16
VanCleef's voice echoed throughout the Council Hall, clear, calm, and without a hint of anger.
He did not rush to refute them, but merely tapped his fingertips lightly against the humming arcane energy projector.
The charts on the light screen looked like an abstract painting from the hands of a top-tier actuary.
Intersecting lines, color-coded bar charts, and dense, nearly illegible annotations beside them.
Most of the nobles present could not understand this.
But they could feel a cold, unquestionable force called "data" rushing toward them through the light screen.
This was a completely new way of debating that they had never encountered before.
It was not a passionate speech, nor a debate citing ancient texts, but a cruelty that was almost like an autopsy, stripping facts down to the bone and displaying them before you.
"Lord Jeremy Martin," VanCleef's gaze fell first upon the fat logging camp lord, "you mentioned earlier that because of the emergence of the Defias Group, the log production of the Eastvale Logging Camp has dropped by thirty percent. This figure is basically accurate."
Jeremy Martin was taken aback; he had not expected VanCleef to admit it directly.
He puffed out his chest, a hint of smugness appearing on his face.
"However," VanCleef's tone shifted, "you seem to have overlooked another, more important set of data."
He pressed the next button on the projector.
The charts on the light screen switched instantly.
A new chart appeared on the wall.
"Trend Chart of Total Timber Production and Average Market Price in Elwynn Forest Over the Past Five Years."
A green curve representing "total production," after four years of stability, had suddenly shot upward in the last year, creating an exaggerated growth angle of nearly forty-five degrees.
Meanwhile, another red curve representing the "average market price" had fallen in response at the same time.
"According to the public statistics of the Stormwind City Commercial Association," VanCleef's voice was like that of a calm court clerk, stating irrefutable facts, "in the past year, the total timber production in Elwynn Forest has not decreased; on the contrary, it has increased by fifteen percent compared to the same period last year."
"And the average market price of timber has fallen by twenty-two percent."
"What does this mean, Lord Martin?" VanCleef looked at him, his eyes devoid of mockery, possessing only the calmness of a teacher testing a student, "It means that timber in the market has become more abundant and cheaper. This is a good thing for the Kingdom. It means our commoners can repair their homes with less money. Our shipyards can build more ships at a lower cost."
"As for the thirty percent of orders you lost—" VanCleef pressed the button again.
The light screen switched. This time, it was a detailed map of Elwynn Forest.
Dozens of logging camps, both large and small, were distributed across the map.
Among them, the one representing Jeremy Martin's family was marked with a red circle.
While the other two, belonging to Count Grayson and Duke Wendell, were marked with green squares.
Beside the chart was a set of cold data comparisons.
"Martin Logging Camp, unit cost per standard plank: 1.2 silver coins. Grayson Logging Camp: 0.8 silver coins. Wendell Logging Camp: 0.75 silver coins."
"Martin Logging Camp, average order delivery cycle: 15 days. Grayson Logging Camp: 7 days. Wendell Logging Camp: 6 days."
"Martin Logging Camp, log utilization rate: sixty percent. Grayson Logging Camp—"
"Enough!" Jeremy Martin could no longer hold back. His fat face turned the color of liver, and he stood up abruptly from his seat, pointing at VanCleef and roaring, "This is slander! You are colluding with Grayson and the others! Using improper means to drive down prices and disrupt the market!"
"Improper means?" The corners of VanCleef's mouth finally curled into a slight arc, "Lord Martin, are you referring to my engineers teaching Count Grayson's workers how to use more efficient two-man logging saws? Or are you referring to our Defias accountants designing an inventory management process for Duke Wendell that reduces storage losses by twenty percent?"
"The market is like a forest, Lord Martin. It does not believe in tears; it only follows the law of survival of the fittest. Your orders have not disappeared; they have simply flowed to those more excellent peers who can provide higher quality, cheaper products."
"As for what you said about the birds in Elwynn Forest no longer singing—"
VanCleef's voice paused, and he pressed the last button on the projector.
On the light screen appeared a shocking satellite aerial view.
It was a scene of the area around the Eastvale Logging Camp, captured from high above using magic.
Large swathes of woodland looked as if they had been scraped by a razor, revealing yellowish-brown, barren land.
Countless massive tree stumps stood on the devastated hillsides like tombstones.
"This is what your logging camp has done to Elwynn Forest over the past ten years. With this kind of destructive, cut-only-and-never-replant mining method, let alone birds, I fear even the earthworms in the soil cannot survive."
"And this," the light screen switched to the scene around Count Grayson's logging camp, "is the'sustainable logging' model that we, the Defias Group, are promoting. For every tree we fell, we plant three more nearby. We also regularly clear weeds and dead branches from the forest to prevent forest fires."
In the image, the green forest was lush and verdant, showing no trace of having been logged on a large scale.
"So, Lord Martin," VanCleef's voice returned to calmness, "what you lost was not orders, but a business model of an old era that refuses to progress or change."
Jeremy Martin opened his mouth, wanting to refute, but found that every word was blocked in his throat by those iron-clad data and facts.
He slumped into his seat, gasping for breath like a fish thrown onto the shore, deprived of oxygen.
The entire Council Hall was silent.
All the nobles looked at the man standing before the podium with a brand new, slightly fearful gaze.
For the first time, they realized that the most terrifying weapon in the hands of this Stonemason was not those iron horses that could run, nor his relationship with the King.
It was knowledge.
A systematic knowledge that they could not understand, yet was sufficient to overturn their entire world.
VanCleef did not pause, his gaze turning to another "victim."
"Baron Ashton."
The stone mine owner from the Redridge Mountains subconsciously tensed his body.
"You accused our 'asphalt roads' of stealing your family's business and leaving your Stonemasons destitute. For this, I express my deep regret."
VanCleef's tone was sincere, but his next words were sharper than a knife.
"However, as the Chief Royal Engineer of the Kingdom, my duty is to provide the Kingdom with the optimal, most cost-effective public infrastructure solutions."
The light screen switched.
"Cost-Benefit Comparative Analysis of the Kingdom of Stormwind Main Road Construction Plan."
"A two-lane road from Stormwind City to Goldshire. If paved using the Grade A granite slabs produced by your stone mine, the total cost would be approximately 120,000 gold coins, and the construction period would be about two years. After completion, at least 5,000 gold coins would need to be invested annually for the repair and maintenance of potholes."
"Whereas if we use our Defias Group's No. 2 asphalt concrete for paving, the total cost would be approximately 15,000 gold coins. The construction period would only take—two months. After completion, almost no maintenance would be required for five years."
"120,000 versus 15,000."
"Two years versus two months."
VanCleef looked at Baron Ashton and asked calmly, "Lord Baron, if you were His Majesty the King, which plan would you choose?"
Baron Ashton's face instantly turned a deep, bruised purple. He stood up abruptly, pointing at VanCleef, and roared with a show of strength that barely masked his fear: "You—you, what kind of monstrosity is that! It's black, it stinks! I heard it's even poisonous! My granite is stone blessed by the Holy Light! It can stand for a thousand years without collapsing!"
"Regarding the toxicity," VanCleef seemed to have anticipated this. He took another document from his briefcase and handed it to the court attendant beside him, "This is an authoritative report issued by the Material Analysis Laboratory under the Dalaran Kirin Tor Council. The report proves that the number two asphalt we use, once fully solidified, is stable in nature, non-toxic, and harmless, causing no pollution to water sources or land."
"As for'standing for a thousand years'—" VanCleef smiled, "Baron, we are building roads, meant for vehicles to travel on, not monuments for your family. Times are changing. Perhaps in a hundred years, we will have materials better and cheaper than asphalt. At that time, we will only need to lay a new layer over the old road surface, rather than like your stone roads, where every single stone must be pried up and re-laid."
"What we, the Defias Group, bring to the Kingdom is not just a new material. It is a development mindset that can be continuously iterated and upgraded."
Baron Ashton was completely speechless. He felt like a primitive man holding a spear, facing a soldier from the civilized world wielding a musket.
All his pride, all his heritage, seemed so ridiculous and vulnerable in the face of the other's cold, logic-filled "dimensional reduction strike."
The atmosphere in the Council Hall became increasingly eerie.
Those nobles who had originally intended to follow the trend and agree were now silent. They realized with horror that their industries they were so proud of, whether it was horse breeding or traditional cargo transport, if dissected using VanCleef's "cost-benefit analysis" method—the results would only be worse than Jeremy's and Ashton's.
Varian sat on the throne, remaining silent throughout. But his fingers, resting on the armrest, were rhythmically tapping. He watched VanCleef, watching him use a precision akin to surgery to peel back, layer by layer, those seemingly unbreakable and deeply entrenched old interest groups, exposing the long-decayed and backward essence within.
"Alright, regarding the minor commercial disagreements, I think we have discussed enough." VanCleef's voice pulled everyone's thoughts back.
His gaze finally landed on the man who had remained calm from beginning to end, even wearing a hint of a playful smile on his face. Stavren Mistmantle.
"Now, let us discuss the heavier and more serious topic raised by Lord Stavren." VanCleef's expression became grave. "Regarding the 'blood and tears' of the Defias."
He turned around, facing the huge light screen. He took a deep breath and pressed the button on the projector. On the screen, the complex charts and data all disappeared. Replacing them was a clear, huge name written in the common tongue— "Karl Reynolds."
When this name appeared on the screen, the corners of Stavren Mistmantle's mouth curled into a victorious arc. Karl Reynolds was the very "victim" at the top of his indictment. A poor miner who had his legs crushed in a mine collapse.
He had already made arrangements; as soon as the King summoned him, Karl would be carried into the Council Hall, and with his tragic encounter and tearful accusations, the Defias Group would be thoroughly nailed to the pillar of shame as a "sweatshop."
"Karl Reynolds, former apprentice of the blasting team at the Defias Group's Westfall Mine No. 3." VanCleef's voice rang out in the silent hall, sounding like he was reading a verdict. He pressed the button again.
On the light screen, Karl Reynolds' personal information was listed line by line. Beside it was even a black-and-white bust portrait taken using magical imaging technology. The man in the photo was around thirty, with a simple and honest face, wearing a hint of longing for the future.
【Name: Karl Reynolds】 【Date of Employment: Year 18 of the Dark Portal, Third Month of Summer】 【Position: Blasting Apprentice】 【Safety Training Record: 12 times in total, Assessment Result: Qualified. Attached: Signature of training instructor, and personal signature of confirmation.】
The screen even clearly projected the training confirmation form with the crooked name signed on it. Stavren's smile stiffened slightly.
"Year 18 of the Kingdom of Stormwind, First Month of Autumn. Mine No. 3, B-7 working face, a small rockfall accident occurred." VanCleef's voice carried no emotion.
The screen switched, showing a standard-formatted, clearly written "Defias Group Safety Accident Report." 【Cause of Accident: The on-duty blasting apprentice, Karl Reynolds, seriously violated Chapter 3, Article 17 of the "Defias Mining Safety Production Code." Before the blasting operation was completed and the safety alarm was lifted, he entered the work area without authorization and was injured by falling rocks.】 【Liability Determination: Karl Reynolds bears the primary responsibility. The shift foreman, Mesfield, bears secondary responsibility for inadequate supervision and was punished with a deduction of his monthly bonus and demotion pending investigation.】 【Attached: Testimonies of three eyewitnesses, all signed and fingerprinted.】
"After the accident occurred," VanCleef continued his statement, "our mine medical team arrived at the scene within five minutes, performed emergency treatment for Mr. Reynolds, and immediately sent him to the defias one employee hospital located in Moonbrook."
The screen switched again. A detailed medical diagnosis report, personally signed by Dr. Hansen, appeared before everyone. 【Diagnosis Result: Comminuted fracture of both tibias.】 【Treatment Plan: Use Holy Light healing to stabilize the injury. Master Brock Steelanvil custom-made a set of dwarven runic steel frames for him to assist in fixation treatment.】 【Prognosis: After wearing the frame and resting for six months, it is expected that over ninety percent of mobility can be recovered.】
"During the six months of treatment and recuperation," VanCleef's gaze swept over Stavren's now somewhat pale face, "the Defias Group covered all of Mr. Reynolds' medical expenses. Furthermore, in accordance with the 'Defias Employee Work Injury Insurance Ordinance,' we paid him his full salary for six months." "Here are the salary payment records between our group's finance department and the Stormwind City bank. Every transaction can be verified."
"After he recovered, considering his physical condition, we offered him a relatively easy position as a material manager at the Moonbrook Town warehouse. But he refused." On the screen appeared a resignation application. 【Reason for Resignation:】 Behind it was a crooked line of text filled in by Karl Reynolds himself. "I want to go home and farm."
"Finally," VanCleef looked around the room, "according to the lump-sum disability compensation clause in the 'Defias Employee Work Injury Insurance Ordinance,' the group paid Mr. Reynolds a compensation sum totaling fifty gold coins." "This is the receipt he personally signed when he received the compensation." A huge receipt stating "Fifty gold coins total," along with that familiar, crooked signature below it, occupied the entire screen.
"Lord Stavren," VanCleef turned around and calmly looked at the man who was already dumbfounded, "you said we threw him away like a rag. But as far as I know, after Mr. Reynolds received this money, he returned to his hometown in Duskwood, bought twenty acres of land, and married a girl from a neighboring village." "He is now a well-known pumpkin farmer in Duskwood. His life is—very good." "Therefore, I do not understand. Who exactly is this 'tragic victim' you speak of?"
