16
The reactions of Chen Shiyu and Zhang Ting were just a microcosm; in fact, after the final episode of Produce Camp was updated, the most immediate reaction came from Weibo.
This app, which was said to have been personally named by Lin Mo before he passed away, was always so fast and convenient when it came to instant social media, instant sharing, and interaction—
"Remember to go back after watching the sea; you can't see the four seasons in the deep sea!"
This was a music review about "the deep sea," written by the famous Xizhou music critic Music Critic Huang Qianyuan.
Music Critic Huang Qianyuan had actually been at the Produce Camp finals that day; he had attended by invitation of the production team.
After listening to the live performance of "the deep sea" by Luo Ning and Gu Xing, he wrote this review in his hotel that very night, but if he had posted it then, it would have spoiled the outcome of the competition, so he held off until today.
And as soon as today's episode was updated, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan posted this review:
"Lin Mo's 'the deep sea' is a song that makes one sink into it. The original melody is like bottomless seawater, carrying a bone-chilling coldness and despair. It accurately depicts the state of being swallowed by emotions and unable to struggle. Listeners can easily find resonance within it, but they are also very easily dragged into the abyss by that intense sorrow, so it is undoubtedly niche.
However, Gu Xing's adaptation completely subverts this!
Especially that rap segment by Gu Xing, which sounded like Buddhist chants—it completely reconstructed the soul of this song. I believe everyone could feel it very clearly when listening to this song:
The moment Gu Xing's rap cut in, it was as if a beam of strong light had suddenly pierced the darkness!
I could feel that this song was no longer just watching a tragedy unfold, but had completed a massive rescue operation!
Or rather, redemption!
Those who have heard the original 'the deep sea' know how desperate and sorrowful it is, yet the moment Luo Ning's voice emerged, it immediately transformed from sorrowful to gradually elevating into a maternal-like care and warmth, carrying a broad sense of tolerance. At that moment, she was no longer just recounting sorrow, but telling everyone experiencing sadness:
'Look, all things in the universe are loving you; why would you choose to give up?'
The original 'the deep sea' sang 'it's too late,' which was the end of total despair. Gu Xing's adapted version actually responds with three words: 'it's not too late.' I even faintly heard them singing it—
This is love, this is redemption, and even more so, it is the beginning of living towards death!
At this moment, I don't want to comment on the reputation or personal morality of Gu Xing as an artist. After all, he and I have never had any interaction. I am just a listener who heard him use his adaptation to engage in a soul-deep dialogue with the original 'the deep sea.'
Gu Xing is saying to someone:
'Even if you sink to the deepest part of the deep sea, there will still be people, light, and all things in this world trying their best to "push you back." This is the gentleness and redemption of a musician.'"
After posting the review, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan was actually a bit nervous, even somewhat apprehensive.
Because Music Critic Huang Qianyuan knew that Gu Xing's reputation was terrible, and praising "the deep sea" in his review might lead to him being scolded by netizens—
Even though Music Critic Huang Qianyuan had added a disclaimer in his review stating that he didn't want to comment on Gu Xing as an artist.
But as a well-known music blogger on Weibo, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan knew that most netizens didn't actually have the ability to separate the creator from the work.
If they hate a person, these netizens will simply reject everything about that person!
Therefore, in the hour after the review was posted, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan didn't check the comments. It wasn't until an hour later, after preparing himself mentally, that he opened his comment section, only to find that in this short time, there were already thousands of netizen comments!
The top-liked comment was:
"After scrolling to this review, I watched the show and still couldn't believe that 'the deep sea' was actually adapted by Gu Xing. I finally had to helplessly admit that I was redeemed. After listening to the song, I feel like my corpse is warming up today, and my livor mortis has even faded."
I didn't get scolded?
Music Critic Huang Qianyuan was very surprised. He looked at the second comment in order of most likes to least:
"After listening to the song, heaven knows how many times I brainwashed myself that the work is innocent. As a result, I don't know if I brainwashed myself too hard, but looking at Deng Deng again, he actually looks somewhat handsome?"
Music Critic Huang Qianyuan raised an eyebrow.
He had thought that the netizens' aversion to Gu Xing might outweigh people's appreciation for "the deep sea," but looking at the reaction in the comment section, it seemed that everyone's appreciation for the work had outweighed their dislike for the artist?
"Is this the 'the deep sea' I've heard? Is this the Gu Xing I know!?"
Seeing the third comment, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan felt that this sentence represented the hearts of most casual netizens. People's impression of Gu Xing was too poor, but the adaptation of "the deep sea" had broken people's inherent impression of him, so much so that everyone didn't know how to accept it for a moment.
Continuing to the fourth one:
"I announce that from today on, I will still listen to Gu Xing's songs, but as for the person himself, I'll have to wait and see!"
Is this giving him a chance?
On the night Music Critic Huang Qianyuan wrote the review, he specifically searched for Gu Xing's name online. As a result, the netizens' little mouths were like they had been dipped in poison, making cold sweat break out on his back as he read.
At the time, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan's feeling was:
Unless Gu Xing could make outstanding contributions to human technology or medical development, it would be very difficult for netizens to forgive him. Who would have thought that an adaptation of "the deep sea" would break the ice now?
"As a complete passerby, I must say that the adaptation of 'the deep sea' is textbook-level."
Another comment, a classic "complete passerby." However, Music Critic Huang Qianyuan tended to believe this person might really be a passerby. After all, Gu Xing wasn't a top-tier celebrity, just someone who had been popular for a while. It was normal for some netizens not to know him before—
"So, this wave not only allows Gu Xing to break the ice, but also attract some passerby fans?"
Music Critic Huang Qianyuan thought to himself and looked further down. The remaining comments were much the same, with only a minority still expressing disgust toward Gu Xing.
For example, one netizen said:
"Just listen to Gu Xing's previous songs, and you'll know he's a total loser. The adaptation of 'the deep sea' being so successful isn't because Gu Xing is great; it's because Lin Mo's original version is great!"
Or another netizen stated:
"What technical content can rap have? This song is clearly sung well because of Luo Ning; it wouldn't make much difference who did Gu Xing's part."
Music Critic Huang Qianyuan didn't reply to any of the comments.
The main reason was fear of bringing trouble upon himself; being able to fairly and objectively praise the adaptation of "the deep sea" had already carried enough risk. Secondly, he suspected whether there might be an "expert" guiding Gu Xing behind the scenes, after all, his previous songs were indeed a bit trashy.
Let's continue to follow this person's subsequent works; I wonder if it will be a surprise or a shock.
And just while Music Critic Huang Qianyuan was reading the comments, a bunch of topics related to Produce Camp had already appeared on the Weibo trending list—
#the deep sea#
#Luo Ning wins the championship#
#Chen Lingshu second place#
#Gu Xing Buddhist chant rap#
When the previous episode aired, Gu Xing's name also trended, but it was purely for being scolded.
With this episode airing, Gu Xing's name trended again, but this time, there were far fewer people scolding him, and there was even a very small number of netizens who didn't hesitate to praise him—
That was the sound of his reputation breaking the ice.
And as one of the main subjects of the trending searches, Gu Xing was naturally surfing the internet intensely at this moment.
"Let's check Luo Ning's first."
Gu Xing clicked on Luo Ning's Weibo and discovered he hadn't followed her yet, so he followed her on the spot. Then he opened the comment section of her latest Weibo post and immediately saw the top-liked sycophantic comment:
"So there is a Phoenix singing in the deep sea!"
Gu Xing chuckled, so Luo Ning is the "Phoenix" from Phoenix Legend, right?
