16
“Let’s not talk about it today. I’ve been thinking about the method for scientific research evaluation, but it feels like there’s too much content. I need to go back and organize my thoughts, and then discuss it with the professors in charge.” Wang Xu casually brushed it off. Today was just a simple review meeting for the Department of Chemistry, and he didn’t want to steal the spotlight.
“Just tell us a little, if it’s not confidential. When you say scientific research evaluation, do you mean this kind of review meeting?” Professor Pang clearly wasn’t going to let Wang Xu off the hook.
“Yes, there’s nothing confidential about it. What do you all think of this review and appraisal meeting model?” Wang Xu didn’t answer; instead, he posed a question.
“Isn’t this how it’s always done now?” The answer didn’t come from Professor Pang, but from the main presenter of the day, the discoverer of this polyethylene fiber process. His attitude clearly showed some displeasure.
“That’s right, I’m not targeting this specific review. I also greatly admire your achievement. A process that can significantly reduce production costs is beneficial to both the country and the people, and its future prospects are excellent. My idea is unrelated to your achievement; it’s about this evaluation method itself.”
Wang Xu knew this situation would arise, so he quickly explained. After all, this was their home turf. If you show up at an appraisal meeting and criticize the appraisal meeting itself, no host would be too pleased.
“Haha, it’s fine, it’s fine. The review meeting is over, so let’s just chat casually.
Just because it’s always been done this way doesn’t mean it’s truly good. I also feel that this method is too subjective and lacks an objective evaluation mechanism. Wang Xu, do you have any good suggestions?”
Professor Pang chuckled and smoothed things over. Ultimately, he had the final say here, and besides, Wang Xu hadn’t really said anything wrong.
“Let’s conduct a survey. We’ve all been saying that the achievement is of ‘international advanced level,’ so let’s each write on a slip of paper what you think the definition of ‘international advanced level’ actually is, and then we’ll read them aloud.”
After Wang Xu finished speaking, he took several sheets of white paper from the side, folded and cut them into a dozen small pieces. He distributed them not only to the professors present but also to the students and teachers observing.
“Everyone write something. You don’t need to write your name. I can tell you clearly that there is no national standard definition for this, so just write down the answer you have in your heart.” Wang Xu finished distributing the slips and stood at the front.
Everyone fell into deep thought. It wasn’t a good time for group discussion, so they were all silently organizing their words, trying to describe their definition of “international advanced level” in their minds.
After about ten minutes, Wang Xu saw that most people had stopped writing. Clearly, everyone had written down their thoughts on the term. He then walked over and collected them, one by one.
With twenty or so slips of paper in hand, Wang Xu didn’t delay. He returned to the front and began reading them aloud, one by one.
“The achievement can be compared to similar products internationally. How to compare, what to compare?”
“The achievement can meet the performance indicators of similar products internationally. Performance, which performances? Highest performance or lowest performance?”
“Internationally leading. Hmm, this friend is concise. But are ‘internationally leading’ and ‘international advanced’ really the same?”
“Can publish international SCI papers. Using papers as a benchmark is an interesting method.”
“...”
Wang Xu read all twenty-something slips of paper once, and everyone quickly noticed one fact: among the twenty-something slips, there were few identical answers.
Everyone seemed to have an understanding of “international advanced level,” but no two people had the same understanding of it.
“You see, among those present are professors, lecturers, and students. In terms of identity, there are judges and those being judged. We are all debating whether an evaluation of ‘international advanced level’ should be given, but we can’t even agree on the most basic definition: what ‘international advanced level’ is.”
Wang Xu explained his viewpoint, uncharacteristically serious. This was a problem he had always overlooked, a very fundamental problem.
Today’s sudden inspiration was not only a novelty for everyone else but also for Wang Xu himself. His act of distributing slips of paper to write definitions was completely impromptu.
Because he suddenly found himself unable to define that conclusion. He had clearly given such an evaluation, but Wang Xu suddenly realized he didn’t know what that evaluation actually meant.
He had always emphasized fundamentals, doing various basic research since he started working on microphones. But suddenly, he realized he seemed to have overlooked the fundamentals of fundamentals.
That is, definition. If you are going to evaluate and give a rating, you should at least explain what your rating means, right?
These terms originated from a guiding opinion issued by the Ministry of Science and Technology in 1986, but few people had truly read that opinion draft carefully, and it did not contain definitions for terms like “domestically leading” or “international advanced.”
Descriptions like “some indicators reach international advanced level” were even invented later during the implementation process. How could such an assessment possibly lead to a unified conclusion?
There are thousands upon thousands of various chemical fiber products sold on the international market, from polyethylene, polypropylene, polypropylene fiber, aramid, all sorts of polymer fibers are simply countless. So, what product are we comparing our evaluated product against?
There’s also a more core question: what exactly is being evaluated at this appraisal meeting? Is it this paper? Probably not, after all, papers should be evaluated at a defense meeting.
Is it this polyethylene fiber? It doesn’t seem so either. This type of polyethylene fiber is already sold on the market; the professors from the Department of Chemistry at Tsinghua University merely produced it.
Therefore, the core of the evaluation should be this new processing technology. But the problem is that the professors present do not know what the processing technology for those polyethylene fibers sold abroad actually is. So, how can they evaluate it?
This was the second question Wang Xu posed: what exactly are we evaluating at an appraisal meeting? For this technology that fills a domestic gap, how should we compare it, against whom, and against which indicators?
This long string of questions instantly stumped all the professors present. Yes, everyone evaluates this way, but the evaluation itself seems to have no objectivity.
It’s not that there’s no comparison, but the comparison with foreign product performance is also focused on the performance of the polyethylene fiber itself. Is it really appropriate to say “international advanced” just because the performance is similar?
As for the processing technology that should be evaluated, you don’t even know what technology is used abroad, so how can you compare?
This appraisal meeting ended in a strange atmosphere, with every scholar who attended taking home a pile of question marks.
Wang Xu was no different. He wasn't an expert in this field, nor did he have knowledge of it from later generations. It's just that in later generations, when commercializing scientific and technological achievements, appraisal meetings were no longer used, but he hadn't truly understood the new evaluation methods.
However, well, in the 1990s, there was a core value: crossing the river by feeling the stones. What if you couldn't feel the stones? You felt the United States.
If you don't know where to find the answer, go to the United States. If you don't know the answer even in the United States, go to the United States military. They definitely have research in these areas.
Therefore, he simply wrote a proposal suggesting that China establish new scientific and technological evaluation standards by referencing the United States military's scientific and technological evaluation system.
In this document, he only wrote about hidden dangers, concerns, problems, and places where answers might be found. He didn't express a single word of his own opinion, because he truly had no idea.
— —
(See you tomorrow)
