16
Although Arthur had often talked nonsense at the Treasury to secure budgets for Scotland Yard during his time at the Home Office...
At least today, his arguments before the Board of Admiralty were not just fabricated.
It was an open secret that corruption was rampant within the Royal Dockyard, but that didn't mean Arthur supported closing the existing seven Royal Dockyard.
Firstly, no government department would ever willingly take a knife to itself.
No matter how corrupt the Royal Dockyard were, they were still subordinate institutions of the Admiralty.
Therefore, reform and reorganization were one thing, but direct closure would be taking things too far.
Secondly, while Arthur could understand Peel's idea of reducing costs and increasing efficiency—and private shipyards did indeed offer lower quotes than Royal Dockyard—if one looked at the long-term timeline, it was easy to see that while private construction costs were lower, the subsequent maintenance costs for the vessels were significantly higher than those of the Royal Dockyard.
The HMS Wanderer, contracted and built by a private shipyard, had an initial construction cost of 7,020 pounds, which was indeed 1,300 pounds cheaper than the HMS Penguin, a vessel of the same class built by the Pembroke Royal Dockyard.
However, when comparing the maintenance bills for these two ships over the following years, it was easy to discover that the Wanderer's total maintenance costs over nearly eight years reached as high as 8,225 pounds, while the Penguin, produced by the Royal Dockyard, cost only 1,540 pounds.
In other words, if one looked at the total economic balance sheet, giving orders to the Royal Dockyard was actually much cheaper than giving them to private shipyards.
Of course, Arthur wasn't saying this to accuse private shipyards of fraudulent quoting.
The reason for such a large difference in maintenance quotes was mainly determined by their respective scale and capital investment.
For private shipyards, their first considerations were cost and efficiency, which meant they couldn't afford to keep large stockpiles of seasoned timber year-round just to wait for government shipbuilding contracts that might never come. If they did that, they would go bankrupt before long.
As for the Royal Dockyard, supported by the national treasury, they never had concerns about efficiency.
In most cases, their worry was whether they could complete the tasks assigned by the Admiralty on time and in quantity, rather than the cost.
Therefore, a very paradoxical point was that the extravagance and bureaucratic style of the Royal Dockyard were, to some extent, even necessary.
There is no such thing as perfection in the world. You can demand a reduction in waste as much as possible, and you can demand a cleanup of bureaucracy, but if you truly required the Royal Dockyard to operate entirely on a market basis, it would instead lead to chaos.
Because of the existence of bureaucracy, the Royal Dockyard could unconditionally execute the Admiralty's decisions.
Because of their extravagance, they could ensure to the greatest extent that the Royal Navy's ships were always in peak condition.
Although the views Arthur presented to the Board were quite counter-intuitive, the gentlemen sitting on the Board were no fools; they knew that even if Arthur wasn't entirely right, he certainly had a point.
But even if Arthur's words made sense, the Earl of Haddington couldn't help but feel his scalp tingle at the thought of tomorrow's parliamentary questioning.
Because on the issue of pushing for the outsourcing of shipbuilding contracts, the Admiralty's opponents weren't just the Benthamites; they even included Prime Minister Peel and the free-trade faction within the Conservative Party.
"Hmm——" The Earl of Haddington leaned back in his chair with his arms crossed. He pondered for a moment, then suddenly looked up at Arthur.
"Sir Arthur."
"My Lord."
"Firstly, I must admit your logic is very convincing. But you also know that even if you were the incarnation of truth, the House of Commons might not be convinced. Humans are very strange creatures; although we are God's most outstanding creation, in many cases, we won't turn back until we hit a wall."
"Are you saying the existing evidence isn't sufficient to explain the situation?"
The Earl of Haddington nodded helplessly. "Exactly. Without evidence so substantial it's irrefutable, the House of Commons will naturally lean toward supporting a private contracting system. Many colleagues within the party also have doubts; after all, with the current economic downturn and the massive pressure of fiscal tightening, every single expenditure will be under the strictest scrutiny."
Arthur had known this wouldn't be easy to push forward, but he didn't intend to give up.
He persisted in defending the dockyard department: "I understand what you mean, My Lord. However, if we look at it from a more macro perspective, the high cost of the Royal Dockyard isn't entirely a burden. Its spillover effects on communities, employment, and the industrial chain are far beyond what private shipyards can match."
At this point, Arthur pulled out another document: "Take a 120-gun ship of the line as an example. Although the Royal Dockyard's current quote is as high as 171,700 pounds, building such a warship doesn't just directly provide 224 jobs for the shipyard. In the upstream and downstream industries, the large amounts of timber, steel, copper, and castings required by the Royal Dockyard mostly rely on domestic factories and numerous naval suppliers. Shipbuilding, especially for the Navy, is vital to the economies of many towns. If we look back at the development of the British economy over the past thirty years, we can easily see that after the Napoleonic Wars ended, many coastal towns suffered severe economic depressions."
Hearing this, First Secretary Herbert suddenly stopped and flipped through the list of House of Commons members in his hand, then spoke softly.
"My Lord, My Lord."
The Earl of Haddington turned and asked, "What is it, Herbert?"
Herbert hesitated. "Well..."
The Earl of Haddington said dissatisfiedly, "Is there something that can't be said directly in the Board meeting?"
"Alright——" Herbert gave a forced smile. "I think, on the point of pushing forward the private contracting system, perhaps the central party caucus needs further discussion."
The Earl of Haddington was stunned for a moment, but soon he caught the meaning. "Who was elected in the towns where the seven Royal Dockyard are located?"
Herbert leaned over and whispered in the Earl's ear, "Except for losing one seat in Plymouth, we've taken all the other regions."
"Hiss——" The Earl of Haddington sucked in a breath of cold air.
As a member of the House of Lords, he wasn't as clear about the seat distribution in the House of Commons as Herbert was.
Therefore, although he knew the Conservatives had won a landslide in this election, he hadn't carefully studied the support rates and vote counts in various regions.
Under normal circumstances, the locations of the seven major Royal Navy Dockyards were traditional Whig strongholds. Who could have imagined that even they would flip in this year's election?
However, even if the Conservatives did well this year, their seats in these traditional Whig areas certainly wouldn't be very stable.
If they cut the Royal Dockyard' orders and business now, wouldn't the Conservative MPs from those regions collectively jump in protest?
Conservative MPs who could get elected in such traditional Whig constituencies were basically figures with great local prestige and considerable personal strength. If they were pushed to the point of opposing the central party caucus or even defecting, then...
At that thought, the Earl of Haddington immediately changed his tune. "While controlling budget spending is the general direction of the government's administration, there's more than one way to achieve that goal."
"So——" Haddington pointed to the several file boxes by Arthur's hand. "Sir Arthur, take these materials you have—including the comparison between the Wanderer and the Penguin, the employment data, and the spillover effects on the industrial chain—and organize them into a complete report as soon as possible. This afternoon, I want to take it to the Cabinet meeting for discussion and study."
"Yes, My Lord." Arthur took notes as he listened. "I'll have someone organize it as soon as the meeting adjourns and have it sent to your office before lunch is over."
"Alright, that's all for today. See you all tomorrow." Haddington stood up, gathered the documents in front of him, and tucked them under his arm. Just as he was about to leave, he seemed to remember something and turned back to advise: "One more thing. What you said just now about the bureaucracy of the Royal Dockyard, the extravagance, and the logic behind the high costs—I can listen to that in the committee. But saying it at a Cabinet meeting would have a different flavor. Some of our colleagues in the Cabinet are firm believers in free trade; they won't stand for talk about the Royal Dockyard being 'irreplaceable'."
Arthur picked up his documents and bowed slightly with a smile. "I understand what you mean. I'll make the report look as good as possible. Don't they like science? I'll write more about the impact of research results on the Royal Navy—for example, how the Froude number will significantly reduce inefficient processes in the dockyard department and enhance the Royal Navy's combat effectiveness."
The Earl of Haddington laughed heartily upon hearing this, as if a weight had been lifted from his mind. "Exactly, write more of that. Sir Arthur, I hope you keep up the good work."
In traditional British views, gluttony has always been considered a sin.
To cultivate a child's resilient spirit and physique, whether from the aristocracy, the middle class, or the lower class, parents would intermittently choose to let their children go hungry for a meal.
Since even children with both parents were often half-starved, it was even worse for orphans in the workhouses.
—
Oliver Twist, the protagonist of "Oliver Twist," being scolded by the workhouse beadle for asking for another bowl of porridge was no artistic exaggeration, but a piece of realist writing.
Of course, in this era where the light of civilization was just beginning to flicker, there were always those who stood against such unreasonable and boorish habits.
In this enlightened age, there was no longer a need to feign pious condemnation of Roman gluttony and debauchery, nor to use the revelries of Tiberius,
Apicius, or Lucullus as warnings of imperial decline. Even Alexandre Dumas's culinary concepts were gradually being understood by British society.
After all, even the miser in Molière's play said: "One should eat to live, not live to eat."
.
However, considering that British culinary standards had long been at the bottom compared to other nations—and would steadily remain so in the future—if you wanted to find high-end restaurants in London, you might as well consider those specializing in foreign cuisine.
In a cosmopolitan metropolis like London, as long as you have enough money, time, and persistence, you can always satisfy your palate within reasonable bounds.
But for a busy man like Sir Arthur Hastings, when, where, and what to eat depended largely on his daytime and evening work schedule.
If official business required his presence in The City during the day, or if he had to attend a rehearsal of a new play published in the Empire at a theater in the evening, he would naturally choose a nearby location.
If his digestion was slightly impaired, a light Italian dinner was clearly more suitable than a rich French one.
If he had engaged in vigorous exercise all day and had an appetite as large as a Germanic tribesman's, then local dishes like steak and mutton chops would receive their due appreciation.
For those acting suspiciously near Nightingale Mansion, there was no better place than the "Bedford Tavern" or the "Crone Tavern" in Covent Garden. The Cabernet Sauvignon at the Bedford Tavern had always been regarded as the finest in London, while at the Crone Tavern, the Port wine had remained extremely authentic to this day.
As for the gentlemen lingering in Leicester Square, they weren't all explorers like Elder Carter.
As a gathering place for foreigners, the exotic Leicester Square had always been a hub for international delicacies; as long as you came here with an empty stomach, you could travel the culinary world within half a day.
Of course, most of the foods mentioned above were affordable; if you wanted to host a distinguished guest, you would need to go somewhere more upscale.
If you could afford the annual membership fee of 6 pounds, the Athenaeum Club was clearly a good choice.
With its excellent collection of books and maps, free access to domestic and foreign dailies and various periodicals, and exquisite dinners costing 3 to 4 shillings, the Athenaeum Club had become the preferred destination for the rising middle class.
For upper-class gentlemen with Whig or Tory political backgrounds, the cooking, wine, and service at Brooks's Club and Boodle's Club were top-notch.
However, since Arthur took office at the Admiralty, the Royal Thames Yacht Club had opened its arms to the Second Secretary.
Perhaps "opened its arms" isn't the right phrase, because judging by the attentive attitude of the club's chairman, Mr. Handel, they were more like throwing themselves at him.
To be honest, compared to London's oldest clubs, the Royal Thames Yacht Club didn't have much of an advantage in terms of service and cooking, but it had one undeniable merit that suited Arthur's tastes perfectly.
Just as their name suggests—Yacht—the club's location wasn't fixed. Every evening after the guests boarded, they would sail away from the port, far from The City's noise and the surveillance of spies.
And the food available on board was not ordinary sailor's rations.
Although they also sold hard biscuits, canned meat, vegetables, milk, cocoa, and rum, they were supplied at club prices rather than at a quartermaster's profit margin.
As long as your wallet was thick enough, everything was available here: from pea soup to real turtle meat, from steamed turbot to crimped Severn salmon, from a mutton chop to a large haunch of venison, from Scotch collops to roast chicken breast with truffle sauce, and from Port wine to Imperial Tokay from the Hungarian Mount Stag region.
When the heavy oak door of the yacht's dining room was pushed open, the smoke, the aroma of coffee, and the sound of conversation all rushed out together.
Walking further in, in a private booth by the window, Arthur was leaning back in a velvet seat, lighting a cigar.
He leisurely puffed out a cloud of smoke: "When will Isambard arrive?"
Elder, sitting opposite him with legs crossed, pulled out his pocket watch and took a look: "Should be soon. The ship sets sail in half an hour."
Speaking of which, Elder familiarly reached for the cigar box and matches in front of Arthur and lit one for himself: "By the way, is Brunel really reliable? I don't know much about shipbuilding, but after so many years at the Admiralty, I've at least seen a thing or two. An iron-hulled screw propeller steamship with a displacement of 3,400 tons and 1,500 horsepower—when I first saw that, I thought I'd miscounted a zero. You should know that the current naval vessel with the highest steam horsepower is only 540; his is nearly triple that of the Royal Navy. If you hadn't told me, I would've thought he was building a first-rate ship of the line, not a liner!"
While Brunel's design seemed insane to Elder, in Arthur's view, the series of steamship plans introduced by the French government was far more unreasonable than Brunel's ideas.
Despite many people accusing him of being conservative, at least in the application of new technology, Arthur was definitely a radical on par with Brunel, perhaps even a step ahead.
From a future perspective, even the horsepower of a domestic car could reach 200. He had no idea what the French Navy intended to do with so many 160-horsepower steamships—were they planning to race them in the Dakar?
Naval funding was already tight, so rather than iterating slowly, it was better to get it right in one step.
Although Brunel's ship, the "SS Great Britain," was a civilian project, if he succeeded, it would certainly serve as a demonstration for the Admiralty, thereby accelerating their pace in embracing steam power. Conversely, if he failed, it would have a disastrous impact on the reformists within the Royal Navy.
Because of this, Arthur had to spare no effort in supporting the visionary dreams of Britain's most outstanding engineer, even if the shipbuilding cost—equivalent to the wealth of two middle-class families—was currently an unbearable burden in his life.
Knock, knock, knock!
A knock sounded at the door.
"Sir Arthur, Mr. Brunel has arrived."
>
