Arriving in Minas Tirith ahead of Faramir and Boromir was a messenger, and because of Denethor's disastrous orders, the news he brought was all the more despair-inducing.

"Even if he manages to successfully cross the Pelennor Fields and return, the enemy will be right on his heels."

He sighed, "The enemy suffered heavy losses while crossing the river, but not as heavy as we had hoped; even Lord Faramir and Lord Boromir were unable to deal them a crushing blow."

"Their plans were extremely meticulous. It now appears that they spent a long time in Osgiliath secretly building a large number of floating rafts and barges, swarming across the river like beetles devouring rotting flesh."

"Yet what truly defeated us was that Black Commander. Few people could withstand or endure even the rumors of his coming; his own subordinates fear him, and they will commit suicide at his command."

The messenger's words shrouded the hearts of the Hobbits like a thick black silk cloth, and despair continuously welled up from the bottom of Pippin's heart.

Yet there was still some hope in this era; the old wizard placed his hand on the Hobbits's shoulder, and the warmth temporarily dispelled the chill brought by fear.

"Then, over there needs me more than here."

With that, Gandalf immediately mounted his horse, his faintly glowing figure quickly disappearing from everyone's sight.

For the entire night, Pippin was unable to sleep, standing alone before the city wall and gazing toward the east.

And the dawn bell in this unillumined darkness was nothing less than mockery; the Great Enemy had already obscured the sunlight and clouds, and his shadow swaggered and danced wildly above everyone's heads.

Just as the bell tolled once more, Pippin saw from afar flames rising from the dimness across the plain—that was precisely the location of the Pelennor Wall.

The sentries shouted aloud, and everyone in the city stood up and took up their weapons.

Now, red lights could be seen darting out from time to time, and gradually, through the heavy air, a rumbling muffled sound could be heard.

"They have captured the Pelennor Wall!"

People cried out, "They are blasting breaches in the wall."

"They've broken through!"

"Where are the sons of Denethor?"

Beregond shouted anxiously, "Don't tell me they have already fallen in battle!"

It was Gandalf who brought back the first reports.

Halfway through the morning, he and four or five cavalrymen escorted a train of wagons back, filled with all the wounded soldiers rescued when the Causeway Forts were destroyed.

He went immediately to see Denethor.

The Steward was now sitting in a high chamber above the Great Hall of the White Tower, with Pippin beside him.

His dark eyes looked out north, east, and south through the dim windows, as if trying to pierce the shadow of fate surrounding him.

He looked north most often, sometimes pausing to listen, as if by some ancient art his ears could hear the thundering hooves on the distant plain.

"Have my sons returned?"

he asked.

"No."

Gandalf did not know whom Denethor meant; he had always believed that deep down Denethor loved Faramir, but it was undeniable that he loved Boromir much more, far surpassing Faramir.

Therefore, Gandalf spoke of both, "But they were still alive when I left. You have two heroic sons who resolved to stay behind with the rear guard to prevent their retreat across the Pelennor from turning into a total rout."

"Perhaps this will allow their men to hold out long enough, though I doubt it; the enemy they face is too powerful, for the one I feared has come."

"The Dark Lord?"

Pippin blurted out.

Denethor gave a bitter laugh and said, "No, Master Peregrin, he will not come yet!"

"He will only come swaggering when he has achieved complete victory, to make a show of force to me."

"He uses others as weapons."

"Master Halfling, all great monarchs do so, if they are wise enough."

"Otherwise, why would I sit in my tower, pondering, observing, waiting, even at the cost of my two sons?"

"Know that I can still take the field and slay enemies!"

With that, he stood up and flung his long black cloak back.

Beneath the cloak he wore armor, and at his waist hung a longsword with a thick hilt, sheathed in a scabbard of silver and black.

"Thus have I walked, and thus have I slept for years now,"

he said with considerable pride, "This prevents the body from growing weak and cowardly with age."

"Even in decline and weakness, I still have the strength to fight."

"Yet the most ruthless of the chieftains under the Lord of Barad-dûr now controls your outer wall,"

Gandalf said quite cautiously, "He is the King of Angmar of old, the Sorcerer, the Ringwraith, the chief of the Nazgûl, the dread spear in Sauron's hand, the shadow of despair."

"Ah, Mithrandir, you have finally met your match,"

Denethor said derisively, "As for me, I have long known who the commander of the Dark Tower's army is."

"Did you break back in just to say these things?"

"Or could it be that you retreated because you were defeated?"

Pippin could not help trembling, fearing that Gandalf would be angered by the Steward's words and fly into a rage.

But his worries were unfounded; Gandalf was not an arrogant man, and admitting facts was not difficult for him. Moreover, the information revealed in Denethor's words was already plenty.

"Perhaps so,"

Gandalf replied softly, "However, the hour to test our strength has not yet arrived."

"If ancient prophecies are true, he will not fall by the hand of man, and the fate awaiting him remains unknown to the wise."

"Whatever the reason, that commander who brings despair has not pushed forward with all his might—not yet. He rules in the wise manner you just mentioned: he stays in the rear, driving slaves to the front first to fight desperately."

"I have returned to guard those wounded who can still be healed."

"Breaches have been blasted everywhere in the Rammas, and the army of Morgul will soon pour in through multiple gaps."

"The main thing I returned to say is this: battle will soon break out on the plain, and a sortie must be prepared."

"Entrust this task to the cavalry; our fleeting hope rests upon them, for there is only one thing the enemy is still ill-prepared in—he does not have many horsemen."

The Rammas mentioned by Gandalf was the Rammas Echor, an outer wall encircling the Pelennor Fields and an important fortification of the city of Minas Tirith.

The wall was over ten leagues (thirty miles) in total length, extending from the foot of Mindolluin to the banks of the Anduin River, forming a long arc.

The northeastern part of the encircling wall was farthest from the gates of Minas Tirith, at least four leagues (twelve miles) away.

Here the wall was tall and stout, with an East Gate upon it, flanked by the garrisoned Causeway Forts.

A causeway with parapets connected the city of Osgiliath with the Causeway Forts.

The old wizard was not at all surprised that the wall had been breached—if Saruman possessed the fire of Orthanc, then Sauron, a hundred times wiser than him, surely possessed weapons of far greater might.

The old wizard thought of Fain Vidien, that young wizard who had imagined such weapons while discussing history with him in his spare time. If possible, Gandalf would very much like to forge them, as that could reduce casualties somewhat.

In addition, the old wizard was also curious, how could those weapons full of dwarven style be conceived from a wizard's mind?

Could he have received a dwarf's education as well?

However, now was not the time for wild fancies.

"A siege does not require so many horsemen,"

Denethor said, "And our cavalry is also very sparse."

Gondor's cavalry was naturally not as numerous as Rohan's; Calenardhon was the best horse-breeding land in Middle-earth.

He said, "It would be well if Rohan could arrive at this critical juncture."

"We are likely to see other new arrivals first,"

Gandalf said, "The defeated soldiers of Cair Andros have already arrived here; that island has fallen."

"Another army from the Black Gate crossed the river from the northeast."

Cair Andros was a long, narrow island about 10 miles (16 kilometers) long in the lower reaches of the Anduin River, lush and verdant with vegetation.

Its shape was like a great ship, with the northern end towering and sharp like a prow, where the waters of the Anduin River struck the sharp rocks, splashing countless white foams.

The place name Cair Andros derived from the island's shape, meaning "Ship of Long Foam".

To the east of Cair Andros lay Mordor, the lair of the Dark Lord, and to the west lay Anórien, where the Gondorian capital city of Minas Tirith was located.

It was one of the few crossings that could allow a large army to cross the natural barrier of the Anduin River (other crossings included the city of Osgiliath and the twin river-forks region within Rohan).

Therefore, Cair Andros possessed great strategic importance for the kingdom of Gondor, and the men of Gondor had built fortresses on the island and stationed a certain number of troops there.

Yet now that place had also fallen, a thing not uncommon in these desperate days, and the kingdom of Gondor was losing her lands piece by piece.

"Mithrandir, surely someone accuses you of taking pleasure in bringing bad news."

Denethor's mental state today was much better than yesterday; that hysterical appearance had vanished entirely.

But precisely because of this, the Hobbits found the Steward all the more terrifying and capricious.

"But for me, this is no longer news: I knew of this before nightfall yesterday,"

the Steward said, "As for the sortie, I have already pondered it."

"Let us go down."

Time passed, and at last the sentries on the city wall could see the retreating outer guards.

At first, there were small, exhausted, and often wounded groups of men, disorganized, some running frantically as if pursued.

Far off in the east, firelight flickered, and now those fires seemed to spread quietly from everywhere, crossing the plain as houses and barns burned one after another.

Then, red flames rushed forward from many places like little rivers, winding through the gloom, converging along the line of the highway leading from the city gate to Osgiliath.

"It is the enemy,"

people murmured in despair, "The outer wall has been breached."

"They are pouring in through the gaps, and they all seem to be carrying torches."

"Where are our men?"

By now it was near dusk, the light so dim that even those with the sharpest vision could not clearly see the situation on the plain from the citadel; they only saw the burning points multiplying, rows of torches lengthening, moving faster and faster.

Finally, less than a mile from the city, a relatively orderly company of men came into everyone's sight; that group was not running, maintaining their formation as they marched forward.

The sentries held their breath.

"The sons of Denethor must be there!"

they said, "Men and horses will obey the command of their noble blood, and there is still hope for them to retreat back."

The main body of the retreat was still two furlongs from the city when a small party of cavalry dashed out from the gloom in the rear—they were the remaining rear guard.

They reined in their horses and turned around, facing the approaching rows of torches once again.

Suddenly, a fierce wave of howling crowded in; the enemy cavalry charged fiercely, and the rows of torches turned into a raging torrent.

Line after line of torch-bearing Orcs, and wild Southrons waving red banners, swarmed forward howling in harsh tongues, overtaking the retreating forces.

With a piercing, uncanny shriek, a flock of flying shadow-shapes descended from the dim sky; the Nazgûl swooped down and began the slaughter.

The invisible fear spread by the Nazgûl turned the orderly retreat into a disordered rout; some had already begun to break away and flee, running wildly and senselessly in all directions, dropping their weapons, shouting in panic, and falling to the ground.

At that moment, bugles sounded in the citadel, and Denethor finally gave the order for the sortie.

All the remaining cavalry in the city had long been gathered in the shadows of the gate and beneath the outer wall of the towering ramparts, awaiting his single command.

They leaped forward on horseback, keeping a neat formation, accelerating into a gallop, and charging forward with loud shouts.

A chorus of echoing cheers and encouragement rose from the city wall as well.

The Knights of Dol Amroth galloped at the forefront across the plain, led by their Prince and his blue banner.

"Amroth fights for Gondor!"

they shouted, "Amroth supports the sons of Denethor!"

They swept past the flanks of the retreating column, striking the enemy like thunder.

A knight rode out ahead of the rest, flying like a gust of wind across the grass—it was Shadowfax carrying Gandalf, who shone all over and once again revealed his true appearance, emitting a brilliant light from his uplifted hand.

The Nazgûl shrieked and flew away in haste, for their commander had not yet come to challenge this adversary emitting white flame.

The army of Morgul, single-mindedly fixed on its prey, was caught unawares by the fierce attack and instantly scattered like sparks in a high wind.

The retreating forces, greatly emboldened, turned around to smite the enemies pursuing them; the hunters became the hunted, the retreat became an offensive, corpses of slaughtered Orcs and enemy soldiers littered the ground, and discarded torches gave off stinking thick smoke that curled upwards and went out one after another.

The cavalry wanted to press forward and charge further, but Denethor did not permit them to pursue too far.

This was not because he did not consider the safety of his sons, but because the enemy's advance had been checked and temporarily repulsed, yet vast numbers of troops were still pouring in endlessly from the east.

The bugles sounded again, blowing the signal to recall troops; Gondor's cavalry ceased their pursuit.

Behind them, the protected retreating forces reformed their ranks and then retreated steadily back.

They reached the city gate and strode proudly into the city, where the people looked upon them with pride and praised them aloud.

But anxiety filled their hearts, for this force had suffered heavy losses.

Faramir and Boromir were the last to return; their men had all entered the city, the knights had returned, and bringing up the rear were the banner of Dol Amroth and their Prince.

Behind the Prince of Dol Amroth followed a horse.

Someone saw the person on that horse and fainted—it was Boromir, with his eyes closed tight, lying before Faramir, who was likewise pale of face.