16
Evan's speculation shocked Hermione. She was extremely surprised and couldn't help but ask, "Are you saying Professor Moody has imprisoned someone else in the castle, and that's why he needs to prepare extra food for him?"
"It's possible. I'm more inclined to believe that person is hidden in his office." Evan nodded.
"So that's why he doesn't allow the Depends on context: House-elf (domestic to clean his room..." Hermione muttered to herself, having realized why Evan had asked those questions earlier.
"But why would Professor Moody do that? I heard he was a formidable Auror before, having captured many Dark Wizards and Death Eaters. It's impossible for him to be working for You-Know-Who!" Hermione was very confused.
If Evan hadn't pointed out the various suspicious points about Moody, she wouldn't have been able to imagine that Professor Moody could be a bad person.
"I don't know... I'm just guessing!" Evan shook his head. He couldn't be sure if it was true; there were simply too many suspicious points.
Moreover, Moody was naturally a very suspicious person, so it was normal for him not to allow the House-elf into his room. This was also why Evan hadn't been suspicious earlier, even though he had noticed some oddities.
"Could it be that someone used Polyjuice Potion to disguise themselves as Professor Moody, and then hid the real Professor Moody?"
Hermione immediately thought of this possibility. Only then would "Professor Moody" have to provide food for another person to keep him from starving to death.
"That shouldn't be it... The duration of Polyjuice Potion is limited. Unless he could replenish it at any time, he would definitely be exposed!" Evan shook his head. He had already checked this; Moody didn't have the habit of carrying a flask around, nor did he drink any beverage from time to time during class.
"By comparison, I suspect Imperius Curse more!" Evan said hesitantly.
Hermione widened her eyes. Of course, she understood what Imperius Curse was; Professor Moody had just explained the effects of this magic in Defense Against the Dark Arts class this year—it could control a wizard without anyone noticing, and it was listed as one of the three Unforgivable Curses!
"Moody is a very cautious Auror with strong willpower. It's impossible for an ordinary person to control him for such a long time. I guess it must have been You-Know-Who who acted personally. Furthermore, to prevent Moody from breaking free on his own, someone must be monitoring him at all times and periodically reinforcing the effects of Imperius Curse..." Evan spoke eloquently.
Evan had also practiced Imperius Curse, such a practical Dark Arts spell, and was well aware of its drawback: it could be broken free from by those with strong willpower.
As for ways to solve this drawback, they weren't non-existent. Just like how he controlled Nott, dispatching someone to monitor and periodically reinforce Imperius Curse could greatly prevent the other party from escaping his control.
Of course, such a method was not perfect.
Because casting Imperius Curse on the same person repeatedly in a short period of time easily makes them develop a corresponding resistance, significantly weakening the power of the spell, which in turn requires more frequent casting, until falling into a vicious cycle.
Hermione's understanding of Imperius Curse was far less clear than Evan's, but she could understand the seriousness of the matter. So, after Evan finished stating his speculation, she hurriedly pulled him and was about to run upstairs. "Since Professor Moody is being controlled, let's hurry and save him!"
"Wait, Hermione!" Evan helplessly stopped Hermione's movement, then, under the Little Witch's puzzled gaze, spoke again.
"I'm just speculating. There isn't enough evidence to prove it! What if Professor Moody really is a big eater, and just happens to like eating late-night snacks while working overtime? That's not impossible."
Hermione was dumbfounded. She stared blankly at Evan, and after a while, she pursed her lips in distress and said, "Then... what should we do?"
"Of course, go back and think it over, and see if we can find more clues in the next few days..." Evan said hesitantly, but this time, before he could finish, Hermione interrupted directly.
"Don't lie to me. You must be planning to go find Professor Moody alone later!"
The Little Witch bit her lip and glared at Evan angrily. How could she not guess that Evan intended to fool her and then take risks alone? For a moment, she wanted to scold him.
However, thinking that she probably wouldn't be of any help if she followed him, Hermione swallowed the words that were on the tip of her tongue. Feeling distressed, she finally whispered aggrievedly.
"It's too dangerous. At the very least, you should tell Professor Dumbledore about this! What if it's actually a trap, and someone is deliberately showing flaws to lure you in?"
Evan looked at the Little Witch in front of him, sighed after a long while, and compromised. "Alright, you're right this time!"
Because many pieces of intelligence were inconvenient to disclose, Evan had become accustomed to solving everything on his own over the years, and had occasionally been tripped up a few times. Hermione's reminder this time, however, made him realize that there was indeed no need to take risks alone for some things.
...
Half an hour later, in the Headmaster's Office at the top of the tower, Evan briefly outlined his suspicions. Dumbledore was pacing back and forth in the spacious office with his brows tightly locked.
"Hals, can you be sure that Alastor has been controlled by someone using Imperius Curse?" Dumbledore asked.
Evan shook his head. Everything he had said was just a guess; he couldn't be one hundred percent sure.
"Professor Dumbledore, isn't there any way to detect this kind of Dark Arts?" Hermione asked confusedly.
"I'm afraid not, Miss Granger. As far as I know, there is no specific Counter-curse for Imperius Curse; otherwise, it wouldn't have been listed as an Unforgivable Curse." Dumbledore replied.
Evan nodded. Imperius Curse was a very troublesome magic that had once caused great trouble for the Ministry of Magic. Death Eaters like Lucius had used it to escape conviction, relying on the fact that Imperius Curse was difficult to obtain evidence for.
Only those skilled masters of Legilimency could discover some clues by browsing memories.
However, Moody's vigilance was simply too high; if anyone used Legilimency on him, they would definitely be detected.
Evan recalled their previous encounters and found that Moody almost always used that magical eye to make eye contact with him. It was obvious that the other party was consciously guarding against this.
Dumbledore pondered for a long time. Alastor was one of his most trusted friends, and throughout this half of the school year, the other party had never revealed anything amiss; everything was so familiar. Therefore, he had never doubted this old friend, even entrusting the important task of investigating the Goblet of Fire to him.
