16
Harry wasn't the only one startled by Lavender's sudden mention of his name.
In the pitch-black room, a Wizard whose eyes reflected a green light had suddenly called out Harry's real name.
Even knowing that the person was the adult Lavender, a fellow Housemate of theirs, Ron still felt goosebumps all over his body.
He kept rubbing his arms, trying to soothe the sudden chill that had shot up his spine.
"Did Lavender recognize him..."
There was almost no doubt in Ron's tone; having witnessed Luna's almost supernatural ability to identify people, he wouldn't underestimate anyone appearing in the Order of the Phoenix.
Besides, Lavender's recognition process at least left a trail, unlike Luna, who just unleashed her 'ultimate move' from the start.
Hermione had already had a premonition.
This premonition became clearer and clearer when Lavender sought the opinion of a child she was supposedly meeting for the first time.
"Pretty much, but I think Lavender is mistaking Harry for 'Harry'," Hermione said with certainty.
No one would easily believe there were two identical people in the world.
Lavender hadn't attended the meeting and hadn't heard Ilowen's explanation regarding Harry's current situation.
Perhaps she had sensed something off about Harry's body from previous clues and then mistook Harry for a version of 'Harry' who had lost his memory due to some error.
That was why she was pressing Harry for his thoughts on the matter.
Hermione couldn't help but worry about how Harry, having taken Veritaserum, would answer truthfully.
She hoped it wouldn't ruin the friendship between Lavender and Harry.
Harry was first a bit rattled by Lavender's long-drawn-out call of his name, and then he was hit with the most difficult question of his life.
If he were 'Harry'...
Actually, there was no 'if'; he was Harry.
If such a complicated situation arose between two of his friends...
"I would go and ask clearly," Harry said, his eyes resolute. "If Ilowen did something wrong, I'd drag her over to apologize; if not, I'd have her explain herself. Have you tried asking her face-to-face?"
"What a cunning answer," Lavender sighed. "But it's not as if I haven't asked."
"Eh?" Harry's resolve suddenly faltered. Surely Ilowen didn't give a vague answer, or worse, no answer at all!
Lavender's expression was faint, her hoarse voice doing a good job of masking her emotions.
"You might have forgotten, but you made a rare Slytherin friend. Just as you suspect, she said nothing at all."
"Actually, not all Slytherins are like that," Zabini tried to break the stereotype others held of Slytherin.
At least when dealing with true friends, they could open half their hearts.
Pansy curled her fingers, signaling Zabini to look at the two most'sincere' and guileless people in their Slytherin house.
Crabbe and Goyle were nodding repeatedly in agreement with Zabini.
Zabini immediately fell silent. Fine, let the stereotype be a stereotype; it wasn't necessarily a bad thing.
Harry, his head throbbing, didn't notice Lavender's inadvertent mention of his circle of friends.
His entire mind was focused on pondering over Ilowen.
Why! Just why?
Harry didn't believe Ilowen would disregard Lavender's life just because of some misunderstandings during their school days.
Setting aside Draco from Ilowen's own House, just looking at Lucius Malfoy—Harry had experienced firsthand how loathsome that man was.
And when Narcissa tried to save her son from Voldemort, her first choice was to lure Ilowen into a trap.
Yet Ilowen still didn't give up on saving the Malfoy family, bringing them out entirely intact.
There was no reason for her to be so harsh toward Lavender.
Another piece of evidence was that if Ilowen really hated Lavender that much, why would she help treat her later?
Could someone be impersonating Ilowen? With Polyjuice Potion appearing so frequently lately, Harry instinctively thought of an impostor.
But he dismissed the idea himself.
At that time, Ilowen was just an ordinary seventh-year student; what benefit would there be in impersonating her?
Then... wait...
Harry suddenly remembered the Q&A he had with Ilowen by the Black Lake.
He had asked what the thin line on Ilowen's wrist was.
'An Unbreakable Vow. I cannot kill You-Know-Who, and in exchange, he cannot harm anything in Hogwarts.'
'Not any person, portrait, ghost, or House-elf.'
'It happened when You-Know-Who attacked Hogwarts. He wouldn't accept conditions that were too harsh, and I didn't have time to waste; people were dying almost every second.'
Those were Ilowen's exact words, followed by her own account of the vow's loopholes—it only restricted Voldemort himself, not his subordinates, and she forgot that Voldemort could take people outside Hogwarts to execute them.
Harry realized he had overlooked something.
If a seventh-year Ilowen could use her strength to force Voldemort into an Unbreakable Vow, she should have sought more help—from Professor McGonagall or Professor Flitwick, for instance—and chosen a more advantageous plan to drive Voldemort out of the school or even kill him once and for all.
Instead of desperately making a mutually binding vow because people were dying every moment.
The way Ilowen forced Voldemort had loopholes.
That war had come so unexpectedly that even the the professors hadn't realized Voldemort would turn the school into a battlefield; many students had to be evacuated in a panic.
By the same token, Ilowen wouldn't have prepared a plan for Voldemort far in advance; it could only have been something she scrambled to put together after the battle started.
In that case, Ilowen's disregard for Lavender's plight seemed to make sense; she was busy saving more lives and ignored the tragedy unfolding right beside her.
Harry found to his conflict that he could understand both sides.
One couldn't say who was wrong in this whole matter; Ilowen, who wanted to save more people, wasn't wrong, and Lavender, who wanted to be saved and sought Ilowen's help, was even more innocent.
To Lavender's questioning, Ilowen could only respond with silence.
Otherwise, was she supposed to say: 'I have nothing against you personally, you were just part of the many lives I selectively gave up on'?
Just thinking about it made Harry feel a pang of heartache for Lavender.
His shifting expressions were caught by Lavender.
Lavender asked softly, "What did you think of?"
Harry said, "The Unbreakable Vow."
Harry was indeed thinking about that.
What he was wondering was, given Ilowen's personality, would she obediently tell everyone who was curious about this experience of making a vow that, in hindsight, was a pure failure?
Even if they were fellow members of the Order of the Phoenix, Ilowen might not be that honest.
She could tell the most realistic lies without blinking, and only when forced to reveal the truth would she stingily let slip a couple of honest words.
Presumably, if Ilowen hadn't been wary of his excessive proactiveness—to prevent him from going on spontaneous trips every day to uncover the truth—she wouldn't have been so transparent with him.
So the question was, was Lavender among those in the know?
