16
“Just say not to speak loudly in the tavern.” Minerva McGonagall glared at Flitwick and Hagrid.
What Tabitha just said: 'Even if You-Know-Who stuck his nose to the window, he wouldn't find the Potter residence,' was Flitwick’s exact remark in the tavern.
Flitwick’s face turned red; he had assumed Hagrid’s voice was the loudest, but unexpectedly, even his words were completely overheard.
Hagrid didn't dare make a sound either, his broad shoulders hunched up, trying to minimize his sense of presence.
Lupin’s attention was entirely on the light screen; up to this point, everything Tabitha had narrated were events that had already occurred.
The turning point seemed imminent.
Luna and the others were more astonished that Black might have been the Potters' Secret Keeper. Previously, they only knew Black was Harry's godfather.
Hagrid hadn't been detailed at the time, and their assumption that his tone of disgust when mentioning Black was because Black was a Death Eater.
Ron observed Malfoy’s expression. Malfoy had known about the complex relationship between Harry and Black earlier than them. Did he also know about the Secret Keeper?
Malfoy was looking at Ron with a provocative gaze.
“He knew long ago! How is this guy so well-informed!” Ron was very unwilling to accept that Malfoy knew things they had worked hard to find out so easily.
“His mother, Narcissa Malfoy, was originally Narcissa Black.” Neville said.
Seeing Ron look over in shock, Neville added, “My grandmother made me memorize the relationships between pure-blood families.”
“But it’s too messy; I only remember a little bit.” Neville smiled shyly.
“That’s not strange then.” Ron felt much more balanced mentally. “So it’s a relative relationship. Then his mother must have investigated the reason her brother was imprisoned.”
“Hermione, what are you thinking?” Ginny noticed Hermione hadn't spoken for a long time.
“Why did the story suddenly switch to You-Know-Who chasing Harry’s family?” Hermione calmly analyzed the logic of the conversation. “Tabitha definitely has more to say.”
Snape knew what Tabitha hadn't said. It was that prophecy...
Tabitha’s hesitant expression only appeared for an instant, but he captured that subtle change.
Then did she also know who foolishly revealed that prophecy to the Dark Lord?
Snape engaged Occlumency, clearing all emotion before he could continue listening.
“Black is the Secret Keeper?”
After Harry asked this question, he felt everything could finally connect.
Death Eater, prison break, pursuit. This was the information he knew.
But why didn't he know Black had betrayed his parents?
Minister Fudge was the Minister for Magic; he surely knew. That’s why he so easily didn't pursue Harry for using unauthorized magic in the Muggle world.
What about Ron’s father? Harry recalled how cautiously he had warned Harry not to seek out Black before Harry’s first year, the look of regret on his face. He was also an insider.
What about Headmaster Dumbledore? Head of House McGonagall? Even Hagrid?
The anger in Harry’s heart burned calmly. Why had no one ever wanted to tell him anything?
Tabitha placed her hand on Harry’s shoulder, and warmth penetrated the layers of fabric, transmitting to Harry.
Harry felt that warmth spread from his shoulder into his heart. He looked up and met Tabitha’s eyes, seriously waiting to listen to what she had to say.
“That was their original plan.”
“They changed the plan?” Harry couldn't help but speak; he asked urgently, wanting to know the truth.
“Yes, Black ultimately did not become the Secret Keeper.” To ensure Harry could hear clearly, Tabitha spoke very slowly.
At the same time, she was closely monitoring Harry’s condition, prepared to administer medicine if Harry had an emotional breakdown.
“Then who could it be?” Harry’s voice carried hatred. “Who betrayed my parents?”
“Peter Pettigrew.”
“That’s impossible!” Professor McGonagall exclaimed, her throat hoarse. “That foolish boy was clearly blown to pieces by Black!”
Lupin, however, felt a sense of relief. He was more inclined to believe this was the truth.
“Let’s keep listening, Minerva.” A sharp glint flashed in Dumbledore’s eyes. If this was true, they had a huge mistake to correct.
Among the students, there were also sounds of murmuring discussion.
“Peter Pettigrew?” Harry repeated the name.
He found it a bit hard to believe that this person was only mentioned when Tabitha was talking about his father’s student days.
Why choose him as the Secret Keeper? Harry felt the possibility of Professor Lupin being chosen was even higher.
However, upon considering that the Secret Keeper betrayed his parents, Harry changed his mind. He liked Professor Lupin very much and was unwilling to place the betrayal on him.
Shock diluted the anger, and Harry waited for Tabitha to explain.
“Your father insisted on Sirius being the Secret Keeper at first. Sirius was the person he trusted most.
Professor Dumbledore once offered to serve as the Secret Keeper, suspecting someone was constantly passing information to You-Know-Who—that person was by your father’s side—but your father and the others refused.”
“Why did he refuse Dumbledore?” Harry said with deep disappointment. If his father had let Dumbledore be the Secret Keeper, he would probably have a happy family now.
“He trusted Black too much; they could entrust each other's lives to one another.”
“Then how did the Secret Keeper become Peter Pettigrew?” Harry snapped out of his regret.
“That happened after they refused Dumbledore. I’ve forgotten exactly who brought it up.” Tabitha spoke righteously. After so long, it was entirely normal for her to forget the details.
“Anyway, one of the two of them had a sudden inspiration and came up with a ‘good idea’.” Tabitha’s tone was slightly strange when she said 'good idea'.
“They thought using an inconspicuous person as the Secret Keeper could serve to confuse You-Know-Who.
They privately replaced the Secret Keeper, still publicly claiming Sirius was the Secret Keeper.
Peter and Sirius would hide separately. Even if You-Know-Who found Sirius, he wouldn't get any information about the Potter family.
But they didn't expect Peter to happen to be the traitor among them.”
McGonagall remained stunned for a long time, two completely different 'truths' swirling in her mind. She didn't know which one to believe.
“But the Ministry of Magic has witnesses. They heard the words Peter shouted before he died that day; he wanted to avenge James and Lily even in death.” This was the first time Hagrid had seen Tabitha, and he couldn't fully trust her words yet.
“Yes, and now Peter is dead, while Sirius is still alive. If Sirius is completely innocent, why didn't he defend himself during the many years he spent in Azkaban?” Flitwick voiced his doubt.
He still held suspicion in his heart, but his address for Black had reverted to Sirius.
