"This makes Stellarators naturally suited for steady-state, safe, and high-parameter operation from a physical standpoint!"

Su Dingping paused, giving everyone a moment to digest the information.

"So theoretically, the Stellarator I've designed can operate continuously for weeks, months, or even years."

"This means we won't need to ignite it as frequently as a Tokamak device to maintain operation."

"For future Controllable Nuclear Fusion power plants, this also means higher availability, simpler operational control, and lower thermal cycle fatigue."

"Therefore, I believe that at this stage, the Stellarator better meets our requirements."

After listening to Su Dingping's explanation, another old academician who specialized in Plasma Physics slowly spoke up.

"Comrade Xiao Su, the logic is sound, and the theory is there."

"The academic community is well aware of the advantages of Stellarators, but the difficulties are equally prominent."

"The most critical point is that the engineering implementation is incredibly difficult, which means higher costs and greater design complexity."

"We all know that the magnetic field of a Tokamak is generally axially symmetric, so its coil design, manufacturing, and installation are relatively straightforward."

"But what about the Stellarator? Its magnetic field is three-dimensionally twisted, to the point where every coil is unique and the shapes are extremely complex!"

"The requirements for manufacturing precision and installation positioning for Stellarator magnetic coils are simply too high!"

The old academician's attitude was relatively mild.

"To use the words of you young people, it's a bit 'insane'."

"Even a tiny error will cause the magnetic surface to rupture, leading to confinement failure."

"And the price of failure... is too high!"

"Stellarators are not without precedent; take that Stellarator in Europe, for example. They mobilized the top industrial power of all Europe, spent over a decade on it, and the cost was staggering!"

"This..."

The old academician didn't continue, but everyone could hear the concern in his voice.

Su Dingping nodded repeatedly, forced to admit that the old academician's concerns were not without merit.

"Elder Wang is right, but that is precisely one of the reasons why I chose to propose this plan now."

"Our Artificial Intelligence is developing by leaps and bounds."

"We can fully utilize Artificial Intelligence technology to design a specialized system to perform global optimization on the configurations of thousands of coils."

"Of course, it's impossible for Artificial Intelligence to be 100% error-free, so we still need manual intervention and screening to ensure everything is foolproof."

"Even though manual intervention is still required in the end, this can still save as much time and cost as possible."

Su Dingping paused and then continued.

"We can completely adopt a combination of metal 3D printing and ultra-precision CNC machining to form key coil components in one piece!"

"In this way, we can control manufacturing errors to the magnitude of one-hundred-thousandth of a meter!"

"Although this precision requirement is somewhat high, with our breakthroughs in high-end manufacturing and intelligent algorithms in recent years, this goal is not entirely out of reach."

Speaking to this point, he finally entered the most critical and core part.

"I have designed a Real-time Online Magnetic Field Compensation System. It can use Artificial Intelligence during operation with auxiliary algorithms to dynamically correct tiny magnetic field distortions caused by thermal deformation, material creep, and so on."

"This means higher stability and controllability, and lower operating costs—features that other devices completely lack."

"Real-time compensation? Dynamic correction?"

Someone frowned slightly.

"It sounds perfect, but the more complex a system is, the lower its reliability becomes."

"This is a Controllable Nuclear Fusion reactor, not some toy in a laboratory; it requires stable power generation!"

"How are you going to guarantee reliability?"

"If something goes wrong in any part of the process, it could lead to a total reactor meltdown or even more serious consequences!"

Su Dingping did not shy away from the possibility of such a situation.

"You are right, but I am not without a contingency plan."

"We can fully adopt more system control redundancy, combined with an autonomous fault-tolerant architecture for the Artificial Intelligence..."

"This allows any single or even double failure to be automatically isolated by the system and switched to backup."

"Through these means, we can ensure the absolute stability of the confinement magnetic field!"

As Su Dingping finished speaking, a low murmur of discussion broke out in the meeting room.

Even the most stubborn old academicians had to admit that Su Dingping's answers were logically rigorous and supported by data.

Furthermore, the technical path he demonstrated was enough to prove that this was not just empty talk.

However, when it came to such a massive leap in direction—especially a major decision to change the technical track—these old academicians could not easily dispel their doubts.

Thinking deeper, did this mean Su Dingping wanted to establish his own school of thought?

By starting a new project from scratch, he could form a new academic clique with himself as the leader...

It wasn't that these people were being overly paranoid or judging a noble man by their own petty standards; these were issues that had to be considered.

Who knew if such a new project was truly for the sake of the country and the people, or if he wanted to use it as a pretext to scramble for power and gain more benefits for himself?

No one could say for sure.

After all, no one would stake the success or failure of national affairs—projects ultimately involving the welfare of tens or even hundreds of millions of people—solely on one person's moral character.

The sounds of discussion gradually died down until there was silence.

After a moment, a person in charge of the Evaluation Center stood up.

"Chief Engineer Su, we have a more realistic problem: funding."

"According to our assessment, if this project is to be launched, the preliminary estimate for the required funds will be twice that of the Tokamak route, or even more!"

"As for the construction period, it will also be relatively longer..."

"You should know that our country's current finances are not exactly abundant, and we have already invested heavily in Tokamak devices, so..."

"Is it necessary for us to start anew and bear the additional financial risks and time costs?"

This person's tone wasn't particularly friendly, and it carried a faint hint of questioning.

But his question was very realistic, and it involved the actual interests of multiple departments and different research groups.

This made the atmosphere in the meeting room even more subtle.

Su Dingping was silent for a few seconds.

He didn't avoid the question but gave another explanation.

"Indeed, in terms of cost, starting from scratch and building a new reactor will certainly require more funds."

"But what we are comparing now is not which one saves more money, but which project can be implemented faster."

"We have indeed invested a lot in Tokamak devices and have studied them for a very long time..."

"But based on our physical understanding of Tokamak devices and considering various instability issues, even if the Tokamak is successfully developed, how long would it take to develop a commercially viable and economically sound Tokamak fusion nuclear power plant?"

"Not to mention the even more engineering problems that may be encountered so far."

"There's a reason why Controllable Nuclear Fusion is claimed to be a technology that is 'always 50 years away'."

"Even by the most optimistic estimates, by the time a Tokamak fusion reactor is actually implemented, it will likely be in the latter half of this century, or even later."

"I don't need to elaborate further on the various advantages represented by the Stellarator; everyone knows them."

"From a long-term goal perspective, the design of a Stellarator power plant may be simpler, and labor costs will be lower..."

"Most importantly, once the Stellarator is successful, we will seize a crucial position in the fusion energy race!"

"And this position will bring absolute strategic advantage and initiative in various fields such as global technology, economy, and even geopolitics for the next few years, decades, or even a century!"

"This is a critical window of time. This window will not exist forever; once missed, it may likely disappear!"

"This will be the fast track to establishing our absolute advantage!"

Su Dingping did not feel displeased by the official's questioning; instead, he explained patiently.

"Fast track?"

The official was unimpressed.

"But if you fail, that's a massive sunk cost, a strategic misjudgment!"

"Can you guarantee success? Can you guarantee there won't be any risk?"

The official was somewhat aggressive, and even with Su Dingping's good temper, he couldn't help but feel a spark of anger.

"Scientific research, including any major technological decision, involves risk."

"There is no such thing as 100% success in this world!"

Su Dingping said coldly.

"Furthermore, foreign countries have been researching Tokamak technology for many years; we may not necessarily catch up to them now."

"Continuing to invest in Tokamak devices seems to have lower risks, but it means we might always be following in others' footsteps!"

"Ha!" The official gave a slight, short laugh.

"Overtaking on a curve—I knew it would be that argument again."

"We cannot always take the path of overtaking on a curve."

"In certain aspects and fields, we must ultimately compete with them directly!"

"The fact is, the tactic of overtaking on a curve is indeed effective."

"Those foreign ideas are not necessarily all correct."

"If we didn't dare to take risks, we wouldn't have the tailless layout and intelligent swarms of the sixth generation fighter jet, we wouldn't have our own nuclear-powered aircraft carrier, and we certainly wouldn't have launched the South Heaven Gate Project!"

"This move may seem risky, but in reality, it's us seizing the key to an intergenerational leap!"

At the mention of the sixth generation fighter jet, the Aircraft Carrier, and the South Heaven Gate Project, the eyes of several committee members with military backgrounds in the meeting room flickered slightly.

Compared to others, these members with military backgrounds understood the weight of Su Dingping's words even better.

All these projects were led by Su Dingping alone, which was enough to prove that his judgment had never been wrong.

The meeting room fell into debate once again.

A titan in the field of materials science, who had been listening in silence, slowly spoke up.

His voice was not loud, but it instantly silenced the entire meeting room.

The prestige of this old titan in the scientific community was beyond what ordinary people could imagine.

"Dingping," Academician Li's voice was raspy but his words were clear, "the physics, engineering, and strategy you've discussed... they all have their merits."

"As an old man, listening to it makes me feel stirred as well, but..."

He looked up, his gaze sharp as lightning.

"There is a most critical and fragile link in your blueprint. How do you plan to solve it?"

"Or rather, when do you plan to give us old folks the real bottom line?"

Su Dingping fell silent.

Academician Li's thin finger tapped lightly on the report.

"The most critical core material you mentioned here..."

Academician Li paused for a moment.

"To be honest, I've spent my whole life working with materials. Whether it's high-temperature alloys, ceramic matrix composites, or even radiation-resistant materials, I've had some contact with them all."

"But the performance indicators required for this material of yours..."

Academician Li shook his head slightly, a complex expression on his face.

It was a mixture of amazement and extreme skepticism.

"Neutron irradiation... thermal conductivity near... can still function under extreme thermal stress... not to mention your... and the synthesis approach..."

Once Academician Li started, he couldn't stop, questions coming one after another.

His gaze swept over the colleagues present who weren't well-versed in the details of materials science, and he said slowly, "I'll just say it straight, Dingping, it's impossible to prepare this material of yours!"

"Don't be in a hurry to deny it."

Academician Li raised a hand and said softly.

"True, from your report, there is indeed a theoretical possibility of synthesis."

"But that possibility is simply too low; it exists only as a theoretical possibility."

"The difficulty..."

Academician Li shook his head slightly.

"Even if we take a step back and say you are extremely lucky to synthesize this material in the laboratory, how can you guarantee stable production at an engineering scale?"

"Without this material, all your ideas are nothing but a castle in the air."

*Whoosh—*

A wave of low exclamations finally broke out uncontrollably in the meeting room.

Academician Li's prestige meant that no one doubted his judgment.

Everyone's heart sank.

Even though most people held opposing views, quite a few had been moved by Su Dingping's speech just now.

But once this question was raised, the looks directed at Su Dingping gradually turned into suspicion.

If these so-called ideas were just a castle in the air, then what was Su Dingping's real purpose... did they even need to consider it?

Question after question arose, and the pressure weighed down on Su Dingping like a mountain.