16
Although it was known early on that the Central Board of Health would not bring any good news, judging from the written documents and oral statements brought by Dr. Russell and Dr. Barry, the current situation can no longer be summarized by the word "bad."
Even before cholera arrived, the Britain government had noticed this disease originating from the Indian subcontinent and had pre-emptively sent experts to investigate in various cholera-hit countries.
They even desperately restarted the port quarantine measures used against the Black Death in the Middle Ages to prevent the importation of cholera.
However, when cholera truly arrived on this island, their efforts crumbled at the first touch.
Over the past two months, more than 700 local boards of health have been established across Britain, but due to Britain's unique national character and ancient traditions of self-governance, communication and guidance from the Central Board of Health to these local boards have been quite limited.
Many measures deemed feasible by the Central Board of Health could only be labeled as "advisory" when passed down to the local level, to avoid being attacked as trampling on civil liberties or a restoration of despotism.
Of course, besides worrying about these spiritual-level attacks, the Cabinet's tendency toward compromise also stemmed from the pressure exerted on the government in Parliament by merchants worried about the impact on shipping and trade.
On the other hand, they also feared local mass riots that could appear at any time around government agencies, hospitals, and cemeteries.
Therefore, when the Central Board of Health's series of health recommendations reached the local level, the ultimate result was that the most they did was steadfastly sweep the streets.
It is undeniable that cleaning up city trash is an essential part of preventing infectious diseases and can indeed improve the sanitary environment.
But the problem is, aside from sweeping trash, their achievements in other areas were truly lackluster.
However, to some extent, their actions were a last resort.
After all, sweeping trash is arguably the cheapest, most efficient, and most visible measure to show that the government is actually doing something.
As for the other measures suggested by the Central Board of Health, they might be very good, but except for a very few areas, they simply could not afford them.
Moreover, as temporary institutions, the local boards of health had no real power granted to them by Parliament from a legal standpoint.
There is no public health law in the country, and the Cabinet cannot bypass Parliament to grant temporary administrative powers to local boards of health.
Going around and around, they really could only make a fuss on the streets.
Even worse, even making a fuss on the streets, many places declared their "ammunition depots" empty after just two months of battling cholera.
According to the Central Board of Health report, the local board of health in Exeter, Devon, sent an urgent message to London yesterday.
The Exeter authorities declared they were in a state of complete paralysis, as they could neither provide separate cemeteries nor continue to clean up the filth in private residences.
They requested the Cabinet to use an earlier Privy Council order to have the poor relief societies, formed by the merger of multiple local poor relief committees, take over the powers of the Exeter Board of Health.
Only after seeing this did Arthur understand why the Bishop of Exeter had to lead the charge locally.
It turned out the local board of health was constrained everywhere; if the Bishop of Exeter did not step forward to preside over funerals and use the power at his disposal to assist in prevention work, they probably would not even be able to approve cemeteries for the dead.
However, although the situation in Exeter was terrible, compared to the news from Leith, it was still passable.
After all, under the leadership of a respected and socially responsible figure like the Bishop of Exeter, the believers in Exeter, with a population of less than 10,000, were at least united, contributing money and effort.
Mr. James Snells, Chairman of the Leith Local Board of Health, in a letter requesting central financial aid sent to the Privy Council earlier, was filled with denunciation and sarcasm toward the local wealthy.
He stated: "In a town like Leith, do not expect any voluntary donations to provide effective preventive measures to ensure the hygiene and comfort of the living environment for the lower classes. We have no municipal funds, and even the police security funds, which could be legally used for public health, have already been exhausted."
For this reason, Parliament urgently passed a "Cholera Act."
In that bill, the government required local parish committees to pay for part of the public health expenses. If the parish refused to pay, they would be subject to corresponding penalties.
Penalty measures included, but were not limited to: the parish committee would not be allowed to withhold taxes during the penalty period, and funds from church funds would be returned to the parishioners.
However, although the bill was established.
From the feedback received by the Central Board of Health, the effect was clearly unsatisfactory.
Not every clergyman could be as responsible as the Bishop of Exeter. Although this old man had once scolded Scotland Yard over the "London prostitute epidemic," from his subsequent actions, the old man's every word and deed were indeed motivated by public interest.
In stark contrast to the Bishop of Exeter taking the lead, parish committees everywhere remained firmly opposed to any increase in monetary expenditure due to the implementation of the Central Board of Health or Privy Council orders after the "Cholera Act" was promulgated.
The Christchurch parish was such a negative example. After the Lord Chancellor's Office, the Home Office, and the Central Board of Health repeatedly requested the parish to execute orders, the Christchurch parish still refused to pay public health expenses and ignored government documents.
As the highest official in charge of national health work, Lord Brougham was naturally furious at the rebellious behavior of the Christchurch parish.
He demanded that the Lord Chancellor's Office directly publish an order in "the london gazette," requiring the Christchurch parish to pay £200 from the poor tax for cholera medical treatment within one week.
But humorously, the local parish committee's response to the Lord Chancellor's Office was just a light sentence — "This is a chaotic order, Christchurch refuses to obey."
But more dramatically, and quite Britishly, after the two sides were deadlocked for weeks, the Lord Chancellor's Office eventually backed down.
A week later, the Lord Chancellor's Office re-published a new order in "the london gazette," no longer requiring Christchurch to enforce the order, but instead agreeing to authorize the local board of health to raise £100 in medical funds through public donations.
When Arthur finished reading these reports, he finally understood the reason for the two doctors' anger.
He felt angry just looking at these things, let alone these two people working inside.
Dr. Russell took off his hat and fanned himself continuously. Although London's winter was cold, it did not affect his ability to overclock his brain at the Central Board of Health.
Dr. Russell said: "Speaking of which, Mr. Hastings, we also saw the report you fed back from Liverpool. In fact, not only is Liverpool conducting investigations into the source of cholera, we are also conducting similar investigations in London. However, introducing statistics into medical work is indeed a very good attempt. We analyzed the cases of the London outbreak based on the Liverpool experience, but the result..."
Arthur raised an eyebrow, put down the file, and asked: "The results differ?"
Dr. Barry nodded and said: "According to the investigation, nearly half of the cases in London occurred south of the River Thames. To figure out why, our medical investigators were sent to Bermondsey, the starting point of cholera in London. It is like this."
"According to the reports fed back by investigators on the streets of London, we did find that the local drinking water situation is not good. It is filled with foul-smelling sewers, and a narrow strip of water even presents a thick, dark green viscous state under the bright sun."
"Some water can't even be called water; they look more like mud. But we learned that this is the drinking water for the area. However, although the drinking water situation is so bad, according to data comparison, we don't have enough evidence to show that residents who draw water from this well suffer greater losses than residents who draw water from other channels."
"The incidence rate of residents in the Bermondsey area is not higher than that of residents in surrounding areas. Of course, we also agree with your view to a certain extent that water flowing from such dirty wells will definitely cause the health of local residents to deteriorate, but whether it is the medium of cholera infection, we cannot easily make a judgment."
Dr. Russell also added with a self-deprecating tone.
"However, although that is said, if you want to transform the poor sanitary environment of the slums, I raise both hands in favor. Because transforming the city, even if it doesn't work for preventing cholera, will definitely have a preventive effect on other diseases like scarlet fever and whooping cough."
"However, whether or not to renovate the slums, or reshape the city's water supply system, is not up to us. Members of Parliament have to consider budget overruns, and the parish councils are unwilling to spend a single penny more on public health. Even if Barry and I were to carry shovels and do the actual work on the ground, digging a dozen feet a day would be our limit."
Baring nodded slightly, looking at Arthur beside him, and said: "Therefore, this is the problem at present. Everyone sitting here agrees to reforming our city. But the issue is that the budget must be approved by Parliament, the concept must gain social consensus, and those willing to invest in public health are currently in the minority."
Disraeli spoke up: "Mr. Baring, to be honest, although you are a Whig Party member and I am a Tory Party member, our views on public works investment are aligned. Rather than resorting to temporary borrowing for prevention every time a disease arrives, it is better to invest heavily to solve the root problem. If we can prevent disease through urban renewal, in the long run, this investment is actually profitable for the government because it avoids large amounts of uncertain, temporary public health expenditures."
Baring replied: "Our views are indeed aligned, but the problems we face are different. As for the Whig Party to which I belong, they are mainly opposed to the expansion of government power caused by cholera, but they are not too resistant to borrowing for construction.
However, for the Tory Party to which you belong, even if Sir Peel is a Tory Party liberal, he still insists on building a strong and powerful government system. If he were in the position of Lord Brougham, he would certainly do everything in his power to make the Christchurch Parish pay up.
But correspondingly, Sir Peel is very sensitive to government debt, and many in the Tory Party feel the same. Asking the government to issue so many construction bonds all at once, especially bonds with uncertain returns on investment, will likely be difficult to pass."
Arthur immediately spoke up: "Actually, the concerns of both of you are unnecessary. In my opinion, these problems are very easy to solve."
Baring took a look at this young Superintendent: "Do you have a good solution?"
Arthur said: "I fully understand the concerns of the Whig Party members regarding the determination to uphold the traditions of British liberty. But time is fluid, and traditions are always changing. Just as at the end of the last century, there were many members within the Whig Party who held great enthusiasm for the French Revolution, and Edmund Burke once sang high praises for the French Revolution.
But as the frenzied tide of the revolution rolled higher and higher, the gentlemen slowly calmed down. When they looked back, they realized that some of their previous views seemed to be nothing more than a rush of blood to the head. It seemed that overnight, the entire ethos of the Whig Party had shifted.
What is insisted upon now does not mean it will be insisted upon in the future. I believe that if they continue to waver on the issue of cholera prevention, when the disaster affects them personally, they will agree to sacrifice a portion of their liberty in exchange for the health and hygiene of the entire society.
If you observe carefully, the current public opinion has actually changed a lot compared to when cholera first arrived. Previously, the traditional view in British society was that infectious diseases were diseases of the poor, but now, if you just flip through the newspapers in London, all the editorials have begun to focus on the impact of poor living conditions, lack of food and clothing, filthy housing, and indulgent lifestyles on health.
Although gentlemen and ladies have always been concerned about poverty, the situation where it is discussed almost every day like now should be a first. The slogan 'Cleanliness is next to godliness' shouted by the Bishop of Exeter has almost become a creed now; perhaps it can be inscribed on his tombstone in the future."
As a prominent figure in the London publishing industry, Disraeli certainly knew about this shift in atmosphere. As a forward-thinking writer, he had already begun to outline a new book around this new hot topic.
Not only that, he even planned to rope Dickens into doing something big with him.
Although they are currently hailed as the leaders of fashionable novels, in Disraeli's view, this is not a good reputation. Even though he made his fortune by writing fashionable novels, if he wants to become a great writer like Shakespeare, he should write works with depth and substance, leaning towards traditional British literature.
After all, he has been unhappy with those enemies at Blackwoods Magazine who claim to have the highest literary taste in Britain for a long time.
Disraeli echoed:
"Actually, I have also noticed this change. In the past, our upper and middle classes always upheld the philosophy of liberty and were not very willing to interfere with the lifestyle of our lower classes.
But in these last few months, I don't know how, but they have all shifted their attention and are willing to share their healthy lifestyles with them. From the initial subtle persuasion to enthusiastic, almost fierce criticism, some gentlemen and ladies have even begun to hope that they can use some... um... active, proactive, and not-so-free means to 'help' them change their living habits.
This year's criticism of workers' 'alcoholism' may be the largest scale I have ever seen in my life. And the bishops are also flattered to have suddenly gained so many supporters. The bench of bishops in the House of Lords even hopes to take this opportunity to promote national prohibition; if they could also ban opium along with it, that would be even better..."
Baring heard this and just coughed lightly: "Mr. Disraeli, you have strayed too far."
Disraeli also understood what Baring meant.
Although he and Baring had the same views on urban renewal, because their parties were different, their base support was still different.
Disraeli was able to rise to power by playing the traditional card; it was appropriate for him to speak for conservatives like the clergy.
But behind Baring was the entire City of London and British trade groups. For these people, neither prohibition nor banning opium was up for discussion.
However, correspondingly, if it really came to the point of prohibition or banning opium, allowing the Whig Party to expand the power of the Health Committee did not seem impossible to negotiate. After all, the current situation of cholera was right in front of them. Between two benefits, choose the greater; between two harms, choose the lesser. This kind of multiple-choice question was very simple to solve.
Arthur's words opened up a new line of thinking for Baring. He raised an eyebrow and suddenly asked Disraeli in a low voice: "If... I mean if... the Tory Party demands that the House of Commons organize a prohibition committee, do you think the success rate is high?"
Disraeli's smile stiffened for a moment, then bloomed even brighter: "Although the success rate is not high, if the will of the bishops is so firm, then as their loyal supporter, I can only reluctantly agree."
Baring closed the document with a straight face: "Of course, although saying this might offend the sacred dignity of the bishops, I think prohibition cannot solve the problem. After all, as you have seen, when Mr. Hastings was in Liverpool, an important preventive measure he proposed was to replace unclean drinking water with beer."
Dr. Russell heard this and couldn't help but show a smile on his tired face: "I heard about that too. Arthur Hastings, the 'British Royal Cask' produced by the University of London in 1829. I have to say, the bishops are really vicious when they curse people. Actually, compared to drinking that unclean, green, mushy water, drinking alcohol might indeed be healthier."
Arthur said nonchalantly: "If the bishops had read our latest report, perhaps they wouldn't be so opposed to drinking beer."
"Hmm?" Dr. Barry asked: "You have new developments on your end?"
Arthur nodded slightly: "Actually, after returning to London, I privately sponsored a cholera investigation team based at the University of London Medical School. The leader is a young man I brought back from Liverpool; it was his report that made me believe there is a certain correlation between cholera and water sources. Of course, this private investigation of mine can at most provide some reference for Parliament.
However, I think if the gentlemen of the Whig Party want to clarify that there is no necessary connection between cholera and drinking beer, it would be best to initiate a special cholera source investigation committee in the House of Commons. If they are willing to do so, I would be very happy to share the materials I have on hand with them."
Baring heard this and laughed heartily, raising his beer to toast with Arthur: "Great minds think alike. Mr. Hastings, in my opinion, Guinness and Chivas should both share some of their advertising fees with you."
Upon hearing this, Arthur just laughed softly and waved his hand: "Mr. Baring, you have misunderstood. I am just a small policeman from Scotland Yard. If they really want to advertise, they can discuss it in detail with Mr. Disraeli."
