“I want to ask a question that our audience is particularly concerned about: can this material be put into practical use? And when will it be practical?” After asking a series of personal questions and receiving cooperative answers, Shui Junyi moved away from the project’s development process and began inquiring about what truly concerned the audience.

“You’ve been holding onto that question for a while, haven’t you?” Professor Duan joked.

“Not really. It’s an interview, so it always needs to progress gradually.” Shui Junyi was no novice; despite his young age, he had interviewed many influential figures in the Bay Area.

“Hmm, let Wang Xu answer this one. Last time we discussed this, he talked us all into a daze. Let him share his thoughts with you too.” Professor Duan smiled and deferred.

He knew he had already taken enough of the spotlight today. He was keenly aware of who the higher-ups wanted to promote. He had already gained enough benefits from this project and shouldn’t overdo it.

“That’s right, let Wang Xu speak. I’m not just praising him blindly; he genuinely has a long-term vision for this. “Zhang Hongyu truly admired Wang Xu, so he spared no effort in praising him. Engineering students are actually very easy to get along with; after a professional debate, whoever is more capable is listened to.

“Then I’ll speak. First, regarding whether it can be put into practical use. My answer is yes, absolutely, but not now.” Wang Xu nodded, giving a firm answer.

“What about the timeline?” Shui Junyi pressed.

“I don’t know. No one knows. It still requires dedicated effort for research. No one knows when it will yield results.” Wang Xu shook his head.

Shui Junyi was silent. He looked up at the two men who had been hyping it up. This is how you said you’d talk people into a daze? You didn’t knock them out, did you? He decided to cut that segment later.

“Professor Duan, what are your thoughts?”

“My view is consistent with Wang Xu’s.” Professor Duan was also a shrewd person. If Wang Xu didn’t say it, he surely had his reasons. If it couldn’t be said, then it was best not to.

In his heart, he elevated the importance of Wang Xu’s extensive remarks from their last conversation and simultaneously shot a warning glance at his Doctoral Student.

“Senior Zhang?”

“I agree with Wang Xu’s opinion.” Zhang Hongyu was also shrewd; seeing Professor Duan’s warning glance, he immediately understood.

Alright, it seemed these three didn’t plan to continue discussing this aspect. Shui Junyi wasn’t a fool; there must be something that couldn’t be said, otherwise, this wouldn’t have happened.

However, it was also simple: he would just cut this entire segment and ask other questions.

“Then let’s switch to another question, Professor Duan. As one of the first individuals to study in the United States after China’s reform, what are your thoughts on the current trend of studying abroad?” Shui Junyi changed the direction of the questions. An exclusive interview couldn’t focus solely on one project; it also needed to address some hot topics and discuss opinions.

“Studying abroad, ah, it’s a good thing. When poor, change; when changed, it becomes accessible. Going out to see and learn is very good. If I hadn’t gone abroad, I wouldn’t even know how to use a scanning electron microscope. Even if the opportunity were in front of me, I wouldn’t have the ability to seize it.” Professor Duan was clearly very emotional.

“So, would you encourage your students to go abroad?”

“Senior Zhang? He is already a Doctoral Student; going abroad would not be very meaningful. Even doing a postdoc would be a waste of time. If they were undergraduates or graduate students, I would encourage them to go.” Professor Duan answered decisively.

“Would you persuade them to return?”

“Of course, I would. You don’t know how short-staffed I am here.”

“Then aren’t you afraid that students might leave and never return?”

“What’s there to be afraid of? For every one who leaves and doesn’t return, there will be some who do. If they don’t come back today, they will come back in the future.

Just as the boss said, if a hundred go out and one comes back, it’s still a gain.” Professor Duan was a loyal admirer of the boss, which Wang Xu and the others had known for a long time.

“Society discusses this issue very heatedly. Many people believe that as the top institution, Tsinghua sends a large number of students abroad every year, but very few return. What are your thoughts on this issue?” Shui Junyi asked a very sharp question.

Wang Xu was a bit dazed. This question, even in his previous life 30 years later, was still being debated. Little did he know, this issue had already been discussed once in the 1990s. However, at this time, those participating in the discussion were still professional media, and they still had some integrity.

Wang Xu remembered that in later generations, the internet was full of scold (criticism) for Tsinghua. As an alumnus, Wang Xu was naturally very angry, so he asked in his class alumni group,

“The internet is full of criticism for Tsinghua. What do you all think?”

“Actions speak louder than words,” was the only reply given in the group, very Tsinghua, and very engineering.

After that, Wang Xu never paid attention to any discussions related to Tsinghua again, nor did he engage in online debates, because he also found it very childish, and even his own act of asking in the group seemed very childish.

Hearing the familiar question now, Wang Xu suddenly found it a bit amusing.

“Even so, they still have to go out. If they don’t go out, we won’t know anything. What will we do if we don’t go out?”

“But most of those who went out didn’t come back.”

“Even if they didn’t come back, they still helped. Most of the international research funding in China now is almost all brought back by those who didn’t return.

They indeed stayed overseas for a better life, and some even became foreign nationals, which, according to current newspapers, is very selfish.

But objectively, they are also helping us. I don’t know about others, but our scanning electron microscope couldn’t have been bought without those people. Personally, I have no standing to criticize them.

Moreover, how do you know they won’t come back later?

By the way, you’d better handle this segment carefully. I’m afraid it might affect their lives overseas and also impact future purchases of similar equipment.”

Professor Duan’s face showed some indignation and some helplessness. He himself had returned, but many of his good friends had remained overseas, and even his own ex-wife hadn’t come back.

He truly had no standing to refute. In the words of later generations, if your wife betrayed the country, how could you still be a good person?

Wang Xu knew a bit about Professor Duan’s story. After all, this set of scanning electron microscopes was quite new, and his successful introduction of it really showcased his personal ability.

In those years, successfully introducing equipment itself was a testament to one’s ability. Therefore, Wang Xu had also inquired about some of Professor Duan’s stories from Senior Zhang. However, Wang Xu had never heard about his wife’s story, as Senior Zhang was just a student.

However, Professor Duan immediately went on to describe the process of introducing the scanning electron microscope. After all, he was facing a China Central Television reporter, and he believed the reporter would handle the broadcastability issue well.

In Professor Duan’s explanation, the introduction of this electron microscope was actually blocked. The approval process alone took a year, and the Department of Materials Science and Professor Duan submitted many appeals, but none were approved.

Later, it was his former mentor who wrote a letter, stating that this item was indeed for scientific research. With this endorsement, the electron microscope was successfully introduced.

And this letter was sought by his ex-wife, who had stayed overseas, from his mentor.

She also studied abroad at her own expense and was a student of the same mentor as Professor Duan. When Professor Duan returned to China, he divorced her peacefully.

She, on the other hand, stayed in the United States and was now working as a teaching assistant at her former university.

A very ordinary love story. If it weren’t for the introduction of the equipment, it would have been as unremarkable as countless other such stories.

But with the addition of this equipment, the story gained a touch of drama.

Wang Xu didn’t know what the woman was thinking—was it for love, for the country, or merely out of a slight sense of guilt towards her ex-husband?

In any case, the result was this: she continued to hold a green card, work as a teaching assistant, conduct research, publish papers, and live a comfortable life.

Meanwhile, Professor Duan’s electron microscope successfully cleared customs and was indeed used for scientific research, causing no trouble for the other side. On the contrary, significant achievements were made, bringing great credit to the other side. Even his mentor specifically called yesterday to congratulate him.

Yes, that’s right. In this era, the United States would receive Science magazine earlier than China, and not just by one day.

In this grand historical era, this matter was truly small, yet it deeply influenced the Department of Materials Science. Other electron microscopes at Tsinghua were incredibly old and likely wouldn’t last many more years, while this one was the latest model and would be usable for a considerable period.

Wang Xu listened to Professor Duan’s narration, his heart unperturbed. Such things were too common in this era. If there were no surprises, a movie called “The Big Gamble” would be released this year, starring Ge You and Xu Fan, telling the story of divorce after going abroad.

In such an era, such stories happening and being performed merely documented the era.

When the era developed, stories would just be stories. People of the new era would no longer understand the era in those stories, so there would be new stories.

Just as Du Mu of the Tang Dynasty said in “Ode to Afang Palace,” “Posterity mourns it but does not learn from it, thus making posterity mourn posterity again.”

Wang Xu thought of similar remarks in later generations, pursed his lips, and had no desire to jump in and answer. This question certainly didn’t require his response.

After all, with his current identity, he was a pure-blooded, domestically educated individual who had surpassed both the Soviet Union and the United States, truly impressive.

No one could criticize him, whether it was twenty years ago or thirty years from now.

The atmosphere grew a little heavy. Shui Junyi realized his previous question was not good, and the answer had exceeded expectations. The anticipated scenario of someone returning from overseas, abandoning a high-paying job to make significant achievements and prove foreign professors wrong, did not happen.

Although there was no help from overseas funds, this crucial equipment was purchased overseas, and the process was quite difficult, even requiring assistance from individuals staying abroad. This made it hard to praise.

Moreover, just as Professor Duan worried, if this were broadcast, it would negatively impact future equipment procurement, which would be undesirable. Debates are fine, but they shouldn't genuinely hinder development.

Therefore, Shui Junyi decided to switch to another current hot topic: education. After all, there was a genius here who was educated domestically, so he could try that angle.

"Wang Xu, the newspapers have been discussing the comparison between domestic and international education recently. Have you looked into it?" Shui Junyi asked a preliminary question first, to avoid a blank stare.

"Yes, I'm somewhat familiar with it." Wang Xu nodded. This was also a fiercely debated topic in the early 1990s, the era when Japan's elementary school education was most popular, and various short essays were reported as facts in many newspapers.

You see, at this time, there was no Baidu or Google, and certainly no countless people living overseas to help debunk rumors. So, whatever the newspapers wrote, the common people believed. Returning to this era, Wang Xu had seen plenty of such short essays.

And why was the West so advanced, Japan so developed, and where had education gone wrong? This was one of the most hotly debated questions of the era. Concepts like quality education, happy education, and interest-based education were all introduced domestically at this time.

Many educators, without knowing the causes and effects, and without understanding the history of development, went abroad for inspections with a pragmatic attitude.

What they saw was a scene of advanced harmony, children growing up happily, and naturally, upon their return, they lavishly praised the advanced Western educational philosophy.

Then, the domestic scene followed suit, as it was a consensus in this era that the Western moon was rounder.

See? It's just that chaotic.

One moment the west wind overwhelms the east wind, the next the east wind overwhelms the west wind.

Even at the same time, on different issues, these two phenomena could appear simultaneously. How chaotic can one word describe it?

This was the 1990s, and Wang Xu, returning to his old days, found it amusing.

In fact, it was precisely this chaos that created the vitality of the 1990s. Various ideas clashed fiercely and wildly, vying for every mind, immersing everyone in it, unable to extricate themselves.

If you don't believe it, observe the people around you who lived through this era, especially those with higher education. Don't they all have an almost conflicted entanglement with overseas matters?

One moment they love it to death, the next they hate it with gritted teeth, even more melodramatic than Korean dramas.

Wang Xu's thinking was simple: there's only one rule that engineering students should remember: "Practice is the sole criterion for testing truth." Simple, crude, but undeniable.

Should people be sent abroad? Yes, because later generations proved that sending people abroad brings back money and technology.

Should quality education be pursued? No, because later generations proved that the college entrance exam is the only fair path to advancement.

"So, do you believe that quality education should be promoted domestically?" Shui Junyi calmly posed his question.

"I don't know much about quality education. Quality education is learning from the United States, right? Since it's about learning, I think I have a relatively strong say.

No matter what you learn, shouldn't you choose to learn what's good and right? If you don't know if it's right, at least make sure it's harmless, right?" Wang Xu's tone was as slow and leisurely as ever, without the initial excitement. A moment of excitement was enough; as a Beijing native, laziness was his true Nature.

"You're right. So how do you distinguish between good, bad, or harmless?" Shui Junyi was clearly intrigued by Wang Xu's opening remarks.

"It's easy to distinguish between good and bad. Practice is the sole criterion for testing truth. Just look at the results of its implementation, and you'll know," Wang Xu said frankly.

"You mean, we should look at the people who are educated?" Shui Junyi didn't answer the question; he was a reporter, and his goal was only to guide the conversation.

"Yes, Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Larry Ellison—these are the most admired new tech magnates from the United States domestically right now, right? Can they be considered successful examples of United States education?"

"Yes, they are all very famous and have achieved extraordinary things. But the achievements of a few individuals cannot serve as evidence for the broader context of education," Shui Junyi remained very rigorous.

"Very true. So what about their peers? Are they the backbone of the United States now?" Wang Xu pressed.

"Hmm, you could say that. They inherited the good foundations left by their predecessors, and now they are the ones sustaining it," Shui Junyi pondered briefly before answering.

"Bill Gates is 37, Steve Jobs is the same age, and Larry Ellison is a bit older at 48. This aligns with people in our own country in their thirties and forties being the backbone of construction, right?" Wang Xu patiently guided him.

"Hmm, I think I understand what you mean, but please explain it to the audience," Shui Junyi understood Wang Xu's logic but still asked him to clarify.

"So-called quality education, or happy education, is a byproduct of the education reform implemented by the Reagan administration in the early 1980s. It began to be implemented in public schools only after the rise of private education, and its actual purpose was to solve the problem of teacher shortages. Even now, it hasn't been universally adopted across the United States.

Regardless, happy education has been implemented in the United States for less than ten years. The people who received this education haven't even reached adulthood yet. How can we say that the success of the United States is a result of this type of education? This is clearly illogical.

The results of education should be observed for at least thirty years, meaning when these people are forty years old. That would be the appropriate time for evaluation.

Hmm, that would be roughly between 2010 and 2020. Everyone can guess what the United States will be like then."

Wang Xu thought about what the United States would be like in the future, and a slight smile appeared at the corner of his mouth. Then he continued:

"The prosperous United States we see now, those elites, the people around forty years old—the education they received in their early years is actually the result of education from thirty years ago. We should look at what kind of education they received thirty years ago, rather than studying the current educational methods of the United States.

This is a basic principle of research. We cannot use current prosperity to prove that the current education system is good; there is no causal relationship between the two.

Those three individuals, or rather, their peers, are the backbone that made the United States what it is today. If the United States is successful, then the education of these people is successful. This is where the causal relationship lies.

But what kind of education did they receive? I'm sorry, they received traditional education, very similar to ours.

The main subjects were reading, mathematics, physics, chemistry, biology, geography, history, and foreign languages.

Teachers could hit students, there were exams every semester, rankings, homework after class, grading, and even parental signatures.

Only after all of this was done did they have time to study elective courses like art and dance.

There was no quality education, no burden reduction, no students grading teachers, no students coming and going as they pleased, no students learning whatever they liked. None of that. They received the same educational methods as us.

The only difference is that the population receiving such education was wider than ours, and the content was deeper, that's all.

Therefore, according to normal logic, we should learn this. We should refine our similar education to be broader and deeper, learning from the United States' education of thirty years ago, rather than rushing to learn about education reforms in the United States whose results are still unknown.

I am not an education expert, but I know that happy education is not a new concept recently proposed; it should have a long history. But it has only been implemented on a large scale in the United States recently. Shouldn't we ask why?"

—

(Professor Duan's story is adapted from a story the author heard years ago about introducing equipment)

(A 5000-word chapter, finishing the exclusive interview, not subdividing it. Don't want it to be fragmented.)

(No update today, had an interview.)