16
February 24, 1943.
Ukraine, on the outskirts of Kharkiv.
After the follow-up forces arrived, the pressure on Hans and the others eased a lot.
The tank force of the Grossdeutschland Division had six Panzer IVs, along with a battalion of infantry.
They quickly established a defense line to block the Russian advance.
"Commander."
Buchner walked over and handed Hans a piece of bread.
"Have something to eat."
Hans took the bread and took a bite.
"Has the Russian advance stopped?"
"It has stopped," Buchner said, "I heard the Russian army is retreating along the entire line."
"Retreating along the entire line?"
"Yes," Buchner said, "The Waffen-SS Panzer Corps is pushing down from the south, cutting off the retreat route of the Russian army. They have no choice but to retreat."
Hans put down the bread and looked at the distant horizon.
The Russian army is retreating along the entire line.
This is Manstein's victory. Surrounding 300,000 people with 100,000 actually succeeded.
"This is impossible..." Hans muttered to himself.
"What's impossible?" Buchner asked.
"The Russian army," Hans said, "How could more than 300,000 people be surrounded by 100,000?"
"Maybe it's because they pushed forward too fast," Buchner said, "Their flanks were exposed and we cut them off."
"Too fast..."
Hans thought of Moscow in 1941.
That time, the German Army also advanced too fast, exposing its flanks and being counterattacked by the Russian army.
What was the result?
Moscow was lost. A large number of German soldiers were surrounded or wiped out.
Now, it is the Russian army's turn to repeat the same mistake.
"Commander," Buchner said, "what do you think will happen to the Russian army?"
"I don't know," Hans said, "but they will pay a price."
He looked at the plumes of smoke in the distance.
Those plumes of smoke were supplies and vehicles abandoned by the Russian army.
During the retreat, in order to speed up, the Russian army threw away a large amount of heavy equipment.
"This is our chance," Hans said, "While they are retreating, destroy as many of them as possible."
Three days later.
February 27, 1943.
Kharkiv.
Hans stood on a tank, looking at the scene before him.
They recaptured Kharkiv.
This second-largest city in Ukraine returned to the hands of the Germans less than a month after it was lost.
The city was full of ruins and craters.
The streets were deserted, save for the occasional German soldier walking by.
"Commander."
Brenner walked over.
"Captain." Hans jumped down from the tank.
"Not bad," Brenner said, "You held that intersection during the thrust, buying time for the follow-up forces."
"It's the credit of the whole crew," Hans said, "Both Kohler and Buchner performed very well."
"I know," Brenner said, "I will report this to my superiors."
"Thank you, Captain."
Brenner looked at Hans and was silent for a moment.
"Hans."
"Hmm?"
"What do you think this victory means?"
Hans thought for a moment.
"It means we have recaptured Kharkiv," he said, "It means the Russian army has been defeated by us."
"And what else?"
"And..." Hans paused for a moment, "It means the war is not over yet."
Brenner looked at him.
"Do you think we can win?"
Hans had been asked this question many times.
Every time he would say "No". Every time he would say "This war could never be won from the beginning".
But this time...
"I don't know," Hans said, "This time I really don't know."
"Why?"
"Because the Russian army lost too miserably this time," Hans said, "More than 300,000 people were surrounded by us, losing a massive amount of personnel and equipment. They need time to recover."
"What about us?"
"We need time too," Hans said, "but at least, we have bought time."
Brenner nodded.
"Yes," he said, "We bought time."
Bought time.
Is this their victory?
Trading countless lives and a massive consumption of supplies for a few months of time?
Hans didn't know if it was worth it.
He only knew that the war was still going on.
He would continue to fight.
Continue to kill and be killed.
Continue to watch comrades die while he himself survived.
Until one day, the war ends.
Or, until he dies.
That night, Hans lay in the barracks, tossing and turning and unable to sleep.
He thought of Borkivka. Those fallen comrades. More than 300 German soldiers, surrounded by Russian tanks and infantry. In the end, only thirty-something broke out.
Those who died, did their families know they were dead?
Would they cry for them?
Would they mourn for them?
Or would they, like millions of German families, receive a notice saying "Your son heroically sacrificed on the Eastern Front" and then go on with their lives?
"Commander."
Buchner's voice came from the side.
"What's wrong?"
"Can't sleep?"
"Mm."
Buchner sat up, leaning against the wall.
"Me too," he said, "Can't sleep."
"What are you thinking about?"
"Thinking about this battle," Buchner said, "We won, right?"
"Won."
"But..." Buchner paused for a moment, "But what kind of victory is this?"
"What do you mean?"
"I mean," Buchner said, "we won this battle, but the war is still going on. We recaptured Kharkiv, but the Russians are still here. We wiped out 300,000 of the Russians, but they have even more people."
Hans was silent.
Buchner was right.
What counted as a victory?
Using 100,000 men to surround 300,000, wiping out a portion of them. But the remaining Russian army retreated and preserved its strength. They could regroup, resupply, and continue fighting.
And what about Germany?
How much longer could Germany hold on?
"Buchner," Hans said.
"Hmm?"
"Do you think we will win?"
Buchner thought for a moment.
"I don't know," he said, "But I know one thing."
"What thing?"
"Win or lose," Buchner said, "I want to survive."
"Survive?"
"Yes," Buchner said, "I want to see the day the war ends. Want to go home. Want to find a job, marry a wife, and have a few kids."
"And then?"
"And then?" Buchner said, "Then tell them I fought in a war. I killed people. I almost died many times. But I survived."
Hans looked at him.
A twenty-year-old kid. Lost a whole platoon of comrades in Stalingrad. Now he was daydreaming about post-war life.
"You will make it happen," Hans said.
"Really?"
"Really," Hans said, "We will live to the day the war ends."
"How do you know?"
"Because..." Hans thought for a moment, "Because we must live to that day."
"Must?"
"Yes," Hans said, "For those who died. Their sacrifice should have meaning."
"What meaning?"
"Living," Hans said, "Living is the meaning."
Buchner looked at him.
"Commander," he said, "do you really believe that?"
Hans didn't answer.
He didn't know.
He only knew that tomorrow, the war would continue.
He would continue to fight.
Continue to kill and be killed.
Continue to watch comrades die while he himself survived.
This was his destiny.
The only thing he could do was accept it.
