16
Chapter 1144 It's Him!
When the Police Chief apologized to Lance, who wasn't even there, some people in the gallery chuckled.
Clearly, these were not good-natured chuckles; they were full of mockery and derision.
Perhaps in the eyes of ordinary people, this was the fairness of federal justice—it wouldn't condone your wrong words or deeds just because you were a Police Chief.
As long as you were found to have made a mistake and someone pointed it out, you had to pay for your error.
But in the eyes of others, this was the power of influence.
Sometimes it's hard to say what the difference between influence and law really is.
Perhaps people might think that influence only caters to a very small minority, while the law can cater to the majority. So, can it be understood as 'the law is the influence of ordinary people'?
Perhaps it can be understood that way, but the sad truth is, the influence of ordinary people, which is the law, is made by those who truly hold influence.
The Police Chief also heard the laughter, and his face flushed a bit, but at this point, resisting the court was meaningless.
In court, with the judge sitting there, even if you knew some of his words were wrong, and some decisions were incorrect, you couldn't question him.
Questioning the judge was tantamount to questioning the Federal law. Any issues could be resolved privately, but conflicts couldn't be escalated openly.
"Please continue, Mr. Chief."
The Police Chief opened his mouth, wanting to say something, but didn't know where to start.
He thought for a moment, then continued from his previous statement, "We had intelligence that someone was going to attack Mr. Lance White in New Gold City, so we planned to apprehend these attackers when they struck."
"These people are from the Perez Family, and they are very resourceful. I dared not underestimate them."
"The attack happened very suddenly and quickly. I didn't have time to react. When I realized the attack had already begun, I called for backup, and then our police cars started to move. That's all."
"I guarantee, I was confident in protecting Mr. Lance White's safety, which is why I made this choice."
Lawyer Robben shook his head and looked at the officer, "Is he telling the truth?"
The officer shook his head without hesitation and said, "He's not telling the truth. He told us to wait until the shootout... I mean, until the attack was almost over, and then we would clean up the mess."
"Because he felt that casualties on either side, attackers or victims, were acceptable. After all..." The officer didn't say the rest, but everyone understood.
Letting two gangs fight it out and then cleaning up the aftermath is an unwritten rule followed by almost all local Police Departments.
They wouldn't actively intervene in a shootout; that would involve great danger, and doing so would be meaningless.
Saving the lives of a few gang members would only lead to them committing more bad deeds in the future, but letting them lie there quietly, the entire city would be grateful to them.
Some things can be done but not said. When not said, it's right; when said, it's wrong.
Lawyer Robben thanked the officer for his statement, then looked at the Police Chief, "So, from the beginning, you knew these people were going to attack my client, and because of your subjective reasons, or some other reasons, you chose to allow them to attack my client in a metropolis like New Gold City."
"This is an act of murder, Your Honor!"
The Police Chief's lawyer immediately stood up, "I object, Your Honor! There is no evidence to support this point. The opposing lawyer needs to apologize to my client!"
He almost repeated Lawyer Robben's words. The judge thought for a moment, but Lawyer Robben explained at this time, "I am merely presenting my conclusion based on my line of reasoning. If you believe there is an issue with me stating the result directly, then I can express the thought process. I hope Your Honor will grant me this opportunity."
The judge's expression remained calm. He glanced at the Police Chief, then nodded, "You may do so, but if the outcome you present differs from what you state, then you will need to apologize to this gentleman."
In fact, he himself knew that if things followed the normal 'procedure,' there would indeed be no issues with the Police Chief's actions. If it were a different plaintiff, the objection might have been valid, and the outcome might have been different.
But the mistake was that the Police Chief picked the wrong person, not that he did something wrong. So the judge now also strongly agrees with this viewpoint: it is a criminal act when the person being attacked belongs to the 'privileged class.'
Lawyer Robben bowed slightly to the judge to express his gratitude, then turned to the Police Chief and asked, "Mr. Chief, is there any... dispute between you and Mr. Lance White, say, regarding work?"
"You said he was a gang member. Have you investigated cases related to him and had disputes?"
The Police Chief recalled. There were too many disputes, but he couldn't say them out loud.
People had just accepted Lawyer Robben's line of reasoning that he 'allowed attackers to assault innocent citizens.' If he were to admit to having a conflict with Lance now, it would be a classic case of abusing power for revenge. He was not so foolish as to say anything at this moment.
"Mr. Lance and I have no disputes whatsoever."
Lawyer Robben then asked, "Then have you recently been involved in case investigations surrounding Mr. Lance White, for example, do you always believe he is a gang organizer, are you investigating criminal evidence concerning Mr. Lance White?"
This was another unanswerable question because the direction was too clear. Simply put, Lawyer Robben was now looking for a motive for "this was a premeditated murder."
One of the most crucial points in Federal justice is the motive for the crime.
Even if a criminal is caught at the scene, but not caught in the act of killing someone, only found at the scene with blood on him—the victim's blood.
But as long as he lacks a motive for killing the victim, and then is given a reasonably competent lawyer, he has a high probability of being acquitted.
Such cases have occurred many times in the Federation. Even though every known piece of evidence points to a certain suspect, no motive for killing someone can be found, and the case ultimately has to be dropped.
Lawyer Robben's actions now were to find this crucial element: what drove the Police Chief to stand by and let all this happen without interference? If a motive is established, then his motive for premeditated murder would also be established.
He could only insist, "I have not participated in any investigation or operation concerning Mr. Lance White. He does not appear frequently in New Gold City, and even if he were to be investigated, it would be the work of other departments and other regional police, not related to me."
Lawyer Robben nodded and continued to ask, "Then you also have no financial dealings, for example, he owes you money, or you owe him money?"
The Police Chief glanced at his defense lawyer, the Police Department's cooperating lawyer, but it was clear that this lawyer was not presenting a very good defense strategy at the moment.
He could only continue to answer Lawyer Robben's questions, "No, Mr. Lance and I have no financial dealings whatsoever, nor does anyone owe anyone money."
Lawyer Robben nodded, "So, in all aspects, there is no possibility of conflict between you, nor does anyone wish to harm anyone?"
The Police Chief thought carefully for a moment, concluded this was not a trap, and nodded, "We have no conflicts whatsoever, and I do not wish to harm him."
Lawyer Robben nodded, "Since there are no conflicts between you, why did you take these actions?"
"Knowing that my client, Mr. Lance White, was in danger, and with the police already near the scene, capable of intervening and stopping the attack before it even happened, you chose to allow these attackers to calmly appear around my client and openly use handguns, submachine guns, and even rifles to open fire on the street?"
"Furthermore, in the immediate aftermath of the attack, you still kept everyone silent until the attack ended before taking action?"
"What were you waiting for?"
"Were you waiting for a result you desired, for instance, for my client, Mr. Lance White, to die in this attack?"
The Police Department's lawyer stood up again, "I object, Your Honor, the opposing counsel is clearly leading the witness with ill intent, his questioning triggers the court rule..."
Lawyer Robben turned to face the judge, "Your Honor, I believe that for anything to happen, there must be a motive, and this was the first lesson I learned in university."
"I believe that if we want to truly understand whether the defendant has some issues in this case, we must first understand his motive."
The judge considered the 'arguments' from both sides. He nodded, continuing to support Lawyer Robben, "Objection overruled."
Then he looked at the Police Chief, "You need to answer this question."
This was clear favoritism, and the Police Department's lawyer also sensed it, but Lawyer Robben's logic was sound. One could only say this was Lawyer Robben's home turf.
It's generally very difficult to win a lawsuit on home turf. As a lawyer, he understood this deeply. He was already considering talking to the Police Chief during the upcoming recess about whether it was necessary to go all out.
The Police Chief was also pondering how to answer this question. If there were no contradictions, disputes, conflicts, or hatred, then why would he do such a thing?
He was also considering it himself; he, of course, knew the reason was that Director Roland had asked him to do it.
He stood silently in the defendant's box, and his lawyer stood up at this moment, "Your Honor, my client is feeling a bit unwell. We need a temporary recess to rest."
The judge looked at the Police Chief, who didn't appear to be uncomfortable, and asked, "Are you unwell?"
The Police Chief nodded, "I'm a bit dizzy. All these questions are confusing my mind. I'm feeling unwell now, and the enclosed space also makes me feel fearful. I'm almost out of breath."
The judge whispered a few words to the person next to him, "Then go get some fresh air. We'll recess for ten minutes."
He said this, struck his gavel once, stood up, and left through a side door.
The Police Department's lawyer immediately went with the Police Chief to the nearby courtyard, because the Police Chief was not yet a'suspect,' so he didn't need to be confined to a room.
This temporary recess was within Lawyer Robben's expectations. He needed to give these two people a chance to think, and it was their last chance.
If the Police Chief still didn't intend to cooperate, then he would bring out some incriminating evidence about the Police Chief, directly condemn him, and then force him to compromise through backroom deals.
For example, the house, car, and the consumption habits of his family, which the Police Chief couldn't afford even if he worked for five hundred years.
There were also some cases he had handled where the results were clearly twisted by the color of power; all of these could send him to jail.
As a lawyer, Lawyer Robben knew very well that the higher a person's position in law enforcement, the more they feared going to jail.
A low-ranking officer might be beaten daily and have a difficult life in jail, but he might also get along well with criminals. It's hard to say, as they've been on the front lines for a long time.
Though they have enemies, they also have friends.
But it's different for those high-ranking members of law enforcement; almost everyone in jail has a grudge against them.
If he doesn't want to die, he'll know what to do.
Indeed, in the garden, the Police Chief's lawyer was quietly conversing with him, "Next, Robben might use more materials to exert strong pressure. Honestly, I'm not very confident I can handle him."
The Police Chief was smoking. He turned his head and looked at the lawyer next to him, "Is this Robben very formidable?"
The lawyer nodded, "He was a star student in law school and has been very successful in his career after graduation, winning many lawsuits that we thought were very difficult to win."
"If it weren't for some conflicts he had with people in the Department of Justice, perhaps his personal law firm would already be a well-known firm."
The Police Chief's first reaction was to find Robben's arch-rivals within the Department of Justice, but he quickly dismissed this idea because there wasn't enough time.
Even if they found someone now, and that person was willing to cooperate with them, it would be difficult to change the trial's outcome.
Unless the judge fell ill and couldn't continue the subsequent trial, he would preside until the end.
The lawyer looked at the Police Chief, who was lost in thought, and softly said, "My idea is, if this matter isn't too tricky, just find any reason to push it onto someone else, don't let the responsibility fall on yourself."
"According to Lawyer Robben's plan, even for the most ordinary dereliction of duty, I would find it very difficult to defend you. Official misconduct leads to jail time."
Hearing the word "jail," the Police Chief snapped back to reality. He pursed his lips, "I will consider it."
With only two minutes left until the court reconvened, Lawyer Robben walked over. The Police Chief's lawyer blocked him, standing between him and the Police Chief, "You're not welcome here."
Lawyer Robben smiled, "I just want to have a quick chat with Mr. Police Chief. You'd better not stand in my way."
As he spoke, he pushed the lawyer aside. The Police Chief, who was behind the lawyer, also didn't object, which allowed the lawyer to move to the side.
"What do you want to say?" the Police Chief asked.
Lawyer Robben smiled, "I'm just here to remind you that the law is just and relies on evidence."
"Anything anyone has ever done will leave traces, and these people often become careless because they weren't punished for things they did before."
"Mr. Police Chief, you not only need to think about yourself, but also about your family."
The Police Chief stared at him, "Is this your intention, or Lance's intention?"
"Are you threatening me?"
Lawyer Robben spread his hands, showing an indifferent expression, "Think whatever you want. I'm just giving a friendly reminder. Once you're in jail, having been a Police Chief for so many years, you're bound to have offended some people."
"I'm saying all this for your own good. Don't let yourself and your family suffer for someone else's business. This has nothing to do with you; you know that!"
He said, taking two steps back, "See you later, Mr. Police Chief."
When the court reconvened, the Police Chief's demeanor had clearly changed. Under Lawyer Robben's persistent questioning, he finally, after some hesitation, stated that his answer involved some important information and was not suitable for public hearing.
Normally, such a request to exclude the public during testimony had precedents and was allowed, but Lawyer Robben would not let him do that.
"My client, Mr. Lance White, once told me after we chatted—"
"Before the law, everyone is equal, regardless of whether you are a president or a beggar. Everyone is an independent and equal individual, and we are all protected and constrained by the law."
"Your Honor, I suggest that right here, in front of everyone, the defendant should say what he wants to say."
While the judge was still thinking, a staff member next to him handed him a note. He only glanced at it twice, then looked up, "A very unique point of view, and I fully support it."
"Defendant, you may speak here."
The Police Chief took a deep breath. He had already seen a dagger aimed at Roland, but he didn't know if this was all of it, all of them, or just the tip of the sword.
"It was... FBI Director Roland who asked me to do it..."
In an instant, the previously somewhat noisy courtroom suddenly became so quiet that only the sound of the cameras operating could be heard. Everyone looked incredulously at the Police Chief in the defendant's box. How did this case involve the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation?
Lawyer Robben got what he wanted. He was naturally the first to react. He walked to the side of the defendant's box, smiling at him, "Are you willing to take legal responsibility for what you've said?"
"Can you guarantee that every word you've said is the truth?"
Since the Police Chief had already made his choice, he naturally wouldn't waver again, "I am willing. I can guarantee that every word I say is the truth!"
