16
"He does have a point," a middle-aged man flipping through a magazine in the corner said, setting down his coffee cup and nodding to his companion beside him.
"I felt a bit like that after finishing the third book too. It's brilliant, sure, but compared to the first two, it feels like something is missing."
"He said it lacked You-Know-Who's main plotline, and I actually think he hit the nail on the head."
"Don't you think that's being too harsh, though?" His companion frowned, tapping the tabletop with his knuckles.
"The third book is so well written! I've reread that twist several times, and every single time it gives me goosebumps."
"Just because You-Know-Who isn't in it, you're calling the book 'incomplete'?"
"I didn't say it was incomplete. I said he made some valid points."
"Valid how? If every book featured You-Know-Who, wouldn't that get tedious? Changing things up in book three and exploring other stories—isn't that great?"
Similar debates were playing out across many corners of London at the same time.
Outside the flagship bookstore on Oxford Street, a young witch wearing round glasses shoved a magazine in front of her friend, her voice tinged with undisguised annoyance.
"Just listen to what he wrote! 'A story is, after all, merely a story'?"
"What right does he have to say that? How does the third book fail to be a complete novel? It has a beginning, an ending, plot twists, and emotion—what piece is missing?"
Her companion took the magazine and flipped through it, wearing an expression somewhere between amused and helpless. "Don't yell at me. I'm not the one who wrote it."
"Didn't you just say he had a point?"
"I said he had 'a bit of a point,' not that he was 'entirely right.'"
"Even having 'a bit of a point' is wrong!" The young witch rolled the magazine into a cylinder and waved it in the air.
"He clearly didn't read it carefully at all. If he really read it, he'd know that even though You-Know-Who doesn't make a direct appearance in book three, his lingering influence is everywhere."
"Why was Black wrongfully imprisoned for twelve years? Wasn't it because of You-Know-Who?"
"Why did Peter betray the Potters? Wasn't it because of You-Know-Who?"
"Aren't these things an extension of the main plotline? Does You-Know-Who have to physically pop out and fight someone for it to count as advancing the main plot?"
Her words drew nods of agreement from several nearby readers, and someone even began to applaud.
Yet, there were dissenting voices as well.
In an old bookstore in Manchester, several regulars sat clustered in armchairs beside the fireplace. One elderly man with a white beard set down his magazine and spoke in a measured cadence.
"This young man says 'a story is, after all, merely a story.' Harsh as it sounds, think about it carefully—doesn't he have a point?"
"What point?" the young man opposite him immediately retorted.
"Look, the first and second books both presented a clear central conflict right before you."
"Book one had the Philosopher's Stone; book two had the secret chamber. And book three? Black broke out of Azkaban, and we all thought he was a villain, only to discover he wasn't."
"So what is the central conflict of this book? Catching an innocent man? Or clearing the name of a fugitive? What do any of these things have to do with the overarching series?"
"Of course they matter—he's Harry's godfather!"
"So what if he's the godfather? Will the next book even follow up on this godfather plotline?"
"If it isn't in the next book, then wouldn't spending an entire book building up this character in book three just be a complete waste?"
The young man parted his lips to argue, but couldn't find the right words in the moment.
Meanwhile, in Edinburgh, Ian McEwan had also read the statement.
Sitting in the old leather chair in his study, he read the article from start to finish several times before finally closing the magazine, resting it on his knees, and gently shaking his head.
Picking up a notepad from his desk, he drew out his fountain pen and penned a brief letter to a friend in London. The letter contained only a few lines:
"Martin has written a fine essay with airtight arguments, but he has forgotten one thing."
"A novel is not an official document; it doesn't require the same stamp on every single page. Sometimes, stamping with a different seal actually allows people to see just how deep those previous impressions were stamped."
However, Ian did not send the letter.
After finishing, he reread it, felt it was a bit too early to say such things, and crumpled the note into a ball, tossing it into the wastepaper basket.
In the editorial office of The Guardian, Harold Larkin let out a long breath and leaned back against his chair after finishing the statement. He then picked up the telephone on his desk and dialed a number.
"Hello, it's me. Write a short commentary for me to run in tomorrow's culture section. Title it... 'Give the Story Some Breathing Room.'"
"What about the content?"
"I'll dictate, you write."
Yet among all this noisy chatter, one writer's words were shared the most widely.
She was an author named Deborah Moss, who had written several well-received children's novels and usually avoided publicly commenting on her peers.
At a small reading salon, a reporter asked for her thoughts on Martin's statement. After a moment's reflection, she set down her teacup and said:
"I've been writing novels for twenty years, and if there's one thing I've learned, it's this:"
"If an author fixates on the very same plotline in every single book, that's just punching a clock. If they take a detour once in a while to write something else, that is true creation."
"Martin claims book three goes off topic, but I believe book three is where this series truly begins to breathe."
The reporter published these remarks alongside a photograph of Martin and a "recent photo of the author" for Allen Wayne (an empty chair), under the headline: "Peers Don't Buy It."
...
Yet while the Muggle world was arguing incessantly over this statement, the atmosphere inside Hogwarts Castle was quite another matter.
Inside the Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher's office, the fireplace crackled warmly. Lupin sat behind his desk with a half-graded essay laid out in front of him, red ink marking several corrections along the margins.
He looked up at Harry standing before the desk, his brow furrowing slightly.
"So, what you mean is, you want to know if it's possible for two different people to have the same Patronus?"
Harry nodded, rapidly and vigorously.
Lupin did not answer immediately.
He placed the quill back into the inkpot, clasped his hands together on the desk, and looked at Harry with his gray eyes, remaining silent for several seconds.
"Strictly speaking," he finally spoke, his pace much slower than usual as if weighing every word, "it is indeed possible."
Harry's eyes lit up instantly.
"The form of a Patronus is determined collectively by many factors—the caster's personality, experiences, emotional traits, and so on. It is a projection of these factors on a magical level."
"If two individuals' inner qualities are exceptionally similar, then it is not theoretically impossible for their Patronuses to assume the same form."
He paused, drew out a blank piece of parchment, and used his wand to sketch a simple diagram on it.
Several curving lines radiated outward from the center, each line ending with a label: Personality, Experience, Conviction, Emotion, Memory.
"You see, the proportions of these elements are different in every person."
"Most people have unique combinations, so most people have unique Patronuses."
"However, if two people's combinations happen to be remarkably alike, then the Patronuses manifested could very well converge."
"Is that sort of situation common, then?" Harry pressed.
"Not common," Lupin said with a shake of his head, pushing the parchment aside. "In fact, the odds are miniscule."
"In all my years studying Defense Against the Dark Arts, having read countless records and seen many cases, I have only ever witnessed two people possessing identical Patronuses among blood relatives."
He paused, taking in the somewhat strange expression on Harry's face, and softened his tone slightly.
"Why do you ask?"
