"What is your wisdom?" Gandalf narrowed his eyes rather dangerously.

If he guessed correctly, Denethor II had indeed done something everyone least wanted to see.

Yet even so, the old wizard did not know what he should do.

The Lord of the City roared aloud, his spit even splashing onto the ground.

"It is enough to perceive that two foolish things must not be done.

First, using this thing is extremely dangerous!

Second, at this juncture, to hand it over into the hands of a brainless Halfling, and bring it into the realm where the Dark Lord personally sits!

It is exactly what you and this son of mine have done, it is simply madness!

If Boromir were there... If Boromir were there, no, if I were there..."

"We have already seen Boromir's choice, what would Lord Denethor have done instead?"

"Neither."

Denethor resumed his grim expression and said coldly, "But he would undoubtedly never place this thing in extreme peril, relying merely upon a fool's hope.

If the Dark Lord regains what he has lost, we will be utterly destroyed.

No, it should be properly stored and hidden away, concealed with extreme secrecy.

I say, never use it unless forced to the utmost, but place it beyond his reach, unless he wins the final victory and may thus lay hands on it.

And by then, whatever happens, we will no longer care, for we will all be dead."

Never use it unless driven to extremes?

The old wizard did not believe a single bit of such talk.

Almost everyone would be tempted and corrupted by the Ring; as long as someone puts on the Ring and becomes Sauron's servant, the Dark Lord's expectation would be fulfilled. From beginning to end, Gandalf had never seen many people who could resist such temptation.

Nor was the old wizard unable to understand Denethor's thoughts—he was the Steward of Gondor, the Ruling Steward of Gondor, and the Lord of Minas Tirith; Denethor had only one choice, and he could only consider Gondor.

"If Gondor falls, where else can others turn for help?"

Anger was hidden on Denethor's aged face, successive betrayals having completely ignited him, and he demanded of Gandalf, "If I were to hide this thing deep within the vaults of the royal city now, we would not tremble in this gloom, dreading the worst, nor would we be hindered in formulating our strategies.

If you do not trust that I can withstand the test, you do not yet know me."

"I do not trust you in any case."

Gandalf said with utmost gravity, "If I trusted you, I would have sent this thing to you for safekeeping long ago, sparing myself and everyone else a mountain of distress.

And now, hearing you speak thus, I trust you even less, just as I do not trust Boromir.

Wait, do not let your anger flare!

Towards this thing I do not even trust myself.

Even when this thing was willingly offered to me as a gift, I refused it."

The old wizard sighed and said, "Denethor, you have a strong will and can still control yourself in certain matters, but if you were to acquire this thing, it would defeat you.

Even if you buried it at the roots of Mindolluin, as darkness grows and worse things that will soon swoop down to attack us follow one after another, it would still burn away your reason."

Facing Gandalf, Denethor's eyes flashed with intense light, and Pippin once again felt the wills of the two clashing. Their gazes traded blows like swords and daggers, sending sparks flying as they crossed. This oppressive atmosphere frightened Pippin so much that he shivered, dreading lest some fatal blow should emerge.

This was not the first time a conflict had erupted between Denethor and Gandalf; ever since Gandalf appeared here, Denethor seemed unable to stomach the old wizard, and consequently grew to detest Gandalf's pupil, Faramir, as well.

The standoff did not last long before Denethor suddenly relaxed, resuming his cold demeanor.

He shrugged.

"If I had it! If you had it!"

He said with a tone of contempt and despair, "Hah, but these are all hypotheses and empty words!

It has already entered the shadow, and only time will tell what destiny awaits it and us.

The time of waiting will not be long.

In this remaining time, let all who fight the Dark Lord in their own way unite, let them strive to keep hope alive, and when hope is shattered, may they retain the fortitude to sustain them in dying freely."

Everyone took their leave of the Lord of the City, retiring to rest while they still could, while the sky outside remained pitch black without a single star in sight.

Gandalf found his way towards their quarters, with Pippin walking beside him holding a small torch.

Neither of them spoke until they entered the room and closed the door, and then Pippin finally grabbed Gandalf's hand.

"Tell me," the Hobbits asked with hope, "Is there any hope?

I mean Frodo, or at least mostly Frodo."

Gandalf placed his hand on Pippin's head and sighed.

"There was never much hope."

He replied, "Just as I have been taught, it is merely a fool's hope.

When I heard of Cirith Ungol..."

He strode to the window, as if his gaze could pierce the eastern night.

"Cirith Ungol!" he murmured, "I truly do not understand, why take that path?

Pippin, when I heard that name just now, despair almost filled my heart.

Yet, to be honest, I believe that the message Faramir brought back contains a glimmer of hope.

For the situation clearly shows that while Frodo is still safe and free, our Dark Lord has finally taken his first step, openly going to war.

Therefore, for many days from now on, his eyes will be turned away from his own domain, roaming about here.

Pippin, from this far away I can feel his haste and fear; he has launched his action sooner than originally intended, he must have been provoked by something.

This is a good thing, for it at least prevents him from discovering the two Hobbits within the shadow."

Gandalf stood in thought for a moment.

"Perhaps," he murmured, "perhaps even your foolish action helped, my lad.

Let me think, around this time five days ago, after the young wizard and I cast spells upon the palantír of orthanc, he found he could no longer communicate with the palantír of orthanc.

Perhaps Saruman and Sauron had some secret signal that we failed to grasp; after the communication was cut off, Sauron guessed that we had defeated Saruman.

But so what? We can make little use of it, or rather, we cannot use it without him knowing.

Is it Aragorn? The time for his trial draws near.

Pippin, he is intrinsically strong and steadfast, bold and resolute, capable of making his own decisions, and dares to run extreme risks when necessary.

It is possible that it is so; he may have used the palantír, displayed his presence to the Dark Lord, and issued a challenge, with the very purpose of provoking the Dark Lord into action.

But this is too risky, the wizard beside him would not let him take this risk, why did Fain Vidien not stop him?

Or rather, did he see something that I cannot see?

The young wizard possesses the power of prophecy, a power that sees even further than mine, yet he refuses to speak of it no matter what.

Perhaps after everything is over, I will know.

Well, when the cavalry of Rohan arrive, we will know the answer—if they have not come too late.

There are terrible days waiting ahead. Sleep quickly while we still can!"

"But..." said Pippin.

"But what?" Gandalf seemed to want to use a light tone to make the Hobbits relax, "Tonight I only allow you to say one 'but'."

"Varies by context: (1) Gulp," Pippin asked rather hesitatingly, "Heaven knows how they got mixed up with him, and even followed him along?

And I can tell that Faramir, just like you, dislikes the place he is taking them to.

What is wrong with that place?"

"I cannot answer that now." Gandalf sighed, "However, I have guessed in my heart that before everything is ended, whether for better or for worse, Frodo and Varies by context: (1) Gulp will eventually meet, but tonight I do not wish to speak of Cirith Ungol.

Betrayal, I fear it will be betrayal, the betrayal of that wretched fellow.

Yet it must be so, none of us can clearly see the tracks of fate!

If the young wizard were here, perhaps he could give me some inspiration, but now, it is too late to say anything, time alone will prove everything.

Let us remember that even a traitor may betray himself and do a good deed he never intended to do."

The morning that ushered in the next day was like a brown twilight.

The hearts temporarily uplifted by Faramir's return sank down once more.

No flying shadow was seen again that day, but high in the air above the city, faint cries would occasionally drift down, causing many who heard them to tremble all over for a moment, unable to move, while the timid cowered and wept.

And Faramir rode out of the city once more at this time.

"They will not let him rest," someone muttered in complaint, "The Lord of the City pushes his son too hard.

Now he must shoulder the responsibilities of two men; it would be good if Lord Boromir also returned, but the front lines need him too."

Faramir indeed did not choose to ride out of the city of his own accord, but the Lord of the City was the head of the council, and on this day he had no mood to listen to the opinions of others.

The council was convened early in the morning, and all the commanders at the meeting unanimously agreed that due to the distraction of the threat from the south, their forces were far too weak; unless the cavalry of Rohan came to reinforce them, their side could not take any offensive action on their own initiative.

And while waiting, they must strengthen the defense of the city walls.

Yet the Lord of the City believed that they should not easily abandon the outer defenses, for Rammas had been built with great effort, and the Dark Lord must pay a heavy price to cross the Great River.

If the Dark Lord wished to launch a massive attack on the city, he could neither take Cair Andros to the north, because there were marshes there, nor come from Lebennin to the south, because the river was wide there and required a vast number of boats; instead, he would deploy heavy forces to attack Osgiliath, just as Boromir had once stopped him from crossing the river (referring to the battle before Boromir set out for Rivendell).

Yet Faramir believed that was a probe by the Dark Lord.

Gondor's forces were vastly inferior compared to Mordor; perhaps today they could make the Dark Lord suffer ten times Gondor's losses when crossing the river, but Sauron could afford to lose a great army, whereas Gondor could not afford to lose a single squad. If the Dark Lord forced his way across the river, those men Gondor sent to the front lines would have to retreat, and would fall into an extremely perilous position.

"Then what about Cair Andros?" said the Prince of Dol Amroth. "If Osgiliath is to be defended, that place must be defended as well.

Do not forget the danger on our left flank. The Rohirrim may come, or they may not.

But Faramir has told us that vast forces are continually going to the Black Gate, and the armies dispatched from there may be more than one, attacking more than one crossing."

"Many risks must be taken in war," said Denethor. "Cair Andros is already garrisoned, and at present there are no more forces to send.

Yet, as long as there is still one commander present with the courage to act according to his lord's will, I am unwilling to retreat without a fight and hand the Great River and the Pelennor Fields over to the enemy."

With that, everyone fell silent, and finally Faramir said: "Father, I do not oppose your will, but this order will place Boromir in peril.

I am willing to relieve him, do you insist upon this?"

"I command it," Denethor said without hesitation.

"Then farewell!" said Faramir. "I will urge Boromir to return to Minas Tirith.

However, should I return, please change your view of me!"

"That depends on the manner in which you return," said Denethor.

Before Faramir rode away to the east, Gandalf was the last person to speak with him.

"Do not cast away your life with bitter hatred or rashness!" he said. "Besides war, there are other matters here that will need you.

Faramir, your father loves you, in the end he will remember this. Farewell!"

Faramir had now set out on expedition once more, taking with him those who went voluntarily and whatever forces could be spared. Some on the city walls gazed through the gloom towards the ruined city, wondering how things stood over there, because nothing could be seen.

Others looked toward the north as usual, calculating the distance for Théoden of Rohan to reach here.

"Will he come? Will he remember our ancient alliance?" they asked.

"He will, even if he comes too late, he will come," said Gandalf. "But think upon it!

The Red Arrow was delivered into his hands at best two days ago, and Edoras is a long way from here."

When night fell again, tidings arrived.

Someone galloped swiftly from the crossings, saying that a great army had set out from Minas Morgul and was already approaching Osgiliath; and the cruel, towering legions of Harad coming from the south had joined this great army.

"We have learned," the messenger said, "that the Black Captain leads the army once more, and the terror he brings has crossed the Great River ahead of him."

The third day of Pippin's arrival in Minas Tirith ended with these ominous words.

Not many went to rest, for everyone felt that now, even for Faramir to hold the crossings for long, the hope was exceedingly slim.

The next day, although the extent of the darkness had reached its limit and deepened no further, it made the feeling in men's hearts heavier, and a great dread enveloped them.

Grim tidings soon arrived again—the Dark Lord had captured the crossings of the Anduin River, and Faramir and Boromir were retreating toward the wall of the Pelennor, intending to reorganize their forces at the Causeway Forts, but the enemy's numbers exceeded theirs tenfold.