Chapter 57: Justice

“Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster. And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you.”

Amygdala woke up from the intense pain. He cried and wailed, lamenting the suffering and torment he had endured.

Killer Croc released Amygdala.

Chen Tao looked at him. Even Amygdala’s chaotic, muddled brain, ravaged by mania, felt Batman’s gaze.

His crying was choked off by an invisible hand. He whimpered and collapsed to the ground, curling his body into a trembling ball.

“It’s all over, Batman. You, too, have become a captive of Gotham’s evil.”

Riddler announced, “Do you remember the Romans? Carmine Falcone. Do you know that young Carmine Falcone’s life goal was to end all crime in Gotham?”

“—And later he became Gotham’s biggest gang boss. You are the same, Batman. When a righteous person succumbs to sin, it is as harmful as a public well being poisoned!”

He said, somewhat madly, “Therefore—Batman is dead!”

He threw the gun in his hand to the ground: “The Bat King has been reborn!”

He bowed exaggeratedly to Chen Tao, like a jester performing on a stage: “Batman! You are now a Criminal too!”

He cheered jubilantly:

“You are no different from us!”

Riddler was convinced by his own logic. In his eyes, Batman, who had directly murdered Joker, was undoubtedly a fellow Criminal like him.

And Batman possessed the same traits as him, but was far more powerful, so therefore—

He surrendered, in every sense of the word.

Chen Tao knew that at this moment, he could probably just crook a finger and Riddler would pounce to frantically lick his toes… Well, maybe he would be a bit more reserved, not quite so exaggerated.

But the underlying attitude would be the same.

As long as Chen Tao wanted, he could immediately get Riddler’s help. If he did that, with Riddler’s intelligence, resources, and combat power, defeating Bane, finding the nuclear bomb, and saving or ruling the entire city would definitely be very convenient, right?

But… I refuse!

“I’ve been a Criminal for a long time, Nygma. Violating personal rights, illegal possession of lethal force, openly breaking the Fortress Law—I’ve never denied it. Now it’s just adding first-degree murder to the charges.”

“But you bastard, listen carefully.”

“Everything you’ve said, I think it’s all bullshit!”

“Your whole ‘darkness engulfs’ theory is just another variation of the ‘one bad day’ theory.”

Chen Tao said:

“You believe everyone will become a slave to some darkness, just as Joker believes that with just one bad day, even Jim Gordon would become Joker. But Jim Gordon didn’t become Joker. Barbara didn’t either.”

As he spoke these words, his eyes looked at Jim Gordon, who was blindfolded.

“Whether it’s a bad day or darkness engulfing, they are just excuses bad guys make to do bad things.”

“The law? The law is just a piece of waste paper to me, Nygma. Please don’t misunderstand, the bottom line I drew for myself in the past was not to protect myself, but to protect you all.”

“I’ve always been thinking, is it just to sacrifice a small part of justice for a greater justice?”

“So do you have an answer now, Batman?”

Chen Tao sighed.

From the moment Edward Nygma spoke, he knew that the person he needed to debate was not the broken Riddler in front of him.

But another member of Gotham’s former ‘Iron Triangle’, the Police Commissioner, Jim Gordon, who had dedicated everything to the city.

He removed Jim Gordon’s blindfold. Jim Gordon looked at him with pity.

“Batman, you used to be hope.”

He said.

Jim Gordon’s expression was somewhat dazed. He stared intently at Chen Tao:

“You told us, you told Gotham.”

“No matter how vast one’s knowledge, or how great one’s talent, one must not be arrogant like Nygma, deeming himself superior.”

“No matter how much one wants to save family, one must not sacrifice innocent lives for family like Victor. No matter how cold Gotham’s nights, one should not warm oneself with the blood of others.”

“Judicial efforts will eventually yield results; society will not always remain in a gray area; justice is ultimately worth protecting.”

“You told us that ‘the world is worth it’, even after experiencing the worst day, even after enduring unimaginable pain, no matter how painful, how crazy, how desperate, it is still worth it.”

He suddenly spoke with a hint of mental breakdown:

“You told us that the greatness of humanity lies in facing the brutal and bloody darkness of human history, yet still holding onto hope for it, striving to heal this human society, instead of shooting it dead! These are all your words, these are all what you taught us!”

“Why? Why let Joker win? Why make such an abrupt decision? Why make yourself like them?”

“Oh God, you should have sent Joker to prison, not shot him dead!”

“I didn’t shoot him dead,” Chen Tao said. “I minced him.”

Chen Tao added, “The finely pulverized kind. Joker paste.”

“Joker, Joker paste. I’m pretty sure that’s some kind of Japanese pun.”

Jim Gordon babbled in anger: “What, do you want to make Joker paste into some kind of Batman-Joker flavored sandwich?”

“And I did just that. I’m sorry, Jim Gordon.”

“You know that by doing this, Batman will fall into…”

“Procedural justice is just a means, Jim Gordon.”

“What?”

“I will only scorn Joker’s corpse, Jim Gordon. Murdering Joker will not turn me into some tyrant or dictator who kills indiscriminately.”

“Do you really believe in the fallacy of the slippery slope? Haven’t we always pursued substantive justice?”

Chen Tao said, “Superheroes have the ability and should inspire and discipline people to make the right choices.”

“When procedural justice and the system can achieve this, I should certainly support the system and procedures. But when the system and procedures fail and become corrupt, I should also supervise the system and procedures themselves.”

“Essentially, the justice superheroes pursue should inherently transcend the law. Otherwise, why wouldn’t I just join the system and become a police officer?”

Jim Gordon responded with silence.

Chen Tao sighed. He stopped what he wanted to say and then shook his head.

This kind of thing was essentially a divergence in ideals and thinking. Jim Gordon had been in the system for too long; his thinking had become constrained.

From the moment he murdered Joker, he had already considered that the two of them could never again achieve a cooperative relationship as they had in the past.

This was a necessary price to pay, and he had anticipated it.

“So now, Mr. Nygma. You’d better obediently tell me where you stole Penguin’s nuclear bomb.”

“What nuclear bomb? I never stole a nuclear bomb!”