Chapter 70 utilitarianism

The omnibus rattled along. Arthur sat by the window looking out, while the young policeman Field sat awkwardly to the side.

Although there wasn't much of an age gap between them—Field was even slightly older.

However, for some reason, perhaps a matter of personal aura, or perhaps because of Arthur's calm, unchanging expression, Field always felt an invisible pressure.

He remained silent for a long time before finally being unable to help asking: "Sir, how on earth did you solve those cases? You might not know, but our place has been going crazy these past few days. Seeing through the truth of that hotel murder case in just a few words—it's simply miraculous."

"Miraculous?"

Arthur leaned against the window: "If you put your heart into it, you can do it too in the future."

"As long as it's a homicide, it's nothing more than a few patterns—either for emotion or for profit."

"While there are indeed heartless, inhuman fellows in this world, they are, after all, a tiny minority. You might handle cases for ten years without meeting someone like that. Moreover, it's hard to find a pattern in their killings; it's very likely just a sudden impulse."

"Dealing with those people, in most cases, one can only rely on technical means to track and pursue them."

"However, the minority is the minority after all. For most cases, you just need to reason according to logic."

"Overall, it's because as long as a person lives in this society, they will always have some social characteristics."

"Of course, society changes, so human sociality changes too. This is indeed worth noting."

Field asked curiously: "Is today's sociality different from the past?"

Arthur pursed his lips and spoke: "Haven't you heard the proclamations of the clergy on the streets?"

"They say that since entering the 19th century, everyone has been looking toward money, and that old, beautiful England is gone forever."

"Therefore, murders for passion have decreased, murders for honor have disappeared, and what's left is all for money and greed."

"Though they don't say these things entirely out of justice—after all, it's well known that the clergy despise the factory owners."

"But sometimes looking back, the clergy aren't entirely wrong."

"Because if you have no clue about a case, starting with the suspect's financial records often leads to unexpected discoveries."

"And the muggers, pickpockets, and thieves on London's streets are right there."

"From day to night, prostitutes can be seen everywhere singing and soliciting customers."

"Those Members of Parliament say that these hardships can temper their spirits and make them better people."

"But they just don't mention that hardships have brought a juvenile crime rate as high as thirty percent to the East End of London."

"They also say poverty is due to laziness, but they don't mention that the average working hours for workers in London factories are over fifteen hours."

"You might not know, but I studied history at university."

"Therefore, I know that even in the dark Middle Ages people talk about, the poor didn't live like this."

"Back then, they could still have a small stone house in the countryside and pick up firewood in the Fields to burn."

"But now?"

"Picking up firewood in a rural Field might break the law because it's not your land; farmers no longer have their own land."

"And let's not even talk about the workers. I know that in Whitechapel, over ten thousand people in two or three thousand families are squeezed into fourteen hundred dilapidated little houses."

"And this isn't just an isolated case, because in places like Bethnal Green or St. Giles, the situation is even worse."

"Many London workers start working in factories at age six. If they're unlucky, they'll be riddled with disease by their teens."

"Then, no place will want them anymore."

"They can only end up on the streets—men selling violence, women selling their bodies."

"And we, this lot of police, have to lock them in prison and fine them."

"The first time they're imprisoned, they might still get some sympathy."

"The second time, they might get some understanding."

"But what about the third or fourth time?"

"By then, the jury and the Magistrate won't show any more mercy."

"So, actually, once a poor person commits their first crime, their fate is already sealed."

"It's either the gallows or exile to Australia, without exception."

"They already live like this, yet after they die, someone still wants to steal their corpses and..."

When Arthur said this, he suddenly felt a tightness in his chest. He remembered the scene he had seen at St. Thomas' Hospital that day.

He took out his pipe, intending to light it, then hesitated and put it back in his pocket.

Seeing this, Field hurried to wave his hand: "Go ahead and smoke, I don't mind."

Hearing this, Arthur smiled and shook his head: "But I do."

Field looked at Arthur and asked curiously: "So, that's why you want to hang that group of body snatchers, the murderers who sell corpses, and those doctors all together?"

Arthur didn't shy away: "From a moral and emotional standpoint, yes. But from a legal standpoint, a corpse is just a corpse. We can only hang those who actually did the killing, but we can't hang those who paid them to kill."

Field thought for a moment and asked: "Then is that right?"

Arthur looked out the window; the rain was still falling: "I don't know if it's right either. I'm just a policeman. I'm told to uphold justice and righteousness, but I'm not clear on what actually counts as justice and righteousness. At least our current written laws don't qualify, because I know many people are not satisfied with them."

The Red Devil's figure flickered behind him. After disappearing for a night, Agares' appearance today was different from before.

Not only had he discarded the pitchfork he always carried, but he had also put on a set of jet-black robes and even wore a pair of glasses.

On his shoulder stood a black raven with blood-red eyes summoned from who-knows-where, and in his hand, he held a parchment roll written in unintelligible characters.

Agares chuckled, rubbing his palms as he spoke: "Arthur, why think so much? Your justice is justice, and your righteousness is righteousness."

"As long as you make up your mind, I can provide you with the killer's location right now. The price is very fair and very cheap."

"Let's finish this case quickly, and then we can head toward an even greater future."

Arthur ignored him and instead turned his gaze out the window. The road ahead seemed crowded with many people, and even the carriage's speed slowed down.

Arthur pulled open the carriage window and leaned out to look. The streets here looked very familiar to him.

This was Gore Street in London's Bloomsbury district, where he had spent four years.

Just as his head leaned out the window, he felt a solid slap on the back of his head.

Arthur turned his head and met Elder's punchable smiling face.

"Arthur! My good brother! I knew you'd definitely come today. After all, the one visiting the school to give a speech today is the spiritual mentor of us University of London students—Jeremy Bentham!"

"Jeremy Bentham?" Arthur fell silent for a moment, seemingly remembering something: "utilitarianism?"