16
After the footage stopped, everyone fell into deep thought.
Amara did not hold; the Imperial fleet was shattered, and the surface was burned to a wasteland.
Logically, if the Menach Dynasty had pressed just one step further, the remaining Imperial forces would not have been able to hold.
Yet, they chose to retreat.
Lion ElJonson said, "Both the Astra Militarum and the Navy have fought to the best of their ability; it was only due to objective facts that the casualties were so heavy."
Guilliman took over.
"Compared to that, I am more concerned that the Necrons should have continued their assault."
"They had already punched through the Navy, the main surface city was destroyed, the supply chain was once connected, and the Imperial defenders were left with nothing but ruins."
"By all logic, they had no reason to stop at that moment."
Leman Russ grinned.
"Don't tell me those tin skeletons also had an internal conflict and staged some kind of The Horus Heresy like we did?"
Khan glanced at him.
"That is not impossible."
"Who says a metallic dynasty cannot have its own dirty laundry?"
"After all, which of the races introduced earlier hasn't been locked in a meat grinder with us in this Universe while dealing with their own various issues?"
Perturabo spoke up at this moment.
"It's not just internal conflict; it could also be damage to their command center."
"Since that surface pyramid could facilitate transport, once it was destroyed, the Dynasty's rhythm of control over the surface of Amara was disrupted."
"Coupled with the damage to the death's Head, and the fleet's main axis retreating, the command chain may have loosened as well."
"The Necrons are not a normal race; they are merely a group of machines with memories of the past."
"Once they judge that the returns from pressing the advantage are insufficient, they will withdraw."
"This is different from humans."
"When humans are driven mad by battle, they will fight to the end for the sake of face, fury, or an inability to admit defeat."
"They will not; they are more like a War Machine recalculating its parameters."
Magnus added.
"There is another layer."
"Dark storms, anomalous pulses, the strange activity on planet Olick—these things are not normal."
"The Menach Dynasty's withdrawal may not just be due to battle damage."
"It is also possible that they received higher-priority orders elsewhere, or some more ancient program was awakened."
"Of course, I suspect it might be that the slaughter these people inflicted on the sector caused a massive reaction in the Warp, drawing the attention of entities within the Warp to this place."
Sanguinius stared at the star map that had gone dark.
"This does not look like a withdrawal forced by defeat, but rather a slaughter interrupted by something else."
Vulkan said in a deep voice.
"Regardless of the reason, Amara being able to catch its breath was not due to luck."
"It was earned by countless people through their own sacrifices."
"Without the earlier ground assault and the subsequent boarding actions, the Empire would not have lasted until that moment."
When the Minotaurs were mentioned, Leman Russ's expression changed first.
He frowned, his voice growing gruffer.
"Speaking of which, I would rather ask about another matter."
"That Minotaur Chapter, whose progeny are they exactly?"
With that, many of the Primarchs around him looked up.
This was a question everyone was actually thinking about.
An Astartes Chapter with absurdly good equipment, absurdly ruthless methods, and absurdly twisted actions, yet they worked directly for the High Lord of Terra.
This in itself was glaring enough.
Angron cursed first.
"A bunch of thugs for mortal politicians?"
"Astartes?"
"If such things truly exist, I would rather cut their chains first, then cut down the people holding the chains."
Ferrus Manus's expression also darkened.
"Obeying the Emperor, obeying the Great Crusade, obeying orders—that is all fine."
"But obeying a group of bureaucrats sitting in high positions fighting for power?"
"And doing it to suppress other Astartes for them?"
"What kind of thing is this?"
Fulgrim said coldly.
"This is corruption, though not corruption towards Chaos."
"It is corruption towards mediocrity."
Lion ElJonson's gaze was cold.
"The records being deleted so cleanly and their origins being erased so thoroughly in themselves indicate that someone does not want others to know who they are."
"The existence of this Chapter holds no small secret."
Guilliman said in a low voice.
"It is not just a question of secrets."
"If the rumors are true, they report directly to the High Lord Council."
"That means in the future, a portion of the Astartes will be used as a hammer for Terra's politics."
"Not against xenos, not against traitors, but against the interior of the Empire."
Dorn tapped his fingers slowly on the armrest.
"I do not accept this."
"The Astartes are not the private army of the council, nor are they a club for some faction of politicians to use to smash their own kind."
Leman Russ grinned, his smile devoid of any warmth.
"When I scold you brothers, I never hold back."
"But that is our own family business."
"Is it the turn of a group of robed mortal councilors to wield the whip?"
"They are not worthy."
Perturabo did not play devil's advocate this time.
He only stared at the screen, his voice hard and cold.
"If that is truly the way of some of my progeny, I will deal with them first."
"Not because they are capable fighters, but because they sold themselves too cheaply."
"A Legion can be a blade."
"But the blade must be held in hands worthy of it; a bunch of parasites who climbed up through political maneuvering are not worthy."
These words were heavy.
Even Guilliman did not immediately respond.
Vulkan simply shook his head.
"Even I cannot imagine such a scene."
"Having Astartes listen to the secret orders of mortal politicians to act as their most convenient tool for suppression."
"I find it hard to imagine our progeny doing such things; regardless of whether they share similarities in value, they would not harm their own kin."
Mortarion said coldly.
"Are you surprised only now?"
"The Emperor has been gone for a long time; Primarchs have died or gone missing, the Legions have been dismantled, but power continues to grow."
"The mortal council will never miss such an opportunity; sooner or later, they will want to put chains on the Astartes."
Horus Lupercal spoke up at this moment.
His voice was not loud, yet it made many look towards him.
"Once the chains are put on, it will not just be a matter of one Chapter."
"It will become a trend; today they let you suppress an out-of-control Chapter, tomorrow they can let you point your guns at other brothers."
"The day after, they will take it for granted and say this is for the stability of the Empire."
"The most ridiculous thing is that there will always be those who believe it."
Sanguinius looked at the bronze-colored Minotaurs on the screen.
"They might call this obedience 'duty', which is what makes it most distressing."
Angron cursed directly.
"Duty, my ass; that is a dog chain."
"I would rather watch them die on the battlefield than watch them act as thugs for a group of vermin."
Only then did Corax speak slowly.
He first looked around at everyone, then said:
"You are all correct."
"But you have missed one thing: we have been gone for too long."
"To us, the Legion is blood, is oath, is brothers fighting side-by-side, is the continuation of father and son."
"To many later progeny, that is not necessarily the case."
"Especially the progeny from ten thousand years later."
"To them, we Primarchs are likely just murals, dogmas, statues, myths, and at most, a nice piece of Legion history."
"They have not truly seen us, nor have they truly lived by our side."
"Therefore, when they make judgments, what they grasp is not their father, but a way to survive."
Dorn frowned.
"You mean they would turn to politicians for survival."
Corax nodded.
"Parent Legions are, of course, better off."
"They have a deep foundation, great reputation, their own home worlds, relics, allies, history, and a sufficiently strong deterrent."
"Whether from a political or military perspective, the Empire would not easily let them disappear."
"But Successor Chapters are different."
"Especially those Successor Chapters with limited forces, limited supplies, long-term dispersion, and those caught in the cracks of large powers."
"They need warships, recruitment authorization, reinforcements, ordnance, right of passage, legal innocence, and to ensure they are not suspected of being heretics."
"Many of these things are held in the hands of mortal elites."
Guilliman's expression had already become very ugly.
Corax did not stop.
"Not to mention, there are even worse situations."
"If the bloodline of certain Successor Chapters is sensitive, their origins cannot be brought to light, or they have unclear old accounts with Traitor Faction Legions."
"If they want to remain in the Empire and not be completely purged, they must find a patron."
"The patron they can grasp will not be us, but living power."
Perturabo looked at him coldly.
"You sound like you are making excuses for them."
Corax looked back.
"It is not an excuse; it is an explanation."
"Explanation does not equal approval."
"I am only saying that they may not be born wanting to be lackeys."
"Many times, they are just forced there layer by layer."
Lion ElJonson said in a deep voice.
"Being forced is no excuse."
"If the Astartes cannot even hold onto why they fight, then what is the difference between them and slave soldiers?"
Corax replied.
"I did not say that was a good thing."
"I am only saying that ten thousand years of the Empire is enough to wear down any good thing."
Horus Lupercal chuckled lowly, the laughter very cold.
"If the Empire has truly reached that point, where even the Astartes must rely on handing knives to the mortal council to survive, then it is rotting faster than I thought."
Lorgar Aurelian also rarely did not argue.
He gazed at the screen and said softly:
"If loyalty is co-opted by politics, if faith is requisitioned by the council, sacred things will become cheap."
"That kind of Empire, even if it is still alive, is already very ugly."
Magnus said indifferently:
"Knowledge is sealed, truth is hidden, bloodlines are deleted, records are erased, and Chapter are treated as secret weapons."
"This fits the look a decaying Empire should have; the most absurd thing is that it can still function."
Leman Russ snorted.
"Function, my ass."
"That is called lingering without dying."
Ferrus Manus stared at the dense list of equipment of the Minotaurs Chapter.
"There is one more thing."
"Their supplies are too good, better than many veteran Chapter."
"This shows that the High Lord is not just using them as a blade, but is also carefully sharpening this blade."
Guilliman's voice grew deeper.
"That is to say, the future Terra council is not just utilizing the Astartes."
"They are even actively cultivating a Chapter that is absolutely obedient, well-equipped, and dedicated to handling their dirty work."
"This is worse than temporary requisition."
Dorn said coldly:
"This is no longer corruption."
"This is usurpation."
Ferrus Manus was surprised at how the Empire had become like this after ten thousand years; although the equipment in the hands of the Minotaurs was relatively expensive during the Great Crusade, it did not qualify as a sacred relic.
Compared to the sacred relics in his hands, these things were simply like children's toys.
Konrad Curze leaned back in his chair and chuckled lowly.
"Look."
"I told you the Empire knows how to grow."
"As it grows, the father's sons become the council's axe."
"As it grows, loyalty becomes a permit, and glory becomes an official document."
"How interesting."
"The great Astartes, in the end, work for a group of mortals who can write, ruthlessly smashing their own kind."
Lion ElJonson's gaze was chillingly cold.
"I do not find this interesting."
Konrad Curze spread his hands.
"But it is very real."
"When you and I are not here, others will always find other uses for what we left behind."
"The Legion is like this, and the Empire is like this too."
Vulkan slowly let out a breath.
"If such a day truly comes."
"I would rather my progeny die in an unknown frontier than have them wear the name of glory while doing such things for mediocrities."
Khan said indifferently.
"At least now, we all understand one thing: the Necrons could not swallow the Empire in one bite."
"But the Empire itself is quite good at slowly wearing away some more important things."
Leman Russ sneered:
"For example, the bones."
Perturabo added:
"For example, the backbone."
Dorn finally said only one sentence.
"The Emperor's Children should not be dogs of the council."
