The first to react were those who had always been critical of "Harry Potter".

Martin Amis didn't step into the fray himself, but the critics around him who often huddled together in the literary circle read Richard Henry's article almost at the same time, accompanied by comments that were more direct than the last.

"Finally, someone has made things clear," a critic named Philip Hansworth wrote in his personal column.

"The quality of the first eleven chapters of "harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban" has clearly declined. This is obviously a fact, not some prejudice."

Another writer named Margaret Thorn wrote even more harshly in her review for "The Spectator" magazine:

"If the author of this book were a newcomer, the publishing house's editors would most likely return the first ten chapters for a rewrite. But he is Alan Wayne, and the sales of the first two installments make the publishing house too scared to even touch his manuscript."

"This is the curse of a bestselling author. No matter how badly you write, no one dares to tell you."

But the voices of agreement did not form an overwhelming advantage; on the contrary, reviews opposing that long article poured out from another direction almost at the same time.

The first to stand up was Harold Larkin, the veteran critic who had previously written that piece "Nobody Cares What You Read".

He wrote in his column in "The Guardian" in a very calm tone: "I have indeed read Richard Henry's article, and I think some of the points he raised are valid."

"But there is one word he used too hastily."

"Talent exhausted."

"I'm not saying Alan Wayne definitely hasn't lost his touch, I'm saying that based solely on the first eleven chapters, you simply cannot draw this conclusion."

Larkin made an analogy in the article.

"Suppose you get a new book, read the first eleven chapters, and find that its pacing is a bit slower than the author's first two books."

"The way this book conveys information has changed somewhat, the handling of character relationships has taken some new approaches, and then you close the book and say 'this author can no longer write anything good'. Do you think this conclusion holds up?"

"The first third of a work—its function is to lay the groundwork, to build up momentum, and to bury all the threads that should be laid."

"You cannot assert that the author has no threads in his hands before he has even begun to reel them in."

"As for 'the single-minded way suspense is guided', I actually think the suspense setup in the first eleven chapters of the third book is more complex than the first two."

"The suspense of the first two books was 'who is the bad guy' and 'what is in the Chamber of Secrets', running along a single thread to the end."

"In the first eleven chapters of the third book, is Black the bad guy? Is Scabbers just an ordinary rat? Why does Professor Lupin always appear at critical moments? Why has Hermione suddenly become so secretive?"

"It's not that these suspense elements don't exist; they just haven't had time to unfold yet."

Larkin wrote at the end of the article: "Richard Henry said 'I loved the first two books, which is why I'm disappointed with the third.' I respect his disappointment, but I think he has mistaken disappointment for judgment."

"Disappointment is merely an emotion, whereas judgment requires evidence. And the first eleven chapters do not yet constitute evidence."

Immediately afterwards, the literary section of "The Daily Telegraph" published a review signed "James Carter".

James Carter was a Professor in the Department of English at Oxford University, but his usual review style was much milder and much more grounded than most academics.

He wrote in the article: "I read the first eleven chapters of the third book again, this time specifically carrying the questions raised in Richard Henry's article."

"After reading it, my feelings were somewhat different from Mr. Henry's."

"He said the information delivery has become lazy, but I feel this is a switch in perspective."

"In the first two books, Harry was unfamiliar with the Wizarding World, so all the information was experienced by him."

"But by the third book, Harry has lived in this world for two years, and many things are already common sense to him."

"You can't expect a thirteen-year-old child to make a fuss over every little thing just like an eleven-year-old. This is not 'a weakening of narrative presentation capability'; this is the natural growth of the character."

"He said the conflict between Ron and Hermione was written thinly, arguing for eleven chapters over a cat chasing a mouse."

"I admit this passage wasn't handled brilliantly, but calling it 'thin' is going a bit too far."

"Thirteen-year-old children arguing most of the time is just over trivial matters that adults think are insignificant. This is not 'deliberately creating dramatic conflict'; this is precisely realism."

"He said the imagination of the spectacle scenes has reined in, and I admit that the Knight Bus is indeed not as shocking as the chessboard and the Basilisk from the first two books."

"But there is something in this installment that neither of the first two had: Dementors."

"The concept of the Dementor, I believe, is the most profound magical creature created by the author so far."

"It doesn't scare people with visual strangeness, but with emotional emptiness."

"Reminding people of fear and making them feel what despair is—isn't this a more brilliant kind of imagination?"

James Carter wrote at the end of the article: "I do not think Alan Wayne's talent is exhausted."

"I think he is trying some new things, and these attempts might not look very smooth in the early stage, but I am willing to give him time."

"If he still hasn't reined in these threads well after the second half comes out, I will reconsider my judgment then."

"But to say 'he has lost it' now is still too early."

Quite a few people in the literary circle stepped into the fray to debate, which actually made outsiders clap in delight.

In a London café, two literary editors were sitting face-to-face, with the supplement of "The Times" spread out on the table.

"Look at this passage written by Henry." The editor on the left tapped a line of text on the newspaper with his fingertip, "The phrase 'information dumping' is much too harsh."

"It is a bit harsh, but you can't say it's completely unreasonable." The editor on the right picked up his cup and took a sip, his voice unhurried.

"That's called pacing adjustment." The editor on the left slammed his cup onto the table, his tone carrying a hint of defensiveness, "You can't possibly make every installment as tight as the second one."

"The third book is clearly spreading a larger net; Black, Dementors, Lupin, the Marauder's Map—these things need space to unfold."

"I didn't say it's bad." The editor on the right put down his cup, "I'm just saying that although some things in Henry's article were harshly said, the flaws he pointed out do exist."

The editor on the left shrugged: "The biggest problem with Henry's piece is precisely this."

"He directly equated 'I feel this passage isn't written well enough' with 'this author has no talent anymore'."

"Right." The editor on the right nodded, "How good is the concept of the Boggart, locking what everyone fears most in a wardrobe—this idea is top-notch in the entire genre of fantasy literature."

"And that entrance method of the Knight Bus—at first glance it's a joke, but think carefully, the timing of that thing's appearance happens to be when Harry is most helpless."

"Are these things perfunctory? Obviously not."

"So I'm saying, the problem with the first eleven chapters of the third book is a matter of trade-offs." The editor on the left spread his hands.

"If you have too many things to lay out, you have to subtract in certain places."

"It's normal for readers to feel unsatisfied where too much was cut. But that's a completely different matter from the author being unable to write things."

In an office somewhere, Charles spread the newspaper across his knees, the Black tea in his hand having gone half-cold, but he hadn't managed to take a single sip.

"I know this person Richard Henry." He raised his head and said to a colleague passing by.

"He's always like this when writing; he grabs onto a single point and digs into it to death, wishing he could turn the entire manuscript into a polemic."

The colleague stopped and glanced at him: "Do you think he went too far in his writing?"

"I don't think he went too far." Charles folded the newspaper and placed it on the desk, his tone carrying a very calm certainty, "I think he was in a rush."

"Only the first half of the third book is out, and the first half is inherently meant for paving the road. Is it reasonable to draw the conclusion that the road-paving person doesn't know how to pave roads before the road is even finished being paved?"

"That's true too." The colleague nodded, "But readers don't care about these things. They bought the book, read the first eleven chapters, and felt it wasn't as good-looking as the first two, so they get angry."

"Of course." Charles picked up the cooled Black tea and took a sip, "But what did that editorial in "The Times Literary Supplement" say?"

"'Fifty years from now, let's see if anyone still remembers them.' As reviewers, we certainly shouldn't be in a bigger rush than time itself to jump to conclusions."