16
Martin's statement was published on the column page of the Literary Review weekly, and the layout was not flashy.
The title used only size-one bold characters, neatly printing "Some Superficial Views on harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban", signed by Martin Amis.
The publication hit the shelves on Thursday morning. Newsstands on the streets of London had just stacked bundles of weeklies onto wooden racks when readers waiting nearby swarmed around, and some even flipped the magazine to that page before waiting for their change.
Martin made a rather straightforward admission at the beginning of the article.
"I read this book, from cover to cover, every single word," he wrote.
"I must admit that the standard of the second half has improved significantly compared to the first half. Those clues that seemed loose and dragging in the first half are indeed tied together quite brilliantly in the second half."
"The twist of Peter Pettigrew is designed quite exquisitely, and the use of the Time-Turner also shows the author's careful thought in structure."
"If we only discuss the question of 'whether it is interesting to read', then I must say that this book is interesting. I do not intend to deny this point, nor is there any need to deny it."
Writing up to this point, his tone was still calm. But starting from the next paragraph, his writing style turned, and it turned quite steeply.
"However, a novel has not completed its entire mission just by being 'interesting to read'."
"From the first book to the third book, I have always been paying attention to a core clue running through the entire series, which is the existence of You-Know-Who."
"In the first book, that person whose name cannot be spoken possessed Professor Quirrell, trying to seize the Philosopher's Stone to restore his power. That is the hidden thread of the whole book, and also the fundamental reason why Harry Potter became Harry Potter."
"In the second book, the teenage Tom Riddle stirred up trouble at Hogwarts through the diary, the Basilisk was released, and Ginny Weasley almost lost her life."
"This clue was further deepened, allowing readers to see You-Know-Who's past, and also seeing one of the fragments of his split Soul."
"These two works, regardless of their respective specific plots, both have a clear main storyline supporting the skeleton of the entire story underneath."
"But what about the third book? Where is You-Know-Who?"
"I searched the whole book from cover to cover and found no substantial content advancing this core main storyline."
"Black's story is written very movingly, Lupin's past is written very delicately, and the Time-Turner and the Patronus Charm are also very imaginative, but what do these have to do with You-Know-Who?"
"Nothing at all. They can be put into any novel set in a magic school and hold up just as well."
"This brings up a very serious problem."
"If an author has laid out a main line running through the entire series in the first and second books, but suddenly shelves it and stops writing about it in the third book, then there are only two possibilities."
"First, he forgot. Second, he doesn't know how to continue writing."
"I don't think an author who can write designs like the Time-Turner and the Marauder's Map would make the mistake of 'forgetting'."
"So the only remaining answer is the second one: he simply doesn't know how to continue advancing You-Know-Who's story."
Martin's writing tone became even more resolute after this paragraph, even carrying some of his usual confidence and composure.
"This is not my personal judgment alone."
"Anyone who has written a novel understands that if a story has a main line, every installment should take a step forward along this main line."
"Even if it's just a small step, even if it's just planting a new foreshadowing, at least it should make readers feel that the direction is still there."
"But what about the third book? You-Know-Who's name only appeared once or twice in the newspaper, and there wasn't even a decent direct confrontation."
"The villain of the whole book is a fugitive who was wronged for twelve years, and that fugitive turns out to be a good guy in the end."
"In other words, from beginning to end, this book does not have a real enemy related to the main line."
"This way of writing, to put it nicely, is called'spin-off style writing'; to put it harshly, it is the author avoiding the core issue."
"He didn't know what to do with You-Know-Who, so he simply bypassed it and wrote a relatively independent mini-story to fill the space."
"This mini-story is indeed well-written, but its position in the entire series is suspended in mid-air."
"If you remove the entire third book, it has almost no impact on the advancement of the main lines of the first and second books."
"I am not saying that every novel must revolve around the same villain."
"Many series works have relatively independent volume structures, where each volume has its own enemy, its own puzzle, and its own climax. This is completely normal."
"But the premise is that these independent volumes must serve the main line of the entire series in some deeper sense."
"Did the third book achieve this? I didn't see it."
"Black's story is very touching, but it has no causal relationship, no logical connection, and not even a substantive chronological relationship with You-Know-Who."
"It is simply a standalone story forced into a series."
In the final paragraphs of the article, Martin's tone slowed down a bit instead, but that slowing down itself was even more uncomfortable than before.
"I do not deny that this book is written interestingly."
"In fact, if viewed as a standalone adventure novel, its completion is quite high, with full-bodied characters, tight plots, and abundant emotions."
"The godfather character named Black is written exceptionally well. I can even say this is the most vivid character I have seen in these three works."
"But it is not a standalone novel; it is the third book of a series."
"As the third book of the series, it has not completed the task it should have accomplished, which is to drive the core conflict of the entire series forward."
"This is like a musician playing a sonata, where the first and second movements are both wonderful, but in the third movement, they suddenly stop to tell a story unrelated to the entire piece. No matter how well it is told, it is still off-topic."
"So my conclusion is this: Alan Wayne wrote a good story, but he has not yet written a good series."
"He has the talent for storytelling, but currently lacks the mastery to grasp the overall structure of a long-running series."
"If in the fourth book he still cannot find a way to advance You-Know-Who's main line, then this series may eventually turn into a bunch of brilliant yet unconnected fragments rather than a complete novel."
"A story is a story after all. Written well, it's still just a story. To become a complete novel, having a story alone is not enough."
On Thursday morning, this statement struck like a pebble thrown into calm water, sending ripples spreading out in circles.
In several cafes on Fleet Street in London, readers who were waiting to see what Martin had to say this time reacted differently after reading it. Some slammed tables, some nodded, and some curled their lips in disdain, buzzing with lively excitement like a boiling pot.
