Silver Blue Bookstore naturally didn't have anyone like He Mingxuan who would specifically lurk in bookstores to watch people. After the Supernova publications were distributed on a large scale across various bookstores in Qinzhou, the only thing that could somewhat reflect market results was reader feedback.

It started as just a few scattered comments.

After all, reading takes time.

For a publishing house, scattered reviews didn't have much reference value. However, as the first batch of readers finished the novels, feedback for the five Supernova works gradually increased on Silver Blue Bookstore's official website message board.

What worried the publishing house was... the Supernova's first-place entry, "Demon King from Another World," which the company had high hopes for, didn't seem to have a good reputation. Out of a maximum score of ten, the vast majority of readers gave it less than five points. It seemed people weren't interested in the novel's formula.

"It's just the same old tropes in a different package."

"The protagonist freaking transmigrated as a Demon King, yet he still feels like a loser. If you're going to write from a Demon King's perspective, can you stop making him so pathetic? Does the author not know how to write a book if the lead isn't a loser?"

"I regret buying this book after reading it."

"Ax it already, I'm not interested."

Qinzhou novels are published in volumes, so the sales of the first volume are crucial. Novels with poor sales are easily axed. The publishing house would notify the author to finish up quickly; a work originally planned for over ten volumes would likely be compressed by the author into three to five volumes for a hasty conclusion. After all, the publishing company needs to free up resources for works with more potential.

Many readers were bashing it.

Of course, not all reviews were negative. Some readers found the perspective of "Demon King from Another World" novel: "Even if it's old wine in a new bottle, at least there's a difference between the protagonist's identity and the traditional isekai adventure model. It shouldn't be axed."

Maybe it'll explode later?

Such situations weren't without precedent.

There was currently a very popular novel on the market that had a very mediocre reputation and disappointing sales when it was first released. The publishing house had even notified the author of its cancellation. Who knew that after two volumes, things would take a turn? The story reached a major climax, and sales exploded, leading to the cancellation of the axing plan. That book is still being serialized today and has reached its twenty-second volume.

However, such examples were rare.

Because if the beginning of the first volume can't attract readers, it's hard for them to stick around until things get exciting later on. Only by hooking readers from the start can a novel continue its serialization steadily.

It wasn't just the first-place entry that had a poor reputation.

The works ranked second to fourth in the Supernova also had very mediocre reputations. Only the second-place entry reached a score of five, but five points is only considered a passing grade in the novel market; it's hardly good.

"This year is going to be tough."

At a departmental meeting at Silver Blue Bookstore a week later, an editor sighed while looking at the reviews for several novels: "I thought sales for 'Demon King from Another World' would explode, but as readers see more and more isekai adventure novels, their standards are getting higher."

"That's true."

"It's not that this year's Supernova is worse than before, but that readers' tastes are becoming more refined. No wonder the Editor-in-Chief and the others have been wanting to support new genres. Readers are tired of the old themes; novels must provide new excitement."

...

In the early days, TV dramas were full of brain-dead plots like car accidents, cancer, and abortions, and audiences still watched them with gusto. But if such plots appeared now, viewers would point right at the director's nose and start cursing.

It's the same in the field of novels.

A few years ago, isekai adventure novels could become popular with just a few gimmicks. For example, there was a novel called "Bringing a Cell Phone to Another World" about a protagonist who had a magical phone that worked in another world, going around showing off and slapping faces. By today's standards, that story might be eye-searing, but readers back then really liked it.

"It's not a total wipeout."

Yang Feng tried to comfort everyone: "Although 'prince of tennis' is the last-place entry in the Supernova, its reputation is very good. Its score is already as high as 8.5, which is quite remarkable."

Yang Feng was right.

Although the reputations of the first four Supernova books were disappointing, the score "prince of tennis" had received so far was very high, and the reader feedback in the comment section was mostly appreciative.

"This one is the best!"

"I didn't expect a sports novel about tennis to be so exciting. I just picked it up at the bookstore for a casual look, but once I did, I couldn't put it down. I'm officially a fan of 'prince of tennis' now."

"A breath of fresh air in the Supernova!"

"I'm tired of isekai adventures. Changing things up once in a while is surprisingly good. I've already recommended 'prince of tennis' to many friends, but a lot of them aren't interested. They're just like I used to be, not understanding the charm of sports novels at all."

...

The editors naturally knew that "prince of tennis" had a high score and was receiving rave reviews. However, for Silver Blue Bookstore, the novel's reputation was merely a consolation prize because its genre was too niche, making a sales explosion almost impossible.

"It's useless."

"The genre is too niche."

"It's critically acclaimed but not commercially successful."

The editors didn't seem too excited. Every publishing house has some novels that are critically acclaimed but not commercially successful. Major publishers generally take a supportive stance toward these types of novels, providing publishing resources even if sales are poor. It's like how movie companies need some art films for prestige, but the company's real profit comes from novel sales.

"Don't be so dejected."

The Editor-in-Chief was very dissatisfied with the editors' state: "Look at you all. The sales figures aren't even out yet. Reputation isn't everything. Some novels have high sales even if their scores aren't high."

"True."

"There's a chance!"

"It's just reputation."

Hope ignited in the editors' eyes. Reputation didn't mean everything. There are books on the market that are acclaimed but don't sell, and there are books with terrible reputations that sell like crazy. These days, many readers are tsundere—saying one thing but doing another. "prince of tennis" was the former in everyone's eyes, so the other Supernova books might just become the latter!

These people are so easy to fool.

The Deputy Chief Editor curled his lip secretly.

Acclaimed but unpopular works are rare, and works with bad reputations but high sales aren't common either. In the general laws of the book market, reputation and sales are usually proportional most of the time... "Meeting adjourned."

The Editor-in-Chief waved his hand.

After everyone dispersed, the Editor-in-Chief immediately became worried. His state was even worse than the editors' just now: "It seems this Supernova has indeed been botched, unless a miracle happens."

"A miracle?"

The Deputy Chief Editor, who also hadn't left, said with a bitter smile, "Let's take a walk to the statistics department. The first-week sales for the Supernova should be tallied by now. Let's see where the miracle is."

Editor-in-Chief: "..."

The two arrived at the relevant department side by side. The Editor-in-Chief and Deputy Chief Editor both looked at the female supervisor of the statistics department: "The first-week sales for the Supernova should be tallied by now, right?"

"You're here?"

The female supervisor's expression was a bit cold, seemingly finding these two guys particularly annoying. After saying one sentence, she turned back to her work: "The statistics table is on the table, look for yourselves. Ask me if there's anything you don't understand."

"Where did we offend her?"

The Editor-in-Chief and Deputy Chief Editor looked at each other, then picked up the statistics table and took a look. This single glance killed their last hope, because the highest-selling "Demon King from Another World" only had 180,000 copies.

This was the Supernova!

In previous years, works published through the Supernova Grand Prize would be embarrassed to show their faces if their first-week sales didn't break 300,000. But this year, the highest-selling of the five Supernova books was actually less than 200,000 copies.

But at least one thing was correct.

That was, the top five rankings of the Supernova perfectly matched their sales. The Editor-in-Chief tried to find humor in the tragedy: "At least our sales ranking predictions weren't wrong. If the sales data is bad, it must be the readers' fault no matter how you look at it."

"Right, right!"

The Deputy Chief Editor nodded in agreement.

The female supervisor, who had left, returned. Hearing their conversation, she immediately flew into a rage and started cursing: "You two idiots' judgment wasn't wrong? Do you know my phone has been freaking ringing off the hook! Every bookstore in Qinzhou is hounding me for stock. Now, whenever I pick up the phone, the first thing they say is prince of tennis, prince of tennis, prince of tennis! They're hounding me so much my head is about to explode! Do you know how busy I've been with shipping and supply these past few days? Do you know I'm about to enter menopause early from all this pressure? Do you know how many nights of peace I've lost!?"

The female supervisor's eyes were bloodshot!

Her rapid-fire words crackled like gunfire, and spittle sprayed all over the faces of the Editor-in-Chief and Deputy Chief Editor. Her sheer intensity made the two of them tremble.

"Uh..."

The two carefully looked at the statistics table and confirmed seriously: "'prince of tennis' is dead last in Supernova sales. How could it be out of stock? My dear lady, why are you so fired up? Something must be wrong here, right?"

"Something's wrong?"

The female supervisor looked at the two of them as if they were idiots: "'prince of tennis' only had a freaking stock of 100,000 copies. That's not even enough to fill the gaps between the teeth of the major booksellers. It sold out on the third day after the Supernova publication. How do you expect it to compete for sales with nothing?"

The Editor-in-Chief and Deputy Chief Editor were stunned.

The two of them had been so focused on the Supernova sales rankings that they completely forgot that "prince of tennis" only had an initial print run of 100,000 copies.

They only remembered after the female supervisor's scolding.

At this moment, their eyes widened as they finally realized something. The miracle they had longed for seemed to have actually happened!

"You two."

The female supervisor revealed a dangerous smile, her tone eerily gentle: "Please tell me, which bastard made the decision to only print 100,000 copies of 'prince of tennis' initially?"

"Him!"

The Editor-in-Chief and Deputy Chief Editor pointed at each other at the same time.

This chapter really isn't! Short! Or! Small!