16
“In this case, we can clearly see in the video that the knife-wielding criminal had already stabbed the elderly man with a dagger. This fulfills the condition of actively committing a crime. The elderly man's counterattack constitutes Special Legitimate Defense, and there is no excessive defense! Therefore, everyone just needs to wait for the old hero to return safely!”
Seeing the lawyer's clear and concise analysis, many citizens who were worried about Chen Jingde's safety breathed a sigh of relief. It seemed that Chen Jingde really would be fine!
The previous “expert” was momentarily silenced. After all, the law was clearly laid out. He could try to sensationalize and fool ordinary people who didn't understand the law, but now that a professional lawyer had brought up the relevant laws and explained them clearly, no one would listen to him even if he wanted to argue senselessly. He couldn't possibly claim that the laws formulated by the state were flawed, could he?
However, it wasn't long before people thought the “expert” had quieted down, yet he jumped out again. This time, he stopped arguing whether Chen Jingde's defense was excessive and instead started accusing Chen Jingde of being too cruel and vicious, lacking Martial Virtue.
“The 'old hero' you speak of, who acted bravely for a just cause, is, in my opinion, a vicious thug who enjoys fighting. He clearly possessed superior martial arts skills and could have easily subdued the opponent, yet he chose to cruelly kill him! Although the victim was a thief, he was still a person and should have been given a chance to reform. If your 'old hero' hadn't killed him, the law would have given him a fair trial, and he would have received the punishment he deserved, but certainly not the death penalty! This misguided young man would have had a chance to repent and start anew! Furthermore, the person who severely injured the four victims should also be arrested! Those four clearly hadn't made a move yet; they might have just wanted to scare them. And this Middle-aged Man in the video, the son of the killer, is just as vicious as his father, actually stepping forward and beating them into severe injury! This is no longer just excessive defense; it should be considered Intentional Injury! I strongly urge the police to arrest him and bring him to justice, giving the victims fairness!”
As soon as his statement was released, it was met with overwhelming condemnation.
When you previously discussed excessive defense, people who didn't understand the law well might still consider it an objective discussion, but now he had elevated the discussion to the level of humanity, belittling Chen Jingde based on “Martial Virtue.” This disgusted the vast majority of people. Justice resides in the hearts of the people; demanding that an elderly man whose life was endangered by a knife attack give the aggressor a chance to reform was simply nonsense!
The accusation against Chen Weiguo was even more ridiculous. If four knife-wielding criminals walk towards you, do you have to wait for their knives to pierce your body before you can fight back?
Countless people left comments below, cursing him vehemently.
“There should be a limit to being unconventional and sensationalizing!”
“How dare you call yourself an expert when you can't even distinguish basic right from wrong?”
“It's easy to talk when you're not the one suffering!”
“Did you take money from the theft ring?”
He had thought this statement would turn the situation around.
Unexpectedly, it drew even more condemnation. The “expert,” who was surprised after failing legally and having finally found a new reason for attack—intending to stand on the moral high ground and use “human rights” to win a round and grab attention—was not new to this game. He often rode on trending topics, publishing theories contrary to mainstream views: if he could argue law, he argued law; if law failed, he argued morality; if morality failed, he dragged in human rights.
In the past, if both sides of an incident had valid points, or if the target of his attack had both supporters and detractors, his tactic might have worked. But this time, he chose the wrong target, or perhaps his past successes made him too confident, thinking the public was too foolish. In this incident, who was good and who was bad, who was right and who was wrong, was clear at a glance. Everyone had reached a conclusion in their hearts, and the vast majority stood firmly on Chen Jingde's side. His decision to come out and sing a contrary tune now could only provoke public outrage.
Aside from the angry curses and condemnation from countless netizens, the lawyer who had previously refuted him immediately posted an article refuting him again.
“Not killing is Benevolence, but killing is Righteousness!”
“I don't understand martial arts, so I don't know if this eighty-four-year-old man could easily subdue the opponent while ensuring his own safety, as claimed by a certain person, when facing the attack of a sharp, potentially fatal dagger held by this 'vicious' criminal. Nor do I know if this 'vicious' criminal, who pulled a knife to kill after failing to steal, would truly repent and turn over a new leaf. I only know that in that moment, the elderly man's life was threatened, and the lives of his family and the bystanders were also greatly threatened by this group of criminals. Under such circumstances, how can you demand that someone hold back? This is not a game between adults and children; this is a counterattack concerning life and death. I ask you, how can you demand that a person whose life is under great threat show mercy to a cruel criminal? If the elderly man had shown mercy, would the knife-wielding criminal have shown mercy?”
“According to a certain person's theory, when police arrest heinous armed criminals in the future, they shouldn't use live ammunition but rather tranquilizer guns, even if the criminal shoots back while resisting arrest, just to give him a chance to reform?”
“Here, I don't want to discuss human rights. I just want to say that indulgence toward criminals is an infringement upon the life and safety of innocent citizens! If that expert had been standing in the circle of five criminals at that time, I believe he wouldn't have made such cynical remarks! You demand others put themselves in danger, yet why don't you offer yourself to the eagles!”
As soon as the lawyer's statement was published, it was met with cheers from countless people. All the comments below the sensationalist “expert's” Social Media Platform posts uniformly changed to “Why not offer yourself to the eagles!”
Seeing that he had slightly messed up and completely incited public outrage, the “expert” began to panic, fearing that if he spoke further, angry netizens might actually show up at his door. He didn't bother trying to clear his name and simply quieted down obediently, ceasing to speak.
This incident was just one of many controversies surrounding Chen Jingde's counter-killing. The various related disputes never stopped. Besides the debate over whether Chen Jingde's actions constituted legitimate defense, the greater focus and skepticism centered on the formidable strength Chen Jingde displayed.
Some people even dug up the details about Chen Jingde's hospitalization after a car accident.
“According to what I've learned, Old Master Chen was severely injured in a car accident a few months ago and became a vegetative patient. He only woke up recently. Furthermore, none of the people who know him were aware that he practiced martial arts, nor had they ever seen him demonstrate it to his family.”
