16
The red train made a rhythmic clattering sound as the scenery outside the window slowly shifted. Initially, churches with red-brick spires were visible, but they were soon replaced by a vast expanse of white snow.
While Michael and Theo both fell into silence, the compartment became unusually quiet. Ryan took out his holiday homework and asked Wade for advice in a lowered voice.
"‘On the Influence of the Seventeenth-Century Goblin Rebellions on the Relationship Between Wizards and Goblins’—it's holiday homework. Professor Binns required three feet, but I've only written an opening."
Ryan said with some difficulty, "I don't know how to start writing."
Wade knew his friend well and understood that this kind of History of Magic assignment wasn't actually difficult for him.
Even a first-year student, when faced with such a topic, could get by by simply copying content from the textbook or finding two extracurricular books on the History of Magic to excerpt a few paragraphs.
So Wade thought for a moment and said, "I guess it's not that you can't write it, but rather that you have too many things you want to say, which is why you don't know where to start?"
As if something he had been bottling up for a long time had been hit right on the mark, Ryan immediately nodded excitedly and said:
"Yes, exactly that!"
He turned around, pulled a thin notebook from a gap in his suitcase, and whispered:
"You know, I have quite a few Muggle relatives. During the holidays, we went to visit an uncle, and I... I saw a few books in his study."
Wade asked, "What kind of books?"
Ryan said hesitantly, "They were about... about their... wars without magic."
Wade raised an eyebrow but didn't speak.
Ryan continued, "After I finished reading them, my mind was full of those words from the books while I was writing the History of Magic essay."
Wade: "For example?"
Ryan said, "For example—the productivity of Goblins and their relations of production with Wizards; and the Magic World's reliance on Goblin craftsmanship. This is what the book called... the economic base, right?"
He looked up at Wade.
"Also, things produced by Goblins belong to Wizards, but the Goblins don't agree. Isn't this a conflict in the definition of property rights?"
He looked down at the messy words in his notebook, as if seeing the chaotic thoughts in his mind from then until now.
"I don't know if I can write it like this."
Ryan said with lowered eyes, "This is different from what Professor Binns taught. I'm a bit confused about what's right and what's wrong..."
"Or should these thoughts of mine not appear in the homework at all?"
"Of course they shouldn't!" Michael, who had started listening at some point, interrupted.
He frowned slightly. "Although I didn't quite understand, Ryan, are you feeling a bit of sympathy for the Goblins? They aren't humans!"
"I know," Ryan said gently. "I know what they are, Michael. I also know that in the past rebellion wars, many humans died at the hands of Goblins."
"Goblins have killed Wizards, and Wizards have killed Goblins. Both sides have the other's blood on their hands. This is an undeniable and unchangeable fact."
"I just think..."
He turned his gaze to Wade and said softly:
"Even if the Goblin rebellions were suppressed, the root cause of the problem wasn't solved. Then rebellions will definitely happen again in the future, and more people will die for it."
"So I feel... I feel..."
Wade understood the words he was struggling to say: "You feel that the reason the Goblin rebellion wars happened fundamentally lies in the exploitation and oppression of one race by another?"
Ryan breathed a sigh of relief and nodded gently.
Theo looked at him with concern. "Ryan, you never told me you were thinking this way."
"Sorry," Ryan said, looking at him with clear apology in his eyes. "I didn't know how to discuss these things with you."
Theo was from a pure-blood background; he didn't know much about Muggle books and might not even understand what Ryan was talking about.
But Ryan knew that Wade would definitely understand.
"It's a good thing you didn't write these words in your essay."
Michael remarked, "Otherwise, Professor Binns would definitely give you a big 'T'."
"It's one thing to sympathize with enemies, but to actually sympathize with Goblins..."
He shook his head and didn't continue.
At Hogwarts, 'T' stands for 'Troll,' the lowest grade a Professor can give a student.
It was only because Ryan and Michael were friends; otherwise, he wouldn't have known what kind of harsh words he might have said.
Wade didn't speak immediately. He reached out and pulled the notebook in front of him, flipped through it, focused on the original book passages Ryan had noted down, and then pushed it back with a smile.
"I think your ideas actually make a lot of sense, but this isn't something that can be explained clearly in a three-foot essay; even a hundred feet might not be enough."
He encouraged, "You can entirely treat it as a long-term project to study slowly. Maybe in ten or twenty years, you'll be able to explain this issue clearly to others, and even tell us how to completely resolve the conflict between the two races."
"But for now, you can think from these perspectives—"
He pulled out a piece of parchment and wrote down three lines:
【Mismatch between Contribution and Treatment】
【Spirit of Contract and Artisan Rights】
【Financial Monopoly and Profit Distribution】
Ryan leaned in to look, his eyes flickering slightly as if he understood something, yet a greater mist still shrouded his heart.
"Wow, Wade!" Michael said in an exaggerated tone. "Can he fit all that into a three-foot space?"
"The homework certainly can't be written like that."
Wade said calmly to Ryan, "Before you clarify your own thoughts, you might as well follow the existing rules for a bit. For example—write an essay that Professor Binns will approve of."
"Don't interpret Goblin rebellions as Muggle wars. These two seem similar, but they are fundamentally different."
"For instance, regarding who weapons belong to, this is actually a difference in how Wizards and Goblins understand transactions. What seems like a reasonable exchange of equal value to us is a kind of robbery to them."
"And as for the economic base, you only need to simply list facts in your essay."
"For example, in the late seventeenth century, Wizards tried three times to limit the Goblins' power in Gringotts, but all failed. Why was that?"
"I know that!" Theo said quickly. "Because only Goblins can maintain the vault system. If Wizards try to move against them, they'll find they can't withdraw their money safely!"
"See!" Wade said with a smile. "Starting from this perspective, first list the facts, then analyze the reasons, and finally predict potential future problems. Doesn't that make the essay much easier to write?"
Ryan nodded. "I know how to write it now... Thank you, Wade."
He took the parchment and stared at those three lines, remaining silent for a long time.
Michael nudged Wade with his arm and whispered, "Seriously, to say such a long string of things right off the bat... You've already thought about the questions Ryan is considering, haven't you?"
Wade raised his eyebrows and smiled. "My holiday homework is the same as yours, did you forget?"
"I know that, of course." Michael looked at his expression and said, "But I think your reasons for considering these things are definitely different from Ryan's."
"Perhaps." Wade propped his arm on the window ledge, looked into the distance, and said, "But our concerns for the future should be the same."
Michael withdrew his gaze and muttered, "...Maybe I should find a couple of Muggle books to read too?"
