16
Inside the office of the Lord Chancellor's Office, Viscount Melbourne and Lord Brougham sat on opposite sides of the sofa.
Before them lay several documents, densely packed with names.
Following these names were various felony charges that were chilling to behold.
Stealing large livestock, burglary, smashing and destroying machines, highway robbery, murder, treason...
Even if these charges were taken individually, they would be enough to warrant a hanging, let alone the fact that many of these individuals faced multiple charges, meaning they could only be sentenced to death repeatedly.
Lord Brougham held the list and studied it for a long time: "Over a thousand felons. If all of them were sentenced to hanging, that would be more than the total number of hangings in the past ten years combined."
Viscount Melbourne smoothed his hair and said: "I am certainly aware of that, and I have previously promised these rioters that as long as they are willing to surrender voluntarily, the government will absolutely consider leniency."
"Therefore, these thousand-plus people certainly cannot all be executed by hanging, and even executing the majority of them is out of the question.
It is no longer the time it was a dozen years ago; the spirit of freedom has taken root in Britain, and every hanging will be scrutinized under a magnifying glass by the British people, not to mention that Fleet Street keeps a group of news media that jump at every shadow."
Lord Brougham held his wine glass, crossed his legs, and leaned back on the sofa: "This is indeed a form of social progress, but at the same time, it has brought a lot of trouble to our enforcement agencies.
Although British courts have always been known for their impartiality and independent judgment, now, even if the court ultimately sentences a person to hanging, only one-tenth of those sentences can truly be carried out."
Viscount Melbourne heard this and said: "My Lord, regarding these Swing Riots, I believe that even a ten percent execution rate is still too high.
Executing over a hundred people all at once would match the total number of executions in England for the entire last year.
Regarding the trials for this riot, I have already consulted with Peel. Whether it is him as the former Home Secretary or me as the current Home Secretary, we both believe that this time, it is sufficient to execute only the ringleaders and those who committed unforgivable crimes such as murder.
As for the rest, those with less serious offenses can be considered for acquittal at our discretion, while those with more serious offenses can have their sentences commuted to transportation or hard labor."
Upon hearing this, Lord Brougham frowned slightly and said: "Viscount, please forgive my bluntness, but no one can interfere with the independence of British judges.
Although I hold the power to appoint judges to vacancies, once they are seated in that position, I have no authority to remove them from office.
If it were just a few criminals, I could indeed help you find a few judges with more flexible methods.
However, for a trial of over a thousand people, it is impossible to complete the proceedings in a short time relying on only a few judges.
Perhaps the Home Office can afford to wait, but there are very few slow-tempered journalists on Fleet Street.
If they start stirring up trouble, things will only get worse."
"No, you have misunderstood my meaning."
Viscount Melbourne said: "I certainly know that the independence of British judges is sacred and inviolable; even His Majesty the King has suffered setbacks at their hands more than once or twice.
When you were a lawyer in your early years, didn't you win that divorce case for Queen Caroline against the late King George IV?
Therefore, I will not and cannot desecrate the fairness of the court.
On the contrary, I hope all courts can conduct fair trials and pass judgments as they see fit.
My intention in proposing the establishment of the Special Tribunal Committee for the Swing Riots to oversee the trials is precisely to demonstrate the fairness, openness, and transparency of the proceedings."
Lord Brougham was no fool; as soon as he heard that Viscount Melbourne did not intend to manipulate the trials, he immediately understood the subtext.
"You want His Majesty the King to issue special pardons for those criminals after the trials conclude, don't you?"
Viscount Melbourne smiled and nodded: "I have already explained this to the Prime Minister in advance, and I will visit the other members of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council one by one later.
As long as you, the Chairman, also agree, then I believe His Majesty the King should respect the collective opinion of the committee."
Viscount Melbourne had expected that he might need to spend some effort arguing in the Lord Chancellor's Office, as Lord Brougham, the senior King's Counsel, was notoriously difficult to deal with.
Besides his somewhat cold personality, Brougham's habitually scathing writing style and rhetoric were also intimidating.
As one of the founders of the Whig Party's official newspaper, the Edinburgh Review, in his youth, besides doing his job as a lawyer very well, Lord Brougham's other great hobby was frequently attacking romantic poets like Byron, Shelley, and Keats, whose dissolute behavior he found disagreeable.
Among these attacks, the criticism of Keats was particularly vicious and intense.
It is said that when Keats was seriously ill, he coughed up blood and died precisely after seeing an article by Lord Brougham criticizing him.
Although this gossip cannot be fully trusted, London citizens still referred to him as 'Cold-blooded Brougham' for a very long time.
However, using 'cold-blooded' to summarize Brougham is actually inaccurate.
Because from the perspective of the Whig Party, he sometimes appeared too 'passionate' regarding his political stance.
In the long-standing rivalry between the Whig Party and the Tory Party, the Tory Party prided itself on valuing tradition, while the Whig Party used freedom and progress as its slogan.
But even from the perspective of the liberal and progressive Whig Party, Brougham still appeared too liberal and progressive.
Even within the already left-leaning Whig Party, Brougham belonged to the radical left wing.
On the legal front, in his youth, Brougham was already one of the fanatical supporters of legal reformer Samuel Romilly.
In terms of human rights, he was an active supporter of William Wilberforce, the founder of the abolitionist movement.
In terms of education, he was one of the first figures in Britain to call for public education.
And with his amazing ability to take action, he didn't just shout slogans; although he couldn't change the views of Parliament, Brougham still raised funds with several like-minded friends to establish the University of London.
As for the political level, Brougham was a staunch supporter of parliamentary reform, and the kind who wouldn't turn back even if ten donkeys were tied to his neck.
Perhaps it was precisely because Brougham's ideas were radical and he had the ability to act that, even though he joined the Whig Party very early and had a high social reputation, it was not until 1810 that he was officially confirmed as a parliamentary candidate by the Whig Party, who really had no one else to use.
Neither the curses of Keats' supporters nor the vicious attacks of political enemies had ever made this Lord Chancellor change his expression.
Such a maverick personality was almost the exact opposite of Viscount Melbourne, who was gentle and lazy to the point of not wanting to get into arguments with others.
Therefore, when Viscount Melbourne came to the Lord Chancellor's Office today, he had long been prepared for the possibility of hitting a wall.
After all, the matter he was bringing up to Brougham was, to a certain extent, completely contemptuous of the court's authority.
However, to his surprise, Brougham readily agreed.
"Actually, even if you hadn't come to see me, I would have petitioned His Majesty to issue a special pardon."
"Oh?" Viscount Melbourne raised his eyebrows in surprise: "What is the reason for this?"
Lord Brougham said: "Originally this matter was still in the preparatory stage, but since we have just happened to run into it, I will simply state it clearly.
Everyone knows that I have been supporting Lord Romilly's call to reform the criminal law for these years.
Although Sir Peel, during his tenure, has greatly promoted the work of abolishing the 'bloody code'.
Now, the number of capital offenses in Britain has been reduced from 222 to 56, but in my view, some capital offense clauses still need careful consideration.
For example, the hanging for 42 types of forgery is inappropriate.
Although in 1830, Parliament passed an act reaffirming the necessity of the death penalty for these forgery crimes, in reality, after discussing with Sir Radzinowicz, I found that in the past year or so, not a single criminal has been executed for committing forgery.
Sir Radzinowicz bluntly stated: 'The discrepancy between legal provisions and legal practice may be even more shocking.'
The jury does not agree with throwing away a living life because of forgery, and many in the judiciary also believe the sentencing is too heavy.
To avoid killing a person, the jury often renders a verdict of not guilty.
If this situation continues, then such a law is equivalent to a dead letter."
"So, for some time now, I have been considering replacing punishments that are disproportionate to their crimes with lighter, but more certain, penalties.
Only laws that gain public recognition can truly be implemented, and only when they can be implemented can they be called laws.
Otherwise, they are no different from Keats's verses."
"Keats's verses?"
"Mm." Lord Brougham took a small sip: "They look flowery, but in reality, they are just empty moaning, serving no purpose at all."
Viscount Melbourne, hearing this, finally felt his heart settle. He smiled and raised his glass: "Appointing you as Lord Chancellor was indeed the right decision. If the Lord Chancellors Office decides to continue pushing for judicial reform, the Home Office will certainly provide its full support."
Hearing this, Lord Brougham suddenly spoke: "However, just as you said, although His Majesty the King will grant pardons to some or commute their sentences to lighter penalties, the verdicts in court must still follow the original statutes.
Those sentenced to hanging in court must still be sentenced to hanging. If we were to show leniency in court, it would be tantamount to encouraging riots, and there would be no way to speak of the dignity and sanctity of the law. This time, it is an act of extrajudicial grace by His Majesty the King, but it shall not set a precedent."
"That is what I think as well."
Viscount Melbourne smiled and said: "Letting His Majesty the King play the good guy, I imagine he must be very happy about it. Come to think of it, the current King seems quite different from his brother; he has a naturally compassionate heart and adheres to humanitarianism.
I have heard that every time the Old Bailey court sends a death sentence to His Majesty for approval, he always reads it over several times, then orders the judge to present the case to him in person before he is willing to sign his name. In the past year, it seems that ninety percent of the death penalty cases were commuted by His Majesty himself."
Lord Brougham joked: "With His Majesty's help, your usual work has become much easier, hasn't it? If he were as lazy as the late King, according to custom, the Home Secretary would be the one approving the death sentences."
Viscount Melbourne also smiled relaxedly: "That is true. His Majesty likely knows my lazy nature and knows that not everyone has as much energy as Sir Peel. He is always very considerate of his subjects, whether they are the Home Secretary or his old brothers from the Royal Navy."
Lord Brougham blinked and smiled: "The pity is that the others in the House of Lords may not think so. A while ago, when the House of Lords was in session, I heard those old fogies complaining that His Majesty doesn't have the taste or style of his brother, that he speaks at inappropriate times, and that when he's drunk, he loves to give a long-winded pre-battle speech like he's on a ship. Even elegant French, when it comes from his mouth, smells of Caribbean tobacco."
Out of politeness, Viscount Melbourne only slightly curled the corners of his mouth without laughing out loud.
He said: "The fellows you mentioned didn't think much of him before he ascended the throne, and His Majesty himself probably didn't expect to inherit the crown. For a long time, he was the invisible member of the royal family.
Whether it was choosing to follow Admiral Nelson when he was young, or later threatening his father that he would join the House of Lords, it all goes to show that His Majesty is a person who craves attention. Although he acts inappropriately in some areas, he truly wants to be an excellent King."
Lord Brougham picked up a handkerchief and wiped his mouth: "So, that is why you gave him this opportunity, to let him show his mercy before the public of Britain and pardon those rioters?"
Viscount Melbourne chuckled softly: "It is merely a coincidence."
Viscount Melbourne was unwilling to spell it out, and Lord Brougham did not intend to press further.
As a professional lawyer, he was not very fond of social nuances, and his headstrong personality made him focus more on concrete execution.
He simply asked: "Now that the candidate to show mercy has been decided, who do you intend to entrust with the task of smearing themselves with filth? The judges' verdicts only exist as a theoretical possibility, and such a task of making someone voluntarily roll in the mud is only something a person with a broken brain would do."
With one sentence, Lord Brougham hit upon the other purpose of Viscount Melbourne's visit.
Viscount Melbourne reorganized his thoughts and analyzed slowly: "We all know the sensitivity of this trial, so we cannot find a fellow with a bad reputation to do it. That would only make the reporters on Fleet Street cheer and the citizens of Britain furious..."
"That makes a lot of sense."
Lord Brougham seemed to say offhandedly: "If you could persuade the Archbishop of Canterbury to be responsible for the prosecution, that would be even better."
"That is quite unnecessary; the prosecutor does not need to be that pure and flawless."
Viscount Melbourne hurriedly interrupted the other's wild idea, knowing that Lord Brougham had likely guessed his thoughts.
Since that was the case, he did not intend to beat around the bush and instead asked directly: "I intend to entrust this matter to the London District Prosecutors Office, or more accurately, to your star pupil, Arthur Hastings."
"Oh..." Lord Brougham rested one hand on the back of the sofa and looked out the window: "I must say, your thinking is quite erratic. From the religious leader of Britain, you suddenly veered to the University of London, that stronghold of atheism."
A simple sentence instantly pulled Viscount Melbourne back from the previous relaxed atmosphere into the cold, hard reality.
The difficulty of dealing with Lord Brougham was instantly apparent.
The reason he was so easy to talk to just now was not because he had a good temper, but because Viscount Melbourne's ideas were on the same wavelength as his.
Once their ideas clashed, it would instantly turn into hail hitting the face and a violent storm.
However, Viscount Melbourne was not incapable of understanding the other's thoughts.
The University of London, as a newly established school that had only recently received its teaching charter, did not have many famous alumni.
A few days ago, The Times had just published an advertisement for the university with Arthur Hastings as the promotional face.
In the blink of an eye, he was now asking Lord Brougham's most valued pupil to carry the dynamite, and there was absolutely no reason for such a thing in this world.
What was even more frustrating was that Arthur had just taken a bullet in Liverpool. Given Lord Brougham's temper, it was already polite of him not to have exploded immediately.
To smear his student at this time was simply not taking him seriously.
However, Viscount Melbourne had thought of this early on, and he brought out the prepared argument to persuade him.
"Actually, if there were other suitable candidates, I would not want to trouble him further. Even from my own personal feelings, Mr. Hastings has been quite helpful to me. A while ago, I had a misunderstanding with Mr. Faraday, and it was he who stepped in to help resolve it. Therefore, after the Liverpool incident occurred, I immediately transferred personnel from Scotland Yard to strengthen his security.
However, in my personal opinion, having Mr. Hastings take charge of this work will be of great benefit to his future growth. To be honest, the Home Office is currently considering revising the Metropolitan Police Act of 1829. Arthur's ability and achievements are plain for all to see.
Although exceptional promotion is not allowed to a certain extent, I have always been generous in promoting capable young people. If Arthur can do a good job with this prosecution, after the reorganization of Scotland Yard, he should be promoted to Assistant Commissioner, and those voices questioning his concurrent position as Deputy Prosecutor of the London District Prosecutors Office can also be suppressed.
Besides that, during the last Privy Council meeting, didn't we discuss the list for the next year's knighthood? The specific candidates have not been officially determined yet. If Arthur can close the case before the list is submitted, I think with this achievement, he absolutely deserves this honor."
Lord Brougham heard this, but the displeasure on his face remained.
He was just preparing to argue a few more words with Viscount Melbourne, but before he could speak, he heard a knock at the door.
"My Lord, Mr. Hastings has returned from Liverpool. Are you available to see him now?"
