Judging a wizard's character based on whether or not they use dark magic is far too hasty.

Dark magic is indeed composed of various negative emotions and magical power, but it isn't only used to harm others or do evil deeds.

Similarly, so-called white magic and general spells are not all used for good deeds.

Magic itself has no inherent good or evil; the key lies in the intentions of the wizard using it.

The crucial factor in determining if a wizard is a dark wizard is whether the wizard themselves is evil, not what kind of magic they use.

Of course, because of their cruel and evil nature, dark wizards use dark magic without restraint, finding it much easier to wield than normal wizards.

That being said, the fact that Dumbledore once dabbled in dark magic is extraordinary, at least for Harry.

Looking at Doge, who was in pain and flustered, Harry felt very sad.

He didn't care if Dumbledore had dabbled in dark magic; he himself had used dark magic to vent hatred.

When a person is in extreme anger, doing so doesn't seem like a big deal.

But what he couldn't accept was the implication of this matter: that what Rita Skeeter said in the newspaper might be true, that Dumbledore had studied dark magic with the dark wizard Grindelwald, and that he had once wanted to overthrow the International Statute of Secrecy and establish a wizarding rule over Muggles.

This implied that Dumbledore's stance of abhorring dark magic and dedicating himself to protecting Muggles was all fake.

Fake, all fake!

Harry felt a chill run through him. He realized that Dumbledore's image, Dumbledore's ideals, and the things Dumbledore had told him might not all be true; there might be false elements within them.

Harry considered this possibility and found that he seemed to have never truly understood the headmaster.

Compared to the confused Harry, Evan knew more.

This kind of thing was indeed difficult for Dumbledore to explain or clarify to others, and he had also resolved to bear the pain alone, saying nothing.

As far as Evan knew, there was a period when Dumbledore was indeed obsessed with dark magic.

He and Grindelwald became close friends, exploring the mysteries of magic together.

The young Dumbledore was well aware of Grindelwald's agenda and knew what he would do with the magic they studied together, but he didn't care at the time.

How to put it, Evan wasn't entirely sure, nor did he know if it was appropriate to evaluate Dumbledore this way, but from what was currently known, the young Dumbledore didn't have such a strong sense of justice and responsibility.

He was frustrated at being forced to stay home and care for his younger siblings.

He was exceptionally talented and believed he shouldn't be tied down by family, unwilling to waste his potential.

Grindelwald's appearance brought hope into his life, and so, two equally talented wizards became inseparable during those two months.

Perhaps drawn to each other's talents, perhaps seeing reflections of themselves in each other, or perhaps for other reasons, Dumbledore and Grindelwald, two of the greatest wizards of their time, met.

In those two months, they greatly advanced the development of magic and influenced the magical world's landscape for the next century.

If no accident had occurred, Dumbledore might have become a Dark Lord with Grindelwald, establishing their ideal new order in this world.

But the tragic accident did happen; after accidentally killing his sister Ariana, Dumbledore had a sudden realization.

From then on, the two great wizards went in different, opposing directions, leading to their subsequent world-shaking duel.

Ultimately, Dumbledore won the duel.

This doesn't necessarily mean he was stronger than Grindelwald in magic and power at that time, but in some aspects, he was indeed more powerful than Grindelwald.

To use the Headmaster's long-held philosophy, that is love; Dumbledore understood more about it than all dark wizards.

Voldemort didn't understand love, Grindelwald sacrificed love for the greater good, while Dumbledore truly embraced love.

Therefore, in that world-shaking duel, which everyone talked about but had no eyewitnesses, he achieved the final victory.

Dumbledore's enduring legacy lies in the fact that he made an unforgivable mistake in his youth, but he ultimately confronted his dark side and became the greatest wizard.

“We don't know Dumbledore's past, Harry, but I think some things can't be simply understood and judged from the surface,” Evan said.

“If you ask me, everyone makes mistakes, and the young Dumbledore was no exception.

The key is the courage to admit mistakes and one's subsequent actions.

What Rita Skeeter wrote might be true, but it's as worthless as a lie.

You know her; her goal is to attract public interest to sell her books, so the more shocking the story, the more it suits her taste.

She'll even deliberately hide important facts or fabricate ambiguous statements to achieve an effect.

Rita Skeeter...”

“Rita Skeeter?! Are you talking about her? Oh, I love her, always read what she writes!” A shrill, cackling laugh interrupted Evan.

Ron's Great-Aunt Muriel clutched a glass of champagne, the feathers on her hat fluttering up and down.

“You know, she wrote a book about Dumbledore!”

“Hello, Muriel!” Doge said, “Yes, we were just talking about that...”

“Is that so! Give me your chair, I'm one hundred and seven years old!” Another red-haired cousin of the Weasleys jumped up from his chair in a panic.

Great-Aunt Muriel, with surprising strength, spun the chair around and placed it between Doge, Evan, Harry, Hermione, and Elaine, then plopped down.

“You lot, have we met before? The goblin-like Weasley family, you all look the same, who can tell you apart!” Great-Aunt Muriel scrutinized Evan and the others for a moment, seemingly trying to recall them, then gave up.

She turned to Doge and said, “Alright, Elphias, let's chat.

What were you just saying about Rita Skeeter?

Do you know she wrote a biography of Dumbledore?

I can't wait to read it; I must remember to order a copy at Flourish and Blotts.”

Hearing this, Doge's face fell, his expression stiff.

But Great-Aunt Muriel drained her glass, snapped her bony fingers at a nearby waiter, and demanded a refill.

She took another large gulp of champagne, let out a loud burp, and then said, “No need to look like a stuffed frog!

I'm not like the young people nowadays who know nothing!

Our generation knows very well that Albus had some very funny rumors about him before he became so highly respected and admired!”