16
The final result would likely disappoint her; Dobby was just an exception and couldn't represent the vast majority of House-elves.
As Hagrid said, every species has one or two oddballs.
Other House-elves wouldn't desire freedom like Dobby, and they certainly wouldn't accept wages; that was an insult to them.
"Thank you, Miss, Young Master Evan!" Dobby said, smiling at them both and showing many teeth. "After Winky was let go, Dobby took her around to many Wizard families, hoping they would take her in. Most Wizards didn't want a House-elf who took wages—that wasn't the quality of a House-elf—and then they slammed the door shut on Dobby and Winky! Some Wizards were willing to let Winky work for them for free, but Dobby couldn't give Winky to them. She needs work, but she also needs to wear clothes and take wages, just like Dobby..."
The Hogwarts House-elves quietly began moving away, avoiding Dobby as if he carried some kind of infectious disease.
Winky, however, stayed put, but the volume of her wailing clearly increased again.
She was crying so sadly that, mid-sob, she suddenly lunged forward off the stool, falling face-down onto the stone tablet floor.
Winky pounded her tiny fists and screamed in anguish.
Hermione quickly crouched beside her, trying to comfort her, but nothing Hermione said had any effect.
Dobby continued his story, screaming loudly, drowning out Winky's wails.
"Dobby suddenly had an idea, Young Master Evan. Dobby thought of Hogwarts. There is enough work here, and it is convenient for Dobby to look after Winky. Furthermore, Professor Dumbledore was very willing to take her in and pay her wages," Dobby said. "He is the greatest Wizard besides Harry Potter and Young Master Evan. Dobby has heard many things about him."
A very bright smile appeared on Dobby's face, and tears of joy filled his eyes again.
"How much does Professor Dumbledore pay you?"
"He originally planned to give Dobby ten Galleons a week, but Dobby refused. Young Master Evan already pays Dobby wages; Dobby is only helping here!" Dobby said. "When the holidays come, Dobby will return to Young Master Evan's home."
"Hmph!" Hermione didn't speak; she glared at Evan.
She knew Evan only paid Dobby one Galleon a week, and she thought that amount was far too little.
She had tried to persuade Evan to give Dobby a raise more than once, but it was useless.
Every time the subject was brought up, Dobby became extremely frightened.
He would weep miserably while hugging Evan, repeatedly asking Evan if he didn't want him anymore!
Dobby believed that too much wealth and leisure time were dreadful. In his words, he liked freedom, but not too much freedom.
Compared to leisure and wealth, he preferred work.
"And what about you, Winky? How much does Professor Dumbledore pay you?" Hermione continued to ask.
If she thought this would cheer Winky up, she was terribly mistaken.
Winky did stop crying, but she sat up, glaring fiercely at Hermione with her two huge brown eyes, her wet face suddenly contorted with rage.
"Winky is a House-elf who was thrown out, but Winky has not sunk to the level of taking wages!" she shrieked shrilly. "Winky has not fallen that far! Winky is ashamed of her freedom!"
"Ashamed?!" Hermione said blankly. "Winky, listen to me! Mr. Crouch should be the one who is ashamed, not you! You didn't do anything wrong, he was too cruel to you..."
But upon hearing this, Winky quickly covered the two holes in her hat with her hands, flattening her ears.
This way she couldn't hear. Then she screamed, "You mustn't insult my master, Miss! You mustn't insult my Mr. Crouch! Mr. Crouch is a good Wizard, Miss! Mr. Crouch sacked bad Winky, and he was right to do it!"
"Winky's wages are with Dobby. She won't take them, so Dobby is saving them for her until Winky needs them!" Dobby squeaked quietly to them. "Dobby decided for Winky and asked Dumbledore for the same wages for her—one Galleon a week—but Winky won't take holidays. Dobby couldn't persuade her..."
"You did well, Dobby!" Hermione said, looking worriedly at the wailing Winky.
Hearing her praise, Dobby smiled sheepishly again.
"I simply can't believe she still thinks Mr. Crouch was right."
"Winky needs time to adjust, Miss. She hasn't adjusted yet!" Dobby continued. "Winky forgets that she and Mr. Crouch have broken ties. Now she can say whatever she thinks, but she can't do it."
"What? House-elves can't say what they think when commenting on their masters?" Hermione asked, frowning.
"Oh, no, absolutely not!" Dobby said, his expression suddenly serious. "This is required by the House-elf's status as a slave. We keep our masters' secrets, we remain silent, we uphold the family's honor, and we never speak ill of our masters. However, Professor Dumbledore told Dobby that he doesn't insist we must do this. He said we can..."
Dobby suddenly became nervous and leaned closer to Evan and Hermione.
He lowered his voice even further, making sure no one else could hear what he was saying.
"He said we can call him a silly old fool if we want to!"
Then, Dobby straightened up and let out a dry, fearful laugh.
"You can say that about me too, if you want. That is your freedom, Dobby!" Evan said.
"Me too!" Hermione added.
"No, no, Miss, Young Master Evan!" Dobby hurriedly shook his head, a look of panic on his face. He shook his head so hard that his two ears flapped, slapping against his skull. "Dobby doesn't want to do that. Dobby will never do that. Dobby likes Young Master Evan and your friends very much. Dobby is willing to keep your secrets and remain silent for you, and Dobby is proud of it."
"Thank you!" Evan said, relieved.
Dobby's eyes were quickly filling with tears again as he looked gratefully at Evan.
"Oh, so what about Malfoy? Can you say whatever you want about him now?" Evan quickly pressed on.
He knew that if he didn't find something else to talk about, Dobby would start weeping miserably while clinging to his leg again.
Hearing Evan's words, a look of fear flashed across Dobby's huge eyes.
"Dobby, Dobby can!" he said uncertainly, puffing out his tiny chest. "Dobby can tell Young Master Evan that Dobby's old master is, is, is a very bad Dark Wizard!"
Dobby stood frozen for a moment, trembling all over, stunned by his own audacity.
Then, he charged toward the nearest table and began violently banging his head against it, screaming, "Bad Dobby! Bad Dobby!"
Evan quickly grabbed the back of Dobby's tie and pulled him away from the table.
"Thank you, Young Master Evan, thank you," Dobby gasped, rubbing his forehead with his hand.
"Well, you just need more practice," Evan said. (To be continued.)8
