16
Everything Varius had been taught, along with his instinctive legal intuition, resisted this entire line of reasoning.
In the classics he had studied, order was granted by those above, and authority came from the endorsement of divinity.
If power could be lent and reclaimed, then law would lose its foundation, loyalty would be reduced to a transaction, and the entire world would be left with nothing but naked calculation.
This was sophistry—at least, that had always been the case throughout his life.
Varius forced himself to calm down, pushing his emotions back into the depths of his heart, just as he had done in the imperial courts.
He quickly scanned the familiar arguments in his mind, attempting to find a flaw strong enough to shatter this system.
After a few breaths, his train of thought suddenly halted.
It was not because he fully agreed, but because he had finally grasped a gap he could refute.
Only then did Varius look up, take a deep breath, and speak again: "My Lord, in the Imperial Capital, I have also seen countless commoners who could not get enough to eat."
"They were slaughtered by knights, yet they remained submissive. If the weak have absolutely no power to resist the strong—"
"—then why would the strong even care about this contract?"
Upon hearing this, Louis laughed.
The light from outside the window gilded his silhouette with a cold edge.
"You are right. In this extraordinary world, commoners cannot kill an emperor. Even if a city is slaughtered, the strong remain seated on the throne."
He walked back to the map and raised a hand to point at the location of the Imperial Capital.
"But rebellion does not only take the form of drawing a sword. In this world, when the contract is broken, the weak indeed cannot kill the strong."
"So they choose another path: they stop contributing anything to this country beyond what is necessary for survival."
He raised his hand and pointed to the patches of farmland marked on the map.
"Farmers no longer till their fields deeply. Because harvesting one extra bushel of grain will not earn them lower taxes, it only brings heavier exactions."
"They only sow enough seeds on their land to get their family through the winter and barely meet tax requirements. Any surplus harvest can neither be kept nor protected."
Louis's finger pointed to the workshop area on the other side.
"It is the same for craftsmen. Repeatedly honing their craft and forging durable tools requires time, energy, and materials."
"But these efforts do not receive extra rewards."
"What they hand over is only met with price-gouging by nobles, skimming by knights, or even forced requisition."
"So they just do the bare minimum; the tools work, but they are not durable."
Finally, his gaze fell upon the areas marked for legions.
"As for the knights, when they discover that charging into the front lines does not earn them honor, but only results in being used as expendable resources time and time again—"
"—when pensions are delayed, fiefs are constantly reduced, and even their families are not guaranteed security after they die in battle, they no longer die for their lords."
"They begin to calculate: How much does this battle pay? Is it worth getting injured? Is it necessary to risk my life?"
Louis lowered his hand: "Order begins to bleed from within. It is not a riot, but the entire kingdom withering away in silence."
The red pen was slammed heavily onto the map, right on the Imperial Capital.
"The current empire has reached this point. The strong cannot be killed, but they will be slowly starved to death."
"When the foundation completely rots, there is no need for foreign enemies. With a single gust of wind, this behemoth will topple on its own."
Louis drew a simple circle on the map.
"Establish order, over-exploit, trust breaks, national power declines, collapse and destruction, a new strongman appears, and order is established anew."
"This is the cycle of death that has never stopped on this continent for a thousand years, and we are currently standing at the darkest end of this cycle."
Varius remained silent for a long time.
Those words unfolded in his mind layer by layer, like old archives being re-examined.
He recalled the history of the empire's rise and fall, and the familiar scenes during the succession of past emperors: increased taxes, deteriorating military discipline, halted workshops, and border rebellions.
When these fragments were placed into the same logical framework, they fit together perfectly.
It was not a coincidence, nor was it moral decay; it was an inevitable outcome.
Varius's lips moved as if he wanted to refute it, but in the end, he said nothing.
Louis turned to look at Varius, his eyes devoid of pity: "That is why I never intended to be a stronger emperor from the very beginning; that would only be the starting point of the next cycle."
He raised his hand and pointed to the city outside the window, intertwined with lights and steam: "What I want to build is a system... In the Crimson Tide, the contract is two-way."
"I give them dignity and channels for advancement, and they give me creativity and loyalty. It is not driven by the whip, but by letting them know that there is truly a path forward if they run."
Varius felt a chill crawl up his spine.
He had spent his entire life upholding the dignity of imperial power, firmly believing that as long as the emperor was tough enough, the country would not collapse.
But Louis's words seemed to deny all of that from the very roots.
The most terrifying thing was never the blades of rebels, but the silence of obedient subjects.
That silent decay was more despairing than a legion rebellion.
Varius finally understood that the Old Empire was beyond saving.
His legs went weak, and he sank heavily into his chair, as if his last ounce of strength had been drained away.
"So that's it..." Varius was covered in cold sweat now. "This is why, no matter how many knights the Imperial Capital has, it cannot stop the decline, because the roots... are already dead."
Louis's entire line of reasoning was too heretical for him, yet it was calm, rigorous, and lacked any obvious logical fissures.
This made him feel a long-lost sense of unease, forcing him to rethink in the field he was most familiar with.
He raised his hand to wipe his forehead with his sleeve, took a deep breath, and finally posed the last core question as a jurist and a survivor of the Old Empire's bureaucratic system:
"My Lord, if, as you say, the nation itself is a contract, then what role should the law play?"
He had carefully considered every word.
"Is it merely a tool you use to ensure the contract is fulfilled? Is it, ultimately, still a sharp sword hanging over the heads of those who breach the contract, used for deterrence and punishment?"
That was his most instinctive understanding: law was equivalent to punishment, equivalent to another form of violence.
After listening, Louis shook his head: "A weapon? No. Weapons are used for fighting wars, suppressing, and dealing with enemies. The law exists to solve something else."
Then Louis posed a question: "What do you think this city resembles?"
He did not wait for Varius to answer, but continued: "Like a massive machine. Bakers, blacksmiths, farmers, soldiers... everyone is a gear embedded within it."
"When gears mesh and turn together, there will inevitably be friction; they will jam and encounter problems."
"The law is the manual for this machine, and it is also the oil that lubricates it."
Louis held up a finger: "The purpose of its existence is not to kill people, but to reduce friction."
"Why regulate private property? It is so the baker knows that this bag of flour is his, and no one can take it away at will."
"Only then can he bake bread with peace of mind, instead of holding a knife and guarding the warehouse door all day."
"Why emphasize contracts? It is to make the blacksmith believe that as long as he forges tools according to the agreement, the other party must pay."
"Only then can he focus on smithing, instead of constantly guarding against being cheated."
Louis lowered his finger and looked at Varius: "At the end of the day, the law is really only doing two things."
"First, it clarifies who owns what and who should bear responsibility."
"Second, when interests conflict, it tells everyone what rules to follow to resolve it, rather than relying on fists and swords."
"What the law truly does is draw a line."
"It tells everyone which piece is yours, which step can be taken, and which step cannot be crossed."
"As long as one stands within this line, people can work with peace of mind and act freely. Only when they cross this line do they need to pay the price."
Louis paused, then added: "In the Old Empire, you carved laws onto stone tablets and made people kneel and worship them. But in the Crimson Tide, people are the subject, and the law is just a tool."
"Since people are the subject, and people themselves are alive and changing, the law cannot be immutable."
"New modes of production will be created, and new problems will be encountered that old rules cannot cover."
"If the law stays in place while people continue to move forward, then it is order itself that will be torn apart."
Varius stood frozen. At this moment, the holy aura regarding the law in his eyes was fading away, bit by bit.
Louis did not seem to notice the change in Varius's eyes and continued:
"The Old Empire's legal code has been in use for three hundred years, almost never allowed to be changed. But in these three hundred years, the land has changed owners, the population has multiplied several times over, and the methods of war have changed... Only the law has remained in place."
"If reality has moved forward a hundred steps, and the law is still standing in place, then it is no longer a part of order, but an obstacle."
He looked up at Varius.
"So what I need you to do is not to guard a set of ancestral laws for me, treating them as untouchable sacred relics."
"Like repairing a running machine, when the structure changes, adjust the gears; when the load changes, replace the parts; when the rules are no longer applicable, rewrite the rules."
"Keep the law useful, clear, and reliable at all times, rather than letting it become a burden that slows down the entire Crimson Tide."
Louis finished his discourse on the nature of law and cast his gaze toward the map, lost in thought.
Varius did not speak immediately either, standing still with his gaze passing over Louis and falling outside the huge glass wall.
The city was still running.
On the streets, night-shift workers pushed carts forward, patrolling knights changed shifts at intersections, and the distant factories spewed white steam, which was then shredded by the cold wind.
Thus, the room fell into a long silence.
The feeling was like a storm having just passed; the old ideas that had been entrenched in his heart were uprooted, but no new creeds immediately filled the void, leaving only a disturbingly clean clearing.
Varius suddenly realized that everything Louis had just said was not denying the law.
On the contrary, it was pulling the law down from the altar and placing it back into the human world.
And this was exactly what he had wanted to do his whole life, but had never been able to achieve.
In those years in the Imperial Capital, he participated in the revision of the New Empire Charter, countless times attempting to add footnotes, explanations, and flexible clauses to the rigid old laws.
But every time, he would be suppressed by one sentence: "The Imperial Code must not be lightly altered."
The law was treated as a symbol of authority, not as a means to solve problems.
He had vaguely sensed that something was wrong, but no one had ever dissected the problem and explained it thoroughly like Louis.
More importantly, Louis was not just talking theory; he had Crimson Tide City, and even the two great provinces of the Northern Territory and Greyrock, as evidence.
It was written into the streets, workshops, mines, and the daily lives of countless ordinary people.
Varius slowly exhaled. Why was he so shaken by these words? Because in the deepest part of his heart, he had long agreed with them.
It was just that the past him lacked the power and the environment to admit it.
Varius had spent his whole life searching for a moral sage-king, pinning his hopes on someone noble and wise enough to correct the world's deviations through personal virtue.
He had once thought that person would be the Fourth Prince, but later that hope was completely shattered by reality. Yet in Crimson Tide City, in this great city, he had once again thought he had finally found the answer.
Until now, he finally realized that what was truly needed was never a perfect person.
But a system that does not rely on saints and can continue to operate.
But Varius fell into a sense of emptiness after being convinced, because the old had collapsed, and the new had not yet been built.
Louis broke the silence, walked to the table, and picked up the draft that had been repeatedly revised.
"Lord Varius," he said, "the reason the Old Empire decayed was not because it lacked laws, but because their laws were like a fog."
"The power of interpretation was always held in the mouths of nobles and priests, but the Crimson Tide is different..."
He tapped the draft lightly. "The foundation here is the contract, but a contract cannot be vague. It must be written clearly and fixed in place."
Louis turned around and looked directly at the old man: "Perhaps I understand how power operates, but I lack a sufficiently precise pen."
"What I need you to do is to write down those abstract things using the most rigorous and clear language."
"Let it become a ruler, measuring the emperor above and the commoners below."
Louis pulled a fountain pen from the pen holder. It was a product of the Crimson Tide Workshop, with a simple design and no unnecessary decorations.
He handed the pen and the draft to Varius: "The Old Empire's legal code has already been burned away along with that fire of yours."
Louis looked at him: "Now there is a blank sheet of paper here. Are you willing to pick up this pen and write the first line of rules for this newborn land?"
Varius's gaze fell on the fountain pen, its black barrel shimmering with cold light under the lamp.
He knew very well what accepting it meant.
It meant that he would personally lay the foundation for a new set of rules, and it also meant that he would completely bury the old rules he had served his entire life.
His hand trembled slightly.
He no longer needed to argue, no longer needed to search for subtle meanings in old files.
The true legal principles were right before his eyes.
Varius did not reach out immediately. He took a deep breath, stepped back half a step, and straightened his worn collar.
Then, he solemnly knelt on both knees.
"My Lord," his voice was hoarse, but unprecedentedly firm, "I am willing to take up this pen."
Varius raised his hands above his head and accepted the fountain pen.
Louis did not let him kneel for too long.
He stepped forward, firmly supported the old man's arm, and helped him up: "Rise. From this day forward, you are the legislator of the Crimson Tide."
The two of them walked side by side to the huge floor-to-ceiling window.
The night had not yet fully retreated, but in the depths of the city, a new round of lights was turning on.
From the distance came the low and long whistle of a train.
That sound pierced through the darkness, announcing that a brand-new order was starting.
