16
Ginkgo leaves covered the floor of the Constitution Drafting Bureau. More than twenty desks were arranged in a circle by module, with the revised 'Autonomous Territory Constitutional Draft' placed in the center. The margins of every page were covered in yellow sticky notes, looking like fruits ripening in autumn.
Tianyu picked up the'Suggestion Summary Book' from the desk, his fingertips tracing over bolded headings like 'Power Checks and Balances' and 'Protection of Rights.' His voice was clear and resonant: "The first round of revisions fixed the major loopholes, but this time we need to refine the details. It's just like sewing clothes—the stitches must be tight for them to be durable, and the clauses must be detailed to be effective."
1. Power Checks and Balances: Adding a 'Double Insurance' to 'Checks and Balances'
"The parliamentary impeachment power is still too loose!" Wang Yanzhi, a censor from the Supervisory Yuan, slapped a sticky note onto the 'Impeachment Process' chapter. "The draft says 'Parliament can impeach officials with a majority vote,' but last year, when the Southern Territory Parliament wanted to impeach a corrupt salt and iron official, they were stalled by the 'one-month official defense period'—by the time the defense was over, the stolen money had already been transferred!"
Mr. Zhang, who was in charge of the parliamentary module, frowned: "The defense period is to prevent false accusations; we can't just impeach on a whim."
"But it can't become a 'protective umbrella' either!" Wang Yanzhi pulled out a confidential file from the Supervisory Yuan. "There was a county magistrate in the Northern Territory who used 'three defenses' to stall for half a year, and in the end, he even bribed council members to overturn the case. This is the loophole created by the clauses!"
After arguing for half a day, they finally reached a consensus on a 'dual-track system':
— Fast-track channel: If it involves corruption, murder, or other emergencies, Parliament can initiate a 'three-day defense period.' With a majority vote, the official's duties are suspended, and the Supreme Court intervenes to investigate, preventing the transfer of stolen funds.
— Regular channel: General disciplinary cases retain the 'one-month defense period,' but the progress of the defense must be made public daily to accept supervision by the people.
Wang Yanzhi added a sentence to the sticky note: "If a false accusation is confirmed after a fast-track impeachment, the proposer will be fined one hundred taels of silver and banned from entering Parliament for life." Mr. Zhang nodded: "This prevents both dereliction of duty and framing; this is what you call balance."
The check and balance between military power and administrative power also added new details. The original 'Lord needs parliamentary filing to mobilize troops' was refined to 'mobilizing more than one thousand troops or for a duration exceeding three months requires two-thirds consent from Parliament,' and a 'Military Funding Freeze Clause' was added: If Parliament does not approve the reasons for mobilizing troops, it can suspend the relevant military funding.
"Last year, the Northern Territory Lord mobilized five thousand troops for a 'hunting exercise,' costing ten thousand taels of silver, but in reality, he was helping a relative seize territory." Xiao Ce, an official from the Ministry of War, patted the new clause. "Now that we have the 'Military Funding Freeze,' if he wants to mobilize troops recklessly again, he'll have to weigh the silver in his pocket first."
2. Protection of Citizen Rights: Tying a'Seatbelt' to 'Rights'
"The boundaries of freedom of speech are still blurry!" Master Zhou, who was in charge of the citizen rights module, pointed to the 'Must not incite rebellion' clause. "What counts as 'inciting'? A farmer said 'The taxes are too heavy this year' and was arrested by the Village Head as 'inciting tax resistance'—isn't this treating 'complaints' as 'rebellion'?"
Everyone pulled out the case from last month: In the Western Territory, a herdsman said at the market that 'pasture allocation is unfair' and was detained by a Patrol Officer for 'inciting ethnic conflict.' In the end, there was no evidence, but the herdsman missed the lambing season.
"We must draw a line for 'inciting'." Tianyu wrote on the sticky note: "Freedom of speech shall not include'specific violent instructions' (such as 'rob the granary tomorrow') or 'fabricating disasters' (such as 'the plague is coming, run!'); all other criticisms and complaints are legal."
Master Zhou added: "For detention cases related to speech, two non-official witnesses must be present, and it shall not exceed twelve hours; if it exceeds this time, it must be reported to the Supreme Court." Batu, a herdsman representative from the Western Territory, touched the sticky note and smiled: "In the future, I'll dare to say 'pasture is unfair' without being afraid of being arrested at will."
Property rights protection also added a 'Retroactive Clause.' The original 'Legal property is protected' was expanded to 'If property is wrongly requisitioned, the government must compensate double the market price and return it within one month,' and it clarified that 'ancestral property passed down through generations, even without deeds, can be recognized as legal as long as three Village Elders testify.'
"There was a family in the Southern Territory whose ancestral home was wrongly requisitioned to build a post station, and the government only compensated for half a room." Lin Wanxing, an official from the Ministry of Revenue, sighed. "According to the new clause, they have to pay double and apologize—that's what you call real protection."
3. Execution Standards: Making the 'Clauses' Implementable and Verifiable
"The 'disaster loss assessment' for tax reduction is too vague!" Old Farmer Chen held up the 'Tax reduction in disaster years' clause. "Last year, the Eastern Territory suffered a locust plague. Some villages had their taxes reduced by thirty percent, while others only by ten percent, just because there was no standard for 'disaster loss assessment,' and it was all up to the word of the officials."
Qin Zhou, who was in charge of the financial module, blushed: "The original clause only wrote 'reduce or exempt based on the degree of disaster loss,' and it indeed didn't specify."
"It must be based on hard standards like 'eighty percent reduction for total crop failure, fifty percent for seventy percent yield loss'!" Old Farmer Chen took out a 'Disaster Loss Measurement Table' drawn by the farmers, on which crooked characters were written:
— Total destruction (no harvest): 80% tax reduction;
— Severe disaster (yield loss over 70%): 50% tax reduction;
— Light disaster (yield loss over 30%): 30% tax reduction.
Everyone thought it was feasible. Qin Zhou immediately added 'Quantitative Standards' and added 'Cross-Assessment': Disaster loss must be assessed by an evaluation group consisting of three people each from farmer representatives, Village Elders, and county officials, and it only counts after they sign and press their fingerprints, avoiding unilateral decisions.
The'Sentencing Scale' for judicial trials also added detailed rules. The original 'Thieves shall be caned twenty to one hundred times' was refined to:
— Theft of less than ten wen: Twenty strokes, compensate for the stolen goods;
— Theft of over one hundred wen: Fifty strokes, one month of hard labor;
— Theft of over one thousand wen (including disaster relief supplies): One hundred strokes, exile for three thousand li.
"Last year, a little thief stole five wen to buy a pancake and was nearly beaten to death after fifty strokes. It was too unjust!" Zhou Yan, an official from the Ministry of Justice, pointed to the new clause. "According to the quantitative standard, five wen only warrants twenty strokes. This is what is called 'punishment fitting the crime'."
4. Incorporating Grassroots Suggestions: Giving the 'Clauses' a Touch of 'Earthy Flavor'
When the review was halfway through, Tianyu had someone bring in a basket of suggestion letters from grassroots officials. On top was the 'Adaptation Proposals for Bitter Cold Regions' from a Northern Territory postmaster.
"In the Northern Territory, it's minus thirty degrees in winter. According to the clause of 'prisoners must have two hours of outdoor time daily,' people will freeze to death!" The postmaster wrote in the letter, "I implore you to change it to 'outdoor time is halved in the dead of winter, and charcoal fires must be increased in prison cells'."
After everyone read it, they added an 'Regional Climate Adaptation Clause' to the 'Judicial Execution' chapter: In cold regions, prisoner outdoor time in winter can be reduced to one hour, and the prison cell temperature must be guaranteed not to be lower than five degrees.
The Southern Territory has many floods, so the Village Heads jointly suggested 'making the repair of river embankments a personal responsibility,' so the draft added 'the names of the river repair official and the Artisan must be carved on every section of the river embankment, and the official will be held accountable if the embankment collapses.' The Western Territory has a lot of sandstorms, so merchants proposed 'payments can be deferred if a sandstorm is encountered during market transactions,' so 'force majeure deferral exemption' was added to the clauses.
"The most moving one is this." Tianyu held up a child's drawing, which had 'I want to eat at School' written in a crooked way. It turned out that children in the Western Territory pastoral areas had to walk two hours of mountain roads to go to school and were often hungry at noon. Wen Zhiyan, who was in charge of the education module, immediately proposed: "Add'School Meals,' with grain allocated by the Autonomous Territory, one bowl of porridge and one piece of pancake for each student every day."
5. Finalizing the Revision: Tightening the 'Hoop' on the 'Draft'
When dusk fell, the revised draft was nearly half as thick as before, and the sticky notes on every page were neatly transcribed into the main text. Tianyu had someone summarize the 'Core Optimization Points' into a table:
1. Power Checks and Balances: Added fast-track channel and military funding freeze clause;
2. Rights Protection: Refined freedom of speech boundaries and property retroactive compensation;
3. Execution Standards: Quantified disaster reduction and graded theft sentencing;
4. Grassroots Adaptation: Adjustment of prisoner outdoor time in cold regions and addition of school meals.
"The current draft is like a cotton coat with patches." Mr. Zhang stroked the pages and smiled. "Although there are many patches, it fits better."
Tianyu looked at the ginkgo forest outside the window. The leaves had fallen, but the branches stood tall. "Governing a country is like planting a tree. Pruning branches and leaves is not to hurt it, but to make it more resistant to wind and snow. For every revision of this draft, the Autonomous Territory gains a bit more stability."
The candle on the desk was relit, illuminating everyone as they signed their names on the revised draft. The handwriting was different, but all of them showed a sense of seriousness—they knew that these words written on paper would eventually grow into shade that protects the people.
