16
"We can imagine that in those days, Dumbledore and Grindelwald studied magic and discussed their ideals together, both feeling that the other was the one in their destiny. They even snuck out to adventure in ancient magical ruins around the world."
Evan said, "Previously, when Sirius and I set out to find the keys to the Secret Treasure of the Giants and Ravenclaw, Dumbledore mentioned to me that he had once been to Sicily with Grindelwald."
"In that environment, such adventurous behavior was very reckless for Dumbledore. Considering Ariana's physical condition, even if Dumbledore was only gone for a short time, it was highly inappropriate."
"But because of Grindelwald, Dumbledore neglected Ariana, and Grindelwald probably also considered Ariana a burden. We all know that Grindelwald was never a good person; he was a thorough Dark Wizard who had conducted many unimaginable studies of the Dark Arts even when he was a student."
"His attitude toward Ariana, who stood in the way of him and Dumbledore, is easy to imagine—he might have even hoped she would die sooner. Ariana's condition at the time required constant care, and she couldn't handle any stimulation. Under these circumstances, her physical condition was bound to get worse and worse."
"Did Dumbledore not know about what you just said at the time?" Harry asked after thinking for a moment.
"I think he didn't know, or he knew but ignored it. At the time, Dumbledore's mind was filled with how to achieve the greater good and realize his and Grindelwald's grand ideals, causing him to neglect his sister. This is also the thing he regretted most in his life," Evan said. "In fact, I suspect that Dumbledore didn't fully understand Ariana's condition at the time. He likely didn't know about Obscurials and simply thought Ariana's magic was out of control..."
"If you have read Mr. Newt Scamander's biography—yes, the author of 'fantastic beasts and where to find them', Mr. Scamander, who gave Hagrid and us a lot of help in the Buckbeak incident—if you have read his biography, Harry, you would find a very interesting description," Evan continued. "As a Magizoologist, the young Mr. Scamander once followed ancient wizarding traditions and went on a global journey focused on studying and rescuing Magical Creatures. His first stop was the United States, and that was exactly when Dumbledore returned to Hogwarts and Grindelwald was rising rapidly. Mr. Scamander met Grindelwald while traveling in the United States. In fact, I think Dumbledore played a big role in Scamander choosing to go to the United States."
"What were they doing there?" Harry was having trouble keeping up with Evan's jumping train of thought. A moment ago they were talking about Ariana, and now they were discussing Newt Scamander's adventures in the United States. Even so, Harry had to admit that he was very interested in these shocking events.
"Grindelwald was expanding his influence at the time. He was already very powerful, but not enough to conquer the world. At the very least, he wasn't entirely sure he could defeat his old friend Dumbledore, and he hadn't found all three Deathly Hallows, so Grindelwald began hoping to acquire other powers," Evan said. "I think he must have witnessed the scene when Ariana's magic went out of control, or even when the Obscurus inside her awakened, and it left a deep impression on him. How could a Wizard like Grindelwald ignore such unimaginably powerful force? He studied it and discovered the secret of the Obscurial. He must have gone to the United States because he received information and wanted to find a new Obscurial, and Dumbledore appearing there was exactly to stop him."
"Of course, with Mr. Scamander's help, Dumbledore finally succeeded in stopping Grindelwald. They fought all the way from the United States back to Europe and finally had that legendary duel at Nurmengard. You can ask Mr. Scamander about these things yourself. I think you should visit him, after all, Grindelwald occupied an extremely important position in Dumbledore's life. If you want to understand Dumbledore, you cannot bypass this Dark Wizard no matter what," Evan said. "If necessary, we can even go to Nurmengard to see Grindelwald himself. He has been imprisoned there ever since he lost the duel."
"That Dark Wizard is still alive?" Harry said in surprise.
"Dumbledore only defeated him, he didn't kill him. The two of them had a very good relationship, better than you could imagine. Rita Skeeter wasn't wrong about that, but having a good personal relationship doesn't mean they wouldn't become enemies, especially for Wizards of Grindelwald and Dumbledore's stature; their ideals were perhaps more important to them," Evan explained. "Alright, Harry, let's turn the topic back to Ariana. As we mentioned earlier, Grindelwald went to the United States to look for an Obscurus because he witnessed the power released when the Obscurus inside Ariana awakened. And the reason for that magical outburst of Ariana was because Dumbledore's brother, Aberforth, found out that Dumbledore hadn't taken good care of Ariana when he came home from Hogwarts for the holidays. He and Dumbledore had a fierce argument. Hmm, if I'm not mistaken, the argument Aunt Muriel's family mentioned to us yesterday was the aftermath of this very argument. In short, they argued very fiercely, and Grindelwald got involved too. In the end, they likely resorted to force. Ariana, who was nearby, was stimulated, and the Obscurus inside her awakened. In that chaos, a spell from Dumbledore, Grindelwald, or Aberforth hit Ariana, or perhaps because the magical outburst was too powerful for Ariana's body to withstand—in any case, she died."
Harry didn't speak, nor did he ask any questions; it seemed he found it hard to accept what Evan had said for the moment.
"Grindelwald believed he was the one who killed Ariana, so he fled after that argument! And because Dumbledore believed he was responsible for Ariana's death, he changed a lot after that. He no longer had those previous ideas but gradually became the Professor we are familiar with," Evan said in the end. "Alright, Harry, that is the story about Ariana. We can blame Dumbledore for the mistakes he made in this process, but everyone makes mistakes, and Dumbledore is no exception. What matters is what we do after we make mistakes. We all know what kind of person Dumbledore is; the slander from Rita Skeeter and Aunt Muriel has no credibility."
