December 19, 1942. Don River Line.

Three days later.

The retreat order finally came down.

"We are falling back to Kotelnikovo." Brenner stood in front of the map, pointing to a location. "We will regroup there and wait for new orders."

"Are we not going to save them?" someone asked.

"We can't save them," Brenner said. "Our forces are already wiped out. If we keep fighting, it will only lead to total annihilation."

A moment of silence.

"What about the 6th Army?" someone asked.

Brenner did not answer.

There was no need to answer; everyone knew the answer. The 6th Army had already been abandoned.

That morning, the German Army began to fall back.

The retreating convoy was in complete chaos — tanks, armored vehicles, trucks, artillery pieces, all kinds of vehicles jammed together, kicking up dust all over the sky. The infantrymen dragged their exhausted bodies behind the vehicles, walking step by step toward the rear.

Hans sat in the turret of the panzer iv ausf. g, watching the scene outside the window.

He thought of a few days ago — they were also like this, advancing in the direction of Stalingrad. Full of hope, thinking they could rescue those three hundred thousand people.

But what about now?

They had failed. They had been beaten back. They had abandoned those three hundred thousand people.

"Commander," Klein's voice came from beside him, "Are we... are we really not going to save them?"

"We can't save them," Hans said.

"But..."

"No buts," Hans interrupted him. "We only have less than twenty tanks left, and a few hundred men. The Russians have thousands of tanks and hundreds of thousands of people. With what are we supposed to save them?"

Klein fell silent.

Hans knew what he wanted to say — wanting to say "But they are also Germans," "But they are still waiting," "But we promised them."

But these words were useless.

War does not believe in promises. War only believes in strength.

And they no longer had strength.

At noon, the convoy reached a village called "Tolgoye".

This used to be a quiet Russian village, but now only ruins and craters remained. The artillery fire of the German Army and the counterattacks of the Russians had turned this place into scorched earth.

"Rest for an hour," Brenner ordered. "Check the vehicles and replenish ammunition."

Hans parked the vehicle next to some ruins and jumped out to stretch his body.

Days of combat had left him exhausted. He hadn't slept well or eaten a hot meal in days. Now he could finally rest for a bit.

"Commander."

Brenner walked over, holding a piece of paper in his hand.

"This is the latest news received." He handed the paper to Hans. "About the 6th Army."

Hans took the paper and glanced at it.

It was the radio communication record of the 6th Army.

"General Paulus requested permission from the Führer to break out," Brenner said, "but it was refused."

"Refused?"

"Yes." Brenner's voice was somewhat hoarse. "The Führer's order is: defend in place, wait for rescue."

"But we have already retreated..."

"So they won't wait for rescue," Brenner gave a bitter smile. "They never will."

Hans looked at that piece of paper.

General Paulus's request was very short, only a few sentences. But between the lines, Hans could feel that despair — the despair of being surrounded, abandoned, and having a request to break out rejected.

"Will the general obey the order?" he asked.

"He will," Brenner said. "He is a soldier. Soldiers must obey orders."

"Even if this order is wrong?"

"Even if this order is wrong."

Hans was silent for a moment.

"So they will die," he said.

"Perhaps," Brenner said. "Perhaps not. Perhaps they will surrender."

Surrender.

This word appeared again.

"German soldiers do not surrender," Hans said.

"Yes," Brenner said. "But if you are surrounded, have no food, no ammunition, and no hope of victory — what else can you do besides surrender?"

"I don't know."

"I don't know either," Brenner said. "But I know one thing —"

"What?"

"If it were me," Brenner looked at Hans, "I would surrender."

"What?"

"To live is better than to die," Brenner said. "Any war theory, any military honor, any order — none of it matters in the face of 'living'."

"But..."

"No buts," Brenner interrupted him. "I said it, Clausewitz said it, war is the continuation of politics. When politics goes wrong, war becomes slaughter. And slaughter needs no reason."

"So, do not believe those high-sounding words. Fatherland, glory, victory — they are all lies."

"The only thing that truly matters is — staying alive."

He patted Hans's shoulder and turned to leave.

An hour later, the convoy continued moving forward.

Hans sat in the turret of the panzer iv ausf. g, constantly thinking about Brenner's words in his heart.

"To live is better than to die."

"The only thing that truly matters is — living."

These words, he had never heard before. In the boot camp, the instructors told them that "To die for the Fatherland is glorious," "Germany is invincible," and "Surrender is a disgrace."

But what about now?

They were running away. They were abandoning those three hundred thousand people. They were leaving comrades who had once fought side by side with them there to wait for death.

Those high-sounding words, what meaning did they have?

"Commander."

Eger's voice interrupted his thoughts.

"What is it?"

"I've been thinking about something."

"What?"

"Why are we fighting?"

Hans was stunned for a moment.

"What do you mean?"

"I mean," Eger's voice was somewhat exhausted, "in 1939 we fought Poland, in 1940 we fought France, in 1941 we fought Russia. Every time we said it was for the Fatherland, for living space, to stop the expansion of the Bolsheviks."

"But what about now? We pushed deep into Russia, occupied vast tracts of land, and then what? The Russians counterattacked and drove us back. Now they have surrounded three hundred thousand of our men."

"What was all this for?"

Hans was silent for a long time.

"I don't know," he said finally.

"I don't know either," Eger said. "I just feel like none of this has any meaning."

"We killed so many people, occupied so much land, but in the end? We are still here, still fighting, still dying."

"Perhaps this war was wrong from the very beginning. Perhaps we shouldn't have fought this war."

"Eger..."

"But we fought anyway," Eger said. "Because of orders. Because we are soldiers. Because we had no choice."

"But what about now? Three hundred thousand people have been abandoned. We are also being abandoned — not by the Russians, but by our own superiors."

"Abandoned by superiors?"

"Yes," Eger said. "They sent us here, told us to save three hundred thousand people, but didn't give us enough troops and supplies. When we failed, they pulled us back and then told everyone 'We tried our best'."

"But they never admitted that this war was wrong from the very beginning."

Hans did not speak.

He knew Eger was right.

This war was wrong from the very beginning. Insufficient troops, inadequate supplies, too many objectives — anyone with basic military common sense could see the problem. But the higher-ups wouldn't listen. They thought they were right, thought Germany was invincible, and thought that if they just pushed a little harder, they would win.

And the result?

Three hundred thousand people surrounded, thousands killed in battle, the sacrifices of countless people reduced to nothing.

And what about those who gave the orders?

They were still in Berlin, still in the Wolf's Lair, continuing to issue orders. Continuing to dream, continuing to fantasize, continuing to send more soldiers to the battlefield to die.

By evening, the convoy reached Kotelnikovo.

A large number of German Army remnant troops had already gathered here — retreating from Stalingrad, retreating from other directions, all kinds of routed soldiers and stragglers. They gathered together, forming a chaotic group.

"Regroup," Brenner said. "We will regroup here and wait for new orders."

"What orders?"

"I don't know," Brenner said. "Maybe continue to defend, maybe retreat."

"Retreat to where?"

"Maybe retreat out of Russia. Maybe retreat to Poland. Maybe..."

He didn't continue.

Maybe what? Maybe retreat to Germany? Maybe retreat to Berlin?

Hans looked at the people around him.

Their faces all carried the same expression — exhaustion, numbness, despair. They had fought for three months, fighting from Voronezh to Stalingrad, retreating from Stalingrad to the Don River, and then retreating from the Don River to here.

They had lost comrades, lost tanks, lost hope.

Now they gathered here, waiting for an unknown fate.

"Commander," Meyer asked, "are we going to die?"

Hans looked at him.

Meyer was only twenty. Three years ago when Hans first went to the battlefield, he was also twenty. At that time, he had also asked the same question.

"I don't know," he said. "But no matter what, we must keep living."

"Live?"

"Yes," Hans said. "Live. To live is better than to die."

"But..."

"No buts," Hans interrupted him. "Brenner is right. The only thing that truly matters is — living."

"Everything else doesn't matter. Fatherland, glory, orders — they are all lies. Only by living can there be a future."

"So, no matter what happens, no matter what orders the higher-ups give — remember one thing: live."

Meyer looked at him, a glimmer of light flashing in his eyes.

"I understand," he said.

"Go rest," Hans said. "There are still many things to do tomorrow."

That night, Hans lay in the turret of the panzer iv ausf. g, unable to sleep.

He thought of many things. He thought of Moscow in 1941, of Stalingrad in 1942. He thought of those dead comrades, of those abandoned comrades.

They were all Germans. All fighting for Germany. All waiting for that victory that would never come.

But in the end?

Some people died, some were abandoned, some were still fighting.

This was war.

This was their destiny.

"Commander."

Klein's voice came from beside him.

"What is it?"

"I heard... I heard the 6th Army is still sending telegrams."

"What?"

"It's news intercepted by radio," Klein said. "They are still transmitting to Berlin. Asking for support, asking to break out, asking for... anything."

"But no one is replying to them."

Hans was silent for a moment.

"They will keep sending," he said. "Until they can't send anymore."

"And then?"

"Then..." Hans looked at the darkness of the vehicle roof, "Then they will die. Or surrender."

"Surrender?"

"Yes," Hans said. "Brenner is right. To live is better than to die. If I were them, I would also surrender."

"But if they surrender..."

"If they surrender, they can still live," Hans said. "Maybe they'll be marched off to Russian prisoner-of-war camps, maybe they'll starve and freeze, maybe they'll die. But at least there's a chance to keep living."

"As long as you live, there is hope."

"Once you're dead, there's nothing left."

Klein was silent for a long time.

"Commander," he finally asked, "will you surrender?"

Hans thought about it.

"I don't know," he said. "But I will try my best to live."

"What if you really can't live anymore?"

"We'll talk about it when the time comes."

Hans closed his eyes.

Would he surrender?

He didn't know. Maybe he would, maybe he wouldn't.

But one thing he knew — from now on, he would no longer believe those high-sounding words.

Fatherland, glory, victory — they were all lies.

The only thing that truly matters.

Staying alive.