16
After the meeting ended.
Baixing Robot immediately used its official account to reply with a pinned comment in the original post's comment section.
"Thank you for the user's authentic feedback.
This is precisely the extreme case we wanted to collect by conducting small-batch real-scene verification.
When a child falls to the ground but does not cry, or the crying is very faint, and there are no large-scale movements, the trigger threshold of the existing posture recognition might indeed result in a missed detection.
This is indeed a limitation of baixing s01.
This limitation already has a prompt in the update pop-up window, but we realize that text reminders are not enough to convey the risk.
Next, we will make two adjustments:
First, change the record of 'fallen posture without crying' from a default-off option into a more eye-catching orange optional reminder in the app, and use a bolded pop-up window on the startup guide and function introduction pages to mark all the boundaries of this function once again.
Second, this case will be recorded into the training data set and incorporated into the requirements document for the baixing s01 complete machine.
Reiterate once more: This function is always just a family auxiliary tool and can never replace adult supervision.
We, Baixing Robot, will always accept everyone's criticisms and continue to iterate and optimize."
...
After Baixing Robot replied.
Although there was still a portion of people who didn't buy it.
The quarrels in the comment section did not subside either.
But at least, it didn't let public opinion continue to run wildly off-course in the direction of "cold-blooded robots".
Now it was just waiting for the storm to slowly cool down.
...
Just as Baixing Robot temporarily stabilized the public opinion storm regarding the child soothing module on this side.
On the other side, a multitude of domestic commercial service robot manufacturers smelled an opportunity taking advantage of this controversy.
Several companies focusing on hotel and shopping mall inspection robots quietly released third-party horizontal evaluation videos.
Although the video did not directly name White Star, it overtly and covertly used its own public version scheme machine to make a scene comparison with baixing s01.
Then it deliberately magnified the flaws of baixing s01.
Moreover, this video editing was also very biased.
One was that in the open and regular environment of the shopping mall, their robots walked stably, responded quickly, and had almost no misjudgments.
As a result, the camera turned, and the scene came straight to the cluttered living room setting of a family.
The occasional hesitation in posture recognition and the trigger restrictions in children's scenes of baixing s01 were repeatedly slowed down and featured in close-ups.
Furthermore, their copywriting was also written quite ambiguously.
"At present, consumer-grade home robots are still in the experimental stage, and many problems as well as safety risks have not been completely resolved.
Commercial standardized solutions are the safest choice at present.
..."
Not long after this video was posted, quite a few digital self-media outlets smelled traffic and then followed up one after another.
Someone compared the limited edition price of baixing s01, which was over 200,000 yuan, with domestic commercial robots priced at tens of thousands of yuan.
And then proceeded to unfold the topic:
Is it really worth it to spend a high price buying an experimental product that is still stepping into pitfalls and making trial-and-error?
And this topic also generated huge popularity.
Seeing this situation, digital bloggers who were still watching from the sidelines previously also took out disassembly data in a smooth trend.
They put baixing s01 and Boston Dynamics' motion performance and other robots into a comparison table.
In the table, the hardware parameters of baixing s01 were not top-notch.
Its robotic arm load and chassis obstacle-crossing ability had an obvious gap compared to industrial-grade machines.
Of course, its advantages were also very obvious; take its visual semantic understanding, home scene adaptation, and full-link data closed-loop for example, these were all at the absolute top level globally.
...
Because of these bloggers' science popularization.
The internet started quarreling again.
Those peers also saw the opportunity and immediately began to fan the flames.
"In my view, White Star is just using users as lab mice.
Using those users' data to feed the algorithm for free, and when problems arise, taking 'auxiliary tool' as a shield—essentially transferring research and development risks to consumers."
...
These voices spread all the way along social platforms.
Some netizens already had lingering concerns about the previous overstepping incident.
After being led by the rhythm, their emotions towards baixing s01 became even heavier.
Unsurprisingly, after these messages were seen by Baixing Robot.
Their Marketing Department exploded directly.
Because those peers deliberately led the rhythm to smear them, coupled with those self-media outlets also magnifying flaws in order to gain traffic.
If this continues, subsequent baixing s01 will definitely be affected.
Therefore, after organizing the information, the Marketing Director immediately went to Jiang Huaixing's office with a group of executives from White Star Technology.
"General Manager Jiang, currently several competing products are making a fuss taking advantage of the controversial points of our grayscale testing.
Now the entire internet is comparing our shortcomings with other people's standardized products.
So should we issue a counter-attack draft and also dissect the shortcomings of competing products' public version schemes?"
The algorithm person-in-charge who came in with him also followed up and said:
"And they even shamelessly use open commercial environments to benchmark against our disordered family scenes.
This in itself is an unfair comparison.
Their commercial robots have fixed environments and preset routes, requiring almost no autonomous decision-making.
While our baixing s01 faces a complex environment where furniture is placed casually, children run around, and debris is everywhere.
The recognition difficulty between the two is simply not on the same magnitude."
Jiang Huaixing listened while flipping through the evaluation videos and comparison tables.
"We don't need to argue head-on with them."
"And what they said is not entirely false.
The initial batch of baixing s01 were verification machines to begin with.
These flaws are indeed objective facts, and we have no need to deny them."
"They compare standardized commercial products with our home robots, which is essentially swapping the concept of scenarios.
The more we argue, the more we will fall into the opponent's rhythm."
The Product Director asked.
"General Manager Jiang, what should we do then?
Could it be that we just let them smear us?"
"No, since the popularity has already risen, we will take the momentum and turn the comparison into industry science popularization."
"First, openly admit that as the first-generation home general-purpose robot, baixing s01 has limitations in scenario adaptation, and we are continuously optimizing all iteration problems.
Second, popularize the science of the differences between the two tracks to netizens.
Let netizens understand that their commercial robots are fixed-scenario execution tools, while home general-purpose robots are dynamic environment autonomous adaptation; the technical goals of the two are completely different, and there is no direct comparability."
"Third, organize the family data sets and safety optimization plans accumulated from our small-batch verification into an industry white paper and make it public."
Hearing this, the Product Director was stunned for a moment.
"Ah? Make our trial-and-error experience public?
Those commercial manufacturers can't even do autonomous decision-making well, if we make the scheme public, wouldn't they be able to take it directly to make up for their shortcomings?
Wouldn't this just cheapen them for free?"
Jiang Huaixing glanced at him and said.
"What do you think our biggest asset is?"
The Product Director frowned.
"Technology?"
