Hermione kept her voice very low, but when those words fell into Harry and Ron's ears, both of them froze at the same time.

The piece of toast Ron had just picked up stopped mid-air. He put the toast back onto the plate and tapped his finger on the table: "Exactly!"

"She wasn't at the scene. Last night by the edge of the Forbidden Forest, there were only a few of us, plus Headmaster Dumbledore, Professor McGonagall, Professor Snape, Scrimgeour, and those Aurors, and then that masked person."

"Rita Skeeter didn't even have a shadow of a presence back then, what right does she have to write it as if she had seen it with her own eyes?"

Harry flipped through the newspaper again, his eyes scanning back and forth between the lines of that report.

Rita's article wrote about the scale of the storm, the height of that silvery-white column of light, and she even mentioned that Dumbledore stood in front of that broken log and spoke with Black, stating that the two of them "chatted for several minutes".

These details were too specific, specific enough to make Harry feel as though that quick-quotes quill was practically stuck right in the dirt of last night's clearing.

"Maybe she interviewed some Auror afterwards?" Harry said, but his tone carried a bit of uncertainty of its own.

Hermione shook her head, her brown eyes revealing a somewhat puzzled unhappiness:

"But if she interviewed an Auror, her article should have quotes, even if they were anonymous quotes, like 'an unnamed Ministry of Magic official stated'."

"But she didn't have any throughout the whole piece. What she wrote was 'according to this newspaper's understanding' and'sources close to the matter reveal', but she uses those kinds of phrases every time, which doesn't explain anything at all."

Ron pushed the plate in front of him forward, propped his elbows on the tabletop, and rested his chin in both hands:

"Then how on earth did she find out? It couldn't possibly be that she herself was lurking around in the Forbidden Forest too, could it?"

"The clearing at the edge of the Forbidden Forest was ground completely clean by the storm last night; all the bushes collapsed, and even a layer of fallen leaves on the ground was blown away."

"If she really had been hiding there, it would have been impossible for her to be completely fine when the storm swept past."

Hermione said with certainty, "And Professor McGonagall later had Professor Spring clear the scene, and no extra traces were found."

Harry frowned. Hermione was right; if Rita had really been in the Forbidden Forest at that time, it would have been impossible for her not to be discovered.

Yet she really wrote it as if she had seen it with her own eyes, and even wrote the exact spot where Dumbledore stood in front of Black with extreme accuracy.

"Could it be Fudge?" Ron suddenly said, "Fudge was also present at the time, and he stood quite close to Dumbledore. Maybe Fudge said something to Rita?"

"Why would Fudge tell Rita these things?" Hermione retorted, "This article writes Dumbledore as entirely worthless, but it also writes the Ministry of Magic into a dilemma."

"If Fudge really wanted to shift the blame onto Dumbledore, he could easily have just talked about the part he saw, but this article even wrote down what Black said, and it was written out of context."

"Fudge was right there listening to Black speak at the time; it's impossible for him not to be able to tell which words were beneficial to the Ministry of Magic and which ones were unfavorable."

"If he really wanted to talk about it outside, he should have kept all of Black's words about 'the Ministry of Magic locked me away for twelve years without a trial' completely suppressed and unmentioned."

Ron opened his mouth, then closed it again.

The three of them sat beside the Gryffindor long table, looking at one another, neither able to come up with an explanation that could convince themselves.

Try as he might, Harry could never have imagined that the beetle in the Forbidden Forest that kept its ear pressed against Fudge's shoulder from beginning to end and heard every single word Black said with absolute clarity was actually Rita Skeeter.

And she was currently sitting at her own desk, spreading out a new roll of parchment, her quick-quotes quill dipped full of ink, with a satisfied smile hanging at the corner of her mouth.

But right now Harry and the others didn't have the time to think deeply about this matter.

Because someone in the Great Hall had already started pounding on the table.

"Take a look at this!" A Slytherin Fifth Year boy slammed The Daily Prophet onto the tabletop, his voice loud enough for half of the Great Hall to hear.

"Dumbledore actually chatted with Black for several minutes? That's a murderer who escaped from Azkaban!"

"My mother said Black blew up a whole street of Muggles all by himself," the girl next to him said in a lowered voice.

Yet her volume seemed even clearer in the quieted Great Hall: "More than a dozen human lives, all done by him."

"Not just that." Another boy poked his head over from the side, clutching the exact same newspaper in his hand.

"I remember the Ministry of Magic said back then that Black was a follower of You-Know-Who, and back then it was he who betrayed the hiding place of the Potters."

"Now the Ministry of Magic has caught him, and Dumbledore actually still stood there chatting with him?"

"Why would he chat with a murderer?"

"Maybe Dumbledore wanted to ask him something?"

"Ask what? What is there to ask? The evidence is all there, he admitted to it himself!"

"He didn't admit to it." A Gryffindor girl softly chimed in, "What the newspaper wrote was that Dumbledore was asking him about what happened back then, and Black gave his own version—"

"What kind of 'own version'? Can a murderer make excuses for himself?" That Slytherin boy scoffed.

"Anyway, I think Dumbledore doing this isn't quite right. He's the Headmaster after all, he should have been the first one to send Black back to Azkaban."

The murmurs of discussion in the Great Hall grew louder and louder.

Harry sat beside the long table listening to these voices, feeling as though something was pressing down on his chest with every single sentence he heard.

He wanted to stand up and say something, but he didn't know what he should say.

After all, the judgment of the Wizarding World back then was crystal clear: Black was a traitor, the person who caused his parents' deaths.

Yet last night in the Forbidden Forest, the words Black spoke while sitting on that broken log didn't sound like lies either.

"Don't be impulsive." Hermione said in a low voice beside him, as if guessing what he was thinking.

"Saying anything right now is useless. They are reading the newspaper; only we were at the scene back then."

"But what the newspaper wrote is clearly biased." Harry said in a suppressed voice.

"I know." Hermione nodded, "You can't convince them, at least not right now."

...

And in various corners of the Wizarding World, similar debates were playing out with even louder volumes and more intense emotions.

Inside the Leaky Cauldron in Diagon Alley, three or four layers of people crowded in front of the bar, and every single table had the exact same copy of The Daily Prophet spread out.

Tom carried a tray, squeezing back and forth through the gaps between people, nearly spilling his Butterbeer several times.

"What is this written here?" An old wizard wearing old leather robes slapped the newspaper onto the bar, his finger pointing at that headline line.

"Dumbledore sheltering a murderer? Has he gone senile?"

"Don't go saying things like that." A middle-aged witch beside him frowned, "Headmaster Dumbledore has done good deeds for so many years, are you going to wipe away his entire life with just a single sentence?"

"So what if he's done good deeds his whole life? Does doing good deeds for a lifetime mean he can shelter a murderer?"

"What about those thirteen human lives? The Muggles on that street back then all died, not a single one was left!"

"Their grievances are staring right at Dumbledore! When his elderly self stood there chatting with Black, did he ever think about those thirteen lives?"

"Didn't the newspaper write 'perhaps there is another story behind this'?"

"Another story? What hidden story could possibly explain more than a dozen lives?" The old wizard slammed his cup down onto the bar, splashing a few drops of the liquor.

"Black was right there at the scene back then, and it was he who gave the hiding place of the Potters to You-Know-Who, and also blew up Peter Pettigrew who tried to stop him."

"What else is there to ask about this? He should be sent straight back to Azkaban, and have the Dementors called back, so he can never even think about coming out for the rest of his life!"