16
Bishop Hincmar's earth-shattering proposal was like a spark thrown into boiling oil, instantly igniting the already blazing political atmosphere in the Paris council chamber and steering it in a direction no one could have anticipated.
After the initial shock, anger, and refutations came a long and fierce debate of weighing options, threats, and compromises.
The "Royalist Orthodoxy" supporting the young lord Charles and the "Strong External Reinforcement Faction" supporting Charles the Fat did not give up easily. Together with the "Pragmatic Realpolitik Faction" supporting Buto (composed mainly of nobles secretly colluding with Hincmar, entangled in interests with the Nord, or simply terrified by the kingdom's continuous decline), they engaged in a more complex and naked power struggle.
The meeting lasted from late autumn to early winter. The sky over Paris grew increasingly gloomy and cold, and the Seine River water became turbid and sluggish, as if reflecting the obscure and uncertain future of the kingdom.
Archbishop Hincmar II's mediation efforts yielded little results, and he himself wavered under pressure from all sides.
In the end, a cold reality gradually overwhelmed all principles and emotions: West Francia, this broken ship, truly needed a helmsman strong enough and ready to take the wheel immediately; otherwise, before a captain could even be chosen, it would be torn apart by wind, waves, and internal pests.
Supporting the young lord Charles meant at least several years of regency chaos, where various factions would inevitably exploit the weakness, and the kingdom could be partitioned from within.
Supporting Charles the Fat might temporarily bring stability, but it was easy to invite a deity and hard to send him away. Once the forces of East Francia deeply intervened, the independence of West Francia would cease to exist, and the interests of local nobles would inevitably suffer.
Moreover, whether Charles the Fat's own ability and prestige could truly suppress this group of unruly princes in West Francia was also an unknown.
In comparison, Buto Wolfson's "advantages" unexpectedly appeared increasingly "prominent" in the cruel realistic comparison.
First, his strength was unquestionable. His army was currently recognized as one of the strongest combat forces on the European continent, especially against the backdrop of having just completed the conquest of Ireland with morale soaring like a rainbow.
If he became the king of West Francia, at least external military threats and most internal rebellions could be expected to be swiftly pacified.
Second, he was not entirely unrelated to West Francia. Through Princess Gisela, he had marital ties with the Carolingian Dynasty.
Through past "cooperation" and "transactions", he shared ties of interest with some West Frankish nobles, especially around the Paris region and Normandy. He was not a completely unfamiliar foreign conqueror, but rather an "in-law" and an "old acquaintance" in a certain sense.
Third, which Hincmar and others constantly hinted at: Buto seemed to pay more attention to practical rule and commercial interests rather than mere territorial annexation or ethnic cleansing.
Look at his actions in England and Ireland: establishing laws, developing trade, retaining some of the local upper class; as long as they submitted to his rule, they could survive and even profit.
For many nobles who only cared about whether their fiefs could be preserved and their wealth increased, this was far more attractive than a young lord with empty bloodline or a distant clan king who might bring unknown risks.
Of course, voices of opposition remained strong, especially moral and jurisprudential attacks.
Letting a Nord, a pagan, and a former raider be the king of the Franks was simply a desecration of Charlemagne's imperial glory and a trampling on the dignity of all Frankish nobles.
But Hincmar and his supporters skillfully—or rather, shamelessly—evaded these accusations.
They emphasized Princess Gisela's Carolingian lineage, stressing that the offspring of Buto and the princess would possess a pure Frankish-Carolingian bloodline. They hinted that Buto had always granted great tolerance to Christianity within his domains.
They even proposed that Buto could be required to promise that the throne of West Francia could only be inherited in the future by the offspring born to him and Princess Gisela, thereby ensuring the continuation of the Carolingian bloodline on the future throne.
This condition of "entailment of the throne" became the key to breaking the deadlock.
It acted like a fig leaf, reluctantly placating some nobles who valued bloodline but felt despairing toward reality.
It turned the matter of supporting Buto from a complete "foreign usurpation" into a sort of expedient measure of "inheriting through marriage and preserving the bloodline for the Carolingian Dynasty", even though this expedient measure sounded so self-deceiving.
After countless days and nights of quarrels, secret talks, interest exchanges, and coercion, and after Bishop Hincmar spared no effort in shuttling and lobbying—and perhaps even utilizing certain unknown "dirt"—the scale finally began to tip.
The faction supporting Charles the Fat began to crack first.
Some nobles close to the eastern border, who were more worried about direct conflict with East Francia or being annexed, began to waver.
Meanwhile, Charles the Fat himself was far away in Regensburg and reacted sluggishly. Aside from sending envoys to express "concern" and "willingness to provide support", he failed to promptly give West Frankish supporters strong substantive commitments or military deterrence.
The faction supporting the young lord Charles became even more isolated.
Duke Richard of Burgundy was the most steadfast and powerful core among them. He not only represented his own vast and wealthy Duchy of Burgundy, but also influenced nobles in parts of Aquitaine and Provence.
Yet he could not completely suppress dissenting voices within—some nobles began to worry that if the stalemate continued and led to total anarchy in the kingdom, or brought about Buto's military intervention, their losses might be even greater.
Finally, on a gloomy December morning, after another all-night meeting, the exhausted yet relieved or deeply humiliated participants reluctantly reached a resolution.
The core contents of the resolution were:
1. Recognizing King Buto I of the Nord Kingdom as the legitimate heir to the throne of West Francia, due to his marital relationship with Princess Gisela, daughter of the late King Charles the Bald, as well as his powerful strength and ability to maintain kingdom order.
2. Princess Gisela was simultaneously recognized as Queen of West Francia.
3. The male offspring born to King Buto and Queen Gisela shall have the first right of succession to the throne of West Francia. The throne shall be transmitted solely through this lineage and shall not be inherited by offspring born to King Buto's other wives.
4. His Highness the young lord "Charles the Simple" shall be granted a noble ducal title and corresponding fiefs to guarantee his livelihood and safety, and shall be protected as a symbol of the direct Carolingian bloodline.
5. King Buto must publicly promise to respect the existing laws and customs of West Francia, guarantee the legitimate rights of the participating nobles and their fiefs, and take prompt measures to restore order in the kingdom, resist foreign enemies, and revitalize the economy.
6. The specific coronation ceremony, power handover details, and clauses guaranteeing noble rights and interests shall await King Buto's acceptance of the resolution and his dispatch of plenipotentiary representatives to Paris for negotiation.
This was a resolution full of contradiction, compromise, and reluctance.
It attempted to find a fragile balance beam between jurisprudence and reality, dignity and survival.
It bestowed the crown upon Buto while trying to constrain him with "entailment" and conditions; it abandoned the young lord while leaving him a way out; it introduced strong reinforcements while worrying about inviting a wolf into the house.
When the resolution was finally read out, the council chamber was dead silent.
Many people had ashen faces with lowered gazes, as if they had just signed a humiliating treaty.
Only a few people, such as Bishop Hincmar, wore faces mixed with complexity and the relief of having completed a task.
However, before the balance beam could be walked steadily, someone kicked it over fiercely.
Just as the resolution finished reading and Archbishop Hincmar II was about to announce the recess and wait to transmit the news to Buto, Duke Richard of Burgundy abruptly pushed open his chair and stood up. His face had turned liver-colored from extreme anger, his fists clenched with cracking sounds, and veins bulging on his neck.
"Enough! This ugly farce should end!"
Richard's voice roared in the silent hall like an injured lion, "You! You cowards! Traitors! For the sake of your pathetic lands and purses, you actually want to put the crown of the Franks on the head of a Nord barbarian, a pagan, and a pirate?! And you even concoct ghost stories like 'marital succession' and 'entailed inheritance' to deceive yourselves and deceive God!"
He reached out to point at the colleagues along the long table who were either shamefully lowering their heads or glaring angrily, and finally pointed at Hincmar whose expression remained unchanged: "Especially you, Hincmar! You Judas bewitched by Satan! The disgrace of Paris! I long suspected you had dirty deals with those northerners! Today, you have finally revealed your true face!"
Richard's chest heaved violently. He looked around, his gaze filled with contempt and resolute determination: "I, Richard, Duke of Burgundy, swear by my family honor and the sword of my ancestors, I will never recognize this despicable and illegal resolution! Burgundy will never bend the knee and swear allegiance to a Nord king!"
He abruptly drew the sword from his waist. With a flash of cold light, he heavily stabbed it into the oak long table in front of him. The blade embedded deeply into the wood, trembling incessantly on its own.
"From today on, the Duchy of Burgundy, along with all nobles and lands loyal to me and sharing the dignity and faith of the Franks, will secede from this 'kingdom' that has betrayed its own soul! We will walk our own path! Anyone who dares to bring the laws and banners of the Nords onto the lands of Burgundy shall be regarded as an invader, and what awaits them will only be the swords of Burgundy's warriors!"
Having said that, Duke Richard no longer looked at anyone. Taking his few trusted nobles and guards, he strode out of the council chamber amidst a silence of death and astonished gazes.
The heavy sound of the door closing struck everyone's heart like a funeral bell.
Burgundy had become independent.
This meant that one of the kingdom's most wealthy and largest regions had split away in an instant.
This was not only a loss of territory, but even more a resounding and direct negation and challenge to the result of this "election" in Paris. It could be foreseen that Richard's action would inevitably encourage other dissatisfied or wait-and-see factions, and the fragmentation of the kingdom seemed already inevitable.
Archbishop Hincmar II slumped in his chair, as if he had aged another ten years in an instant.
The other nobles looked at each other. The fragile consensus they had barely reached seemed so ridiculous and vulnerable amid Duke Richard's roar and sword drawing.
However, the bad news did not stop there.
Soon after the news of the Paris resolution and Burgundy's independence spread at top speed, the response from the east also arrived with thunderous momentum.
The king of East Francia, Charles the Fat, flew into a great rage upon learning that the nobles of West Francia had actually chosen a Nord barbarian instead of him—a Carolingian kinsman and descendant of the Roman Emperor.
He issued an extremely harshly worded statement in his court at Regensburg.
In the statement, Charles the Fat denounced the Paris resolution as "shameless betrayal", "a desecration of Charlemagne and all Frankish ancestors", and "a mad decision made under the temptation of the devil".
He declared that he would never recognize any claims or rule of Buto over West Francia.
"The Kingdom of West Francia is the sacred and inseparable heritage of the Carolingian Dynasty!"
The emperor's envoy read aloud at the princes' assembly in central Germany: "His Majesty the Emperor, as the direct descendant of Charlemagne and Emperor of the Roman people, has the responsibility and obligation to defend the family's honor and the integrity of the empire! To those traitors blinded by ambition and fear who attempt to hand the kingdom over to pagans, His Majesty the Emperor will mete out the most severe punishment!"
Immediately following this, orders for military mobilization began to be issued from Regensburg.
Charles the Fat gathered his troops—mainly forces from Swabia, Bavaria, and Franconia—and called upon other princes in the empire loyal to him to provide soldiers.
The banner he raised was "punishing rebels, restoring Carolingian glory, and defending Christ's world from pagan erosion".
Obviously, he intended to use force to negate the Paris resolution and would likely take the opportunity to incorporate West Francia into his direct rule, or at least prop up a puppet entirely obedient to him.
The pressure from both east and west instantly plunged the core West Frankish nobles, who had just made a difficult choice, into even greater panic.
Burgundy split in the southwest, Charles the Fat threatened from the east, and their pinned-hope "new king" Buto was still far away in London at this moment, with an unclear attitude and reinforcements not yet arrived.
Paris, this isolated island on the Seine River, seemed to have become the only temporarily calm yet most suffocating place in the eye of the storm.
The nobles panicked, blaming and shifting responsibilities onto each other while having to step up discussions on how to cope with the immediate crisis.
Some people began to regret their previous decision and secretly sent messages to Charles the Fat's envoys; others became even more determined to introduce Buto, believing that only the Nords' army could simultaneously cope with the threats of Burgundy and East Francia.
Bishop Hincmar, amidst this sudden double crisis, instead appeared unusually calm.
He frequently contacted all parties, pacifying the panicked and strengthening supporters, while sending everything that happened in Paris—the resolution, Burgundy's independence, East Francia's declaration of war—at the fastest speed to London across the strait through secret channels known only to himself.
