The content regarding the Ecclesiarchy finished playing.

Before the Primarchs or the Emperor could react,

Lorgar was the first to stand up.

His face was flushed, his eyes wide open, and the veins on his bald head—etched with scriptures praising the Emperor—bulged. He looked like a religious volcano about to erupt.

"Heresy!"

Lorgar's roar exploded, so loud that even Lion ElJonson, sitting at the furthest distance, frowned slightly.

"Utter, complete heresy!"

The Primarch of the Word Bearers slammed his fist against the railing in front of him; the metal dented and deformed under his blow, and every word felt like magma erupting from the deepest depths of his soul.

"These! These maggots who use the banner of faith in the God-Emperor! These parasites who exploit the people in the Emperor's name! These scumbags who raise the tithes again and again just to build palaces for themselves!"

"Utter, complete heresy!"

"Do they deserve to be called believers? They aren't even as good as heretics! At least heretics genuinely believe in something! These guys only believe in their own bellies and vaults!"

Lorgar's voice grew higher and sharper as he entered a state of near-fanaticism.

"These guys should all be sent to the stake! Every last one of them! Judge them in the way they like best! Let them taste the feeling of being burned by their own faith!"

The Primarchs and the Emperor couldn't keep a straight face for a second.

The Empire had fallen to such a state, yet the first thing Lorgar said was, "Send these guys to the stake."

Angron was the first to lose his composure.

The Lord of the Red Sands let out a laugh from the restraining device specially customized for him.

It was not an angry roar, nor a painful scream.

It was laughter.

Angron was laughing.

The laughter was coarse and hoarse, but it was undoubtedly a pure laugh born from something "so absurd that even the Butcher's Nails couldn't process it."

Then Angron spoke.

"Are you fucking sick in the head?"

"The Empire has rotted to this state, and the first problem you see is 'these people aren't pious enough'?"

"Do you want me to hammer a nail into you too? Maybe your brain will work better after that."

Leman Russ muttered, "Even Angron thinks you're sick. Just think about how ridiculous you are."

Lorgar's face flushed even redder.

But to everyone's surprise, he wasn't angry.

He took a deep breath, looked around the hall, and began his defense in a "calm" tone that he believed was perfectly reasonable.

"I do not deny the rot I caused during the rebellion. I fell to Chaos, I betrayed the Emperor, and I committed unforgivable sins. I admit all of this."

He paused.

"But I will never admit that these heretics are believing in the God-Emperor!"

"Although we, the Word Bearers, believe in the God-Emperor,"

"even though you didn't let me believe,"

"we have never done such things as exploiting believers!"

"Do you know how my City of Perfection, Monarchia, was built?"

"It was all voluntarily donated by mortals! Not a single brick was requisitioned by force! Not a single pillar was obtained through oppression!"

"Furthermore! Those who wanted to donate all their property were instead scolded by us! We would tell them,"

" 'You are disloyal! True faith does not require you to go bankrupt. True faith is using your actions to honor the God-Emperor within the scope of your ability!'"

"But what about this so-called Imperial Ecclesiarchy? They raise the tithes until the people cannot survive!"

"They use the Skitarii to suppress dissenters! They label opponents as heretics and burn them! They—they have tarnished the very word 'faith'!"

"These people should face an inquisition! This group of heretics should be severely and thoroughly purged!"

Guilliman forced his voice to sound normal as he said,

"Lorgar, have you noticed a problem? That 'perfect system of faith' you just described,"

"mortals donating voluntarily, no forced requisition, no oppression, scolding believers who try to go bankrupt,"

"after you fell, all these things became the exact opposite of what those 'heretics' you mentioned are doing."

"In other words, you personally created a 'template of correct faith,' and then you personally betrayed it?"

"And then, ten thousand years later, a group of people using your banner turned it into the very thing you despise the most."

"You aren't scolding them, Lorgar. You are scolding your own reflection ten thousand years later."

"How do you know they aren't pious?"

The Khan immediately added,

"In their eyes, they are sincere too. Perhaps they also feel they are fighting for the God-Emperor."

"Perhaps they would also say that those who want to donate all their property 'will be scolded by us for being disloyal.'"

"It's just that their standard for 'all their property' is different from yours."

"You think donating one-tenth is piety, and donating everything is excessive."

"They think donating one-tenth is the baseline, and not donating is heresy."

"The difference between you and them is not the purity of faith. It is the scale of power."

"When you only have one Legion and one planet, your faith is warm, voluntary, and beautiful."

"When your faith becomes a massive organization spanning the galaxy with trillions of believers,"

The Khan paused.

"It becomes the very thing you just cursed."

"Not because it was tarnished by 'heretics.'"

"But because it grew up."

"Any faith, when it grows large enough, becomes a machine that devours its believers."

"Your Monarchia didn't become like that, not because your faith was purer than theirs."

"But because your Monarchia was burned down by Guilliman before it could grow up."

Lorgar was stunned for a moment.

But only for a moment.

Then he raised his head, his eyes burning with the fire of faith staring directly at Guilliman and the Khan, his voice not softening, but becoming even firmer.

"Roboute, what you said sounds very reasonable. But you have committed a fundamental logical error."

Guilliman raised an eyebrow slightly.

"You say I created a template of faith, and then this template was corrupted, so faith itself is problematic."

Lorgar said, in a rhythmic and persuasive tone like a preacher on a pulpit, "But if this logic holds,"

He turned and pointed his finger directly at Guilliman.

"what about your Codex?"

Guilliman froze.

"You designed a perfect administrative system, and then you fell."

"A thousand years later, your successors turned this system into a hotbed of corruption."

"The High Lords gild themselves with your name, use your system to exploit the Imperial Fists, and use your council to hide intelligence and foster enemies to maintain their own power."

Lorgar's voice grew more impassioned, and that innate, moving charisma belonging to the Word Bearers Primarch began to fill the entire Viewing Hall.

"According to your logic, Guilliman's system was corrupted, so is the system itself problematic?"

"Guilliman's Codex was abused, so should the Codex not exist?"

"If you want to use this deduction to deny my faith,"

"then burn your own Codex first."

Guilliman's mouth opened, then closed.

Because what Lorgar said was logically impeccable.

Everyone was surprised.

Lorgar, the religious fanatic they had always thought only knew how to repeat slogans, had actually counter-attacked and defeated Guilliman in the debate.

(Don't be surprised why the Primarchs were disdainful of a religious leader like Lorgar who had spread his faith across several sectors; to the Primarchs, wasn't that just a basic skill?)

(Furthermore, except for Guilliman and the Khan, most Primarchs probably wouldn't consider how Lorgar managed to preach while fighting all the way and still maintain a large-scale Legion; they only looked at the battle lines.)

Lorgar did not stop.

He turned to the Khan.

"Khan, you just said, 'Any faith, when it grows large enough, becomes a machine that devours its believers.'"

"You said my Monarchia didn't become like that only because it was burned down by Guilliman before it could grow up."

The Khan half-closed his eyes, the corners of his mouth slightly raised, waiting to see how Lorgar would continue.

"Then let me ask you, what about your White Scars?"

The Khan's eyes widened slightly.

"Does your White Scars Legion not have its own traditions?"

"Does it not have its own faith? Your Stormseers, your shamanic culture, your worship of the Father of the Heavens,"

"have these things been twisted in the ten thousand years since you left? Have they been alienated?"

"Have they become something you wouldn't recognize?"

The Khan did not answer.

Because they all knew the answer.

Any culture, any tradition, any faith, once it loses the protection of its founder, will deform under the erosion of time. This is not a problem of faith, nor a problem of the system.

This is a problem of time.

This is a problem of human nature.

"All of you," Lorgar looked around the hall, his voice becoming nearly solemn,

"are making the same mistake. You are treating the 'result of corruption' as the'sin of the thing itself.'"

"Guilliman's system was corrupted, so is the system guilty?"

"Dorn's Imperial Fists were treated as expendable, so is the division of the Legion guilty?"

"The Emperor's Imperial Truth was forgotten,"

"so is the Truth guilty?"

"If this logic holds, then nothing in this Universe is innocent."

"Because anything—any ideology, any system, any ideal—as long as it is left to mortals to operate for long enough, will be twisted, corrupted, and turned into the thing the creator despises most."

"But this is not the creator's fault."

"This is the price of the Guardian's absence."

Lorgar slapped his breastplate hard, emitting a dull metallic clanking sound.

"My faith is not wrong. My Monarchia is not wrong."

"The wrong one is me."

"I fell, I left, and I did not continue to protect it."

"So it became what I despise most ten thousand years later."

"Just like Guilliman's system is not wrong."

"The wrong one is that Guilliman fell, and no one continued to maintain it."

"The question has never been 'is the faith correct?' The question is, when the Guardian of the faith disappears, who ensures it is not tarnished?"

"And these so-called Imperial Ecclesiarchy, these maggots who exploit the people in the Emperor's name,"

"they are not the heirs of faith. They are the grave robbers of faith."

"They stole a sacred shell and stuffed it full of their own greed and selfish desires."

"This is why I say they are heretics."

"Not because they believe in the wrong god."

"But because they are not believing at all. They are just using faith."

"A person who uses faith to exploit the people is ten thousand times more despicable than a person who never believes."

"Because an atheist is at least honest, while these false believers tarnish not only the name of the God-Emperor, but also the light in the heart of every sincere believer."

Everyone was thinking seriously, and with a touch of reluctant approval.

Because every word Lorgar said was well-founded and logically self-consistent.

He did not avoid his own fall. He did not defend his own sins.

He admitted everything and then, with a higher-dimensional argument, dragged "faith" back out of the mire of "corruption."

Guilliman closed his eyes.

He did not refute it.

Not because he had nothing to say. But because the argument Lorgar used to refute him was exactly the same argument he had just used to attack Lorgar.

Lorgar simply flipped the mirror, letting Guilliman see his own reflection.

Your system and my faith essentially face the same dilemma.

You have no right to use a problem that you yourself cannot solve to deny my answer.

Sanguinius spoke softly.

"Lorgar."

The Angel's voice was like a clear spring, devoid of previous pity and admonition, replaced by a kind of pure, heartfelt curiosity.

"You are right. Faith itself may not be wrong. It is not faith that is corrupted, but people."

He paused.

"But I want to ask you a question."

Lorgar looked at Sanguinius.

"If you had not fallen. If you had always been protecting your faith. If Monarchia had not been burned down, but had continued to grow for ten thousand years under your protection,"

Sanguinius's voice became even softer.

"are you sure it wouldn't have become the thing you just cursed?"

This question was like an extremely thin, almost invisible silver needle, precisely piercing the only tiny crack in Lorgar's entire argument.

Because Lorgar's argument was built on one premise:

"If the Guardian is not absent, faith will not be corrupted."

But Sanguinius asked, "Even if the Guardian is not absent, will faith really not be corrupted?"

Lorgar was silent.

But only for three seconds.

Then he raised his head, his eyes burning with the fire of faith staring directly at Sanguinius, and said,

"I am not sure."

There was another subtle silence in the Viewing Hall.

Because no one had expected Lorgar to say the four words, "I am not sure."

Everyone thought this guy would say he was sure.

"I am not sure." Lorgar repeated, his voice becoming even firmer.

"But this is precisely the meaning of faith."

"Faith is not certainty. Faith is choosing to believe amidst uncertainty."

"I cannot guarantee that Monarchia would not be corrupted ten thousand years later."

"Just as Guilliman cannot guarantee that his Codex will not be abused ten thousand years later."

"Just as the Father cannot guarantee that his Empire will not become a dark and terrifying hell ten thousand years later."

"But this does not mean we should not try. It does not mean we should not build. It does not mean we should not believe."

"If we abandon faith because we are afraid of corruption,"

"then what difference is there from giving up the fight because you are afraid of failure?"

He looked at Dorn.

"Dorn, would you not build a wall because you are afraid it might collapse one day?"

Dorn sat there expressionless.

But he did not shake his head.

"Leman Russ, would you not lead the pack because you are afraid it might scatter one day?"

Leman Russ took a swig of ale and said nothing.

Lorgar saw it.

He was not triumphant. He did not cheer.

He just said the final sentence in a voice calmer than any of his usual sermons.

"The value of faith does not lie in whether it can never be corrupted."

"The value of faith lies in the fact that after it is corrupted, there will always be someone who stands up to polish it clean again."

"Those who stand up, those who still persist in true faith under the stake,"

"they are the Guardians of faith. Not those maggots sitting in golden cathedrals counting money."

"Therefore, I say send those maggots to the stake."

"Not for the revenge of faith."

"But to let true faith illuminate the darkness once again."

After Lorgar finished this sentence, he slowly sat back in his seat.

Leman Russ finally spoke.

"The Empire is almost dead, and you are still obsessing over who has the orthodox faith."

The Wolf King shook his head and downed the last of the ale in his cup.

"But the things you said,"

he paused, and added in a tone he himself wasn't quite sure of,

"are not entirely without reason."