16
"HMS Lutine, I presume this name must still be fresh in the memory of Lloyd's."
No sooner had Elder finished speaking than, as expected, the three representatives from Lloyd's couldn't sit still.
For the global shipping insurance giant Lloyd's, the 1799 sinking of HMS Lutine after hitting a reef was absolutely the most painful memory in the company's century-long history.
As one can tell from her name, HMS is the abbreviation for His/Her Majesty's Ship, which means this vessel was a commissioned warship of the Royal Navy.
Just like many of the Royal Navy's decorated warships, HMS Lutine was not built in Britain, but was the work of French engineers.
This Magicienne-class 32-gun frigate was launched in Toulon in 1779 and was initially controlled by the French Legitimists. However, after the Siege of Toulon ended in 1799, to prevent HMS Lutine from falling into the hands of the Republicans, the Legitimists handed her over to the British fleet commanded by Lord Hood along with fifteen other ships.
After the Royal Navy acquired her, they quickly refitted her into a 38-gun fifth-rate frigate and sent HMS Lutine to serve in the North Sea, during which time she also participated in the blockade of Amsterdam.
During the War of the Second Coalition, in order to overthrow the Batavian Republic and restore the House of Orange's rule in the Netherlands, the British government decided to send 28,000 troops to land in the Netherlands. To secure supplies for the Army and maintain the fragile wartime economy of their German allies, HMS Lutine was tasked by the Admiralty with transporting approximately 1.2 million pounds in gold bars and silver coins to Cuxhaven.
Unfortunately, on the night of October 9, 1799, a fierce northwest wind raged. Influenced by the severe weather, HMS Lutine accidentally went off course and was dragged by the tides rushing into the Wadden Sea, where she struck a reef near the island of Terschelling. Of the 240 passengers and crew on board, all but one perished in the surging waves.
Due to the harsh weather conditions, British rescue ships could not set sail before dawn, so by the time they arrived, nothing remained on the sea surface except for the wreckage.
For Britain and the Anti-French Coalition, this was, of course, an unfortunate incident. 240 lives and 1.2 million pounds in hard cash simply disappeared to the seabed of the West Frisian Islands. Even an economic powerhouse like Britain could not easily say, "This is just a temporary setback."
However, the silver lining was that the cargo carried by HMS Lutine was insured, so after the ship met with disaster, the cargo owners at least received compensation from the insurance company.
Well then, who paid this money?
Presumably, smart people have already guessed it. After all, searching the whole world, the only company capable of swallowing an insurance policy of this scale at once was Lloyd's.
According to the records at Lloyd's headquarters, the cargo carried by HMS Lutine was underwritten by Lloyd's of London, and this policy worth 1.2 million pounds was paid in full.
Although Lloyd's was wealthy, the compensation amount of 1.2 million pounds—
Let's put it this way: last year, the Belgian government's fiscal revenue was approximately 4 million pounds. In other words, Lloyd's had to pay out 30% of Belgium's tax revenue in one go.
It is no exaggeration to say that if the Lloyd's brand in The City were not so solid, causing many banks to extend a helping hand after the HMS Lutine incident, and if the cargo owners had not agreed to installment payments, perhaps the century-long history of Lloyd's would have come to an end in 1799.
Of course, Lloyd's did not pay this money for nothing. According to the abandonment clause, as the underwriter, Lloyd's automatically obtained ownership of the gold from HMS Lutine after paying the claims, though this right was practically worthless to them.
Shortly after HMS Lutine sank, the Admiralty instructed Captain Portlock of the squadron to attempt to salvage the cargo for the benefit of the owners, but unfortunately, the sea conditions at the wreck site were complex, and it was during the Napoleonic Wars, so the salvage work was soon abandoned.
Although Lloyd's had sent agents to survey the wreck, and even the Dutch government had asserted sovereignty over the cargo on HMS Lutine, claiming it as spoils of war, none of the salvage teams organized by the Admiralty, Lloyd's, or the Dutch government managed to recover much cargo.
After the Napoleonic Wars ended, Dutch merchant Pierre Eschauzier successfully petitioned King William I and obtained exclusive salvage rights based on a Dutch royal decree, on the condition that half of the proceeds from the salvage be given to the Dutch royal family.
But after Lloyd's learned of this, they immediately sent people to lobby the British government, urging them to lodge a formal protest with the Dutch government to uphold Lloyd's ownership of the HMS Lutine wreck.
After two years of negotiations, the two governments finally reached a consensus. King William I of the Netherlands issued a decree granting the Netherlands' legal rights to the HMS Lutine wreck to the British royal family to demonstrate the friendly relationship between the Netherlands and Great Britain.
Although the Dutch never acknowledged Britain's sovereignty over the wreck from the beginning, as the saying goes, you can't have your cake and eat it too. Since the Dutch agreed to give the substance of the salvage to Britain, Britain naturally had to give the Dutch some face.
King George IV of Britain first thanked his Dutch brother for his generosity, then gifted this little present given to him by William I to Lloyd's. Lloyd's, having merely received back what was theirs, still had to thank both Majesties for their extreme generosity.
Although this sounds quite stifling, the matter was far from over.
Because after Lloyd's regained the salvage rights, they immediately organized a team to go to sea. To their disappointment, due to decades of seawater erosion and changes in underwater currents, the wreck had sunk from the original 7.5 meters underwater to nearly 14 meters. Moreover, because most of the wooden barrels containing the gold and silver had disintegrated, the seawater had long since scattered and buried most of the cargo.
In the end, Lloyd's spent more than half a year on salvage operations, yet more than 90% of the cargo was not recovered.
Now, nearly 20 years have passed since the last large-scale salvage operation, and Lloyd's had long ceased to hold any hope for salvaging HMS Lutine. If Elder hadn't mentioned it just now, most insurance brokers at Lloyd's would probably only regard the "HMS Lutine treasure" as some ancient legend. But now—
Robinson was so excited that his hands were trembling slightly: "Mr. Carter, you mentioned HMS Lutine, could it be that this exploration project by the Admiralty—"
Elder cleared his throat and spoke in a theatrical tone: "Ahem, sorry, Mr. Robinson, do you have any wine here? Before announcing this good news, I would like to moisten my throat first."
Perry hurriedly shouted toward the door at the top of his lungs: "Quick! Someone, bring—"
But halfway through his shout, he suddenly remembered that this was in the Lloyd's office, not on a barge salon at the Lord Mayor of London's inauguration ceremony.
He swallowed the second half of his order and hurriedly walked to the mahogany liquor cabinet in the corner himself.
Perry pulled open the cabinet door, where several bottles of whiskey and silver goblets were neatly arranged, but he didn't even look at them. Instead, he bent down and pulled out a bottle of French cognac sealed tightly with wax from the very bottom of the cabinet.
"This bottle is a vintage from 1815." Just as Perry placed the bottle on the table, Hawkins had already hurriedly handed over the letter opener at hand. Perry carefully scraped off the wax seal, his wrist gave a slight shake, and the deep red, almost black liquid slid slowly down the side of the glass, diffusing the mellow aroma of oak and black cherry throughout the meeting room: "I had originally planned to open this bottle at Christmas, but, to hell with it! Today is the best time!"
Elder took the glass, first held it up to the sunlight to admire the color, and then leaned in to sniff it. It wasn't until he noticed Arthur staring at him that Elder leisurely took a small sip.
He placed the glass by his hand, looked at the three Lloyd's representatives in front of him who were so anxious they could have stood on the table, and finally said: "Gentlemen, when Colonel FitzRoy was conducting a seabed topographic survey of the waters around the island of Great Britain, he accidentally discovered that a straight channel had formed near the Goodwin Sands. This channel happens to run right across the top of HMS Lutine. According to the report sent back by Colonel FitzRoy, the wreck is not only free from sand coverage, but even the bow, stern, deck, and sides have completely detached, with only the keel, inner keel, and some attached ribs remaining intact. Therefore—"
Seeing Elder putting on such an act, Arthur had to take the initiative to add: "Based on the preliminary assessment by the Admiralty's scientific department, the external conditions for restarting the salvage work have matured. Moreover, considering that the news may leak at any time, which would inevitably attract a large number of busybodies to engage in illegal salvage, we suggest that Lloyd's should organize personnel to go to the incident area as soon as possible to maintain their legal rights."
No sooner had Arthur finished speaking than Robinson stood up from his chair in excitement.
"Sir Arthur, this news—this news—you have truly brought me a surprise!"
Feeling as if his face were about to cramp from smiling, Robinson couldn't help but turn to Perry and Hawkins: "Gentlemen, did you hear that? HMS Lutine! It's that damn HMS Lutine!"
Perry was holding the newly opened bottle of cognac. He had been busy pouring drinks for Arthur and Elder, and it wasn't until Robinson shouted for the second time that he woke up as if from a dream, placed the bottle on the table, and hurriedly took out his pocket watch from his jacket pocket to take a look.
"Today is Thursday—" Piri muttered to himself, then suddenly looked up and said: "If we send a letter to our agents in the Netherlands right now, and have them arrive at Terschelling before the weekend, we could have the report by next Friday at the earliest. If everything goes smoothly, the first batch of gold bars could be shipped back to London before the end of the year. This is simply—simply a godsend of a Christmas gift!"
Hawkins appeared to be the calmest of the three, but in reality, that was only because his legs had gone weak, rendering him unable to stand.
"Sir Arthur, Mr. Carter, the news you two brought today is of no less value to Lloyd's than the transatlantic telegraph project you are currently pushing!"
Arthur waved his hand, a gentle and appropriate smile on his face, as if this were merely a small favor and not worth such a fuss.
"Mr. Hawkins, that is too formal. Maintaining the legitimate overseas rights of British companies has always been the duty of the Royal Navy. The ownership of the Lutine shipwreck was clearly assigned to Lloyd's as early as the reign of His Majesty George IV; the Admiralty is merely fulfilling its obligations. On this matter, you need not thank the Admiralty, and certainly not me personally. If you must thank someone, you might as well thank Colonel FitzRoy for his keen eye. If he hadn't happened to linger for a few hours on the West Frisian Islands that day, we likely would have missed this newly formed channel."
These words were spoken with such grandiosity and were so watertight that Hawkins was momentarily at a loss for how to respond.
However, Piri and Robinson had long been waiting for what would come next. Sure enough, as soon as Arthur finished speaking, Elder, who was in charge of playing the 'good cop', spoke up.
"Mr. Hawkins, Mr. Robinson, and Mayor Piri, I must point out one thing. Gratitude is never just something you say; it must be demonstrated through actual actions. Sir Arthur is humble by Nature and seeks no reward, but as Assistant Secretary to the Admiralty, I cannot sit by and watch the hard work of the Royal Navy go to waste. Lloyd's isn't really planning to just send a few ferries out to sea to salvage that one million two hundred thousand pounds of gold, are they?"
Robinson immediately understood the implication and laughed heartily: "Mr. Carter, rest assured. While Lloyd's dares not compare itself to the Royal Navy, we do have some experience in handling shipwreck salvage. I will wire our agent in the Netherlands tonight and have him rush to the site immediately. Salvage ships, divers, lifting equipment—nothing will be missing. Of course, regarding maritime security, I hope the Admiralty can provide some convenience—"
"That goes without saying," Arthur nodded slightly: "I have already instructed Colonel FitzRoy's survey ship to remain in the nearby waters. Before Lloyd's salvage ship arrives, they will be responsible for monitoring the situation around the wreck to prevent any unauthorized, illegal salvage vessels from approaching. However—"
He changed the subject, his face showing difficulty: "Mr. Robinson, as you know, the Royal Navy is currently facing pressure from budget cuts, and the number of ships available for deployment is limited. Colonel FitzRoy's ship cannot stay near Terschelling indefinitely; after all, he still has to return to report on his survey mission in the English Channel. Therefore, time is not on Lloyd's side, and I hope you can understand that."
Robinson knew this was Arthur urging them to make a quick decision on the submarine telegraph investment. He gritted his teeth: "Sir Arthur, to be honest, I was indeed hesitant about the submarine telegraph matter before. But the news you two brought today has made me completely resolve to proceed."
He turned around to face Piri and Hawkins: "Gentlemen, what do you think?"
Piri rubbed his chin, pondered for a moment, and said: "Although Lloyd's primary business is shipping insurance, we understand better than Fleet Street that information is money. If the submarine telegraph can truly shorten the message transmission time between London and Brussels to within a day, its value to the shipping industry will be no less than that pile of gold on the Lutine. If a board meeting is called, I will certainly cast my vote for the submarine telegraph."
Hawkins also stated his position: "As a representative of Lloyd's Register, I believe the submarine telegraph is equally beneficial for the ship classification business. If we can obtain meteorological and shipping lane information from continental European ports in real-time, we will have more accurate data support when assessing vessel conditions and route risks. Since you both have stated your positions, I have nothing more to say."
"Good!" Robinson turned to face Arthur: "Sir Arthur, Mr. Piri, Mr. Hawkins, and I, representing Lloyd's, The City of London, and Lloyd's Register respectively, are willing to each contribute funds to jointly—"
Unexpectedly, before he could finish, Arthur raised his hand and interrupted him.
"Wait, Mr. Robinson." Arthur's expression suddenly turned serious, and his brows furrowed slightly: "I think you have misunderstood something. Although I am the Second Secretary to the Admiralty, the transatlantic telegraph project is my personal interest and has nothing to do with the Admiralty. My conversation with you all earlier regarding the submarine telegraph was merely an extension of the casual chat we gentlemen were having in the smoking room." He stood up, tapped his cane lightly on the floor, and swept his gaze slowly across the three men's faces, his tone rather blunt: "If you think that I, Arthur Hastings, came to visit today to use the Admiralty's discovery as a bargaining chip for my own private commercial project, then I am going to be displeased."
The office, which had been bustling just a moment ago, fell silent instantly.
"No, no, no!" Robinson was the first to react: "We absolutely did not mean that! Sir Arthur, please do not misunderstand. Your noble character is well known on Fleet Street—no, not just Fleet Street, but the entire City. My words just now absolutely did not imply that you were abusing your power for personal gain; it was purely—"
"Purely out of our sincere admiration for the transatlantic telegraph project!" Piri quickly took over the conversation. The new mayor was clearly a bit anxious. He set his wine glass on the table and gestured excitedly in the air with both hands: "To put it mildly, this project is a milestone of British engineering and another great conquest of the forces of Nature by humanity. Although we are not as knowledgeable as you, we at least consider ourselves amateur science enthusiasts. Furthermore, once the submarine telegraph is built, it will be of great benefit to Lloyd's and The City. Why wouldn't we participate in a project that benefits both the nation and the people? This is a professional business judgment and has nothing to do with the Admiralty."
Hawkins also stood up, his tone so sincere it didn't sound like acting, as if he truly believed it from the bottom of his heart.
"Sir Arthur, I said as much last time at the Electrical Society. Precisely because science makes no distinction based on status, and everyone is equal before the truth, anyone with a passion for scientific endeavor should do their utmost to contribute to this great cause. We are willing to invest in the submarine telegraph purely out of passion for science and respect for you personally. If you are being polite to Lloyd's on this matter, you are actually pushing us out the door."
Arthur stared at the three men before him. His serious expression remained for a short while, then, like thin ice in early spring, it melted away little by little.
"So that's how it is." He sat back down in his chair, picked up his cognac, and took a sip. The smile on his face was as warm as if nothing had happened just moments before: "Then I have misunderstood you gentlemen. Sigh! To tell you the truth, ever since rumors spread that the Board of Trade was going to acquire the telegraph company, I have become a bit sensitive. Sometimes, even when others mean well, I cannot help but overthink things. On this matter, I must apologize to you all; I am truly sorry!"
"Not at all, not at all!" Robinson quickly waved his hand: "We completely understand your concerns; the Board of Trade is truly going too far on this matter. Rest assured, if Gladstone dares to make an issue of the telegraph company again, Lloyd's will be the first to object."
Piri and Hawkins also chimed in with righteous indignation. After a few glasses of cognac were downed, the atmosphere in the office relaxed once again.
Elder leaned back in his chair, crossed his legs, and casually observed the three men before him, as if everything that had just happened was within his expectations. In fact, after these few months by Arthur's side, he had slowly grown accustomed to this kind of political game of playing hard to get.
Robinson took out his pocket watch, glanced at it, and put on a smile again: "Then it's settled. We will hold a board meeting tomorrow to discuss the investment intention for the submarine telegraph project. What do you two think?"
Just as Piri and Hawkins were about to nod, Elder's voice rang out, unhurried and slow.
"Then—" Elder flicked some non-existent dust off his cuffs: "Since the submarine telegraph matter is settled, let's—let's get back to the main topic."
The three men were stunned.
Hawkins seemed not to have reacted yet: "The main topic? Mr. Carter, what main topic are you referring to—"
"The Lutine." Elder gently swirled his wine glass: "Gentlemen, the submarine telegraph is a personal interest of yours and Sir Arthur Hastings, so that topic can be set aside for now. But the salvage of the Lutine shipwreck was something our colleagues in the Royal Navy achieved with a high degree of professionalism and at the high cost of weeks of drifting at sea. How do you all intend to fulfill this gratitude toward the Admiralty?"
Robinson's smile froze on his face, Piri's hand holding the wine glass stopped in mid-air, and Hawkins narrowed his eyes and pushed up his glasses.
The three men almost simultaneously thought to themselves: "Damn it! We've been played!"
