16
"Fish Daddy is so impressive!"
"I just love it when you two collab!"
"Is this song meant to compensate Chu Kuang?"
"Writing a song to help out since Chu Kuang obediently changed the plot?"
"This divine friendship, I love it, love it!"
"Since Fish Daddy saved Sherlock Holmes, I'll definitely support the new song!"
"Xian Yu writing original songs for a novel—on the entire Blue Star, only Chu Kuang's novels get this kind of treatment!"
"Shadow has drawn several manga, but I haven't seen Xian Yu help write any related songs..."
"..."
Sherlock Holmes is a hot topic lately.
Xian Yu's collab has fully capitalized on the hype.
Netizens are discussing this matter enthusiastically!
And just as everyone was discussing it happily...
A music industry professional named 【North Platform Facing Sun】 suddenly posted an update:
"Isn't Teacher Xian Yu aiming for twelve consecutive championships on the season chart? If so, the song in June is crucial. Is a song created for a novel really suitable for climbing the charts?"
This person is a quite active musician online with a significant following.
His post quickly attracted the attention of netizens.
After a bit of thought...
Many netizens immediately realized what he meant.
Of course, some netizens expressed confusion, so North Platform Facing Sun patiently explained:
"I don't mean to belittle Sherlock Holmes, but we have to admit the fact that not every listener has read Sherlock Holmes. Can listeners who haven't read the novel really feel the charm of this song?"
Now everyone realized it!
For a moment...
This blogger's comment section became lively:
"Almost forgot about that!"
"Xian Yu is aiming for twelve consecutive championships!"
"If it's a theme song for a novel, wouldn't it be too niche?"
"If this song wants to reach the top in June, it must satisfy both book fans and listeners who haven't read the novel. Isn't that too difficult?"
"Maybe Xian Yu wants to use the hype of Sherlock Holmes to climb the charts?"
"The idea is good, as the hype of Sherlock Holmes is an invisible foundation, but it also invisibly increases the difficulty of creating the song. Trying to cater to both sides can easily lead to neglecting one!"
"I'm reminded of 'Fairy Tale Town'. Wasn't that song written by Fish Daddy for Chu Kuang's novel?"
"Exactly, 'Fairy Tale Town' is an example. Although it's a good song, with its quality, trying to reach the top of today's season chart is a bit of a stretch, especially when Fish Daddy needs to ensure he firmly secures the June championship track!"
"..."
Normally, netizens would be delighted to see a collab between Chu Kuang and Xian Yu, but since Xian Yu has made it clear he's aiming for twelve consecutive championships, this song seems a bit risky!
Because of this argument...
...more and more people joined the discussion.
Seeing his comments attract attention, the musician named North Platform Facing Sun became more active:
"Music themed around Sherlock Holmes clearly has Sherlock Holmes fans as its core audience. This group of fans can support a significant number of downloads, and with Teacher Xian Yu's contribution to Sherlock Holmes, the downloads will surely be higher. But the downside is also obvious: Teacher Xian Yu has confined himself to a certain circle. His goal is to reach the top in June, and he can't achieve that solely with the support of Sherlock Holmes fans. Unless countless people who haven't read the novel also like the song, which would require the song's popularity to break through and go mainstream. Isn't that too difficult? That's why I said Xian Yu's decision is a bit risky. I hope Teacher Xian Yu considers it carefully, as I'm also looking forward to Teacher Xian Yu continuing to Winning the championship!"
This musician didn't belittle Xian Yu.
He was just objectively expressing his views.
These comments didn't trigger dissatisfaction among Xian Yu and Chu Kuang's fans; instead, they gained widespread agreement. Some even went to the comments of Xian Yu's June song update, hoping he would play it safe... after all, going mainstream is too hard!
Trying to satisfy both Sherlock Holmes fans and ordinary music fans is not an easy task in itself!
Think about 'Fairy Tale Town'.
The quality of that song doesn't rank very high among Xian Yu's works.
Without the novel's hype, that song would even be considered average or below average among Xian Yu's works!
Clearly...
...this is because Xian Yu wanted to balance the readers' feelings and the fans' experience, which imposed certain restrictions on his creation and led to an average performance.
In comparison, 'the great detective sherlock holmes' is even harder!
This novel isn't a fairy tale; its style is very distinct!
If not handled well, Xian Yu might not only fail to satisfy ordinary fans but even Sherlock Holmes fans might feel the 'flavor' isn't right!
At this moment...
...someone countered: "Isn't Teacher Xian Yu's chart-topping piano piece 'Für Elise' from this month great? Wasn't that also created based on Chu Kuang's novel?"
Not long after Xian Yu's concert ended...
...the closing track of the concert, 'Für Elise', won the championship on this month's season chart.
Based on the title...
...everyone believes the piece is a tribute to Chu Kuang's fairy tale work 'alices adventures in wonderland', although Xian Yu himself hasn't provided an explanation.
But the name is too coincidental... the vast majority of people are willing to believe this piece is connected to Chu Kuang's 'alices adventures in wonderland'.
Quickly...
...that musician replied to the netizen who countered:
"Teacher Xian Yu said he's releasing a song in June. The biggest difference between a song and a piano piece is that a song uses more instruments and involves lyrics. Lyrics for Sherlock Holmes won't be easy to write. Besides, even though 'Für Elise' is excellent, I personally believe this piece has nothing to do with Chu Kuang's novel."
Yes.
Although everyone feels the piece is connected to Chu Kuang's 'alices adventures in wonderland', many also believe the mood of the piece doesn't match the novel.
Consequently...
...some industry insiders believe it's just a coincidence of names, and Xian Yu's piano piece actually has no connection to Chu Kuang's novel.
With the discussion and controversy, everyone gradually clarified the key issues:
First is the audience issue: it's too difficult for Xian Yu's new song to cater to both music fans and book fans.
Second is the lyrics issue: how can the novel 'the great detective sherlock holmes' be presented in lyric form?
Third is the style issue: Sherlock Holmes's style has a bit of a dark aesthetic, and this kind of track can easily become niche.
Fourth... in short, there are many problems and the difficulty is immense.
Countless netizens believe it's extremely challenging for Xian Yu to reach the top of next month's season chart with a song paying tribute to Sherlock Holmes!
And as the netizens' consensus was forming...
...the musician with the online handle 【North Platform Facing Sun】 spoke out again:
"Even though I've listed many difficulties, there's still a great hope for Teacher Xian Yu to reach the top. After all, his fame and strength are there, and I believe many people want to help him achieve twelve consecutive championships. If the Sherlock Holmes fans are truly satisfied, they will surely contribute huge support. But the real key is: do you think other Composer Gods will just sit by while Teacher Xian Yu aims for twelve consecutive championships on the season chart? According to the custom of Blue Star, any Composer who aims for twelve consecutive championships will face a'snipe'. This is a challenge that those aiming for twelve consecutive championships must endure. In the coming months, the opponents Teacher Xian Yu faces will be stronger each time. This is the law of the music industry. If Teacher Xian Yu falls in June, all the efforts of the previous five months will be in vain!"
It's already going to be so difficult!
And Xian Yu is still increasing the difficulty for himself?
