16
Without needing to use magic detection, Dumbledore could keenly sense the stability of a person's soul. This had happened many times; he could feel Voldemort's unstable soul due to repeated splitting, and he could also sense Harry's soul becoming unstable due to influence.
In other words, he already knew that Harry had a fragment of Voldemort's soul inside him!
That really is an impressive talent.
Evan had learned from Dumbledore how to sense magical power and witness the traces of magic, but he couldn't sense a person's soul state. This was a higher level of perception than witnessing magic.
"That diary, Riddle's diary, is undoubtedly a Horcrux. At the very least, it served the function of a Horcrux, keeping the fragment of Voldemort's soul stored inside safe until it was destroyed," Dumbledore said. "But that's not what shocked me. What truly interested and surprised me was the phenomenon you described to me, which I had never seen before: that fragment of soul, having its own actions and thoughts? That fragment of soul, actually absorbing the life force of Mr. Weasley who held it?"
"Other Horcruxes can't do that?"
"No, they cannot. This is not the first time I have encountered a Horcrux, but Voldemort's Horcruxes are clearly different," Dumbledore said. "While confirming that the diary was a Horcrux, it raised more questions for me. For instance, it was treated both as a protective device and as a weapon."
"What?"
"It perfectly fulfilled the role of a Horcrux; the soul fragment hidden inside was safe and indeed helped its master avoid death. But that wasn't all. Riddle undoubtedly wanted someone to read that diary, hoping his soul fragment would possess someone else so that the Monster of Slytherin could be released again."
"I know what this is about, Professor!" Harry offered his opinion. "He wanted people to know he was the heir of slytherin because he couldn't get recognition at the time."
Evan did not rush to speak. He was pondering Dumbledore's words: Voldemort's Horcruxes were different from others, serving both as a protective device and a weapon.
Its activity level was very high.
"Activity level"—using this adjective to describe a Horcrux might not be precise or professional enough, but it was undoubtedly Evan's first thought.
A highly active Horcrux doesn't just quietly fulfill its function; it also selectively and actively attacks or lures those who approach it.
It was only after Dumbledore's reminder that Evan realized Voldemort's Horcruxes were indeed unusual, possessing strong offensive capabilities.
But something felt strange... Thinking of this, Evan asked, "Professor, does a Horcrux need this kind of aggressiveness?"
"Generally, no. This is the second key point we should focus on, besides the sheer number of Voldemort's Horcruxes," Dumbledore said. "Imagine if Voldemort wanted the diary to be passed to, or rooted in, a future Hogwarts student—he was being extremely careless with the precious soul fragment inside. As Professor Slughorn said, the purpose of a Horcrux is to safely seal away a part of one's soul, not to throw it into someone else's path and risk annihilation... And that is exactly what happened: that fragment of soul no longer exists. As you saw, compared to other destroyed Horcruxes, that diary had a stronger initiative, and its destruction was largely related to its own actions."
That's not entirely correct. If Evan hadn't had so many concerns at the time, and had possessed the ability to destroy the Horcrux, he would have destroyed that diary long ago!
But if Evan had known nothing and Riddle inside the diary had taken the initiative, this Horcrux would eventually have been destroyed anyway.
This process was not initiated by him; it was entirely Riddle inside the diary bringing trouble upon himself. Causing such a commotion right under Dumbledore's nose—it would be strange if it weren't destroyed.
"In fact, Voldemort's carelessness regarding this Horcrux makes me feel greatly uneasy. It suggests he likely planned to make more Horcruxes, so losing one wouldn't be so dangerous, or perhaps there are other, more terrible reasons that we don't know about. I am reluctant to believe that."
"Later, more and more facts proved that he did create multiple Horcruxes, just as you told me two years later he had once said: he had gone farther than anyone else on the path to eternal life. Death Eaters would never know the true meaning of that sentence, but I am certain that what he meant was that he created multiple Horcruxes," Dumbledore said. "Yes, multiple Horcruxes—I believe this is something no other Wizard has ever done. But all the signs fit: Voldemort seems to have become less and less human over the years, and I think that transformation can only be explained by the damage done to his soul exceeding what we would call ordinary evil..."
"Wait, Professor, I still don't quite understand," Harry said. "He achieves immortality by killing? If he wants eternal life so badly, why doesn't he create a Philosopher's Stone, or steal one? That seems simpler."
"The number of Philosopher's Stones is limited. In a sense, using a Philosopher's Stone is much harder than creating a Horcrux, as the latter only requires murder, which is nothing to Voldemort," Dumbledore said. "The most important point is that the Elixir of Life does extend life, but one must drink it frequently, forever, to maintain immortality. In that case, Voldemort would be completely dependent on the potion. If the potion ran out or became contaminated, or if the Philosopher's Stone were stolen, he would die just like everyone else. Voldemort prefers to act alone, remember? I believe he would find dependence intolerable, even dependence on the Elixir of Life. Of course, Harry, he was willing to drink it to escape that terrible half-life state after attacking you, but that was only to regain a body. Afterward, I believe he intended to continue relying on his Horcruxes: he wouldn't need anything else, provided he could regain a human form. He is already immortal... or rather, closer to immortality than anyone else."
"To defeat Voldemort, we must destroy all the Horcruxes. Fortunately, we have currently destroyed three and found the most peculiar one. The two remaining are Hufflepuff's Cup and the evil god statue..."
"Professor, the golden cup was a Horcrux Voldemort made before his first failed escape. He must have hidden it," Evan reminded him, looking into Dumbledore's eyes. "He either hid it in a place of special significance to him, like the Diadem and the ring, or entrusted it to his servants, the Death Eaters he particularly valued, like the diary..."
