“Of Gotham City's 30 million residents, 5 million have been directly or indirectly involved in first-degree murder.”

This was one of Gotham City's underground safe houses, the Riddler's lair, the safest and most secretive kind.

It was set up like a normal study. Killer Croc, sitting on the sofa, pulled out a copy of Kant's "Critique of Pure Reason" from a nearby bookshelf. After flipping through it for a while, he realized he couldn't understand a single word, so he angrily threw it on the floor.

The Ventriloquist picked it up and put it back.

“Approximately 15 million people have a history of Criminal behavior. The remaining 10 million who haven't committed crimes aren't good citizens; they're all reclusive drug addicts, gamblers, and prostitutes from the red-light district.”

The Riddler's voice echoed in the room. Jim Gordon was tied to a chair, blindfolded, with a cloth gagging him.

“And the reason they haven't joined the Criminal army isn't due to any noble qualities, but because they haven't been pushed to the brink.”

The television was broadcasting. The Riddler confirmed it was a live feed. Batman was there, just as he had planned. He continued:

“So, do you understand? There are no good people in Gotham. The only ones who can be called good are the drug addicts and gamblers, because they don't harm anyone but themselves.”

“I'm so tired, year after year, day after day. Living among a pile of trash, constantly committing crimes.”

“If crime is so tiring, why don't you stop?” Movie Freak said, “You can stop committing crimes, right?”

“No, you simply don't understand.”

The Riddler stood up somewhat nervously, then squatted on the sofa, hugging his legs like a lonely, helpless child.

“This is a war. If we truly give up crime because of fatigue, then he wins... Batman wins.”

“So what? Can't we live without committing crimes?”

Killer Croc found a bag of potato chips nearby, tore it open, and threw them directly into his mouth.

“No, it's not like that. Batman wins, but I don't lose.”

Huh? Killer Croc thought he had gone completely insane.

He knew that riddles were the Riddler's trademark, just like the hot dog vendor at the park entrance would have his unique recipe. But the Riddler had never uttered such incomprehensible riddles, at least not in his memory.

The Riddler was somewhat neurotic. He hugged his knees, like a little boy hiding in a corner during a thunderstorm.

“You don't understand, I'm not me at all. I mean, I don't represent myself at all.”

He rambled on, “I naturally attract my own kind, just as Batman has always attracted all of us. Just like you, Killer Croc, you've always attracted all the Criminals in Gotham City with a beast-like heart, just like yours.”

“So you have a massive following; you can easily raise an army fiercely loyal to you.”

“You are their king. Purely beast-like Criminals flock to your side, just like the high-IQ Criminals around me, the desperate Batman Who Laughs around the Joker, and the fearful worshippers around Scarecrow.”

“We, our so-called super-Criminals, we are their spiritual pillars. Batman said it very well: Criminals are mostly superstitious and blindly obedient…”

The Riddler continued:

“We possess the same qualities as them, but we are far more powerful, which is why they are so easily subdued by us.”

“We no longer represent ourselves, but a part of Gotham's evil. We represent those people, becoming a concrete manifestation of that evil.”

He stared blankly at the television.

“Killing me is useless. Kill me, and Tutankhamun, the Cluemaster, or some other similar Criminal will take my place. He might not be as strong as me, but he will certainly be the strongest of the remaining ones, and so on… and so on!”

“We are never special! So Batman knows very well that killing us won't stop crime; on the contrary, his act of murdering us will only further fuel the proliferation of crime.”

“Every successful crime is a huge encouragement to other Criminals. Once he opens that door, he truly becomes part of the darkness, and therefore can never eliminate the darkness, you understand.”

“If Batman truly did that, then he would be like us; he would attract other Criminals, attract others to imitate his act of murdering Criminals, and then this metropolis of 30 million people would turn into a slaughterhouse, rivers of blood, piles of corpses. Because if you want to be serious, everyone is a Criminal!”

The Riddler said:

“Everyone can shout slogans of justice and kill indiscriminately. The law will become a piece of waste paper. Batman would never do that.”

“Alarmist.” Movie Freak commented, “Supervillains are just special.”

“What's so special about me?” The Riddler said:

“Before us freaks, there was Romans Falcone. Before Romans Falcone, Gotham had the Lion King. Before that, there were Gotham's four great families. Before that, and before that, I'm just a puppet of Gotham's evil, a marionette. Whether this puppet is called Riddler or Edward Nygma is irrelevant.”

“Like the Joker, how many times has the Joker died? How can you say he's still the same Joker he was before?”

“We saw him disappear in an explosion, and then two or three months later he was back. He fell into the river, disappeared, and two or three months later he was back. He's back, he's back, he'll always be back. He can only be dispersed but never Death! Gotham only needs a madman who can split his mouth to his ears. Does it matter what that madman's real name is?”

“He defeats me again and again. Our game will never stop until one side can no longer stand and falls. Batman is trying to reverse the entire city with his own strength! You simply don't understand how awe-inspiring that is. He is invincible, never hesitates, doesn't need to rest at all. He is brilliant, extraordinarily intelligent, his will is as hard as steel, like a god walking among humans!”

The Riddler's voice gradually rose. He stood up, waving his hands:

“This is unscientific, this is impossible! How can such a person exist?!”

“You simply don't understand how desperate it is to face such an opponent!”

“No matter how much you struggle, how hard you struggle, you will be sent back to Arkham. This is too sad!”

He slumped back onto the sofa.

“Death might be a release for me. That way, I won't have to be bothered by my own incompetence and Gotham's evil. I can no longer stop committing crimes.”

“Not just because of my mental illness. No matter what resolution I make, planning to do anything other than crime, Gotham's evil will be like an invisible pair of hands pulling me back on track. It enslaves me! It drags me along!”

“No matter how I cry and struggle, he will force me to use those damned riddles, to manipulate me! To show his fangs to that son of Gotham, born of darkness yet betraying darkness! I am the evil dragon that should be slain by the knight, but also a servant of darkness!”

“Only Death can give me peace. But Batman won't even grant me this final tranquility. He doesn't even kill the Joker! Do you know? Batman is a cruel avenger, but his target of revenge isn't me, not Two-Face, not the Joker! It's Gotham City's evil! What he wants to end isn't the Criminal, it's crime itself!”

“But evil and crime cannot be ended. As long as a single human lives in this world, evil and crime can absolutely never be ended! But he just does it! He's trying to achieve a goal that's absolutely impossible to achieve, tormenting himself, tormenting everyone! He's practically not human!”

He lost all his strength, as if all the bones had been pulled out of his body, and slumped onto the chair.

“I'm tired, I'm really tired.”

He murmured in a low voice, “So now there are no more riddles, no more tests, and no more games. Everything should come to an end.”

He picked up the phone on the table and connected to Batman on the TV: “Batman—now, as I say, kill the Joker!”

He walked over to the whimpering Jim Gordon, pulled out a pistol, placed his own head and Jim Gordon's side by side, and then pressed the gun to his own temple.

“No riddles, no hints. Now I only have one command. Kill the Joker, or Jim Gordon's head and mine will burst open instantly.”

“Either kill the Joker and save me and Gordon, or let the Joker go and let me and Gordon die.”

“Batman, you can hear me. Make your choice. Don't think about pretending to stab or shoot the Joker in non-fatal places. I want you to dismember the Joker. Only when I see him dismembered will I confirm his Death and release Jim Gordon.”

“Whether it's you, me, the principle of being dragged along, the unbreakable iron law, today they must all be destroyed. If they can't be destroyed, then destroy me.”

“I've decided to use femtosecond laser pulverization technology to kill the Joker. This technology can pulverize materials on a microscopic scale. In a sense, the Joker is about to be dismembered.”

“That's right, do it now.”

The Joker crawled into the red cabinet, and then quickly, the cabinet's wooden panels fell off, revealing its original appearance as a crystal coffin.

“Kill him immediately, no matter how you do it!”

But Batman ignored him. He walked forward and talked to the Joker for a while.

“Kill him, why aren't you… Wait.”

The Riddler suddenly realized something. He wasn't such a foolish person; he shouldn't have just noticed now.

The bat-shadow with pointed ears appeared behind him. The Riddler heard that voice; it was Batman.

“You see, I made a mistake. I always thought that supervillains like you enjoyed games. I assumed your desire for games was endless.”

“I'm a fool, just like you. You see, you're in your room now, making the same smart mistake as me.”

“You assumed I couldn't break the iron law.”

“You assumed I was unprepared, without foresight.”

“You assumed my mercy was endless.”

“You assumed I didn't have the courage to deal with the consequences of the no-kill rule being broken.”

“You assumed these weren't pre-recorded videos, assumed I was currently in the old Wayne Tower saying final nonsense to the Joker.”

Amygdala tried to move but was immediately pinned down by Killer Croc. He was pressed to the ground, tied up.

“You also assumed the Ventriloquist and Killer Croc weren't my people.”

“—You assumed Movie Freak couldn't be Batman in disguise.”

Click!

The Riddler pulled the trigger, but no bullet came out. Although he had already anticipated this outcome.

“You even assumed I hadn't secretly swapped the bullets in your gun.”

“Why do you underestimate me so much, Edward Nygma? Why do you assume only you can break convention?”

The Riddler turned, a bitter smile on his face.

“So, the Joker wasn't killed? You tricked me?”

“Nygma, Nygma… You are still so arrogant.”

“Guess, Edward—you and I have only met once, but from now on you will always know me. Who am I?”

“Please note, what I'm about to say is not a metaphor, rhetoric, theory, or anything else.”

The Riddler heard Batman say:

“The Joker has already been killed by me.”

Actually, I originally wanted to spend a few chapters writing about how the Riddler recruited Killer Croc and the Ventriloquist, from the perspective of a first victim of the Riddler, and how the protagonist disguised himself as Movie Freak and blended in, hiding clues about the protagonist's constant presence in the chapters, repeatedly hinting to everyone that Movie Freak was problematic, and then creating this surprising twist. But perhaps it really shouldn't have let the protagonist disappear for too long, and the Joker's presence also raised expectations, overshadowing the main character too much. Readers' feedback was very bad, so I just used one sentence to gloss over the Riddler recruiting Killer Croc and them. I originally thought that the Joker's Death was not the climax of this story arc, so I pulled him out for a flashback, which should be fine, and then slowly narrated the Riddler… But I didn't expect the Joker's popularity to exceed my expectations. Everyone was looking forward to the Joker, and no one cared about the poor Riddler. I had to drastically cut the Riddler's scenes. I was wrong. Next time I will never play with this kind of wrong operation again. I'll add one more chapter as compensation. Everyone must remember to follow along!

Also, recommending a friend's book:

Book Title: "Miss Witch, Please Behave Yourself"

【Recommendation】: The original title was "The Taste of a Witch is Really Good," but it was canceled due to special reasons.

Official Recommendation: What's it like to marry a witch right after transmigrating?

Roy says: "The taste of a witch is really good."