Immediately after, another piercing, prolonged shriek rang out and then faded away, and Pippin shrank back from the edge of the wall, panting desperately like a hunted animal.

Aside from that blood-curdling shriek, he heard what sounded like a faint horn-call drifting up from far below, its final note long and high-pitched, as if squeezing through the narrow crevices of the stone wall.

"That is Lord Boromir! Or else Faramir! It is the call of summoning!" cried the sharp-eyed Beregond, pointing below the wall. "That is truly brave! Yet, if these wicked birds from hell possess weapons other than fear, how can he manage to reach the gate? But look! They are holding firm; they will charge to the gates. Oh no! The horses are running wildly out of control. Look! A man has been thrown off, and they are running on foot. No, there is still one man on horseback, but he is riding back to find the others. In any case, that must be the noble son of Denethor, for whether man or beast, he can control them. Alas! One of those evil things is diving down at him! Save him! Save him! Is no one going out to aid him?"

With that, Beregond cried out, drew his weapon, and rushed into the gloom.

Guard Beregond thought first of his beloved lord, while Pippin felt ashamed of his own fear.

If Gandalf or Fain Vidien were here, they would comfort him, for the power of the Nazgûl is to instill fear, and only steadfast resolve can resist it.

Of course, this might also make Pippin feel even more ashamed, for he had always envied his companions and the unwavering determination they possessed.

The Hobbits crawled to his feet and looked outward, and at that very moment, he caught sight of a flash of silver and white coming from the north, like a tiny star falling from the sky onto the gloomy plain; it moved swiftly as an arrow, gathering speed as it flew rapidly toward the four figures fleeing toward the gate.

Pippin saw that it seemed to emit a faint halo around itself, and the heavy shadows shattered at its touch.

As it approached, the Hobbits felt as though he heard a resonant voice calling out, a voice full of power like long-absent sunlight breaking through the clouds to shine into the depths of his heart, ringing as deafeningly as the echoes between city walls and dispelling all fear.

He knew who it was; in Minas Tirith, only one person possessed such power.

"Gandalf!" he shouted. "Gandalf! He always appears in the darkest hour. Forward! Forward, White Knight! Gandalf, Gandalf!"

The Hobbits shouted wildly, like a spectator watching an exciting race, cheering on a runner who needed no encouragement at all.

Just then, those diving dark shadows noticed the newcomer, and one circled and flew toward him. Pippin felt as though he had raised his hand, and a beam of white light burst forth from his palm, thrusting straight upward like a long lance.

The Nazgûl emitted a long, shrill, and pitiful wail; it beat its wings fiercely, veered around, and flew away. The other four hesitated upon seeing this, then quickly spiraled upward, flying eastward into the low-hanging dark clouds above, disappearing from sight entirely.

For a moment, the Pelennor Fields below seemed slightly less dark because of that beam of light.

Pippin watched below as the horseman joined Gandalf, and they stopped to wait for those on foot.

Only then did the people pluck up the courage to emerge from the stone city and hurry out to meet them; soon, they all arrived beneath the outer wall and vanished from view.

The Hobbits knew they were entering the gate, and guessing they would come up immediately to the White Tower to see the Steward, he hurried toward the entrance of the Citadel.

There he encountered many others who had also watched this race and rescue from the high walls.

This gave him a strange sense of comfort.

Before long, a clamor arose from the streets leading up from the outer ring. Voices cheered, shouting the names of Faramir and Mithrandir. Pippin saw torches, and the thronging crowd closely followed behind two slowly riding horsemen.

One was dressed all in white, though no longer shining, appearing only pale in the twilight as if his flame had been exhausted or hidden, his face showing extreme exhaustion; the other wore dark clothing and kept his head bowed.

They dismounted, and a groom led away Shadowfax and the other horse. They stepped forward toward the guards at the door.

Gandalf walked with a steady stride, his grey cloak thrown back over his shoulders, a faint flame still burning within his eyes. The other man, clad in green, walked very slowly like someone exhausted or injured, his steps somewhat unsteady.

As they passed beneath the lamp under the archway, Pippin squeezed to the front, and at the sight of Faramir's pale face, he could not help but hold his breath—a face struck by great fear or suffering, yet now restrained and calmed.

Faramir stood still for a moment, speaking with the guard, looking solemn and grave.

Pippin stared at him and found him strikingly like his brother Boromir—Pippin had liked Boromir from the very beginning and greatly admired that prominent man's noble and kindly demeanor.

Although their interactions were not extensive, they were enough for Pippin to grow fond of him.

Although the Hobbits felt somewhat disappointed that it was not Boromir who had come, a strange, unprecedented emotion surged within Pippin's heart toward Faramir.

For this man possessed a nobility occasionally revealed by Aragorn, perhaps less lofty, less unfathomable and out of reach, yet he was one of the Kings of Men, born out of his time, yet steeped in the wisdom and sorrow of the Elder Race.

Now Pippin understood why Beregond spoke their names with such reverence, for Faramir was a commander whom people were willing to follow, even beneath the shadow of the black wings.

The Hobbits gripped the short sword at his waist and shouted along with the others.

"Faramir!"

Amidst the clamor of the townsfolk, Faramir noticed his foreign accent, turned around, looked down at him, and was greatly startled.

"Where do you come from?" he said. "A Halfling! From whence..."

But before he could finish, Gandalf stepped up beside him.

The old wizard said: "He came with me from the land of the Halflings; he came with me, but let us not linger here. There is much to say and much to do, and you are tired too. He will come with us. Come, Pippin, come with us!"

They reached the Lord's inner chamber, where soft chairs were arranged around a brazen brazier burning charcoal, and wine was brought in by attendants.

Pippin stood behind Gandalf's chair, being so small that he was scarcely noticed.

The Hobbits listened eagerly to every word, almost forgetting his fatigue.

After eating some white bread and taking a sip of wine, Faramir sat down on a low chair to his father's left.

Gandalf sat on a carved wooden chair on the opposite side, a little further away. At first, he appeared to be dozing, because Faramir initially only mentioned the mission he had been sent out on ten days ago, news the old wizard cared little about.

Faramir brought back news of Ithilien and the movements of the Enemy and his allies. He reported the battle on the highway that defeated the Haradrim and their great beasts (referring to the battle where Frodo and Sam were captured); this sounded like a commander reporting to his lord on military intelligence frequently heard in the past—all trivial matters of border clashes that now seemed both useless, unimportant, and devoid of glory.

The Haradrim were a collective term for the various peoples dwelling in the southern region of Harad in Middle-earth. Cruel and bellicose, they had invaded Gondor many times in history and were one of the sworn enemies of the Kingdom of Gondor.

Sometimes submissive, sometimes rebellious, they were enemies Gondor frequently fought, and no one would be surprised by an invasion of the Haradrim.

Immediately afterward, Faramir suddenly looked at Pippin.

"Yet now we come to a strange matter," he said. "For this is not the first Halfling I have seen emerge from the legends of the North into the South."

Hearing this, Gandalf instantly widened his eyes and sat up straight. He gripped the armrests of his chair in silence, stopping Pippin's exclamation that was already on the tip of his tongue with a single glance.

Denethor looked at their faces and nodded, as if to indicate that he had grasped the whole story long before it was told.

This caused Gandalf to cast a somewhat surprised glance at him, but the old wizard said nothing, sinking instead into thought—he did not know where Denethor had obtained his intelligence; he knew the military reports from Osgiliath, but they had never mentioned a Hobbits.

A terrible possibility suddenly occurred to the old wizard, and he stared intently at Denethor's face, trying to find some flaw.

This was his oversight; he should have thought of it long ago!

No wonder Denethor's attitude was so strange; with the existence of that thing, everything was easily explained.

But the old wizard could do nothing yet, and moreover, compared to those matters, Gandalf now wanted more to hear about Frodo and Sam; he wanted to know where they were and how they were doing.

The others sat in silent stillness as Faramir slowly told his story.

Most of the time he looked at Gandalf, but occasionally he glanced at Pippin, as if thereby recalling his memory of the other two he had seen.

He recounted how he met Frodo and his servant, and what happened at Henneth Annûn.

Pippin noticed that Gandalf's hands gripping the carved wooden chair were trembling.

Those hands looked pale and aged then, and as Pippin stared at them, he suddenly felt a shiver of fear as well, realizing that even Gandalf himself was deeply anxious at this moment, perhaps even afraid.

The room was suffocatingly oppressive, and finally, when Faramir spoke of parting from those travelers, the arrival of Boromir, and their decision to go to Cirith Ungol, his voice grew first excited and then despondent.

Faramir shook his head and sighed, while Gandalf sprang to his feet at the words.

"Cirith Ungol? The Valley of Morgul?" he asked anxiously. "When, Faramir, when was that? When did you part from them? When will they reach that accursed valley?"

"I parted from them two mornings ago," Faramir said. "If they went straight south, it is fifteen leagues from there to the valley of Morgulduin, and after that they are five leagues distant from the accursed tower to the east (the Tower of the Moon, Minas Ithil); the earliest they could reach there is today, and perhaps they have not arrived yet."

"Indeed, I know what you are afraid of, but this darkness was not caused by their adventure; it began yesterday evening, and last night all Ithilien was shrouded beneath this shadow."

"I believe the situation is clear: the Enemy has long plotted to attack us, and the time of the assault was fixed long before those travelers were under my protection."

Gandalf paced back and forth. "Two mornings ago, nearly three days' journey! How far is this place from where you parted?"

"The straight-line distance as a bird flies is about twenty-five leagues," Faramir said, looking at his father. "Yet I could not hasten back any faster."

"Last night I stayed at Cair Andros, a long island north of the Great River that we use for defense, with the horses hidden on this side of the bank."

"As the darkness spread, I knew I needed to act with urgency, so Boromir took over my defense, and I brought back three other men who could ride. The rest of the warriors I had already sent south to reinforce the guard forces at the crossings of Osgiliath, led by Boromir."

"I hope I was not wrong in doing so? At least my brother supports me."

"Wrong?" roared Denethor, a sharp light flashing in his eyes instantly. "Why do you ask me? Those men are under your command, or are you asking what I think of all your actions?"

"Boromir pampers you far too much, Faramir; his doting blinds him to your true nature!"

"Before me you appear respectful and courteous, but long since have you acted upon your own will, giving no heed to my advice."

"Look, as always, your speech is full of craft, but I—did I not see you constantly watching Mithrandir with your eyes, seeking whether you spoke well or spoke too much?"

"He has long since made you entirely obedient to him."

"My son, your father is old, but not doting."

"I can still see and hear as well as ever."

"Half of what you say and half of what you leave unsaid, I know full well; I know the answers to many riddles!"

"Where is your brother, why does he not come to see me!"

"Father, if what I have done displeases you," Faramir said in a low voice, "I truly wish I had known your views beforehand, before such heavy criticism was laid upon me."

"And would that have changed your actions?" Denethor retorted. "I believe you would have proceeded just the same. I know you well."

"You have always longed to behave like the kings of old, noble and majestic yet generous, gracious and kind, wise and benevolent."

"That may be fitting for a sovereign of illustrious royal birth, holding supreme power in times of peace."

"But in times of peril, the reward for kindness may well be death."

"Even if it means death," Faramir said.

"Even death!" roared Denethor. "But that is not just your death, Lord Faramir!"

"That includes your father's death, the death of all your people, and Boromir will die too!"

"I should not have held you in such high regard; Boromir would have done better than you! Where is he? Why has he not returned!"

"He will not return," Faramir said. "Those are his own words."

"He said: After enduring the most terrible ordeal in the world, my eyes have become incomparably clear; if Father wants that thing, let him go and take it himself!"

"Impossible! Boromir is loyal to me, he is not a wizard's pupil." Denethor roared forcefully, spittle flying onto his garments. "He will remember his father's needs, he will not waste the boon of fortune in vain, and he will bring me a mighty gift!"

"Not you, Faramir, you are lying! Where is my son!"

Faramir seemed unable to endure his father's accusations any longer, and he said: "Father, I would remind you why it was I in Ithilien and not he."

"Not long ago, your opinion prevailed at least on one occasion; had I gone to Rivendell and Boromir stayed behind to hold the defenses, he would not have brought that thing to you."

"In fact, he would have returned empty-handed."

"You should be comforted!" Gandalf said. "In any case, Boromir would not have brought it to you, yet you are deceiving yourself."

"If he were to reach out and seize this thing, once obtained, he would surely fall."

"He would claim it for himself, and when he returned, you would no longer recognize your son."

Denethor's expression grew stern and cold.

"You find Boromir not so easily managed, do you not?" he said softly. "Yet I am his father, and I say he will bring it to me."

"Mithrandir, you may have wisdom, yet even the wise can err."

"A way may be found, but it will neither be the wizard's snare nor the fool's rashness."

"In this matter, my lore and insight are greater than you suppose."