16
People on the streets shouted the names of Denethor's sons and wept, but Faramir, the only one barely conscious, did not reply as they bore him and his brother along the winding roads to their father in the Citadel, that father whom they had betrayed.
Yet Faramir did not feel that he had done wrong; he believed that Boromir was also doing what was right, and that their father simply did not understand for the time being.
Just as the Nazgûl wheeled and fled from the White Rider's attack, Faramir was confronting a mounted Harad warrior when a deadly feathered arrow flew and struck him from his horse; had it not been for the charge of the Amroth cavalry rescuing him from the crimson swords of the Southlands, they would surely have hacked him to death where he lay.
As for Boromir, his situation was even worse; a Harad warrior cut down his horse, and Boromir tumbled from the galloping steed, wounded by the attacker. Had not Boromir's silver armor been exceptionally conspicuous, Prince Imrahil might not have found him—he had watched Boromir fall from his horse and at the time thought Boromir's neck had been broken.
When Prince Imrahil brought Boromir and Faramir to the White Tower, Faramir and Boromir, having lost too much blood, could hold on no longer and fainted.
Prince Imrahil arranged for servants to carry them into the inner chamber and said to the Lord who had long been waiting, "My lord, your sons have returned after achieving glorious deeds."
He recounted everything he had seen.
"My lord, we need Gandalf the Grey," Prince Imrahil said. "If anyone can heal wounds like these, it is only Mithrandir."
Denethor stood up, gazed upon the faces of his two sons, and said not a word.
Then, he ordered beds to be prepared in his inner chamber, placed Boromir and Faramir upon them, and commanded everyone to withdraw, arranging neither a healer to treat them nor servants to care for them and wash their wounds.
The Lord went up alone to the secret chamber at the top of the tower, and many people looking up there at the time saw a faint light shining through the narrow window, flickering and swaying for a while before flaring once and extinguishing.
After Denethor came down, he walked to the bedside and sat down in silence, his complexion ashen, looking even more like a dying man than his sons.
Minas Tirith was besieged, plunged into the enemy's total encirclement—the Rammas Echor had been breached, and the entire Pelennor Fields had been abandoned to the Enemy.
Before the gates closed, a troop of soldiers galloping back from the North Road brought back the last news of the outside world; they were the remnant soldiers of the guard holding the key road entering the gate area from Anórien and Rohan, led by Ingold. Less than five days ago, it was he who had allowed Gandalf and Pippin to pass when the sun still rose and hope remained in the morning.
"There is no news of the Rohirrim." The message brought by Ingold was terrible; he believed that Rohan would not come now, and even if they did come, it would be of little help to Gondor.
A new army of Mordor had arrived first, said to have crossed the Great River via Cair Andros, and they were mighty in number.
There were hordes of Orcs under the Eye, alongside countless human troops—people of a new race never seen before, short of stature yet sturdy, fierce-looking, wearing beards like Dwarves and wielding large axes.
These new people guarded the North Road, and many had already invaded Anórien; the Rohirrim could not come.
"Now, all of Middle-earth is attacking Minas Tirith, and we are done for," he said despairingly.
Upon hearing this news, many others plunged into despondency along with him.
The gates were closed, and the sentinels on the walls could hear the enemy's movements all night long, sounds that kept them sleepless throughout the night.
The enemies roamed everywhere, burning fields and trees, and hacking down anyone they found outside, whether the person was dead or alive.
In the darkness, no one could see the number of enemies that had crossed the river, but by morning—or when the dim shadows of morning quietly shrouded the plain—it became clear that even though they had harboured fear in the dark and imagined threats everywhere, they had hardly overestimated the enemy's numbers.
The plain was black with marching enemy forces, and as far as the eye could see, camps made of countless black or dark red tents popped up like poisonous mushrooms, tightly surrounding Minas Tirith.
In the distance, hurried Orcs bustled like ants, digging deep trenches a bowshot away from the walls, pieced together into a massive ring.
As soon as the trenches were dug, great fires ignited within them, but how those fires were lit, or how fuel was added, whether by skill or sorcery, no one could clearly see.
All day long they labored continuously, while the people of Minas Tirith could only watch helplessly, unable to stop them.
Whenever a trench was completed, they saw carts approaching, and soon more enemy bands arrived, taking cover behind the trench barricades to rapidly assemble massive machines for throwing stone projectiles; there were no catapults on the walls large enough to reach that far nor capable of halting their work.
At first, the drunkards in the city laughed heartily and were not very frightened of such devices.
This was because the main wall of the stone city was extremely high and astonishingly thick, built by the exiled men of Númenor before their might and technology declined; its outer wall surface was like Orthanc—hard, black, and smooth—which neither steel nor fire could conquer or destroy, unless a massive earthquake caused the very earth upon which it stood to fracture and collapse.
"Fat chance," they said. "Not unless He-who-must-not-be-named comes in person, and as long as we live, even He will not get in."
But some sober-minded people knew their plight was perilous; under such circumstances, the men of Gondor could not live long, and Sauron possessed a weapon that had caused many impregnable fortresses to fall since the beginning of creation—hunger.
Now, all roads were cut off, and Rohan would not come.
Blind optimism and blind pessimism coexisted under one roof, but as those machinery devices were gradually built, blind optimism began to fade, because those devices did not waste ammunition on the indestructible walls; directing the attack against the Dark Lord's greatest enemy was neither bandits nor Orcs chieftains, but rather a malicious force and will guiding the assault.
As soon as those huge catapults were installed, amidst a chorus of shouting and the squeaking of ropes and pulleys, they began hurling projectiles.
The projectiles flew at an astonishing height, thus skimming just over the battlements and crashing down within the first ring of the stone city; many of the projectiles seemed to have undergone some treatment, exploding into balls of fire as they rolled.
Behind the walls quickly became a terribly perilous sea of fire, with flames darting everywhere, and all available men were busy putting out fires.
Then, mixed among these huge projectiles, another sort of thing fell like hail—less lethal, yet far more terrifying.
They were small and round, rolling down into the streets and alleys behind the gate; these did not explode, but they were much more horrifying.
When people ran over to see what they were, they either screamed in terror or wept bitterly, because what the enemy hurled into the city were the heads of soldiers who had fallen in Osgiliath, or at the Rammas, or upon the plain.
Their appearance was gruesome; although some were battered out of human shape and others cruelly hacked into bloody pulps, the features of many heads were still recognizable, appearing to have died in agony.
All the heads were branded with that evil mark—a lidless Eye.
Despite these heads being defaced and defiled, people could often recognize familiar acquaintances among them, recalling how they once walked proudly in military uniform, plowed the fields, or rode into the city from the verdant mountain valleys on holidays.
The people in the city shook their fists in vain at the cruel enemy swarming before the gates, but the enemy could not understand the language of the Men of the West, nor did they pay any heed to the curses, shouting only with harsh, grating voices like beasts and carrion birds.
Before long, very few people in Minas Tirith had the courage to stand up and challenge the host of Mordor, for the Lord of the Dark Tower possessed another weapon that worked even faster than hunger—fear and despair.
The Nazgûl came; the Dark Lord was now growing in strength, and as he unleashed his power, the voices of the Nazgûl, which spoke only for his will and malice, were filled with evil and terror.
Evil magic and souls constructed their bodies, and wherever they passed, they spread terror.
They constantly circled above the stone city like vultures, waiting to fill their bellies with the flesh of doomed mortals; they flew out of sight and range, but people could always feel their presence, their deadly voices piercing the air.
Each new cry did not make people grow used to it, but rather made it more and more unbearable.
In the end, even the strong and brave would hurriedly throw themselves to the ground or stand in a daze when that hidden threat flew overhead; a dark blankness filled their minds, letting their weapons drop from powerless hands, with no more will to fight, wishing only to hide.
Throughout this dark day, Boromir remained in a coma, his complexion growing increasingly ashen, while his brother Faramir also lay upon the bed in the inner chamber of the White Tower, unconscious with a high fever.
Some said that the noble sons of Denethor were dying; this news quickly spread through the stone city, and everyone knew that Boromir and Faramir were in mortal danger.
And their father sat beside them without a word, only watching his children and caring no longer about any defenses.
No one blamed the Lord.
In such darkness and despair, fathers could only watch their children die, and sons could watch their elders die; almost everyone was already in despair, and the bravest men were either standing on the walls or had their heads struck off by the Enemy and hurled into the city.
This was the darkest moment Pippin had ever experienced; even when he was captured by the Uruk-hai, it had not been this bad.
Every day, he wandered around the city and saw all the irrational things men did out of despair—some cursed Mordor while shaking their fists at their own kin; some seized the opportunity to dash about abandoned houses searching for anything of value; others dragged out all the wine, drinking from morning till night until they became corpses.
If brave soldiers had not still shouldered the task of maintaining order, this city would likely have been burned to ashes in fires of its own making long before Mordor attacked.
This was also the hungriest moment Pippin had ever experienced.
Even as the Lord's guest, he had only a few pieces of bread to partake of each day.
Such food was already considered exceptionally good; the residents in the city had already begun filling their bellies with water.
Had Mordor's siege begun any earlier, the soldiers would likely have had to throw the corpses of those who died of hunger down from the walls every day.
The Hobbits had seen the Lord; Denethor summoned no one, yet he refused no one who came to see him.
Pippin felt that Denethor was aging gradually under his gaze; something in his proud will seemed to have collapsed, and his steadfast mind had been shattered.
Perhaps what caused this was grief, along with remorse; he saw tears upon that once cold and merciless face, which was harder to bear than anger.
"Don't cry, my lord," he stammered. "Perhaps they will get better. Have you asked Gandalf?"
"Do not try to comfort me with any wizard!" Denethor said. "That fool's hope has been shattered. The Enemy has found it, and now his power is great; he has seen our thoughts and desires, and all our efforts will come to naught. I sent my son to run pointless dangers without thanks or blessing, and now he lies here with venom flowing in his veins! No, no, now whatever the outcome of this war, my line shall be cut off, even the line of the Stewards shall fail its heritage, and once the final survivors of the King of Men hiding in the mountains are hunted down to the last, the rabble shall rule them!"
Now, the hour of despair had truly arrived.
Denethor refused any defense and was unwilling to leave his son's side.
Thus, Gandalf took over the command of the final defense of the city of Gondor.
Wherever he went, people's hearts lifted once more, and the winged shadows vanished from memory; he strode tirelessly back and forth, from the Citadel down to the gates, patrolling the walls from north to south.
Prince Amroth, clad in gleaming armor, followed him; the Prince and his knights, like true nobles of Númenor blood, always remained calm amidst danger.
Yet as soon as the two of them left, the shadow surrounded the people once more, their hearts began to cool again, and Gondor's valor withered completely into ash.
Thus, they slowly endured the dim daylight in fear and ushered in a hopeless night.
The fires in the first ring of the stone city were now completely out of control, and the garrison forces on the outer wall had their retreat cut off in multiple places.
However, very few remained at their posts, faithful to their duty; most had already fled into the second ring of the city.
