16
Barty Sr. spoke, looking at the task designs on the paper.
"First, the Maze Hunt."
"Construct a giant hedge maze on the Quidditch pitch, placing the trophy at its center. The first champion to touch the trophy wins."
"Various magical traps and obstacles will be placed inside the maze to test the champions' overall adaptability."
Having finished reading this proposal, he paused, lifting his gaze from the parchment to look across at the others present one by one.
Karkaroff tilted his head, his goatee curling slightly with the movement, his facial expression somewhere between contemplation and a somewhat dissatisfied weighing of options.
"Set this one aside for now," he said, his voice unhurried, though his tone carried an unmistakable reservation.
"There are five more proposals. It will be more efficient to discuss them all together after reading through them."
Barty Sr. raised no objection and shifted his finger down a line.
"Second, Underwater Rescue."
"The champions must dive to the bottom of the Hogwarts Black Lake within an hour to rescue a captive hostage."
"The hostage will be held by the lake dwellers. Exactly who that is will be decided later."
"This tests the application of underwater magic, on-the-spot judgment, and the champion's ability to handle pressure under time constraints."
Karkaroff did not speak immediately this time, but Madame Maxime tilted her head slightly, a thoughtful look surfacing in her calm eyes.
Barty Sr.'s finger moved further down.
"Third, Dragon's Lair Treasure Hunt."
"The champions must retrieve a Golden Egg from the lair of an adult Dragon. The Dragon will be provided by the Ministry of Magic, and the lair will be set up in an open area at the edge of the Forbidden Forest."
"This tests courage, bravery, and adaptability when facing absolute power."
When he finished reading this item, Karkaroff finally couldn't help but let out a soft snort through his nose.
Barty Sr. did not look up; his finger kept moving down.
"Fourth, Sky Race."
"The champions will ride Flying Broomsticks along a predetermined aerial course lined with magical obstacles and distractions. The first to reach the finish line wins."
"This primarily tests flying skills and judgment at high speeds."
Karkaroff slapped both hands onto his knees, his expression taking on an "I knew it would be like this" look.
"Fifth, Corridor of Riddles."
"Champions will pass sequentially through a series of enclosed rooms, each containing a riddle requiring specific magical knowledge or logical deduction to solve. The champion who solves them all in the shortest time wins."
"This tests the breadth and depth of one's knowledge, as well as composure in an unfamiliar environment."
Madame Maxime's eyebrows twitched slightly, but she did not interrupt immediately, merely folding her hands together over her knees.
Barty Sr. pressed his finger against the final line and read the sixth proposal.
"Sixth, Capture the Flag."
"Champions from all three schools will compete simultaneously in a designated arena. A flag will be erected in the center of the arena, and whoever captures the flag and holds it for five minutes wins."
"This tests direct magical combat ability and tactical cooperation."
He pushed the parchment toward the center of the table, pulled his hands back to rest on the tabletop, and raised his head to look at the two Headmasters opposite him.
"Six proposals in total. According to the tradition of the Triwizard Tournament, we ultimately need to finalize three tasks."
"In other words, we have to eliminate three of these six."
Karkaroff hardly hesitated before speaking first.
His voice was somewhat brighter than before, and his pace was noticeably faster, as if he had already turned that proposal over in his mind multiple times.
"The fourth proposal, Sky Race. I oppose this one first."
He held out one hand palm up in an "obviously" gesture.
"Flying Broomstick racing—which of our three schools doesn't hold that every year?"
"Hogwarts has Quidditch, Durmstrang has the high-altitude obstacle course, and Beauxbatons has its own flying event."
"If you put this in the Triwizard Tournament, what would you call it? That's just bringing each school's physical education class to a bigger stage."
He paused, drawing his hand back to rest on his knee.
"The Triwizard Tournament is being restarted for the first time in over two hundred years. Are champions picked from three schools just to see who can fly faster?"
"This is far too simple—so simple that it fails to excite anyone."
"Besides, when the time comes, people outside might even claim our school's champion has an unfair advantage," he scoffed.
Madame Maxime turned her head to look at Karkaroff thoughtfully, as though she had guessed the choice of champion for his school.
However, her expression remained unchanged; she merely gave a subtle nod, which was enough to show that she too felt this proposal lacked weight.
Encouraged by her nod, Karkaroff sat up slightly straighter and added, "I have no objection to removing this item."
Barty Sr. lightly scratched a mark with his fingernail next to the fourth proposal on the parchment, without saying another word.
Madame Maxime unclasped her hands, rested them on the armrests, and spoke unhurriedly.
"Fifth, Corridor of Riddles."
As she spoke these words, there was a tone of disapproval in her voice.
"This one is too complex."
She turned her gaze to Barty Sr.
"It is a very interesting proposal. If it were in a specialized academic competition, I would be the first to approve."
"But this is the Triwizard Tournament."
Her gaze shifted from Barty Sr.'s face to Dumbledore's, and then to Karkaroff's, as if ensuring everyone was listening to her.
"How much time would the champions spend in those rooms?"
"If they get stuck on a riddle, are they to sit there doing nothing all day, or do we set a time limit?"
"Without a time limit, compared to the other tasks, the timeframe for this one is on an entirely different scale."
She raised one hand from the armrest and made a light gesture in the air.
"Furthermore, this proposal has a critical problem: what is the scoring criteria?"
"The shortest time? Or the most riddles solved?"
"If it's the shortest time, then if one champion encounters a particularly tricky riddle while another happens to get one in their specialty, both put in similar effort, yet the outcomes will differ drastically."
"There is too much element of chance; it is unfair to the champions."
She drew her hand back to rest on the armrest, her voice softer than before, yet her tone remained firm.
"As for the Corridor of Riddles proposal, my recommendation is to remove it."
Barty Sr. scratched another mark next to the fifth proposal, his movement as swift as before, without chiming in.
Karkaroff glanced at Madame Maxime, the corners of his mouth curling slightly, as if to say, "Well, you spoke fairly this time."
Madame Maxime ignored him, turning her gaze instead toward Dumbledore, waiting for him to speak.
Dumbledore picked up his teacup at this moment, the sound of the porcelain bottom touching the saucer ringing distinctly in the quiet office.
He folded his hands on the table and looked at the others from behind his half-moon spectacles. The gentle smile on his face withdrew slightly, replaced by a subtle air of gravity.
"Then let me share my view."
His voice was as unhurried as ever, yet every word resonated clearly.
"Sixth, Capture the Flag."
After reading out the name of the proposal, he paused for a beat.
"The issue with this proposal lies not in its design, but in its danger."
Karkaroff raised an eyebrow as if about to say something, but Dumbledore raised a hand to press downward, signaling for him to hear him out first.
"Champions from all three schools engaging in direct combat in the same arena at the same time—what does that imply?"
"It means they will be employing every offensive and defensive spell they have learned simultaneously in a free-for-all brawl."
"In such chaos, champions will have to capture the flag, defend, and attack all at once. The scene will become extremely chaotic."
"Amid this chaos, a champion might face attacks from two opponents simultaneously or cast a spell beyond expectations in a moment of desperation."
He opened both hands and rested them flat on the table.
"How many accidents have occurred in the history of the Triwizard Tournament? You two Headmasters ought to know better than I."
"The reason the 1792 tournament was discontinued was precisely because the direct combat between champions spiraled out of control. I do not wish to see history repeat itself."
He paused, looking at Karkaroff and Madame Maxime.
"As for the Capture the Flag proposal, my recommendation is to remove it."
The office fell silent for a few seconds.
Karkaroff pondered for a moment, then slowly nodded.
Madame Maxime gently patted her hands against her knees and nodded as well.
Barty Sr. scratched the final mark behind the sixth item, then turned the parchment over to the back, pulled out a quill, and began listing a new line in the blank space.
"Very well. Removing the three proposals—Sky Race, Corridor of Riddles, and Capture the Flag—what remains is—"
