When Ishigami first appeared, he was timid, but at this moment, his style shifted suddenly; his image instantly transformed from an unremarkable high school teacher into a high-IQ monster delivering a heavy blow!

Living next door.

Ishigami, who was completely absent from the scene, was actually able to deduce the murder case based on a pair of shoes and Hanako Yasuko's reaction, even asserting with the certainty of an eyewitness that Yasuko did not kill the person alone, and that her daughter, Misato, was also involved!

And now.

Ishigami intended to use reverse reasoning to help Hanako Yasuko and her daughter create an alibi, allowing them to successfully escape conviction by the police!

"Damn!"

"Awesome!"

"I thought he was just an unremarkable high school teacher at the start, but now it seems this Ishigami is definitely no ordinary person!"

"He's a ruthless genius!"

"Ishigami was already wearing gloves when he knocked on the door, clearly not wanting to leave fingerprints; it turns out he had long ago decided to help Hanako Yasuko and her daughter destroy the evidence!"

"So cool!"

"The motive is very clear now; Ishigami is doing it for love, after all, the first chapter of the novel mentioned he really likes Hanako Yasuko."

"So this time it's not about deducing the murderer?"

"Next, we'll see how Ishigami uses reverse reasoning to help Hanako Yasuko and her daughter solve this problem."

"Chu Kuang is amazing!"

"This book has already hooked me in just two chapters!"

...

Qin Continent.

Lu Yang suddenly felt an inexplicable palpitation, even though he had only read up to the third chapter of the novel: "So the upcoming plot should be about the battle between the police and the criminal?"

It seemed he hadn't guessed wrong.

The story indeed shifted to the police perspective.

Togashi's body was discovered outside.

More colorful characters appeared one after another.

Among them, the most heavily depicted character was Yukawa Manabu, a physics professor at a prestigious university in Chu Continent, whom even the police often consulted when handling cases, showing just how formidable he was.

Through Yukawa Manabu's introduction, Ishigami's identity was revealed.

It turned out that Ishigami was a math genius back in college, and even Yukawa Manabu, now a physics professor at a prestigious university, couldn't stop praising his mathematical genius.

Why was such a genius so destitute now?

It turned out it was because Ishigami's parents were plagued by illness, leading to very poor family conditions.

Even with an extremely tight family budget, and even working while studying, Ishigami still couldn't scrape together the living expenses for the family of three, and naturally, he lost the qualification to take the postgraduate entrance exam.

Here, the background of the novel must be mentioned.

Chu Kuang set the novel's background many years ago, when Blue Star was relatively backward; if you had no money, you had to give up your studies, unlike today where there are various forms of financial aid. Furthermore, Ishigami was known as a "freak" at school and simply didn't know how to handle interpersonal relationships.

In short, because of bad luck, problems in the academic field, and various difficulties in reality, the current Ishigami was so destitute.

...

A battle of wits between Yukawa Manabu and Ishigami?

Central Continent writer Xu Ping stared intently at the text on the computer screen, unconsciously biting his lip until it turned white.

It was indeed a battle of wits.

Yukawa Manabu had originally been uninterested in the case the police consulted him about, but upon learning that it involved Ishigami, he immediately became enthusiastic and even made a special appointment to meet with Ishigami.

At the beginning of the meeting, Yukawa Manabu took out a mathematical conjecture that made many internationally renowned mathematicians feel complicated to test Ishigami.

However, Ishigami took it down in just six hours, clearly revealing his genius in mathematics!

But mathematics did not seem to equal reasoning.

Or rather, a math genius like Ishigami did not seem to possess the corresponding criminal ability.

Even though his methods of helping Hanako Yasuko destroy the evidence and divert attention were already very clever, the police still gradually caught some clues.

Was it about to be exposed?

Just when Xu Ping was thinking this, the plot took a turn, and Hanako Yasuko actually escaped suspicion of murder with an alibi.

"What an amazing Ishigami!"

"What an amazing Yukawa Manabu!"

The confrontation between the two was definitely brain-burning; the police no longer suspected Hanako Yasuko, but Yukawa Manabu insisted on some of his suspicions!

At this moment, Xu Ping racked his brains but couldn't figure out how Ishigami had completed the entire layout and guided things to this development?

The point is the alibi!

What method did Ishigami use to create an alibi for the mother and daughter?

The police investigated and found: from school, to the ramen shop, the movie theater, the KTV, and finally home to leave a message for Sonoko on the home phone, the mother and daughter's timeline was unshakeable!

However, the first two chapters of the novel clearly pointed out that Togashi died at the hands of this mother and daughter that night.

This timeline was definitely problematic!

...

The timeline was indeed problematic.

But no one understood where the problem lay.

However, the subsequent plot exceeded everyone's expectations!

Ishigami actually turned himself in!

He took all the blame upon himself!

What was even more terrifying was that he had designed his motive so perfectly that the police couldn't even overturn his statements!

"What's going on?"

"Why did Ishigami suddenly turn himself in, and his charges are completely substantiated with corresponding evidence; did he want to kill Togashi all along?"

"I can't figure it out!"

"We all know the mother and daughter killed Togashi, so how did Ishigami manage that fake timeline chain?"

"Wait!"

"Could this book be using Narrative Trickery?"

"If this is Narrative Trickery, I'll fight the Old Thief!"

"If it's a narrative trick, the plot should have deliberately omitted some clues, like collusion between Ishigami and Hanako Yasuko?"

"How could they collude on this?"

"That movie ticket really existed, and Hanako Yasuko and her daughter really went to watch the movie, so what the hell is going on?"

"My IQ can't keep up."

"I feel like I'm being crazily toyed with by the Old Thief."

"Keep reading, Yukawa Manabu seems to have found a clue."

...

Yukawa Manabu did indeed find a clue.

This person, the only one in the entire book who could keep up with Ishigami's IQ, did not explain the reason to the police or the excited readers; he went directly to find Hanako Yasuko.

Hanako Yasuko was a bit flustered.

She had already learned the news of Ishigami's surrender.

Yukawa Manabu smiled: "You seem to think I'm here to persuade you."

Hanako Yasuko forced herself to be calm: "No, I haven't. What do you have to persuade me about?"

Yukawa Manabu said somewhat embarrassedly: "That's true, I did say the wrong thing. I apologize to you, but I just wanted you to know one thing, which is why I came to find you."

"What exactly is it?"

"As for that."

Yukawa Manabu paused before speaking slowly, his eyes fixed on Hanako Yasuko: "What I want to say is, you know nothing about the truth."

At this moment, not to mention Hanako Yasuko's reaction, countless readers instantly widened their eyes.

Lu Yang in Qin Continent and Xu Ping in Central Continent felt a burning pain on their faces!

What does "you know nothing about the truth" mean?

On the surface, this sentence seemed to be spoken by Yukawa Manabu to Hanako Yasuko.

However, in reality, Lu Yang, Xu Ping, and countless readers felt that this was the Old Thief Chu Kuang ruthlessly mocking all the readers!

Damn it!

That detestable Old Thief!

What exactly is the truth!?

...

The truth was finally revealed!

In this scene, which could be called the great climax of the book, Yukawa Manabu said to Hanako Yasuko: "I think your alibi is probably true; you should have really gone to the movie theater, and the same for your daughter. You and your daughter did not lie."

Lu Yang: "This is impossible!"

Xu Ping: "That makes no sense!"

Hanako Yasuko in the book was bewildered, until Yukawa Manabu continued: "But you must also be wondering in your heart, why didn't you need to lie? Why was the police's investigation so lax? Because Ishigami had already arranged for you to just tell the truth when facing the police's questioning. No matter how the police pressed step by step, he had already arranged for the police to be unable to convict you. As for how exactly he arranged it, I think you probably don't know. You only know that Ishigami seems to have used some clever sleight of hand, but you are not clear about the actual content. Am I right?"

Hanako Yasuko was stunned.

Yukawa Manabu continued, channeling Sherlock Holmes and Poirot: "He made a huge sacrifice to protect you and your daughter, a heroic sacrifice that ordinary people like you and me cannot even imagine. I think... he probably made the worst-case plan from the moment the murder happened, deciding to take the blame for you when the time came, because all his plans were designed with that premise. Conversely: only that premise absolutely cannot be dismantled. But that premise is too cruel, anyone would back down, and Ishigami himself knows this. So, in order to make it impossible for him to go back on his word at a critical moment, he cut off his own retreat in advance. At the same time, that is also the most astonishing sleight of hand this time."

Hanako Yasuko began to tremble!

Yukawa Manabu finally revealed Ishigami's layout!

The true culprit of the body that died in the Old Edogawa was indeed Ishigami!

Because that body was not Togashi, who was killed by the mother and daughter at all!

Yukawa Manabu looked at the woman in front of him with complex eyes: "It seems you finally understand what I mean. Yes, Ishigami committed another murder case to protect you, which was on March 10th, the day after Togashi Shinji was killed."

Togashi died on March 9th!

On March 10th, Ishigami killed a homeless man whose traces no one could find, disguised him as Togashi's body, and successfully confused the police's line of sight!

What is a homeless person?

A so-called homeless person is that kind of bottom-dweller who disappears suddenly without causing the slightest attention.

Even other homeless people wouldn't be surprised, because someone among them is always disappearing suddenly.

No one would call the police.

Because they have no family, no friends, and even Ishigami himself didn't know the name of the homeless man he killed.

The timeline was of course no problem.

After all, Hanako Yasuko's alibi was actually about March 10th; Hanako Yasuko could just tell the truth, as there was nothing shameful about what she did that day.

Anyway, Togashi had already died the day before!

Ishigami killed the homeless man, making all the clues blurry, and intentionally guided the police to suspect Hanako Yasuko and her daughter, making them gradually conclude that the body was Togashi. Not to mention that in order to keep the police from doubting the authenticity of the body, Ishigami intentionally left three clues to prove that this was the body they were looking for, so the entire layout could be said to be foolproof!

...

Boom!

Lu Yang was stunned!

Xu Ping was stunned!

Countless readers who were discussing the plot and guessing the reasons while reading were stunned, as if their brains had been hit by a storm; they could no longer say whether their inner feelings were shock, being moved, or feeling horror!

"Amazing!"

"We all knew there was a problem with the timeline, but none of us could have imagined that the root cause of the timeline problem was actually because Ishigami killed someone to impersonate Togashi's body in order to confuse the police!"

"Hanako Yasuko doesn't like him at all."

"But to protect that woman, he didn't hesitate to kill another person. Such cruel and cold-blooded methods, a unrequited love filled with bloodshed!"

"What kind of devilish love is this?"

"The most terrifying thing about Ishigami is that to ensure there were no slip-ups, he went straight to turn himself in and take the blame. Now, the police are convinced that Ishigami killed Togashi. Even if someone discovers the real body of Togashi in the future, it won't be exposed, because no one would suspect that it's actually the real Togashi's body, since the Togashi case is already closed, unless Ishigami himself appeals to overturn the verdict."

"Devotion?"

"No wonder the book is titled 'the devotion of suspect x'. This is sacrificing one's own life to love this woman!"

"Why?"

"Although the truth is out, the only thing I can't wrap my head around in this story is why Ishigami would love Yasuko Hanaoka so much, enough to sacrifice his own life for it—this is the death penalty!"

Of course, there is a reason.

However, Chu Kuang clearly wouldn't let the logic of the truth become blurred. The subsequent plot is Ishigami's flashback.

...

That day.

Ishigami, having lost all hope for life and the future, wanted to commit suicide, when Yasuko Hanaoka and her daughter suddenly moved in and knocked on his door to greet their neighbor.

Ishigami opened the door.

The mother and daughter greeted Ishigami with smiles.

Yasuko's eyes were filled with a longing for life.

Even if the plot didn't explicitly state it, everyone knew that perhaps Yasuko Hanaoka and her daughter must have believed at that moment that they would completely break free from Togashi and live a happy, normal life.

It was such a simple reason:

That smile struck Ishigami instantly.

Ishigami suddenly didn't want to die anymore. He had once said this: "Sundays are the happiest. Just by opening the window, I can hear the voices of two people talking."

This was the beginning of love.

But is this really love?

Or was Ishigami's devotion just to repay a debt of gratitude?

Perhaps there are some things that even readers with a god's-eye view cannot distinguish. However, such an ending is clearly not the most cruel part.

At the end of the novel.

Misato Hanaoka committed suicide.

After learning the truth from Manabu Yukawa, Yasuko felt very agitated and heavy-hearted. But so that everything Ishigami had done wouldn't be in vain, and for the sake of her daughter's happiness, she decided to continue living with the burden of guilt.

However, the news of her daughter's suicide crushed her.

Her daughter couldn't bear such immense pressure and was tortured by a strong sense of guilt herself. As a mother, wasn't she the same? This was the straw that broke the camel's back.

Yasuko Hanaoka turned herself in.

When she made this decision and walked into the police station, all the schemes Ishigami had laid out, at the cost of an innocent person's life, were rendered completely futile.

...

The police station.

The two met again.

Yasuko Hanaoka's back was shaking violently, and her voice was hoarse: "I'm sorry, I'm really, really sorry. To have you do this for us... for a woman like me..."

"You're talking nonsense! What are you saying... foolish things... you're talking nonsense..."

Ishigami muttered in his mouth like he was chanting a spell.

"How can only we obtain happiness... that's impossible. I should also atone for my sins. I want to accept punishment. I want to accept punishment together with Mr. Ishigami. This is all I can do, this is all I can do for you. I'm sorry! I'm sorry!"

Yasuko supported herself with both hands on the ground, her head pressed against the floor.

Ishigami shook his head while backing away, his face twisted in pain.

He suddenly turned around, clutched his head with both hands, and let out a beast-like roar, which was also a wail mixed with despair and chaos.

That cry moved everyone who heard it.

A police officer ran over, trying to stop him.

"Don't touch him!"

Manabu Yukawa blocked them: "At least, let him cry it all out..."

Manabu Yukawa placed his hands on Ishigami's shoulders from behind.

Ishigami continued to roar, as if he were vomiting out his soul.

Defense broken.

When the final psychological line of defense was breached, Ishigami, who had calculated everything with no room for error and had played the whole world in the palm of his hand using counter-deduction, completely collapsed.

He should have succeeded.

He had already succeeded.

However, he lost to the human heart.

He lost to the instinctual human heart of guilt.

In the book.

The novel emphasized this sentence: "Sometimes, just by living well, a person is enough to save someone."

Yet there are some people who aren't even willing To Live.

But whose fault is this?

Togashi's or Yasuko Hanaoka's?

Or perhaps Ishigami, who loved pursuing extreme logic and should have become a great mathematician?

...

Qin Continent.

Lu Yang, who had been stunned for a long time, suddenly sighed.

The ending is the design of the puzzle's solution, allowing this mystery novel to showcase its greatest charm.

By laying foreshadowing throughout regarding the characters, the time and place of events, and even using some guiding methods to give readers a preconceived impression, and finally bringing a huge shock and surprise when the mystery is unraveled—this is the most successful part of this novel.

Unlike pure literature.

Besides its narrative quality, this mystery novel also possesses element of surprise and the rationality of its layout.

But is this Narrative Trickery?

A type of Narrative Trickery mystery pioneered by Chu Kuang?

Chu Kuang leading the reader toward a time-based deception is, theoretically, in line with some characteristics of Narrative Trickery.

However, the key point is that the reader and the police are always in a unified perspective, which breaks the setting of Narrative Trickery.

This is not Narrative Trickery.

Readers had the opportunity to guess the truth.

In fact, whether it is Narrative Trickery or not is no longer important.

What is truly important is that the extreme plot twists in the last few chapters of the novel bring too much shock!

Is this a novel that Chu Kuang rushed to write?

If this is a novel he wrote in a short period to compete for the rankings, then the extent of this person's terror is likely even beyond what I had previously imagined!

Perhaps he is not weaker than Xian Yu.

It makes sense that "southern xian yu, northern chu kuang" are mentioned in the same breath. Isn't this kind of plot setup a form of talent?

...

Central Continent.

Xu Ping smiled bitterly.

Most novels on Blue Star are black and white, praising justice and criticizing evil, or saying that legal principles and emotions are opposites.

Yet this novel by Chu Kuang sits in the middle ground between the two.

Yasuko, who is willing to bear the crime for her daughter;

Manabu Yukawa, who struggles between legal principles and friendship;

Ishigami, who breaks the law for the pure love in his heart.

The emotional expressions or motives of these characters can be said to be inconsistent with traditional justice, but it is difficult for readers to make a clear definition after finishing the novel.

Are they ultimately good or evil?

Perhaps this is no longer the focus of attention.

Complex feelings of heartache, sympathy, and regret intertwined are the reader's first reaction after facing the interrogation of the plot.

The detective is not entirely the embodiment of justice.

The criminal is not necessarily the representative of evil.

Regardless of which side, they all have human weaknesses and are drifting between legal justice and moral emotion. The characters inside are the epitome of complex human nature within a chaotic social value system.

Perhaps this is the terrifying part of Chu Kuang.

Under his pen, the key to solving the mystery is not limited to scientific deduction, but lies in the observation of human nature.

This is the space for reflection left for the reader outside of the deduction in the mystery novel.

As a reader.

Xu Ping once thought he already knew the answer to the mystery, so in the subsequent content, it should just be watching the battle of wits between the police and the criminal, not knowing that he had already fallen into Chu Kuang's trap at that time.

When the true answer to the mystery was revealed;

When the true meaning of the word "devotion" was clarified;

Xu Ping knew he had lost.

The tenth place in the writer rankings is likely going to change.

...

Novel comment section.

Centering on the ending of the novel, specifically how Ishigami, in order to protect Yasuko who committed murder, spared no effort to create a carefully crafted time-based deception through self-devotion, and finally turned himself in for love by taking the blame, became the focus of discussion.

"It feels stifling in my heart after finishing it."

"Ishigami continues to roar, as if to vomit out his soul; this closing sentence makes one want to cry a little."

"This is a mystery, not a tear-jerker, but Chu Kuang's writing has a kind of ability to make readers feel heartbroken. He has always been like this, leaving one's heart unable to calm down."

"After finishing, I feel like I've been ruthlessly played by Old Thief."

"This writing style is not Narrative Trickery; the story itself is the most shocking part."

"Ishigami, who calculated everything, used his incomparable brain to formulate an impeccable plan. After single-handedly orchestrating a trick that confused everyone, including the readers, he still failed at the final step of returning to the origin."

"Yasuko turned herself in, and I, like Ishigami, had my defenses broken."

"I think Yasuko's final decision to turn herself in can be attributed to the word 'conscience', so there is no need to feel regret over the ending."

"I cannot like Yasuko!"

"Yasuko's final action was a fatal blow to Ishigami. Only she herself has a clear conscience. If she truly felt grateful for Ishigami's sacrifice, Yasuko should have repaid it, and the only way to repay it was to give meaning to Ishigami's sacrifice."

"Ishigami's love is bloody and heavy."

"What touched me most was not Ishigami's love, but Ishigami's resistance against loneliness. Everything Ishigami did was merely one person's resistance against loneliness. All actions of seeking and maintaining a spiritual belief are, in essence, resistance against loneliness. The ending is certainly something to sigh about, perhaps even regrettable, because Ishigami's state of mind has transcended conventional cognition such as morality."

"Ishigami is not worth defending."

"Although Ishigami is indeed a genius, and his experience evokes sympathy, the fact that he didn't hesitate to kill an innocent person to protect a girl is truly detestable. He's just a paranoid simp who likes to indulge in self-pity."

"I do not accept any comments trying to whitewash Ishigami."

"Yasuko's act of turning herself in completely and utterly erased everything Ishigami had done. From this perspective, Yasuko is selfish, and Manabu Yukawa, who considered things from his own values and told Yasuko the truth because he felt his friend's death was not worth it, is also selfish."

As expected.

Good and evil cannot be sorted out.

This is 'the devotion of suspect x'.

And no matter which side the readers stand on, they cannot erase one fact: the degree to which everyone acknowledges this novel.

In fact.

Even those who vehemently criticized the novel's characters, such as Ishigami, Yasuko, or Manabu Yukawa who was determined to win against Ishigami, loved the novel itself deeply.

On this day.

'the devotion of suspect x' became a hit.

— — — — — — — —

PS: This kind of plot requires a large chapter, otherwise it always feels not smooth enough, so the update is a bit late. I hope what I wrote is clear to everyone. If you really can't understand it, you might want to consider reading the original work, as the space here is limited and I can't cover everything. Also, if you have any monthly tickets, please help click on them, supporting every dream~