He suddenly lifted his head, and an unprecedented, bright light burst forth from his eyes!

“Make those high-and-mighty nobles willingly spend all the money in their coffers!”

“Let money flow like the magma of the Burning Steppes, forever and fiercely!”

“This is what truly matters!”

VanCleef's face revealed a relieved smile.

He knew that this Lion King had completely grasped the essence of this lesson.

He stood up, walked over to Varian, patted his shoulder, and summarized in a tone as if sharing a business secret:

“So, Your Majesty.”

“If the rich don’t learn to be extravagant,”

“How can the poor earn money?”

Varian’s body trembled slightly.

He looked at the matter-of-fact expression on VanCleef’s face and was speechless for a moment.

He felt that he might never be able to look at the words “extravagant” directly again.

Just then, Varian seemed to have thought of something, and the spark of hope that had just ignited in him was mostly extinguished by a bucket of cold water.

“But, VanCleef.”

His brows furrowed tightly again.

“The theory is perfect, but reality is cruel.”

“Those nobles in Stormwind City, I know them better than you. They are a group of greedy, short-sighted, and extremely stingy misers! Their wealth is firmly tied to things like land, castles, and mines! Making them take gold coins out of their coffers to spend is harder than killing them!”

“How can you make them willingly spend their money?”

Varian’s question was like a precise scalpel, cutting into the core and most difficult crux of the entire plan.

Yes, the theory was perfect.

Allowing wealth to flow could revitalize the entire economy.

But how to start this cycle?

How to make those nobles, who were accustomed to hoarding wealth and enjoying the fruits of others' labor, open the rusty doors of their coffers?

This was like trying to persuade a dragon to share its treasure, an almost impossible task.

However, there was no sign of difficulty on VanCleef’s face.

He merely showed the confident and cunning smile of a businessman who saw a huge business opportunity.

“Your Majesty, we certainly cannot use ‘coercion.’”

“Coercion will cause backlash and create enemies. Our Defias Group is a legitimate business organization, and what we value most is making money in harmony.”

He walked to the control panel of the command center and tapped his fingers lightly on it a few times.

“We don’t force them.”

VanCleef turned around and mysteriously winked at Varian.

“We — entice them.”

“Entice?”

“Yes.” VanCleef snapped his fingers, “I am preparing to launch a brand new, epoch-making project for the entire upper class of the Kingdom of Stormwind.”

“I’ve named it — ‘Noble Class Consumerism Upgrade and Comprehensive Quality of Life Improvement Plan’!”

Varian: “...”

He swore he had never heard such a long, strange, yet—seemingly impressive name in his life.

“Consumerism? What is that?”

“Simply put, Your Majesty.” VanCleef’s smile became somewhat like a fox preparing to steal a chicken, “It’s about creating demand! Creating a demand they didn’t have before, but once they see it, they can never live without it!”

“Look, have the lives of nobles essentially changed over the past few hundred years?”

“No!” VanCleef answered his own question, “It’s nothing more than living in a bigger castle, wearing more luxurious silk, and eating more roasted meat. It’s too boring! Too unimaginative!”

“Their desires are still stuck at the most basic physiological and safety levels! How can this be?! This seriously hinders the healthy development of the Kingdom’s economy!”

As VanCleef spoke, he brought up a series of futuristic and technologically advanced design drawings on the 3D sandbox.

“So, my plan, step one!”

He pointed to a peculiar machine design, composed of gears, sound tubes, and crystals.

“Remember Rivigaz’s little gadget? The ‘Goblin Jukebox’.”

“We will launch its deluxe upgraded version—the ‘Noble Walkman’!”

“Its casing will be crafted by our best artisans using pure silver and thorium! It can store ten different pieces of music! From the most elegant serenades in the court to our Lava Fort’s most explosive ‘We Workers Have Strength’!”

“Imagine, Your Majesty. What would happen when Count Andre’s son pulls out such a gadget at a noble salon and plays a piece of music unique to him, which no one else has?”

The scene immediately appeared in Varian’s mind.

Count Fitzban’s son would be mad with jealousy! Then, he would cry and beg his father to buy him one too! And he would want a more expensive one! A diamond-encrusted one!

“This is no longer just a tool for listening to music, Your Majesty.” VanCleef’s voice was full of temptation, “This is a symbol of status! A trendsetter! A mark distinguishing ‘old money’ from ‘new nobility’!”

“With the first step, there will be a second step!”

VanCleef's finger swept across the sandbox, and more design drawings appeared.

“We will launch a series of luxury goods that ordinary people would never use, but which nobles cannot resist!”

“For example, the ‘Dragon’s Breath’ series of perfumes, personally blended by Master Mario! Each bottle contains zero point zero one percent of dragon pheromones, ‘amicably negotiated’ from Ony—um, from Countess Prestor! Spray it on, and you’ll be the brightest star at the ball!”

“Another example, the ‘Chimera’ series of pets, personally supervised by our future honorary dean of the ‘Life Sciences and Genetic Engineering Academy,’ Lord Nefarious! Perfectly combining the bravery of griffons and the elegance of hippogryphs! Each one is unique! Walking it down the street is a hundred times more impressive than riding a purebred elven warhorse!”

“And there’s the ‘Starfall’ series of jewelry! Crafted by artisans we hired at a high price from the Night Elves, who will polish the magical crystals of Eversong Forest into the shape of stars! At night, they will automatically emit a soft glow! Wear it, and you will be the brightest star in your husband’s eyes!”

Varian was utterly dumbfounded!

He felt that VanCleef wasn't designing products!

He was designing... traps of desire!

He precisely grasped the pathetic vanity, competitiveness, and possessiveness of the nobles, and then custom-made for them a series of irresistible, sweet cages!

“This is just the beginning, Your Majesty.” VanCleef seemed very pleased with Varian’s shock.

“Once they get used to these little gadgets, we will launch our—ultimate weapon!”

He waved his hand, and the entire 3D sandbox image transformed into a magnificent, luxurious, and modernly designed noble estate!

“The ‘Defias Smart Home’ total solution!”

“Why do a duke’s castle and a baron’s manor look almost the same, except for their size? This is unreasonable!”

“We will provide comprehensive, customized—interior design services!”

“The floor must be laid with our newly developed ‘Arcane Composite Flooring’ with built-in underfloor heating! The walls must be covered with ‘Velvet Wallpaper’ provided by Duke Wendell, which is fireproof and moisture-proof! The ceiling must be adorned with ‘Arcane Crystal Chandeliers’ personally forged by Master Brock, which can adjust brightness!”

“We will also have automatic flushing toilets! Refrigerators that can cool! And even an ‘internal communication system’ that can transmit your voice throughout the entire castle!”

“We will create a brand new, unprecedented living standard called ‘Modern Luxury’!”

VanCleef’s voice echoed in Varian’s ears like the whisper of a demon.

“When a noble enjoys the convenience of walking barefoot on the floor even in winter, drinking chilled wine even in summer, and not having to call servants to empty the chamber pot after using the toilet—”

“Do you think other nobles can still tolerate their dark, damp, peculiar-smelling, medieval-style antique castles?”

“No! They cannot!”

“They will frantically wave their checks, begging us to install one for them too!”

“Because this is no longer enjoyment! This is dignity! This is the last shred of noble pride!”

Varian was completely speechless.

He looked at the man before him, and for the first time, he felt an inexplicable chill from the depths of his soul.

This plan was terrifying!

It was interconnected, step by step, starting from a small “Walkman,” gradually pulling the entire noble class into an endless consumption vortex he meticulously built!

He wasn’t selling things!

He was redefining the meaning of the word “noble”!

He was using a slow-boil-the-frog method to convert all the solidified land and wealth in the hands of the nobles into flowing gold coins, and then letting these gold coins continuously flow into the vast economic cycle he had built!

This was more thorough than waging a war!

This was more effective than implementing a reform!

This was a—civilizational, dimension-reducing strike!

“How about it, Your Majesty?” VanCleef looked at Varian’s fluctuating face and asked with a smile, “Are you satisfied with my ‘small business’?”

Varian pondered for a long time, then looked at VanCleef with an extremely complex gaze.

“VanCleef—what kind of person are you, really?”

“Me?” VanCleef thought for a moment, then revealed a pure and harmless smile.

“I’m just an ordinary foreman.”