16
Among the various Legions in the Astartes area, there was a long silence where no one spoke.
Even the Legions that were usually the most eager to chime in held back this time.
It wasn't that they had nothing to say, but that the words were truly difficult to voice at this moment.
If everything were just betrayal, it would be simple; but if everything is a closed loop, then it's trouble.
This isn't a matter of who reached out first or who got stabbed later.
This is a whole sequence of events that has come full circle and latched back onto the First Legion itself.
Among the Ultramarines, Hill was the first to speak.
She didn't look elsewhere, speaking directly toward the First Legion's seating area.
"Look at the bigger picture."
"At least this has given you a definitive answer."
"It's not that a single person was rotten from the start, nor that a single person was born to take the blame."
"It's that too many things were pressed together, eventually twisting the path into a dead knot."
There was still no response from the First Legion.
Hill didn't mind and continued.
"This might not be pleasant to hear."
"But it counts as the truth; you've finally cleared one thing up."
"It's not that anyone is purely evil or purely wronged; it's that everyone took half a step forward and ended up in the pit together."
Hill tilted her head slightly.
"If things are truly like this, then the last thing you should do now is continue rushing to condemn each other to death."
From the White Scars' side, Yesugei added a comment.
"There is truth in that. If there were a clear cause followed by an effect, it would be easier to sever."
"Now it's reversed."
"Seeing the effect first and then searching backward for the cause makes it very difficult to curse anyone outright."
Among the Space Wolves, a pup clicked his tongue.
"No wonder even our Primarch stopped arguing just now."
"Anyone would feel stifled by this."
Another replied.
"It would be the same for anyone."
"If you fought hard for ten thousand years, only to find out at the end that the first blow was struck by your own family, anyone would be dazed."
Among the Raven Guard, Sharrowkyn looked toward the First Legion.
"The thing they find hardest to bear right now might not be Luther, nor Lion."
"It's that they suddenly have to admit that no one is an outsider."
"The situation was created by their own steps, one by one."
Finally, someone from the First Legion spoke.
The first to speak was Corswain.
He stood in place, taking a long time before uttering a single sentence.
"These words may sound light, but falling upon the Legion, they are too heavy."
Hill looked at him.
"I didn't say they were light."
"I only said they are more useful than blind cursing."
Corswain didn't snap back.
Because he also realized that trying to push the blame onto 'one person's fault' no longer worked.
Luther spoke up then.
"Hill isn't wrong, but hearing this doesn't make one feel any better."
"No one is purely at fault, yet no one can remain clean."
Astelan leaned to one side, and hearing this, he suddenly let out a cold laugh.
"Well, this is new."
"After all that cursing and fighting, it turns out we were cursing ourselves and fighting ourselves."
"The First Legion truly is capable."
Corswain glanced at him.
"If you only want to make sarcastic remarks, then shut up."
Astelan was quick to retort.
"I'm not being sarcastic."
"I'm telling the truth. Before, I thought those people on Caliban made such a mess of things, they were truly rotten."
"Now, it's just great."
"Turns out none of us have the right to laugh at the others."
"This blame has been passed around from Terra to Caliban, and from Caliban to ten thousand years later, completing a full circle."
A Terran-born veteran said gruffly.
"That's what's most annoying."
"If it were just one person who was rotten to the core, we could just kill them and be done with it."
"But in this current situation, it's not something that can be settled by killing just one person."
Someone from the caliban-born side chimed in.
"Don't just use those words to mock people."
"You Terran-born aren't much cleaner than we are."
"When it really came down to it later, didn't your descendants do the same, pinning the label of Fallen Angel on everyone's head?"
Zahariel looked up.
"It wasn't something that happened in a day, nor was it just one argument."
"It was many words left unsaid."
"Many frustrations left unresolved... many people clearly standing together, yet always refusing to lay bare what was in their hearts."
Astelan snorted.
"To put it bluntly, everyone thought they were being tough."
"Lion didn't speak, Luther didn't ask, and none of us were willing to back down."
"In the end, everyone wanted to prove they weren't wrong, so the only choice was to keep going down the wrong path."
Luther turned to look at him.
"You're actually not wrong this time."
Astelan grinned.
"That's rare."
Corswain ignored their bickering.
He looked at Zahariel.
"You always used to talk about misunderstandings, saying that if things could have been explained clearly, they might not have reached that point."
"Do you still see it that way?"
Zahariel paused for a moment.
"I still see it that way."
"But I'm no longer just focusing on that one misunderstanding."
"The misunderstanding was just the spark that set it off; the things piled up underneath had been there for a long time."
A caliban-born Knight said in a low voice.
"So it wasn't just a moment of confusion for someone."
"It was the entire Legion slowly sliding in that direction. In the end, when the storm came, no one could keep their footing."
On the Terran-born side, finally, no one was in a hurry to refute.
Because they recognized the truth in those words too.
A veteran said.
"You caliban-borns like to use oaths to pressure people."
"We Terran-born like to use seniority to pressure people."
"The Primarch likes to use orders to pressure people."
"Luther likes to use personal ties to pressure people."
"Everyone has their own way of applying pressure."
"No one ever thought that sooner or later, all these things would collapse together."
Another Terran-born veteran spoke up.
"Well, now it's happened."
"It really collapsed, and after the collapse, our descendants are digging through the ruins."
"In the end, they dug everyone up and found they were all the same."
"Doesn't this just prove the roots were rotten long ago?"
Some among the caliban-borns looked grim hearing this.
"Those words of yours are still too harsh."
The veteran replied.
"Setting aside whether it's harsh or not."
"Whether it's wrong or not, you've heard it for yourselves."
Seeing that tempers were about to flare again, Hill spoke up once more.
"That's enough."
"Stop being so quick to twist the knife into each other."
"What you should be doing now is not stoking old fires."
"Instead, acknowledge one thing: the reason this whole affair is so terrifying isn't because of traitors."
"It's because every one of you felt that your own step didn't matter much."
"The result is that while each step seemed like nothing, it eventually turned into this."
Corswain nodded slowly.
"I acknowledge that."
"Over these years, no one in the First Legion was willing to be the first to uncover the wound."
"We always thought to suppress it a bit more, delay it a bit longer, relying on military discipline, on face, on the Primarch's prestige, and on the title of Knight to brush things aside."
"But the things that cannot be brushed aside will eventually return."
After hearing this, Luther replied evenly.
"They will return... and when they do, they are often even uglier than before."
A younger warrior spoke.
"Then how should we judge this now?"
"If the closed loop is truly like this, do we still need to distinguish right from wrong?"
Luther glanced at him.
"Of course we must."
"If we don't, things will only get worse."
"But we can no longer use the easiest methods to distinguish them."
"We cannot say someone must have rebelled just because they were on Caliban, nor can we say someone is definitely superior just because they were on Terra."
"And even more so, we cannot condemn everyone who went astray today to death just because Fallen Angel appeared in the future."
Astelan raised an eyebrow.
"Those words of yours sound like you're leaving a way out for yourself."
Luther did not get angry.
"Of course I am also talking about myself, because I am in this game."
"It would be ridiculous if I tried to exclude myself."
Zahariel said softly.
"That's what's most distressing."
"Everyone is in the game; no one is purely standing on the outside pointing fingers."
Corswain took over.
"So Hill's 'look at the bigger picture' was actually only half right."
Hill looked up.
"Which half?"
Corswain looked ahead.
"Being able to understand that it wasn't just one person who was rotten is indeed a good thing, but the other half is that this makes it even harder for us to find excuses for ourselves."
"Because once we admit it's a loop, it's the same as admitting that everyone was pushing it to turn."
After those words fell, there was another silence from the First Legion's side for a few breaths.
Someone from the White Scars also spoke up.
"Because to catch a traitor, you only need to draw your sword."
"Cutting out the old sickness within oneself is not so easy."
Among the Space Wolves, a pup grumbled.
"When all is said and done, you lot are just too good at bottling things up."
"If there's something wrong, just have a proper fight and curse it out clearly. How did it end up piling up like this?"
The person next to him slapped him.
"Say less."
"Not everyone is like you, using an axe to reason whenever something happens."
The pup snorted but did indeed shut up.
Astelan then tilted his chin.
"So we're just going to accept it?"
"Accept that this is a mess that no one can wash clean?"
Corswain looked at him.
"Whether we accept it or not, it's there."
"You curse Lion, he is at fault; Luther resents Lion, he is also at fault."
"You Terran-born kicked people to the rear and then complained that Caliban bred trouble—you can't escape it either. We caliban-borns circled around old wounds and suppressed our resentment—we can't escape it either."
"This isn't accepting fate; it's settling the account."
Astelan twitched the corner of his mouth.
"You Paladin, your words are sharper than usual today."
"Someone has to say it."
Corswain replied evenly.
"With things laid out like this, maintaining that air of Knightly dignity is worse than not having it at all."
Luther suddenly nodded.
"Someone must speak the truth clearly, otherwise this loop will just keep turning."
Zahariel said in a low voice.
"It has already turned for too long."
"So long that the people of the future are left with nothing but capturing and interrogating."
"So long that they've almost forgotten that at the very beginning, everyone just wanted to protect what they cared about most."
Hill listened and looked at Zahariel.
"That is what you can still do now."
"Don't let those people of the future be unable to even hear these words."
"At least for now, you are still sitting here."
"You can manage to end this cycle of tragedy, instead of everyone walking toward error unknowingly as they did before."
Corswain slowly exhaled.
"You Ultramarine, you've actually said a few decent things today."
Hill smiled.
"I have to be of some use."
"Otherwise, if our 13th Legion is always on the receiving end of your blades, wouldn't that be too much of a loss?"
These words managed to break the atmosphere slightly.
Even on the First Legion's side, someone managed a strained smile.
But quickly, that slight loosening tightened up again.
Luther pondered for a moment before looking at Corswain.
"We are trapped in a loop... and it's not like we never had a chance to stop."
"It's just that every time, no one was the first to stop."
Corswain replied.
"Because everyone thought they could do better, everyone felt that only they could lead the Legion toward the right path, toward that glorious future."
"But we were only leading the Legion toward a cycle of tragedy."
Astelan said suddenly.
"Then what about Lion?"
"Much as I hate to admit it, the Primarch is one of the few existences that both our sides can acknowledge, and only he can end this tragedy, this ten-thousand-year hunt."
"But do you still believe he can pull it back now?"
As soon as these words were spoken, many in the First Legion looked toward Corswain.
Because this question, in the end, had to fall back onto the Primarch.
Corswain did not answer immediately.
After a moment, he spoke.
"I won't speak grand words for the Primarch; I will only speak of what I see before me."
"He has at least begun to settle the account, which is not easy for adults Primarch."
Astelan scoffed.
"Settling the account is enough?"
Corswain looked at him.
"Of course it's not enough, but it's a start."
"If we don't even have this step, nothing will follow."
Zahariel also spoke up.
"I ask for nothing else now."
"I only ask for one thing."
"When that day truly comes, I hope Lord Lion can still remember what he saw here today."
Luther added in a low voice.
"Remember that people are not tools."
A caliban-born Knight said slowly.
"And remember that Caliban is not an old stone to be tossed away at will."
On the Terran-born veterans' side, someone finally followed up.
"And he must remember that the First Legion cannot be held together by intimidation alone."
Astelan didn't argue this time.
He just stood there, taking a long time before uttering a single sentence.
"If we really look at it this way... in the end, it seems like no one was wrong."
Luther closed his eyes.
"But it also seems like everyone was wrong."
After these words were spoken, no one followed up.
Because the root of the matter had been reached.
The Dark Angels of the future, the Dark Angels of the past, the Dark Angels of the present.
The Primarch, the lieutenants, the Terran-born, the caliban-borns.
No one had truly intended to destroy everything from the start.
Aside from those traitors who truly wanted to betray the Emperor, everyone was just doing their best to save it all.
Yet the path they ended up taking happened to push everything in that direction.
In the heavy silence that followed, Corswain finally spoke the last sentence.
"We are trapped in a cycle."
"The terrifying thing isn't that it turns."
"The terrifying thing is that every time, even though it's already creaking beneath our feet, we still refuse to stop."
"We always wait until the situation is completely out of control before we're willing to look back at what we've actually done."
He paused.
"As for me now, I only hope for one thing."
"I hope that when Lord Lion returns from the long night, he can truly sever this tragedy with his own hands."
"And reforge the shattered First Legion."
