By the time the bronze bell chimed for the last time, it was pitch black outside the window.

Spells across all four rings ceased at once. The students, having practiced all evening, lowered their Wands; some leaned against cushions to stretch their wrists, while others squatted to clean up the feathers and wood scraps scattered around the silver lines.

Flitwick stepped back onto the platform in the center of the room.

"That will be all for tonight. Check your Wands and personal belongings before leaving. Our next meeting will still be on Friday."

The students pushed the protective barriers back against the wall and neatly stacked the cushions. Passing the doorway, the third-year girl who had dueled Caesar earlier raised her Wand to him with a quick salute before leaving with her companion.

Caesar picked up his outer robe resting by the wall.

"Mr. Nero, please stay for a moment."

Waiting until the last student closed the door behind them, Flitwick pulled out the sheet he had just been writing on from a few rolls of parchment.

"In the first match, you only used a single Disarming Charm."

"Yes."

"In the second match, there were several opportunities to end it, yet you switched to other Spells," Flitwick asked. "Why?"

"I wanted to see how she would defend when those Spells hit a real person."

The reasoning was straightforward enough.

Stationary wooden targets wouldn't dodge, wouldn't use a Shield Charm, nor would they counterattack immediately after blocking a strike. Having finally found an older student willing to fight seriously, Caesar didn't want to end it with just another Disarming Charm.

Flitwick waited for a moment. "That's the only reason?"

"That Senior wasn't bad-looking either," Caesar said. "She deserved a few more courteous rounds than the previous one."

Flitwick's hand holding the quill paused.

He clearly hadn't expected this answer among the ones he had anticipated.

"Appearance generally shouldn't dictate the duration of a duel."

"Which is why my main goal was still testing the Spells."

Flitwick stared at him for a few seconds and ultimately decided not to write that line down on the parchment.

"What about at the end?" he asked. "When you cleared the central path, did you know she would drop her defense?"

"I felt she would."

"Based on what?"

Caesar paused to think.

"Hard to say. She kept wanting to counterattack, so if I opened up the space, she'd naturally strike."

"Did you anticipate the shift in her grip on her Wand beforehand?"

"Maybe I did," Caesar said. "I wasn't overthinking it at the time."

Flitwick set down his quill.

He had originally intended to ask Caesar when he judged his opponent's next move, and whether he based his decision on positioning, gaze, or casting intervals. But Caesar hadn't methodically analyzed any of those factors before choosing the correct move.

When his opponent raised her hand, he naturally knew where to dodge. When the distance shifted, he knew where the next Spell should land. When he wanted to end the duel, he offered an opening, instinctively knowing she would pounce.

These judgments translated into action first; the rationale came only afterward.

"Have you ever received formal dueling training before?" Flitwick asked.

"No."

"I don't just mean Hogwarts coursework. Family training, private tutoring—even if only for a few weeks?"

"None at all."

"Has anyone taught you how to gauge distance, or how to strike in the brief pauses between an opponent's spellcasts?"

"No," Caesar said. "I practiced Spells on my own and have been in a few actual skirmishes."

After a moment, he looked up.

"This isn't a learned tactic."

Caesar waited for him to continue.

"It is instinct," Flitwick said. "More precisely, a dueling instinct. Many students practice for years and still need to think through which Spell to use first. You haven't even learned those rules, yet your body already seizes the opportunity for you."

His voice remained steady, but his gaze grew far more serious than before.

"You are a born duelist, Mr. Nero."

Only a few lights along the wall remained lit in the practice room.

Caesar looked down at the ebony Wand in his hand.

"But instinct cannot replace training," Flitwick continued. "It can tell you when to move, but it cannot grant you footwork, defensive charms, or counter-curses you've never learned."

He retrieved a footstool from behind the platform, stepped up onto it to push the last protective barrier back to the wall, and then pointed to a spot near the boundary line from the second match.

"When you dodged the Binding Curse, your right foot landed too straight. Tonight's opponent didn't capitalize on it, but next time, against someone more experienced, you might be forced to keep retreating."

Caesar walked over to that spot and stepped back once, recreating his earlier movement.

Flitwick lightly tapped the tip of Caesar's shoe with his Wand.

"Turn it outward slightly. That way, you can react in time regardless of which direction you go."

Caesar repeated the movement. With his toe angled outward, turning his body indeed felt much smoother.

"And then there's defense," Flitwick said. "You spent almost the entire night dodging. Speed can help you evade a Spell, but a trained opponent will first force you into the only position you can move to."

"So I should practice footwork and defense first?"

"And common counter-curses. Not learning ten harder offensive Spells first."

Flitwick returned to the desk and pulled out the schedule for the next club session from the bottom.

Caesar's name had originally been written on the first line of the beginner group, followed by stationary targets, basic defense, and two rounds of restricted sparring.

The quill struck through his name, erasing it from its original spot.

"Starting next time, you won't be participating in the regular new members' practice."

Flitwick added a column on the other side of the paper, placing Caesar into the combat group under his direct supervision.

"I will pair you with different types of upperclassmen. Some excel at defense, some move fast, and others like to chain crowd-control Spells. Your instincts will tell you how to fight, and I will correct the parts it hasn't learned."

"Including footwork like earlier?"

"We'll start right with footwork."

Flitwick wrote a new arrival time next to Caesar's name, blew the ink dry, and slipped the roster into a binder.

"Next Friday, twenty minutes early. Bring your Wand and be on time."