"I switched Secret-Keepers. Not even Headmaster Dumbledore knew."

Black looked away from Dumbledore's face. "After James and Lily went into hiding, I didn't tell anyone. I didn't dare tell anyone."

"I thought as long as I was alive, You-Know-Who would come after me, and no one would go looking for them."

His Adam's apple bobbed, as if he were swallowing something down.

No one in the clearing moved.

The wands of the Aurors behind Scrimgeour were still pointed in Black's direction.

Yet their expressions had shifted from initial tension to subtle bewilderment, as if unsure whether the man they were aiming at should be counted as an escaped convict or something else entirely.

Professor McGonagall stood beside Harry and the other two, her eyes behind her spectacles staring unblinkingly at Black.

Snape leaned against the trunk of an old oak tree on the far edge of the group, his Black eyes fixed on Black, the sneer on his face seemingly frozen.

"You all know what happened after that night."

Black's voice rang out again.

"I went to James's house. By the time I arrived, the house had already collapsed. James was lying in the Entrance Hall, Lily was upstairs, and Harry was still alive."

"When Hagrid arrived, I was still standing there. I gave him the flying motorbike and told him to take Harry, while I went after Peter. I knew his address very well."

He raised a hand and wiped the corner of his mouth with the back of it.

"When I found Peter, he was hiding on that Muggle street—the one that was later blown to ruins."

"When I cornered him, he was ducking into an alley. As soon as he saw me, he started screaming that Sirius Black was a traitor, that he had betrayed James and Lily."

"And at that moment, only one thought filled my head: I was going to tear this creature to pieces. But right after that, the street exploded."

"Peter might have planned it out long before. He blew up half the street, killing over a dozen Muggles on the spot. The blast knocked me flat onto the ground, and by the time I scrambled back up, Peter was already gone."

"All that was left on the ground was a single finger—a finger he severed himself to stage his own death," Black sneered.

"Standing there in that ruined street, I suddenly started laughing. I didn't even know why I was laughing at the time—maybe because it suddenly struck me as utterly absurd."

"James and Lily were dead, Peter had escaped, a street full of Muggles was dead, and here I was—the one who swapped the Secret-Keeper—still standing there without a single scratch on me."

"Then the Aurors arrived. Crouch's people pinned me to the ground, and before I could even finish a coherent sentence, they dragged me away."

Fudge stirred then, his hand clenching tighter around the brim of his bowler hat as if he wanted to cut in, but he couldn't find a proper opening.

"The Ministry of Magic convicted me that very night," Black continued, rattling off the charges. "Traitor, murdered Peter Pettigrew, killed twelve Muggles in an explosion, aligned with You-Know-Who."

"Crouch signed the order, and by the next morning, I was marched onto a boat."

He paused, his gray eyes lifting to sweep across Fudge's face, then Scrimgeour's.

"Did any of you ever ask me?"

Fudge's Adam's apple bobbed, and he gripped his hat even tighter.

"No," Black answered his own question. There was barely any resentment in his tone, only an exhaustion that had dragged on for far too long.

"No one ever asked me. Because everyone thought the matter was clear—far too clear."

"Peter was dead, with only a finger left at the scene, and I stood by the ruins laughing. What more was there to ask?"

"A killer standing at the scene of his crime, laughing—did that case even need a trial?"

"Then why didn't you speak up at the time?" Scrimgeour's voice suddenly cut in, his bushy tawny eyebrows knitted tightly, his shoulders under his dragon-hide coat leaning slightly forward.

"When you were arrested, when you were led away—you had chances to speak."

"Even if you'd just yelled, 'Peter is still alive,' someone would have at least noted it down. Why didn't you say anything?"

Black looked at him, a trace of self-mockery surfacing in his gray eyes.

"If I had said it, would anyone have believed me?"

He asked very softly, as if he had known the answer to that question all along.

"Back then, the entire Wizarding World knew Peter Pettigrew was dead."

"He was a hero. He pursued Black to avenge the Potters and was blown to bits by Black, leaving behind nothing but a finger."

"If I had shouted at that moment, 'Peter is alive! Peter betrayed James and Lily!' what would I have been in everyone's eyes?"

"A madman who killed and then tried to pin the blame on a dead man?"

"Peter was already 'dead.' Dead men don't talk back. Anything I said would have looked like throwing mud at someone who couldn't defend himself. No one would believe a killer caught at the scene claiming, 'The real killer got away.'"

Scrimgeour's lips parted, but he didn't voice a rebuttal.

"Besides, back then, I didn't even know Peter was alive," Black said very slowly, as if speaking to himself.

"I genuinely believed he had died in that blast. During my first few years in Azkaban, I thought about only one thing over and over again."

"Switching the Secret-Keeper was my idea. I was the one who persuaded James to place his bet on Peter. I pushed them into it with my own hands."

"If I had been blown up by Peter on that street, things would have been simple. But of all things, I didn't die. I was locked up in Azkaban, and every day the first thing I did when I woke up was torment myself with wild thoughts."

He raised a hand and wiped his face.

"At a time like that, you expect me to speak up in defense? I couldn't even forgive myself. What defense could I possibly offer?"

"If I said, 'It wasn't my fault, it was Peter's,' everyone would just tell me Peter was dead—that Peter died trying to avenge James and Lily, that Peter had chased me onto that street."

"I couldn't even refute it, because I thought Peter was dead too. So all I could do was hate myself—hate why I ever trusted Peter... when I knew full well he was the weakest."

The clearing was so quiet that the only sound was the occasional call of a night bird from the Forbidden Forest.

"And after that?" Scrimgeour asked, his voice lower than before, though still tinged with the caution characteristic of the Head of the Auror Office.

"You spent twelve years in Azkaban. In those twelve years, you had plenty of time to figure it out, plenty of chances to speak when people from the Ministry of Magic came for inspections."

"Minister Fudge has visited Azkaban every year for the past few years. Why didn't you tell him?"

Hearing his name mentioned, Fudge tightened his grip on his hat once again, his eyes darting quickly toward Black.

"Because during the first few years, I didn't want to talk at all," Black answered bluntly. "All I thought about in my first few years in Azkaban was how to die."

"The Dementors prowled outside my cell every day. They drained your happiness away bit by bit until, in the end, I couldn't even remember why I was alive."

"My mind was filled with the sight of James lying in the Entrance Hall, Lily on the stairs, and that scar on Harry's forehead."

"I felt like all of it was my fault. I didn't even have the strength to stay alive—who was I supposed to defend myself to?"

His voice dropped lower, before picking up again.

"Later, I slowly came around. I thought about so many things. Was Peter really dead? The severed finger he left behind certainly seemed to suggest so."

"But what if? What if he blew up that street and fled? What if he cut off a finger to fake his own death? Once that thought popped up, I couldn't push it down."

"During those years in Azkaban, I thought about that every single day. The more I thought about it, the more plausible it seemed."

"Peter might have seemed clumsy on normal days, but when it came to saving his own skin, he was sharper than anyone."

"Back when he was at Hogwarts, he could turn into a rat and scurry anywhere. If he wanted to run, no one could catch him."

"And then you saw the newspaper?" Dumbledore's voice interjected, calm and measured, yet drawing everyone's attention right back to him.

Black glanced over at him and nodded.

"This summer, when Fudge came to Azkaban for an inspection, he tossed me a copy of The Daily Prophet."

"He probably thought that after twelve years in prison, I was completely broken, so giving me a newspaper to pass the time wouldn't hurt."

"He threw down the newspaper and left. I leafed through it, and turned to the photo of the Weasleys' trip to Egypt. Just like that, I spotted him."

Black appeared remarkably calm.

A few faint gasps sounded across the clearing.

Harry heard Ron's breath hitch sharply beside him. He turned his head; Ron's face was as white as paper in the moonlight, his lips slightly parted, unable to close for a long time.

"So you broke out of Azkaban," Scrimgeour said, his tone revealing neither emotion nor judgment. "To go after Peter."

"To go after Peter," Black repeated.

"You just said you caught him in the Forbidden Forest." Scrimgeour twirled his wand in his hand, his gaze turning sharp again. "You caught him, and then?"

Black gave a bitter laugh.

"I caught him, but the Dementors arrived."

"Peter took advantage of the chaos, turned into a rat, scrambled under tree roots, and escaped. By the time I tried to pursue him, those Dementors had already surrounded me. If not for that—"

He paused, as if weighing how to refer to the person wearing the fox mask.

"If not for the trench-coated man stepping in, I'd probably have been kissed by the Dementors by now."

After those words were spoken, an eerie silence settled over the clearing.