16
After this thought emerged, the netizens' minds were in a whirl...
No one could provide a definitive answer to the three questions Long Yang had raised.
For a moment.
Everyone's curiosity was piqued, and they continued reading.
After throwing out those three questions, Long Yang indeed provided explanations in the subsequent film review:
"Let's start with the first question: why did the ferry meet with an accident?
Many people overlooked the scene where the father feeds the animals; since animals get seasick, the father hoped to use sedatives to keep them calm during the voyage.
But the unexpected part is...
These tasks were previously done by servants, and the father had never fed sedatives to the animals before, so he accidentally put the sedatives into the crew's food as well.
And because of the argument between the mother and the cook, the protagonist's family did not eat during the day.
Therefore.
When the storm arrived, the people on the ship didn't wake up due to the effects of the sedatives, and with no sailors to take timely and effective measures, the ferry met with an accident. This is the definitive reason why Pi always avoids the cause of the shipwreck.
Top-tier filmmakers will not give you any useless shots.
Those seemingly meaningless shots might be foreshadowing hidden in the dark. If you don't think carefully, it's easy to overlook key information. The protagonist's family not eating, and the sedatives fed to the animals, are the key pieces of information I'm talking about!
..."
The netizens' eyes widened!
No one had thought of this question beforehand!
The shipwreck...
Was actually because of the father's mistake?
Some netizens subconsciously wanted to refute this: then how did the cook and the sailor get into the lifeboat?
However.
The interpretation of the next two questions provided the explanation and effectively shut the netizens up.
"Once there is an answer to the first question, the answers to the second and third questions can directly overturn the second story Pi told.
I believe some people have already guessed it.
In fact, there were no sailors or cooks at all!
The entire crew was wiped out; the ones who boarded that boat were the protagonist's family!
The so-called zebra was not a sailor, but the protagonist's father; the hyena was the protagonist's older brother; and the rat was the protagonist's girlfriend—she had also snuck onto the boat as a stowaway. I believe many netizens have already guessed this, as 'rat' is a term used to describe stowaways.
This is the answer to the third question.
Why did the mother hit the cook, yet the cook did not fight back?
Because the cook was the hyena, which is the protagonist's brother.
It is perfectly normal for a mother to hit her son, and for the son not to fight back.
The brother used the father's amputated leg to fish; naturally, the mother couldn't tolerate it. But the brother was a rational person—the first thirty minutes of foreshadowing weren't for nothing. It's just that the father died because he couldn't get effective treatment for his amputation, so the brother ate the father's flesh in order to survive.
..."
The netizens were completely stunned!
No cook and no sailor?
It was actually the protagonist's family who boarded the boat?
This interpretation is countless times more terrifying than before, making one's blood run cold!
"You should all have guessed the rest of the story: a conflict broke out between the mother and the brother, and the mother was accidentally killed by the brother.
The protagonist was thoroughly enraged, and he killed the brother!
If the brother were really the cook, he would have fought back long ago, but he was actually the brother, so he didn't fight back because he knew he had done something wrong.
Thus, only the protagonist and the brother remained on the boat.
The protagonist said he remembered every detail of his last day with his girlfriend but couldn't remember how they parted ways. Actually, it's not that he couldn't remember; it's that they never parted ways, and the way they finally parted was too cruel—Pi couldn't even bring himself to try and make it up.
..."
Having recounted this far, Long Yang summarized:
"My guess might not be entirely correct, but it is certainly closer to the truth than the second version.
There are too many metaphorical shots in this film; for example, the sulfuric acid that appears in the center of the lake on the cannibal island at night is actually human stomach acid, and so on. But I can be certain that there are loopholes in Pi's second version. The film provided hints about this, especially the controversial point of whether bananas could support the weight of an orangutan—that is the biggest hint. And it must have been the protagonist's family on the boat; this is why the first thirty minutes of the film were spent laying the groundwork with the story of the protagonist's family!
As I said before.
Brilliant filmmakers do not include meaningless shots. The seemingly useless foreshadowing in the first thirty minutes is actually the setup for the cook and the sailor being family members. Once you understand this, you will truly understand the horror of this film.
..."
The film review ended.
After reading the review, the netizens were dumbfounded!
Cannibalism itself is already terrifying, but everyone hadn't expected the real truth to be countless times more terrifying than the second version of the story!
It was a family on the boat!
This is no longer the same concept as the story in the second version!
"I want to refute this, but I can't find any ground to stand on!"
"Holy crap, the protagonist ate his girlfriend and mother in the end?"
"Ahhhhh, give me back the first version!"
"The first version was beautiful, and the third version is just as dark!"
"So the tiger was the protagonist's animal nature! Pi taming the tiger is the process of humanity taming animal nature!"
"This interpretation is truly brilliant!"
"I was wondering why the first thirty minutes were so boring, telling a bunch of stuff about the family, and then after the ferry accident, the whole family died, leaving only the mother and the protagonist on the boat. So that's why!"
"A story like this, yet it was filmed so beautifully; my worldview has collapsed!"
"This is the movie with the most metaphors I've ever seen. What happened to it being a commercial film!"
"Xian Yu's imagination this time is truly invincible!"
"Oh my god!"
"..."
The interpretation reached its most insane climax!
Of course, it wasn't that no one refuted Long Yang in the comments; it was just that more interpretations were extensions, and there was no way to unify the versions. For example, some people thought the hyena was the father and the zebra was the brother, because the father ate meat while the other family members were vegetarians.
Even.
Some people brought up God, the Lord, and the power of religion and faith, which also made a lot of sense.
Clearly.
The film provided no standard answer, and the creators wouldn't provide one outside the film either; this is precisely where the charm of art films lies.
Just like in the story of Journey to the West, where the Sun Wukong is always interpreted from strange and bizarre angles...
Whether it's the facts or secondary creations, they are destined to be shrouded in a layer of mist!
The only thing that is certain is that this story is far darker than everyone imagined!
After researching and researching, the netizens were about to go crazy!
And the actions of Life of Pi also sparked countless controversies!
Some think Pi is insane.
Some think Pi went from being lost to finding redemption, achieving a liberation of humanity.
This seems to return to the question at the end of the film:
Do you like the version with the tiger, or do you like the version without the tiger?
Very strange.
When the second version appeared, many people felt that the one without the tiger was more exciting; but when the third version's interpretation appeared, everyone suddenly started wanting to choose the first version.
The film itself means exactly this.
You can just believe in whichever one you like.
Thus, the question left by this film became thought-provoking—
Which version do you prefer?
——————
PS: The plot holes in this film have been filled for the most part. I haven't thought about what to shoot for the next film yet. Asking for monthly tickets, and by the way, does anyone have any good suggestions?
